| Why do you let other people's opinion dictate how you personally feel about a show? O.o It's someone's right to hate all they want just as it is a right for you to enjoy something all you want, just ignore the "haters" (which for some reason include people with legitimate criticisms...) and like what you like, unless they're personally going on your page and bullying the hell out of you, I don't see any reason to get mad. Jesus Christ, if you run on this logic god help you if literally anyone in your life has the slightest dislike for ya, must be a pain in the ass to wake up in the morning. =.= |
  |
Gazz said: i actually agree bro like many people are saying that the animation is bad yeah it sucks ass but just because they are saying it,it doesn't mean that something is going to Change i am sick of all This negativity the animation Isn't even that badCan you JC Staff haters here stop ruining this anime? I know manga readers is expecting too much because of how awesome manga art is on battle scenes, but you guys are just nitpicking. The animation is ofcourse not perfect but hey its not that bad. Its even above vs other action anime. You guys talking like Madhouse is creating the best animation. Have you even see how ugly their CGI is on Overlord? That's Madhouse for you! https://www.reddit.com/r/overlord/comments/9jcyur/overlord_fans_complaining_about_bad_cgi/ Let us anime-only-watchers enjoy our damn show. I'm thankful JC Staff adapt this anime while your Madhouse is focus on their overrated Overlord show. I watch for the story. And so far its good with still a lot of room for improvement. Worth the wait. Again..., to those people who hate this season 2.  |
Monarch-Reli said: Why do you let other people's opinion dictate how you personally feel about a show? I'm trying to ignore all of the negativity surrounding the animation of One Punch Man but its too much its getting on my nerves. You see, I'm that person who watch an anime for the story, not animation or fight choreography. For a non manga reader, I couldnt be much happier that someone adapted the OPM. |
 |
| Episode 3 is out and same animation as always. Not the perfect 11/10 but its pretty good. The tank top battle and vs Golden Ball are good (atleast in my opinion). Its on the level of some Hero Academia fighting scenes. P.S. Genos still look ugly though. |
|
| I agree with @gazz who cares about good animation. The story isnthe important part. If you had to chose between both i think i know what you’d chose. I do think tha cg is often SHI—-IIIIIIT. But they use it to save time. It isn’t a reason to hate an anime. (There are exeption. One which i can think bout right now but won’t mention) ... i assume there has to be a steady release of anime but not enough time. Of course, I’m no expert but I’ll enjoy what i have. If i or you don’t like it then i leave it. Hating NEVER solves the problem. If you don’t get that— then i say “wake up”. Blah blah blah you get it move on... have a good day! |
Overlord has more plot than OPM tho... And that's not really Madhouse for the first season... |
| I don’t know how anyone can be okay with a second season looking worse than the first, especially after 3-4 years. As far as I’m concerned, this production is a disaster and the nail in the coffin of One Punch Man ever getting an adaptation that does it justice. I just can’t believe how ugly and poorly made it is... |
Modernoir said: It's stunning to see how many people are so willing to accept mediocrity. Why even watch the anime when the manga is better in every way? The anime has around a minute of actual animation per episode so far, it's such a far-cry from season 1 it's hilarious. Why do people default to the "be grateful we even got it!!!" bullshit line of reasoning? We'd waited years and people are still okay with them soullessly rushing everything? Don't be sheep, you morons, at least we still have the great manga and webcomic but nothing pisses me off more right now than thinking that J.C. are going to butcher the Elder Centipede fight, which was nothing but pure art in the manga. It's honestly insane how many people are willing to pay for a product then use the "grateful" mentality as if it was a gift. It's a product being purchased, it's quality should be scrutinized. It's art, it's quality should be scrutinized. Do they think they will receive better quality by throwing their money at shit? No, it just sets the standard lower every time they do it. Express disdain, tell these studios we don't want their shit. Tell them to improve or die. They'll improve before they die, that is the way of business. Accepting mediocrity is just harming the industry's quality and harming your own hobby. It's a Lose-Lose, no one wins except for studios cutting corners to maximize profits. I wonder if these same people would thank a chef for serving them a literal shit log on a plate after ordering a filet mignon? |
on 
| It's not hating, what's the point of an adaptation if it's worse than the source material, and it's only normal to expect a certain quality when season 1 was a magnificent adaptation. It's not about manga vs anime, you as an anime only watcher should be expecting the same quality as before too. |
| Well, if you think anime-only watchers are "fine" with the quality of the second season, you're very damn wrong. I'm an anime-only watcher, but the animation quality is disgusting me, because I keep comparing it with the first season, I can't help it. I decided to watch it because I wanna know the story and have some laughs every now and then, but I always have this weird feeling when watching the anime, it's not good, the haters definitely have a point. |
| I haven't gotten started on S2 yet (just picked back up the manga and i'm on vol. 14). Is the JC attempt really that bad? |
| You're bashing Madhouse just because of one or two shows they animated badly, but dude have you even seen, besides OPM S1, HxH 2011 or Death Note's animation? Plus, I think I'm not the only one that's starting to get tired of these threads... |
| OPM S1 was a once in a lifetime combination of talent amassing the hottest names in the industry at the time that have all moved on. You weren't getting that again for a S2 no matter what. Stop complaining. Madhouse is average most of the time to above average to great. OPM S1 was a rare great, boogiepop is above average and quite good as well. Manga readers, you're seriously the people who complain always. It gets tiresome. The entitled complaining after we just learned someone at Madhouse collapsed from overwork, amazing. |
| IKR!? Manga readers are just perfectionist elitist who won't have it either way, they'll just find some path to hate and rag on about the show quality comparing to it, you know what? the manga itself looks BAD compared to the anime dare i say. JC staff surely outdid themselves by putting quality product to the fans of the show |
 |
ovo4 said: deg said: character animation on Boogiepop was usually poor compared to the character animation of One Punch Man season 1 that have mostly the same talented staff, people are not expecting battle animation for that anime like you are claiming OPM s1 didn’t have that much good Character acting scenes(although it wasn’t really the main focus). But boogiepop did have some here and there (especially episode 10 and 18). Also not all of the OPM staff was apart of boogiepop. Some of them went to mob psycho 100 it did not have much but it has still more character acting scenes than Boogiepop and ye i know thats why i said the keyword "mostly" have the same talented staff ovo4 said: deg said: err im sure you know character animation is much easier to draw for talented animators like the one that did Boogiepop and One Punch Man season 1 anime but that did not happen in Boogiepop because of the news saying they got a big production schedule issue think about it whats the point of having talented staff working on Boogiepop if they do not care about making it look good anyway you are only basing your reasoning on your own terms Actually character animation is just as hard as action/fx animation. Most of the people on OPM s1 were fx and background animation specialists who work on action shows so character animation in a series like boogiepop would be out of their comfort zone. Add to that the fact that they had only 3 months to make 18 episodes, it certainly didn’t make things easier for them i know that there are character animators specialists but im mainly pointing out the good character animation stuff like those that can be seen on OPM S1 and that is the point im making why they are contracted to do Boogiepop when it requires more character animation stuff then and ye i know about the production time problem that Boogiepop had |
| Big Facts. Holy shit I was waiting for someone to say this. |
Iskandar87 said: You're bashing Madhouse just because of one or two shows they animated badly, but dude have you even seen, besides OPM S1, HxH 2011 or Death Note's animation? Plus, I think I'm not the only one that's starting to get tired of these threads... Good point. But do you really believe that if Madhouse animated this season 2 instead of JC Staff, it would have been a lot better? As in, 300% better? (Coz thats what some guys saying. Season 1 was good, imagine 3 years after where animation is more advance) Me personally, not. Like I said above, Madhouse recently had a series of shit CGI animations. Hell, I'll even prefer MAPPA than madhouse coz theyre on fire. Not yet on the level of prime Madhouse or Bones but every year, theyre getting good. click here for the MAPPA's Inuyashiki scene I believe JC Staff is doing the best they can. And each episode, its getting better overall. JC staff deserves the praise for this project. |
|
| Not all manga readers are JC Staff haters. A title like that is just gonna attract even more haters. Don't tell us what and what not to do. |
| How is this whiny, inflammatory thread now locked yet? In fact, you do realize it ain't even just the manga readers shitting on this show, right? It's also the people who...are critical of anime visuals in general (all of whom have already demolished the visuals of all 3 Overlord anime in great detail). That's cuz this show looks pretty bad, and I mean, bad enough to look worse than a lot of non-action anime that have aired within these past 6 months. tbf yea some people are sorta dumb saying "JC Staff ruined everything" and "if Madhouse or even the OG team came back, this anime would look amazing" when really, they're sorta blaming the entity and not those who mismanage it, and given how bad the visuals (especially the artwork and designs) for Boogiepoop 2019, a show Madhouse and the OG OPM team worked on look terrible, it's clear that the latter wouldn't necessarily be the case. Plus, people are tearing apart the visuals of the two new Madhouse shows...at least the few people who are watching them are... |
| Being wrong is just an occupational hazard. Follow me on twitter. I have an anitube channel so feel free to check it out and subscribe if you like what you see. |
Gazz said: Can you JC Staff haters here stop ruining this anime? I know manga readers is expecting too much because of how awesome manga art is on battle scenes, but you guys are just nitpicking. The animation is ofcourse not perfect but hey its not that bad. Its even above vs other action anime. You guys talking like Madhouse is creating the best animation. Have you even see how ugly their CGI is on Overlord? That's Madhouse for you! https://www.reddit.com/r/overlord/comments/9jcyur/overlord_fans_complaining_about_bad_cgi/ Let us anime-only-watchers enjoy our damn show. I'm thankful JC Staff adapt this anime while your Madhouse is focus on their overrated Overlord show. I watch for the story. And so far its good with still a lot of room for improvement. Worth the wait. Again..., to those people who hate this season 2. You... and threads like these is what's wrong with the MAL community. Just a bunch of whiny kids. |
| "You can't spell slaughter without laughter". |
Gazz said: Iskandar87 said: You're bashing Madhouse just because of one or two shows they animated badly, but dude have you even seen, besides OPM S1, HxH 2011 or Death Note's animation? Plus, I think I'm not the only one that's starting to get tired of these threads... Good point. But do you really believe that if Madhouse animated this season 2 instead of JC Staff, it would have been a lot better? As in, 300% better? (Coz thats what some guys saying. Season 1 was good, imagine 3 years after where animation is more advance) Me personally, not. Like I said above, Madhouse recently had a series of shit CGI animations. Hell, I'll even prefer MAPPA than madhouse coz theyre on fire. Not yet on the level of prime Madhouse or Bones but every year, theyre getting good. click here for the MAPPA's Inuyashiki scene I believe JC Staff is doing the best they can. And each episode, its getting better overall. JC staff deserves the praise for this project. J.C. Staff is not doing it badly, just they're not at OPM S1 level and that's why most people are disappointed. Animation quality is closely related to production schedules and talented staff, basically. It doesn't really matter how good the studio is if they have to animate a big amount of shows every season, one episode per week, since the animation will be most likely bad. If Madhouse paid the same staff to animate OPM S2, I'm quite sure they would have brought us another masterpiece regarding animation unless their production schedule was fucked up (like most studios). |
| It really doesn't matter whether you love, hate, like, or dislike this series of OPM 2. We all have our opinions, and that's completely fine, but it doesn't seem like either side is trying to at least attempt to understand the other and merely dismiss it. That isn't something one side can just claim the other is doing. It really isn't good that people that don't like OPM 2 are completely disregarding people who do in fact enjoy it despite it's flaws, but how are you any different if you're just gonna dismiss the criticisms and call it nitpicking? You're telling people to accept your opinion when you aren't willing to accept theirs. The actual show in question is pretty irrelevant. Seriously, you all are being dumb about this. Disagreements can be done in a civil manner. To the people who hate this season, you can do so without alienating those that do enjoy it. To you people that try to go against the haters, you can at least do so after acknowledging and understanding what it is these people are trying to say. |
 |
Hime03 said: BRUTALOCLES said: I haven't gotten started on S2 yet (just picked back up the manga and i'm on vol. 14). Is the JC attempt really that bad? No. Well yes and no. Ep 3 has given me hope thats its going to be really good I was watching a bit of S2;episode 1 last night. It's definitely noticeable but it wasn't supremely awful and didn't compromise the experience of watching the show (so far). |
| so basically what you're saying is this: |
 |
Recycled_Content said: Yea that. It's a mix of being laughable and embarrassing, even as someone who will stomp on this show any chance I get. If people are being toxic, they're being toxic, no matter which side of the issue they're on. Still more interesting than the show itself, which is not exactly a good thing.I just find it ironic that both sides are so entrenched in their own camps that they are bitterly duking it out over whenever its flaws are brought up. sure i agree that the story is as good if not better than s1, having an arc with a goal in mind does wonders to make something more interesting and attention grabing, but the pruduct feels off on a direction framework. its clunky and messy at times, so while i can still enjoy it it does detract from it. honestly i just enjoy seeing people getting salty and mad over the scores that something like this provides, never ending source of entertainment. might be even more entertaining than the show itself, to see its fans take shots at each other. its just pathetic tbh, but considering how this is merely a internet forum where strangers rant about cartoons and other hobbies they share. just learn to not take opinions from others so seriously to heart man. |
| Being wrong is just an occupational hazard. Follow me on twitter. I have an anitube channel so feel free to check it out and subscribe if you like what you see. |
turbulent said: At the same time, you began to nitpick on Madhouse for it's animation made on another show which had nothing to do with this topic. You have already exposed yourself by giving the impression that you are a fan of JC staff and this thread is simply made for that purpose, not for One Punch Man S2. Even your first paragraph gave this impression that you are a fan of JC staff. Honestly I actually find it ironic that most of these fans bashed Madhouse for made some bad animation, and yet they praised J.C Staff for doing the same thing lol. |
MahiaErebeaNegiMay 18, 2019 9:36 AM
| In the beginning I thought I'd watch it for the story, but they have ruined everything. |
 |
| hmmm.agreed #for the plot |
| It's awful man, the series went from a nice 8.71 to a humiliating 7.9. Just goes to show how much JC. staff messed up this one. |
 |
| Don't compare madhouse with jc staff , just cause you're a fanboy , OP. JC STAFF fucked up the animation , and that's the truth. OPM season 2 is mediocre at best. |
DomineLkiraMay 19, 2019 4:45 AM
DomineLkira said: OPM season 2 is decent at best. You meant mediocre at best lol. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jul 2, 2019 |
389 |
by THEBIGNOODLER
»»
Apr 10, 2:30 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )xShinigami3125 - Jun 25, 2019 |
200 |
by Craneface
»»
Mar 28, 2:52 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )xShinigami3125 - May 7, 2019 |
244 |
by scorpioniclibra
»»
Mar 14, 3:26 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 2nd Season Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )xShinigami3125 - Apr 23, 2019 |
367 |
by Dr_tardo
»»
Feb 21, 6:24 PM |
|
» Bro deadass nearly diedMei-o_Scarlett - Jan 17 |
3 |
by Mei-o_Scarlett
»»
Jan 17, 3:07 AM |