Forum Settings
Pages (3) [1] 2 3 »
Post New Reply
Mar 13, 5:59 PM

Joined: May 2017
Posts: 42
I don't consider myself the harshest critic but I do take my rating style pretty seriously. So while I do give a lot of 8s and 9s (which by my standards is still fairly high).. I don't give out a lot of 10s.

A 10 for me isn't necessarily "flawless", just that said series had little to no flaws that bothered or annoyed me. Also it had to be a series that I considered a piece of art that really resonated with me on a personal and emotional level. Like the kind of stuff that constantly had me in awe time and time again and never had a dull moment. And just never left my mind months (even years after watching) because the impression it had on me was so great.

Lastly, the Anime has to be complete with a proper ending that ties up all loose ends! Leaving nothing more to be desired because it had a satisfying payoff!

How do y'all decide if an Anime is a 10/10?
Mar 13, 6:11 PM

Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 6612
A rare fusion of entertainment and quality that I felt was either extremely enjoyable or meaningful to watch (like 4% of what I've watched). The story was fantastic, the characters were likable to the point where it made me get emotionally attached and care about what was going on, it was well made, and it ended conclusively or satisfyingly.
Modified by Kruszer, Mar 13, 6:28 PM
"All heroes eventually die of overwork."
-Ikta Solork (Alderamin on the Sky)

Mar 13, 6:14 PM

Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 551
1: a compelling plot
2: a finished story (the story has to have a proper ending by the end of the series)
3: good characters
4: enjoyable to watch
5: a minimum of 20 episodes
If the anime meets those criteria than I will consider giving it a 10.
out of the 169 shows i have completed I have a total of 6 shows that I gave a 10
Modified by Fakegoose, Mar 13, 6:22 PM

"Do you know why snow is white? 
Because it's forgotten what color it's supposed to be." - C.C.

Mar 13, 6:15 PM

Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 1223
Very rare and almost non-existent in my standard. Not even my favorite anime is 'perfect' either.

In short, I don't have any shows I rated a 10.

Mar 13, 6:20 PM

Joined: May 2009
Posts: 3188
I don't currently use the 10. My rating scale presently only goes up to 9.

The 9 for me represents a series that I love, and didn't give me enough qualms to drop it to an 8.

Compare 7, which means I like it, but not to the intensity of loving it. A 5 is a meh, a 3 is a dislike, and a 1 is a hate.
Mar 13, 6:20 PM

Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 1294
it has to be the best of all time to be a 10/10

Mar 13, 6:22 PM

Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 29346
It has to start with Cowboy and end with Bebop and not much in between tbh.

StephenCovey said:
Most of us don't listen with the intent to understand, they listen with the intent to reply.

Mar 13, 6:25 PM
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 392
Just give it a 10 if you really want to, there's no need to think it out.
"When you die, everybody knows you are dead, except you. It's the same when you have shit taste."

Mar 13, 6:30 PM

Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 11
I don't think too much about my ratings, but I save 10s for anime that has had an impact on my life.

Objectively, I don't think all - or perhaps even most - of my 10s deserve a 10, but for me, they're irreplaceable.

caution- we're coming for your head
so call the feds and get files to shred
every textbook read said bring you the bread
but guess what we got you instead

Mar 13, 6:34 PM

Joined: Apr 2017
Posts: 2604
Terrific storytelling
Incredible character development
Tense drama
Superb art style

"The Senators and Representatives shall receive a Compensation for their Services, to be ascertained by Law, and paid out of the Treasury of the United States. They shall in all Cases, except Treason, Felony and Breach of the Peace, be privileged from Arrest during their Attendance at the Session of their respective Houses, and in going to and returning from the same; and for any Speech or Debate in either House, they shall not be questioned in any other Place.."
Mar 13, 6:39 PM
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 85
If a series was entertaining from start to finish. If I love the world,characters and plot. And if I believe it was well made and high in quality.
Mar 13, 6:43 PM
Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 673
This is my personal definition that I wrote in my profile of an anime I would personally rate a 10/10:

"10: This anime completely captured my heart, and I loved everything about it (characters, animation, writing, etc)! I often binge-watch most animes I rate a 10 just because I love it too much to stop, LOL. I would recommend this to everyone. I would definitely rewatch it over and over again."

It's quite simple but that's because I'm not really a critic. I usually rate animes based on my overall enjoyment while watching it. xD
Modified by chareexnicole, Mar 13, 6:54 PM
Mar 13, 6:45 PM

Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 596
When a series manage to capture exactly what I wanted from it.
Mar 13, 7:40 PM

Joined: Aug 2015
Posts: 262
i know that it may be absurd but one of the main standard for an 10 on 10 anime for me is that it should be quite an emotional show.hence Angel beats,Natsume Yuujinchou, Anohana and Colorful(movie) are highly rated in my list
Mar 13, 7:47 PM

Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 4210
10 needs to have a memorable / developed cast, the story has to be thought out and have good structure, pacing ++ if small details are added along the way down the line for early readers, be the absolute best of its genre aka no other title can knock it out with better premise handling.

Added bonus if it made me cry, lots of 9's made me cry too but that'll usually solidify it.
Mar 13, 7:54 PM
Joined: Apr 2016
Posts: 184
For me a 10/10 is something I felt a strong emotional resonance with (Welcome to the NHK, Evangelion), something that I think about a lot and had an impact at the way I look at things (Haruhi and Evangelion again), or sometimes its just something thats really well produced and does what it does amazingly (The Chimera Ant Arc in Hunter X Hunter was reminiscent of something that in my head I wanted to see play out forever and the fact it did that in a very well made show and Nichijou is just really fucking and the fact that its so well animated and very comfortable feeling adds to it)
Mar 13, 7:56 PM
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 65
In my opinion there is no 10 out of 10 anime or any piece of media everything has a flaw where ever you look at it
Mar 13, 7:58 PM

Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 171
if the show makes me impatient like i wanted to finish the entire episodes as fast as i can because i can't wait to know what happened next because of its good story.
Mar 13, 7:59 PM

Joined: Aug 2014
Posts: 65
being a 10/10 anime

no need to thank me
Blood tastes like iron
Mar 13, 8:01 PM

Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 521
I've never rated an anime a 10/10.
Mostly because it lacks yuri, lolis, and incest.

gfl id - 33297
Mar 13, 8:03 PM

Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 156
If I enjoy it a lot, then I will give it a 10.
Mar 13, 8:04 PM

Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 866
There is no fixed standard, and it's very hard to describe as I rate them based on feeling.

But when I'm rating an anime 10/10, I'm definitely enjoying it thoroughly. They are usually comedies.
Mar 13, 8:04 PM

Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 162
I've never given an anime a 10/10 immediately after watching it. It may sound silly, but if I'm still awestruck about a particular anime many months after I've finished watching it, ill give it a 10. An anime has to resonate with me on an emotional level. And sometimes that takes awhile to sink in. Like you said OP, 10s aren't necessarily flawless, however for me it comes down to pure enjoyment. I don't hand out 10s very often, but when I do, I hold them in exceptionally high regards. Those are my standards for 10/10s.
Mar 13, 8:07 PM

Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 4
A 10/10 is an anime that inspires me and truly exemplifies what I love about the medium.
Has to strike me with masterful storytelling, amazing visuals and a memorable/well utilised soundtrack, but also resonate with me conceptually and thematically.

I usually find myself re-watching my favourite scenes from an anime shortly after finishing it, and a 10/10 will have a lot of these scenes, so much so that I'm virtually starting the whole series again.

I would probably be able to recommend these anime to anyone.
Modified by Zawren, Mar 13, 8:11 PM
Mar 13, 8:14 PM

Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 140
Out of 300+ Anime I have completed that I can remember I think only 3 have a 10 rating? For me a 10 rating is something that is profound and leaves an impact. Also I tend to give favor to anime that have original idea's and themes. For example Shin Sekai Yori. The show starts off in a bit of a lull but takes us on a fantastic joyride into the supernatural as well as makes us consider the rules we as a society impose on others. The theme IMO is original, the artwork is well done and doesn't need flash to make itself known. The soundtrack is memorable to be sure, and the characters for me were unique and real.

I take the MAL rating system serious and find too many people rate everything from 5-10 usually 8-10. I find these people to be either dishonest, ignorant of how a rating system works, or that I just cant take them seriously when they rate or review something. Personally unless your new to anime if your mean score is 7+ I think your doing something wrong.
Mar 13, 8:20 PM

Joined: May 2017
Posts: 18
There are so many people who spam 10 randomly.. but i take it very seriously.

Perfection for me means 9 honestly. the jump from 9 to 10 is something very hard and that i have to feel inside.. Must be a godly creation that let you think about it, complicated in many aspects that make me say WOW. If i put a 10 it totally means i will never forget it and will leave something forever inside me.

There are so many times i have watched something that in the end made me felt great.. but with passing of time you almost forget it. I haven't put any 10 to an anime yet, i have three 9 tho. My favourite is chihayafuru, i'm evening learing to play karuta but i felt to put 9, about death note i think the second part doesn't deserve a 10. And shingeki well... for now is 9.. might change later when i get to discover everything about titans

the visual novel steins;gate is the only 10 i put in my life. While i voted G-senjou no maou 9,5 because some common route is boring, but the true route is 10/10 100%
A person's life is not comprised of four repeating season, but a year-long winter wilderness, whether or not you stop to wipe your blood or tears, they will inevitably freeze over.
Mar 13, 8:29 PM

Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 412
I only have one criteria for a 10: I enjoyed that show more than Your Lie in April and Slam Dunk. Not both shows together, but individually enjoyed.
Mar 13, 9:03 PM

Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 248
I'm not hyper critical. I watch Anime to be entertained. So if it ebtertains or intrigues me in any way possible then that usually helps the score.

How I rate my animes depends on hiw I found the story, characters, animation and entertainment or intrigue value.

I love a good anime that draws me in and makes me ponder whatd gonna happen next.

Or an anime that flat out makes me laugh or smile or just enjoy whats happening.
Mar 13, 9:18 PM
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 4
In my opinion, there's no such thing as a 10/10 anime.
Mar 13, 9:26 PM

Joined: Aug 2015
Posts: 1299
my standards are that i have to enjoy it a lot
Mar 13, 9:28 PM

Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 178
A 9 for me is already pretty much near perfect, going above and beyond to craft a masterpiece that sticks with me. But a 10 needs to go even further than what is essentially perfection to get that score, it needs to really delve deep and hit me hard, personally. I need to be hit so hard intellectually or emotionally that I think about it all the time after and it becomes something that shapes who I am.
Mar 13, 9:35 PM

Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 728
if i like it a lot its a 10.
if im going to seriously rate it tho thats a different story, because no matter how i want to convince myself re zero deserves a 10 at the end of the day its not a 10 show

but then again its how i rate shows if i like what i gave it then i keep the score i gave it. if i give a show a 9 but know deep down it deserves a 7, screw that im going to give it a 9 because its my rating lmao not yours
Do not stick dick in crazy.
Mar 13, 9:41 PM
I Have Enough

Joined: May 2014
Posts: 483
OfLove111 said:
10: Something I consider nearly perfect and/or something I enjoyed far too much to give it a lesser score. It doesn't need to have high production values to reach the second requirement, but it can't have any serious flaws. These are the shows where it's likely I would seek out to buy merchandise, DVDs/blu-ray, and/or manga. I wouldn't mind dropping whatever I'm doing to rewatch at least some of it.

Yeah, that means I give out 10s more often than they deserve, but eh, well.

i don't know where and i don't know when
but i know we'll be lovers again
i'll see you some day before the end
oh darling my hearts on fire
for you graph
Mar 13, 9:43 PM

Joined: Dec 2016
Posts: 220
discussions about scores or how people score are absolutely the most boring shit
Mar 13, 9:58 PM

Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 4173
It just have to blow all my preconceptions of what is good and just impress me a whole lot with whatever it has going for it. But that's actually harder nowadays since I'm becoming more jaded lol.
Mar 13, 10:02 PM

Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 5613
If I managed to fap to it at least 10 times, of course.
Mar 13, 10:08 PM
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 211
My rating is based on how much a show annoys me. It starts at 10 and goes down from there. I don't think that a 10 rating means that the show is perfect, but that it has no flaws that inherently put a damper on my enjoyment of the show.

I should also point out that I'm a pretty harsh critic. So, it's easy for a show to annoy me.
Mar 13, 10:12 PM

Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 1613
it's simple. which can satisfy me, make me feel speechless, and make me always remembered even though i've watched other anime. like me enchanted to give that high rating

"I don't mind. We'll take them on. Please start the match."
Mar 13, 10:15 PM

Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 1613
Rudan said:
discussions about scores or how people score are absolutely the most boring shit

indeed. agree with you. that's just people perception. can't argue with that shit.

"I don't mind. We'll take them on. Please start the match."
Mar 13, 10:33 PM

Joined: Oct 2015
Posts: 4032
A fusion of quality and an emotional connection to the show/manga. And that's why I only have 2 10s in my list.

Come love,
I'll shape you to be a fine man

Mar 14, 12:00 AM

Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 463
I don't know. I just feel like it deserves that rating based on my enjoyment of the show as a whole.

Help, I'm hooked into the Fate series (not all) and am obsessed with Shirou x Saber!
Also, forever hoping for a ufotable remake of the Fate route!
Mar 14, 12:13 AM
Joined: Feb 2018
Posts: 63
Something super fun that I would recommend to my friends.
Mar 14, 12:16 AM

Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 225
when i think that nothing can get any better than it, it's an instant 10
Mar 14, 12:20 AM

Joined: Mar 2016
Posts: 1132
10 - can ignore or love everything wrong with it
1 - can only see what's wrong with it
"I like young-girl sexual creations, Lolicon is just one hobby of my many hobbies," he says.
I ask what his wife, standing nearby, thinks of his "hobby".
"She probably thinks no problem," he replies. "Because she loves young boys sexually interacting with each other."
Mar 14, 12:23 AM

Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 843
Perfect story with no plotholes. The characters are good and understandable. Art is high quality.
Mar 14, 1:44 AM

Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 124
Well, if 10 means perfect anime, then there's no such thing. I have only given movie series is Kara no Kyoukai only because I want people to watch it and appreciate it even if they don't enjoy it. I think it's an anime what people need to experience.
Mar 14, 3:15 AM

Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 15883
anime that is top tier in one thing or another that greatly outweighs the negative parts
Mar 14, 3:26 AM

Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 74
I just have to like it, that’s all.

"Nothing can stay unchanged."
Mar 14, 6:37 AM

Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 2833
I don't use this system anymore, but this used to be my description of a 10/10 anime.

An irreplaceable rare pearl of this medium, with nearly non-existing flaws within. A phenomenal show that upon completing left me with that weird bittersweet aftertaste: the joy of witnessing something genuinely astonishing and the sorrow because that feeling couldn't have lasted forever. A resourceful project which has done what it was aspirating to do splendidly. Presented, executed and explored to its fullest potential, being an exceptional creation surpassing and transcending any boundaries of the medium. The sheer amount of entertainment I've received from watching it is beyond rational speak: every episode, every minute, every second have been an ultimate joy to watch.
Mar 14, 6:40 AM

Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 829
If i like it its a 10/10. ᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠᅠ
Pages (3) [1] 2 3 »