Which of these shonen is the best in your opinion?

Only read MHA. Prefer the anime , but only the first seasons. try Cage of Eden or Bio-meat nectar instead.

Stay away from shounen shit, kiddo. Watch something else.

From that list is Fire Force(30 limit characters).

@Absurdo_N can you explain please why fire force instead of all these ? I've heard a lot or praise of it and I'm planning to read it but i'm afraid to just find another cliche shonen with some differences.

@Yaaceen

I like how Fire Force only has powers involving fire and yet all the powers and battles feel different from each other.

@MichaelJackson thnx but both these two are survival ones and if you ask me I have an overdose of it with Gantz right now '-_-

@Absurdo_N what about the story, plot twists and the characters ?

@Yaaceen shonen is a demography. what you mean is "battle shonen".
you have to be more specific. and survival is a top tier genre. nothing wrong about adding more and more to your list. up to you

Why ask us? And Ao Ashi is seinen so why is there?

@Yaaceen

The story is very simple, the protagonist loses his family and finds a team that becomes his new family and now they are going to save the world from eccentric villains.

The characters are very charismatic.

Telling the twists in the plot is too spoilery, so I won't say it.

@Nurguburu why ask me these questions ?

@Absurdo_N thank you, but I see that fire force is not getting a lot of votes here :(

Btw people are always toxic on these threads and on MAL in general that's why I don't comment here :(

@Yaaceen ....

Ok. You said you are going to leave the site the previous year so I'm curious of why now you ask this lol. Besides you didn't answer why you put Ao Ashi if you ask about shounen.

@Yaaceen

It's sad that there is so much toxicity, but there's not much you can do to avoid it, just ignore certain comments.

It's sad Fire Force got few votes, it's a very fun and very creative show.

@Nurguburu for ao ashi i added it coz from what i watched (anime) it appealed to me that it's clearly a shonen (maybe the manga is more mature i don't know).
And for what I said previous year: I said I leave commenting here yes , not leaving the database system (bty, did you know it by reading my profil or you just remember me and my drama last year ? (Between us,the reaction of people then hurt me).

@Absurdo_N for fire force what about the anime? And comparison with the manga

@Yaaceen Seinen and shounen have nothing to do with appealing to their respective demographic or enjoyed only by people of that demographic, many adults enjoy shounen and many teenagers enjoy seinen. Even I can see why Major is shounen and Ookiku Furikabutte is seinen even if both are baseball sports. Some series cannot be classified as seinen, shounen, josei or shoujo. And I remember you from a locked thread which annoyed me.

@Yaaceen Seinen and shounen have nothing to do with appealing to their respective demographic or enjoyed only by people of that demographic, many adults enjoy shounen and many teenagers enjoy seinen. Even I can see why Major is shounen and Ookiku Furikabutte is seinen even if both are baseball sports. Some series cannot be classified as seinen, shounen, josei or shoujo. And I remember you from a locked thread which annoyed me.

@Nurguburu can you explain me please why did you enjoy fate a lot and not kara no kyoukai ? (You also stopped watching it after the 5th movie like I did).

@Yaaceen Besides I'm more exposed to Fate since I was a kid (I watched Zero as a kid lol), Fate lore and characters are generally better and more interesting. I think KnK work better as a mystery show but it doesn't help KnK are only movies unlike Fate. It's hard to connect to KnK characters due movie length (I just forget I didn't rate the 5th movie lol)

@BigBoyAdvance What do you suggest instead? which is similar to shonen but mature, and without forcing itself to be mature, as the majority do.

@BigBoyAdvance What do you suggest instead? which is similar to shonen but mature, and without forcing itself to be mature, as the majority do.

@Yaaceen Season 1 of vinland saga is pretty battle shounen-y in a lot of ways.

or you could for something like beastars which even though its a shounen, feels a lot more like a seinen taking place in highschool.

@APolygons2

Vinland Saga started publishing as shonen manga it later switched to a seinen magazine.

@MichaelJackson I know all this ty but its well known that when we say just "shonen" everybody understand that it means battle shonen.
And it's nothing wrong to add many survival mangas to my list (like you) but i clearly meant that at the moment I need to change style , before one day I read another survival one.