2018 Manga Reading Challenge - Discussion

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Fantasy_Land said:

Scarlett_ryuken said:

18) double arts
cardcaptor sakura
tokidoki
Marie no Kanaderu Ongaku

35)
tsukihime
hoshi no samidare

I like to know what item number you use for Marie no Kanaderu Ongaku

it's applicable for both
i used it for my challenge
and i gave it an 8, which is considered as highest rated

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 12, 2018 1:19 AM

#902

Offline

Dec 2016

246

Scarlett_ryuken said:

Fantasy_Land said:

I like to know what item number you use for Marie no Kanaderu Ongaku

it's applicable for both
i used it for my challenge
and i gave it an 8, which is considered as highest rated

Why I ask is because they want to know for what challenge you use it for

Apr 12, 2018 1:55 AM

#903

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Fantasy_Land said:

Scarlett_ryuken said:

it's applicable for both
i used it for my challenge
and i gave it an 8, which is considered as highest rated

Why I ask is because they want to know for what challenge you use it for

oh urm
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1696290&show=0#msg53605827
^check my challenge

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 13, 2018 9:27 AM

#904

EION

Offline

Mar 2013

121

I need some help with my only yaoi/shouen-ai manga challenge

47. Read a manga from the ones listed under manga relations in the Hidden Gem of Manga club
54. Read a manga by an author and artist duo
64. Read a manga adapted from light novel, video game or original anime
78. Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member

Thank you in advance!

Apr 13, 2018 7:41 PM

#905

Offline

Oct 2009

72

EION said:
I need some help with my only yaoi/shouen-ai manga challenge

47. Read a manga from the ones listed under manga relations in the Hidden Gem of Manga club
54. Read a manga by an author and artist duo
64. Read a manga adapted from light novel, video game or original anime
78. Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member

Thank you in advance!

Apr 15, 2018 5:53 AM

#906

L0ro

Offline

Jun 2016

4458

Hello,
Can you help me with: "(41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world"?

Also,about "(35) Read one of the highest rated and completed manga titles from another challenge participant" i must use something that the other challenge participant used for the challenge or it doesn't matter?

Thanks in advance!

Apr 15, 2018 6:22 AM

#907

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

L0ro said:
Hello,
Can you help me with: "(41) Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan, but in the real world"?

Also,about "(35) Read one of the highest rated and completed manga titles from another challenge participant" i must use something that the other challenge participant used for the challenge or it doesn't matter?

Thanks in advance!

https://myanimelist.net/manga/731/Eden__Its_an_Endless_World relatively counts

https://myanimelist.net/manga/729/Emma

https://myanimelist.net/manga/1517/JoJo_no_Kimyou_na_Bouken_Part_1__Phantom_Blood

35)
anything, as long as it's 8 or higher

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 15, 2018 10:01 AM

#908

Maffy

Review Moderator

(｡•̀ᴗ-)⌒✧

Offline

Jun 2007

1954

@MRC_mod (and the rest of the helpers please!)

I want to ask if this manga, Marin to Yuurei, is eligible for #65 (a series based on a oneshot)! The oneshot is included in the first volume of the series, so it doesn't have a separate entry, but there's a note for it in "More Info". I assume it is, but because it's not as obvious as other series, I wanted to make sure! Thanks!

PS: And if it is, you can add it to your list (I checked the FAQ)!

Apr 15, 2018 1:45 PM

#909

Offline

Apr 2013

1050

Maffy said:
@MRC_mod (and the rest of the helpers please!)

I want to ask if this manga, Marin to Yuurei, is eligible for #65 (a series based on a oneshot)! The oneshot is included in the first volume of the series, so it doesn't have a separate entry, but there's a note for it in "More Info". I assume it is, but because it's not as obvious as other series, I wanted to make sure! Thanks!

PS: And if it is, you can add it to your list (I checked the FAQ)!

It's eligible. :)

Apr 15, 2018 4:20 PM

#910

Offline

Dec 2016

246

I like some recommendations for these two challenges (Like it to have romance if possible)
(42) Read a manga with a child MC
(72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field

And can I use a manga that takes place in a Prefecture for (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan since in the explanation is stated that it needs to be a city in a city

Apr 15, 2018 5:31 PM

#911

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Fantasy_Land said:
I like some recommendations for these two challenges (Like it to have romance if possible)
(42) Read a manga with a child MC
(72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field

And can I use a manga that takes place in a Prefecture for (76) Read a manga that takes place in Japan since in the explanation is stated that it needs to be a city in a city

42)
wandering son
https://myanimelist.net/manga/655/Boku_no_Chikyuu_wo_Mamotte

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 16, 2018 7:02 AM

#912

Offline

Aug 2017

7

Is twi4 (publisher of Tomo-chan and Mousou Telepathy) an online magazine?

Maes_MustangApr 17, 2018 7:12 AM

Apr 17, 2018 10:02 AM

#913

minimiau

Offline

Aug 2007

3792

I want a recomendation for: (71) Read a manga about food, music or art: I have Your lie in April. Coincidentaly It began publishing here in my country, but every volume will be publishing bimonthly. So I wont complete reading the manga to the end of the year (I dont want to read it on scans... pirate scans. I want to wait until all volumes to be published).

1. I want another recomentadion. Avoid Nodame Cantabile. I saw the anime, I dont feel motivated to read the manga. It can be an art manga also.

2. I dont know too much about food mangas, but if it is dedicated to desserts the best.

3. 10 volumes or less if is possible.

Thanks!

Apr 17, 2018 5:40 PM

#914

omakase

Offline

Oct 2007

1187

@minimiau I don't see why you can't use You Lie in April? Ongoing publishing manga are allowed.

Though I guess you can also try Genkaku Picasso

密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。

Apr 18, 2018 5:33 AM

#915

Offline

Apr 2013

1050

Maes_Mustang said:
Is twi4 (publisher of Tomo-chan and Mousou Telepathy) an online magazine?

Yes. :)

Apr 18, 2018 8:09 AM

#916

Offline

Aug 2017

7

HeNrYTG50 said:

Maes_Mustang said:
Is twi4 (publisher of Tomo-chan and Mousou Telepathy) an online magazine?

Yes. :)

Thanks :)

Apr 18, 2018 10:00 AM

#917

minimiau

Offline

Aug 2007

3792

omakase said:
@minimiau I don't see why you can't use You Lie in April? Ongoing publishing manga are allowed.

Though I guess you can also try Genkaku Picasso

Thanks for the rec. The problem is not the ongoing. It that I wont be finishing on time.

Apr 18, 2018 11:24 PM

#918

Bad_beach

Offline

Sep 2016

6

Can some one help me with,
53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group

Thanks!

Apr 18, 2018 11:32 PM

#919

https://myanimelist.net/manga/1249/Claudine
https://myanimelist.net/manga/1207/Terra_e

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Bad_beach said:
Can some one help me with,
53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group

Thanks!

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 19, 2018 4:37 AM

#920

Maffy

Review Moderator

(｡•̀ᴗ-)⌒✧

Offline

Jun 2007

1954

Thanks for the swift response @HeNrYTG50 :D Sorry it took me a while to reply!

Apr 19, 2018 7:26 PM

#921

yu6

Offline

Apr 2012

128

@Scarlett_ryuken, @omakase, @HeNrYTG50, @AudioTsunami and @i_yuuko-chan could I please have a recommendations for (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member?

Thank you :)

Apr 19, 2018 8:19 PM

#922

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

yu6 said:
@Scarlett_ryuken, @omakase, @HeNrYTG50, @AudioTsunami and @i_yuuko-chan could I please have a recommendations for (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member?

Thank you :)

bastard
devilman
franken fran

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 19, 2018 8:36 PM

#923

Offline

Oct 2009

72

yu6 said:
@Scarlett_ryuken, @omakase, @HeNrYTG50, @AudioTsunami and @i_yuuko-chan could I please have a recommendations for (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member?

Thank you :)

Let me add some too. =3

From your PTR
Bokurano | v11.ch66 | (seinen, drama, mecha, psychological)
Bonnouji | v3.ch36 | (comedy, romance, slice of life, seinen)
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso | v11.ch44 | (shounen, drama, music, romance)
Wizard's Soul: Koi no Jihad | v4.ch22 | (drama, game, seinen)

Other suggestions
Haikyuu!! | publishing | (comedy, drama, school, shounen, sports)
Kamisama no Iutoori | v5.ch21 | (action, horror, psychological)
Katekyo Hitman Reborn | v42.ch411 | (shounen, action, comedy, school, super power)
Tsubasa: RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE | v28.ch233 | (action, adventure, drama, fantasy, shounen)

Apr 19, 2018 9:22 PM

#924

Offline

Aug 2017

7

(52) Read a light novel:

Does it count as completed if I read only one of the volumes of the FMA novels? (I think all 7 volumes have different stories)

Apr 20, 2018 3:17 AM

#925

Offline

Aug 2017

7

Fantasy_Land said:

Maes_Mustang said:
(52) Read a light novel:

Does it count as completed if I read only one of the volumes of the FMA novels? (I think all 7 volumes have different stories)

No you need to complete the whole light novel or till where the English translation left of

Thanks!

A couple more question guys:

Could I use Futatsu no Spica for this item? It's English translation is Twin Spica but Futatsu still means two, right?
(84) Read a manga with a number in the title:

Are the MCs in Made in Abyss considered children? I just started the manga and I've not seen a specific age mentioned for them.
(42) Read a manga with a child MC:

Apr 20, 2018 4:01 AM

#926

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Maes_Mustang said:

Fantasy_Land said:

No you need to complete the whole light novel or till where the English translation left of

Thanks!

A couple more question guys:

Could I use Futatsu no Spica for this item? It's English translation is Twin Spica but Futatsu still means two, right?
(84) Read a manga with a number in the title:

Are the MCs in Made in Abyss considered children? I just started the manga and I've not seen a specific age mentioned for them.
(42) Read a manga with a child MC:

btw, you only need to read 1 vol(full vol) of the LN if you're gonna do the Ln challenge

42)
she starts the series at the edge of 12, barely safe

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 20, 2018 4:09 AM

#927

Offline

Aug 2017

7

Scarlett_ryuken said:

Maes_Mustang said:

Thanks!

A couple more question guys:

Could I use Futatsu no Spica for this item? It's English translation is Twin Spica but Futatsu still means two, right?
(84) Read a manga with a number in the title:

Are the MCs in Made in Abyss considered children? I just started the manga and I've not seen a specific age mentioned for them.
(42) Read a manga with a child MC:

btw, you only need to read 1 vol(full vol) of the LN if you're gonna do the Ln challenge

42)
she starts the series at the edge of 12, barely safe

Thanks! So I can indeed use that FMA novel :)

Apr 20, 2018 12:03 PM

#928

yu6

Offline

Apr 2012

128

Scarlett_ryuken said:

yu6 said:
@Scarlett_ryuken, @omakase, @HeNrYTG50, @AudioTsunami and @i_yuuko-chan could I please have a recommendations for (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member?

Thank you :)

bastard
devilman
franken fran

i_yuuko-chan said:

yu6 said:
@Scarlett_ryuken, @omakase, @HeNrYTG50, @AudioTsunami and @i_yuuko-chan could I please have a recommendations for (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member?

Thank you :)

Let me add some too. =3

From your PTR
Bokurano | v11.ch66 | (seinen, drama, mecha, psychological)
Bonnouji | v3.ch36 | (comedy, romance, slice of life, seinen)
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso | v11.ch44 | (shounen, drama, music, romance)
Wizard's Soul: Koi no Jihad | v4.ch22 | (drama, game, seinen)

Other suggestions
Haikyuu!! | publishing | (comedy, drama, school, shounen, sports)
Kamisama no Iutoori | v5.ch21 | (action, horror, psychological)
Katekyo Hitman Reborn | v42.ch411 | (shounen, action, comedy, school, super power)
Tsubasa: RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE | v28.ch233 | (action, adventure, drama, fantasy, shounen)

Thanks a lot! It will be difficult to choose something XD (everything seems interesting XD)

Apr 20, 2018 4:05 PM

#929

Offline

Dec 2016

246

Can I use Ore ga Akuma de, Aitsu ga Yome de. for challenge (72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field

The mc is a demon and he make a contract with a human by granting any wish exchange for their soul and in the manga has it being stated that he get paid for every wish she's making

Apr 20, 2018 5:35 PM

#930

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Fantasy_Land said:
Can I use Ore ga Akuma de, Aitsu ga Yome de. for challenge (72) Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field

The mc is a demon and he make a contract with a human by granting any wish exchange for their soul and in the manga has it being stated that he get paid for every wish she's making

no lol,
it must be a job that can be done in real life

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 21, 2018 1:14 AM

#931

Offline

Dec 2016

246

Scarlett_ryuken said:

no lol,
it must be a job that can be done in real life

I had to try my luck lol
Do you have any good suggestion for the challenge that may be similar from what I'm reading or already read on my list

StrangerZzApr 21, 2018 1:26 AM

Apr 21, 2018 2:14 AM

#932

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Fantasy_Land said:

Scarlett_ryuken said:

no lol,
it must be a job that can be done in real life

I had to try my luck lol
Do you have any good suggestion for the challenge that may be similar from what I'm reading or already read on my list

https://myanimelist.net/manga/1224/3-gatsu_no_Lion
professional shogi player

https://myanimelist.net/manga/729/Emma
works as a maid

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

Apr 22, 2018 3:15 PM

#933

KuhakuyaL

Offline

Sep 2016

260

can i use Aisopos for item 58? if not i'd like some suggestion

Past Forum sets

Apr 22, 2018 4:01 PM

#934

Offline

Apr 2013

1050

KuhakuyaL said:
can i use Aisopos for item 58? if not i'd like some suggestion

You can. :)

Apr 22, 2018 4:41 PM

#935

KuhakuyaL

Offline

Sep 2016

260

@i_yuuko-chan

i need help for this (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member
(possibly completed or at least not in a super early stage)

Past Forum sets

Apr 23, 2018 4:22 AM

#936

Manga Reading Challenges Club

Offline

Oct 2009

72

KuhakuyaL said:
@i_yuuko-chan

i need help for this (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member
(possibly completed or at least not in a super early stage)

Hello, KuhakuyaL!

I hope you find something to your liking. =3

From your PTR
All You Need Is Kill | v2.ch17 | (action, sci-fi, military, seinen)
Bakuman | v20.ch176 | (shounen, comedy, slice of life, romance)

Other suggestions:

Up to 10 volumes:
Bonnouji | v3.ch36 | (comedy, romance, slice of life, seinen)
Jumyou wo Kaitotte Moratta. Ichinen ni Tsuki, Ichimanen de. | v3.ch18 | (shounen, drama)
Kakukaku Shikajika | v5.ch34 | (josei, slice of life)
Kanshikan Tsunemori Akane | v6.ch27 | (action, sci-fi, horror)
Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu: Dai-1 Shou - Outo no Ichinichi-hen | v2.ch11 | (action, fantasy, seinen)
Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan | v1.ch08 | (seinen, drama, psychological, romance)

10+ volumes
Death Note | v12.ch108 | (mystery, drama, shounen, supernatural, psychological)
Hikaru no Go | v23.ch198 | (shounen, game, drama, supernatural)
Katekyo Hitman Reborn | v42.ch411 | (shounen, action, comedy, school, super power)
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso | v11.ch44 | (shounen, drama, music, romance)
xxxHOLiC | v19.ch213 | (seinen, supernatural, mystery, comedy, drama)

Apr 27, 2018 11:48 AM

#937

k3ti

Offline

May 2017

1839

@MRC_Mod here are some banners ^^

[img]https://i.imgur.com/y07fMR4.png[/img]   [img]https://i.imgur.com/K2bu2ZO.png[/img]
[img]https://i.imgur.com/FEy4eEN.png[/img]   [img]https://i.imgur.com/sBIQ43N.png[/img]
[img]https://i.imgur.com/tyd4Qed.png[/img]   [img]https://i.imgur.com/NZNehVV.png[/img]
[img]https://i.imgur.com/DmHqjXz.png[/img]   [img]https://i.imgur.com/O48h6R0.png[/img]

● 𝚌𝚛𝚎𝚊𝚝𝚒𝚘𝚗𝚜
● 𝚌𝚘𝚕𝚕𝚎𝚌𝚝𝚒𝚘𝚗
● 𝚍𝚎𝚕𝚒𝚟𝚎𝚛𝚢

Apr 28, 2018 1:15 PM

#938

Schlopsi

Offline

Mar 2016

1075

(21) Read a webmanga or 4-koma manga

Can I have a few recommendations for that one please? Having trouble with finding interesting web manga which are actually in the MAL db... preferably max. 70 chaps and finished.

Apr 28, 2018 5:42 PM

#939

Manga Reading Challenges Club

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Schlopsi said:

(21) Read a webmanga or 4-koma manga

Can I have a few recommendations for that one please? Having trouble with finding interesting web manga which are actually in the MAL db... preferably max. 70 chaps and finished.

technically, you have no need to read something on mal, as long as you properly link what you read from another source here

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

May 1, 2018 7:57 AM

#940

Schlopsi

Offline

Mar 2016

1075

Scarlett_ryuken said:

technically, you have no need to read something on mal, as long as you properly link what you read from another source here

Sorry for the late reply! So, web toons like the following would count for example, correct? https://www.lezhin.com/en/comic/save_me

I could also need a rec for "(74) Read a manga based on real event or person" (anythings fine as long as it's not about ancient rome/greek and finished.

May 1, 2018 8:28 AM

#941

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Schlopsi said:

Scarlett_ryuken said:

technically, you have no need to read something on mal, as long as you properly link what you read from another source here

Sorry for the late reply! So, web toons like the following would count for example, correct? https://www.lezhin.com/en/comic/save_me

I could also need a rec for "(74) Read a manga based on real event or person" (anythings fine as long as it's not about ancient rome/greek and finished.

i mean, sure, was thinking you more link the manga updates page but that works too

74)
urm
if you dont mind long, vagabond
or that lesbian manga that won a CR award

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

May 1, 2018 10:13 AM

#942

Salamak

Offline

Sep 2017

436

so i wanted to read 2 novels, can't i pick both?..there is only one challenge for novels. can you pick a novel and a light novel?

May 1, 2018 12:38 PM

#943

Dust_

Offline

Aug 2016

67

hello everybody hope the challenge is going well, read hard :P

Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.

May 1, 2018 3:14 PM

#944

Offline

Oct 2009

72

k3ti said:
@MRC_Mod here are some banners ^^

Added!
Thank you!! =3

May 2, 2018 12:23 AM

#945

Offline

Oct 2015

17263

Salamak said:
so i wanted to read 2 novels, can't i pick both?..there is only one challenge for novels. can you pick a novel and a light novel?

nope, only can use novel for the novel challenge :s sry

nothing's stopping you from reading the novel on your own time tho

It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime.
Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others

May 2, 2018 2:02 AM

#946

Salamak

Offline

Sep 2017

436

Scarlett_ryuken said:

Salamak said:
so i wanted to read 2 novels, can't i pick both?..there is only one challenge for novels. can you pick a novel and a light novel?

nope, only can use novel for the novel challenge :s sry

nothing's stopping you from reading the novel on your own time tho

oh well..

you should have more challenges for novels and manhwas, having just one challenge for each is not enough i guess..

thanks for answering :)

May 2, 2018 2:29 AM

#947

ColdBlackTeaFan

Offline

Jan 2012

170

Is Death Note Another Note: Los Angeles BB Renzoku Satsujin Jiken eligible for challenge (52) Read a light novel?

May 2, 2018 2:56 AM

#948

Offline

Apr 2013

1050

Salamak said:

oh well..

you should have more challenges for novels and manhwas, having just one challenge for each is not enough i guess..

thanks for answering :)

You can use manhwas, manhuas, and online comics for every item, though. :)

May 2, 2018 3:06 AM

#949