| - Relatable - Enjoyable - Interesting plot - Remember-able character - Nice animation to an extent - Meaningful - Leaves an affect on me |
| It just has to be better than any other anime I've seen, even with its imperfections. |
 |
| I give 10 to all anime on my favorite list, except one piece. |
| I haven't given a 10 yet but If I do then it will be something truly special. |
| I give 10s to all anime I really like. |
 |
| I’m not too harsh when giving anime 10s but I do have certain things I look for: 1. Did this anime change me or inspire me? (ex A Place Further Then The Universe (a 10/10 as of airing)) 2. Did this anime have a likable cast all around? (ex Haruhi Suzumiya, K-On!) 3. Did this anime make me think? (ex A Silent Voice) Is it overall a 10/10 experience that I would recommend to anybody? That’s what I look for. That being said I would consider any anime I rate 9/10 to be a favorite as well, just not one that Id recommend to everybody |
| My standards for a 10/10 anime are that I have no standards for anything and anyone, anything is a 10/10 but at the same time nothing is, and the reason for this is because who actually cares about how other people score things. |
| every single one of my forum posts is dumb and invalid except for 1, I don't claim them it was a different person it was all fake |
| Well I haven't rated anything with 10/10 for me to do that the show would have to be perfectly entertaining and keep me invested for the entire run time witch is something that hasn't occurred up until now |
| To give an anime 10/10, it needs to have a few things: 1) A very good plot; 2) Character development; 3) A good dose of action; 4) And it needs to keep all of the above through all the episodes. But I can appreciate an anime even if it's not a 10/10 |
 |
| 10/10 for me is the kind of anime that I can rewatch and still enjoy it. |
| It must be on Death Note, Ping Pong The Animation and Kaiji level |
 |
Lalakoboldslayer said: To give an anime 10/10, it needs to have a few things: 1) A very good plot; 2) Character development; 3) A good dose of action; 4) And it needs to keep all of the above through all the episodes. But I can appreciate an anime even if it's not a 10/10 Gundam Seed has only the 3), and just barely. The plot barely holds together and is a poor and uninspired copying of older gundam series, while characters are horrible and inconsistent, and their development, especially going into Destiny, is just bad. |
 |
| If everything is fuwa fuwa and kira kira I'll rate it 10/10 |
| if I like the anime a lot, I give it a 10 |
| For me 10/10 isn't flawless, it just has to hit two or more of these expectations Cried / Felt depressed Pure nostalgic bias Hilarious as heck Its just really really good |
  |
| I hardly ever give a 10/10 rating. But my standards would be that it must have a good cast of characters and maintain my inteterest throughout the series. That’s what makes a great anime. |
Imaishi said: Lalakoboldslayer said: To give an anime 10/10, it needs to have a few things: 1) A very good plot; 2) Character development; 3) A good dose of action; 4) And it needs to keep all of the above through all the episodes. But I can appreciate an anime even if it's not a 10/10 Gundam Seed has only the 3), and just barely. The plot barely holds together and is a poor and uninspired copying of older gundam series, while characters are horrible and inconsistent, and their development, especially going into Destiny, is just bad. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. What a beautiful world we live. |
LalakoboldslayerMar 15, 2018 2:54 AM
|
| 1. Rewatchable 2. enjoyable 3. Enjoyable the 5th time. Normally I rate anime higher based on: Character Design Good Music Having an ending Standards on Hentai: No rape between the main pairing Liking the main characters Character design Humor Slice of Life Standards: Is it as good as Bambi? |
Energetic-NovaMar 15, 2018 2:13 AM
The anime community in a nutshell.  |
| it has to be an anime which truly made me feel something else, even with it's flaws that it had i was able to ignore them, maybe even crying over how good it was that also left a void to some extent. the reasons as to why fmab and gurren lagann are my only 10s. |
Edward Elric > your waifu  |
| I generally give pretty high overall scores for anime and manga, however, I only have two that I have ever rated 10/10. Looking back at them there is nothing that sticks out as making it FLAWLESS. I can criticize my ten rated anime/manga heavily but it is the ability to make me overlook these issues and walk away from a series feeling completely happy and satisfied that warrants a 10/10 |
| A 10/10 anime for me are those that transcended and did a better job at any aspects of what the majority of anime haven't done or achieved. |
ChiisaiInu said: I take the MAL rating system serious and find too many people rate everything from 5-10 usually 8-10. I find these people to be either dishonest, ignorant of how a rating system works, or that I just cant take them seriously when they rate or review something. Personally unless your new to anime if your mean score is 7+ I think your doing something wrong. There is no wrong way to rate anime. The reason behind the difference in rating method is difference in interpretation of the little words next to the score. According to those little words next to the score 4 = bad 5 = average 6 = Fine 7 = good 8 = very good 9 = great Imagine a person think almost every anime he have seen is great. Then an "average (5) anime" for him is basically the same thing as a "great (9) anime". It would make sense for him to spread his score at both 5 or 9. However, even the meaning of "average" is comparative, "bad" (4) and "fine" (6) are not. A "very good" anime to a person can be below average ("comparatively bad"), but it couldn't be just "bad", so it won't make sense for that person to spread his score around 5 instead of 9. I am a person who takes the later approach (literal interpretation). So I'm rating starting from 6, because if I finish watching an anime, it is definitely at least fine (6), even though it can be comparatively bad. Just like food, if I'm eating it, it is at least fine, even though it could taste comparatively bad. |
nbyung09Mar 16, 2018 3:04 AM
| There are some things that make an anime perfect i.e. 10/10 for me, 1. A compelling plot which makes you think and not just follow along 2. Relatable characters and higher the number, the better 3. Must bring out an emotional reaction from me quite often 4. Fabulous art, an intriguing world and settings 5. Some kind of a message expressed as a whole, I prefer positive ones. As some observation, all the anime I have rated 10 have amazing OPs, EDs and soundtrack but the reverse scenario is not true. They also have a higher number of episodes i.e. 20+ because I like my pace slower, multiple seasons is fine too. There is always a romantic subplot that pays off in the end, its satisfying to see a ship sail. But of course many anime can have all that and I still not feel it, so the final point still depends on a feeling. A feeling that it is worth a 10! |
on 
Pullman said: It has to start with Cowboy and end with Bebop and not much in between tbh. Either this, or starts with Black and ends with Lagoon. |
 |
| A 10/10 for me is an anime where I can't find any flaws, I actually feel heavy emotions and of course enjoy it a lot. It makes me think and might actually change me as a person or make me realize what kind of person I am. Apart from that, as these are also the criteria I have for a 9/10, it just has to feel like I can't give it deserves less than a 10. I do put great consideration into this though because they are the cream of the crop to me and even when decided I question myself if it's really the only justified score. Usually the highest score I give is a 9. |
 |
| i use mals term "masterpiece". if it is a masterpiece it gets the 10. it doesn't have to be my favorite, it just has to have a really good plot with great characters and not be boring even slightly. i have plenty of 10s |
 |
| I would give an anime 10 if I enjoyed it so much that I end up rewatching it again and again. |
| cute girls, hot girls, sexy girls, fanservice |
   |
| I didn't give many 10s, but for me there's not much difference between a 9 and a 10. I also don't go on every thread and praise them to high heavens. But if I rate an anime with a 9 or a 10 then I really liked the story, characters, art/animation, and soundtrack. That's available for an 8 too, except maybe I got too annoyed by a character or something. |
| Something that is consistent and extremely enjoyable to watch, even multiple times, and is prone to be a subject to discuss about because there are so many topics, chars and/or scenes worth talking about. |
| some series make me wanna give more than a 10, so I scaled down the numbers to reserve 10s for those over-the-top ratings. 10 is more accessible than the ∞ sign. |
 |
| Not sure. I don't rate things since I think it's kind of silly, but the best things I've seen, heard, or read usually evoke some sort of emotional response from me. Something physical that excites me or moves me in some way. Or maybe something that gets me to think about something in a totally different way. Something revolutionary. |
 |
| 10 gives me what I want with no bullshit. I wanted something like "Love Stage!!" but with girls, and Citrus delivered. Sakura Trick didn't have enough drama, so it only got an 8 from me. |
 |
| For me 8-10 are similar but something about a 9 appeals to me more then a 8 and same for a 9 to 10. I give out 8-10s more easily because most of the shows I watch I enjoy. |
| 10/10 is awesome story, or made me feel alot of things.... a glorious work of art EDIT: ah yes impact ... thats the word. like how hard are you gonna hit me 9 is a 10 with flaws or just not unique enough 8 and below is anime. its just stuff made to be entertainment |
kisbMar 16, 2018 7:03 PM
| Must meet these requirements: - It fits my preferences of the type of anime I like (which is usually action, super power,...) - Have the ability to easily move my emotion (no matter if it is intended or not) - I don't find any of the main cast annoying - I find myself very attached to one or more of the main cast (and other major characters) - The relationship between the characters must be deep and great enough to born a new OTP - Glorious music to add to epic moments is a plus - Distinctive and somewhat original story in it's own way - Must contain some form of bromance or very deep or complicated bond between the main cast - Has multiple epic, unforgettable moments - I find myself extremely hyped everytime I watch it - I find myself rewatch it unlimited times - I find myself buried in it's meta, theories, character analysis, fanarts, fanvids, fanfics, doujinshis for years to come |
 OTP: KidLaw | IzuKatsu | GureShin | EruRi | AoKi | See more!» My art » My translation » Doujinshi collection » Favorite Kurobas doujinshi  BISHIES X RAP |
| The ones i count as my favourite, ones which i binged all night and enjoyed the most |
 ☆ Set by Nate ☆ |
| if my enjoyment is a 10/10 mostly? But also when an anime hit me so hard that all my emotions are on the ground, and I felt like I got stabbed in the heart maybe, or just when I reeeally love a good lineup of characters in the show, good characters certainly make a good anime, doesn't matter if the plot is good or not. Like HxH 2011 wasn't a 10/10 only because of plot, it's a very simple plot, but the characters and everything the show was all about, the arcs and the awesome choreographed fight scenes made up for everything. |
 |
| All a 10/10 anime needs to do for me is to move me in some way or the other. Flaws and problems I have with it are instantly nullified and relegated to unimportance if it manages to do that. I don't believ in valuing negatives and positives equally. So if a show manages to do that then I'll immediately baptize it with a 10. Well, that or be Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei which I can't stop flinging tens at for some reason. The above, however, has only ever happened with one show. |
 |
| I don't really have a clear and definite description for a 10/10 show, even if I had one it'd have to be a very broad definition as I don't think being deep, thought-provoking, philosophical or having compelling characters and a well-written plot is a prerequisite for a 10/10 show like many do. For me a 10/10 show is a show that engaged me in a way that none ever did, one that I want to return to for years to come. |
 |
| Resisting the urge to quote people and say toxic shit about their favorites |
More topics from this board
» Who are your allies in the anime industry/community?Catalano - May 1 |
35 |
by Rinrinka
»»
29 seconds ago |
|
» name a non-anime you think is better than 80% of animeKenzolo-folk - 5 hours ago |
30 |
by zckfox
»»
44 seconds ago |
|
» Gurren Lagann & KlK creator said "Fanservice in anime is necessary, else humanity will disappear"Dije - 9 hours ago |
41 |
by TheMechaManiac
»»
46 seconds ago |
|
» what kind of fashionarhttr - May 13 |
18 |
by Rinrinka
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » What type of manga -> anime adaptation do you preferVentus_S - 8 hours ago |
9 |
by zckfox
»»
6 minutes ago |