| I can't watch it because it have more then 24 ep's. I can't watch it because of the animation, it's old, so it's bad. |
 |
HanashiD4 said: Pretty bad example, the positions of the aforementioned can also be reasoned out and detailed. People like C needs to understand people not liking what he likes ≠ they didn't understand it. Person A: Man, this X show is for cry and misery porn because... ( blah blah blah)... logically speaking. Person B: Yeah, this X show is a melodramatic shit. I can't feel anything because of how "illogical it is". Person C: Hold on! Lemme elaborate you the context and explanation behind the reason for his *crying moment*. *jotting down the details on why X character was crying and suffering in the first place* |
 |
| I remember when I literally showed someone how the ending of Angel Beats doesn't have this so-called "plot hole" people with low attention span like to point out, how that twist was actually foreshadowed and built up to in the last few episodes, their answer was something like "Well it's still a plot hole to me because I didn't catch that stuff when I was watching" |
| Who are you and why do you show your hostility towards a complete stranger whom you've not once spoken with before. Are you seriously asking to get blocked? Well, if that's what your intent is; to tempt me into throwing hands with someone as lowly and insignificant as you, then i may grant your wish provided you articulate yourself a bit better when trying to spite a person of my wavelength. |
| @MavisVermillion- sorry but it's only Fail Tail that is taking it to that level of stupid. If we could make Fairy Tail darker, remove friend ship beats everything, remove fanserivce, add in a few deaths then we are talking. I'm far from tired of Battle Shounen it's a rather enjoyable to watch. But taking it to the level they did in Fairy Tail is rather stupid, as it could be one of those shows fighting for the top spot. But it didn't do it, and never will. The show is rather childish for a battleshounen and that's what makes people run away from it. |
|
01Sharjeel said: EcchiGodMamster said: it does. it really does. Highschool of the dead is the living breathing example of it. Sure, keep it ecchi but they overdid it and ruined an anime that actually had an interesting plot and setting. I can't even recommend it to anyone the worst criticism i've ever heard i think everyone knows by now the fanservice ruined the scene/show Interesting plot and setting? Seriously dude do you people fucking read what you write? It's highschool teenagers fighting zombies. The ecchi literally makes it better. |
| The beauty of humans is that they say one thing then do another, but at the same time that can also be their ugliest side. |
MavisVermillion- said: I'm tired of Fairy Tail haters making out the show to be the worst thing in existence, while projecting onto it all the faults of their favorite battle shonens that they fail to see and disregarding all its good points or in series explanations. https://fairytailfanon.fandom.com/wiki/Flames_of_Emotion Friendship power-ups are not even a thing when in series you have the "Flames of Emotions" which is a well functioning system on its own. Disregard how every other shonen uses that same trope with even lesser justification behind it and gets away with it. No, coming from a FT fan the only good season of FT is the first one after that it just gets worse and worse. |
| The beauty of humans is that they say one thing then do another, but at the same time that can also be their ugliest side. |
| Someone once told me that Space Battleship Yamato 2199 was mediocre. Well, I showed him and that chump isn't getting a friend request from me! |
 |
SoftImpaler said: Someone once told me that Space Battleship Yamato 2199 was mediocre. Well, I showed him and that chump isn't getting a friend request from me! Well, it's not like you would send any friend request. So I guess I was right on Space Battleship Yamato 2199 being mediocre. |
| Fairy Tail, change it to the darker, yeah I trult belive that it would make the show way more poular. People are always hating on the same thing as that's what shines in the anime, bad fanservice, friendship beating everything, close NO death. Even someone die that are brought back to life. Ofc people will hate on it, it's the same reason people are hating on SAO, every character got the same character design, it show has some of the thiccest plot armor. What we see and hear is what we will like or dislike. Only big shounen I haven't watched yet would be Gintama. And out of OP, Bleach, Nura-Clan, Naruto, Demon Slayer, they all got a bit of comedy here and there or a whole ep's some time here and there. But Fairy Tail got that from start to finish. It's not seriously, and the show above is so far from this level, they are not even on the same map. I have always been a huge fan of Shounen, it was what I loved when I started to watch anime years ago and still are. But shows like 7DS and Fairy Tail that shines in the way they do. Will always be shit on. It's just to accept those facts. Fairy Tail shines with friend ship and fanservice, while Demon Slayer shines with amazin animation and high quality. And owow, they are getting a adaption, ofc if they show this on the TV the small children will love it, thanks to how childish it is. Watching Fairy Tail is like watching bolibompa on the swedish TV, it's for 4-8 years old kinds. While watching Naruto/OP/Bleach feels like they are for the double in the age. And have you ever checked the stats of Fairy Tail here on MaL, how more and more people have stopped caring the more content they released ? Or you're are just ignoring those facts, it's INSANE to see. @MavisVermillion- |
|
HanashiD4 said: This is hilarious and especially relevant since I just coincidentally wrote a review that mentions each one of these points. The point is that while drama manipulates, it should not call to attention that manipulation, and when someone gets the feeling that a particular event arises inorganically as a cheap attempt to evoke a feeling from the audience, then that signifies bad drama, that the drama has failed to convince people to suspend disbelief. It might sound "ridiculous" to people who have higher tolerance for bad drama, but retorting that the event is justified by some back story misses the point. It isn't the story that's necessarily the problem, but how the story is told.Note: I'm just gonna write it in scripted format for simple and relatable sake Person A: Man, this X show is for cry and misery porn because... ( blah blah blah)... logically speaking. Person B: Yeah, this X show is a melodramatic shit. I can't feel anything because of how "illogical it is". Person C: Hold on! Lemme elaborate you the context and explanation behind the reason for his *crying moment*. *jotting down the details on why X character was crying and suffering in the first place* Person A & B: Pffft~ Bad writing! You're just presenting an excuse! I'll bring up my own review as an example. One Piece Dressrosa arc spoilers ahead: The bad drama doesn't make me more engaged with the plot. It makes me feel disgusted and dirty for watching such poorly written exploitative drama. It lacks nuance. It lacks importance in the story, as if the plot could have carried on without it. It's practically
And it literally does not matter that he wrote a reason into it, because it's a shit reason, the events were constructed in an unbelievable way, the direction was too forceful and lacks nuance, it plays on the most base of emotions, and it's the consequence of all the protagonists' own stupidity. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
01Sharjeel said: EcchiGodMamster said: it does. it really does. Highschool of the dead is the living breathing example of it. Sure, keep it ecchi but they overdid it and ruined an anime that actually had an interesting plot and setting. I can't even recommend it to anyone the worst criticism i've ever heard i think everyone knows by now the fanservice ruined the scene/show as one of the greatest movie lines once said: "yea, well you know.... thats like like, uh...... your opinion... man" sucks for you lol |
   |
| i see so many people hate on certain characters for actions that portray them as realistic/real people?? personally i like when characters are written more human, it makes them more relatable |
I like FT but I think, even when you're not comparing it to other shonen, sometimes it just falls flat as a narrative. Then again I feel the same about The Legend of Korra. |
SmordolaOct 5, 2020 6:25 PM
My favorite part when people say this is on a thread about an ecchi anime. Lmao. |
| "Well, she's flatter than a pancake" -Mimi Alpacas |
katsucats said: HanashiD4 said: This is hilarious and especially relevant since I just coincidentally wrote a review that mentions each one of these points. The point is that while drama manipulates, it should not call to attention that manipulation, and when someone gets the feeling that a particular event arises inorganically as a cheap attempt to evoke a feeling from the audience, then that signifies bad drama, that the drama has failed to convince people to suspend disbelief. It might sound "ridiculous" to people who have higher tolerance for bad drama, but retorting that the event is justified by some back story misses the point. It isn't the story that's necessarily the problem, but how the story is told.Note: I'm just gonna write it in scripted format for simple and relatable sake Person A: Man, this X show is for cry and misery porn because... ( blah blah blah)... logically speaking. Person B: Yeah, this X show is a melodramatic shit. I can't feel anything because of how "illogical it is". Person C: Hold on! Lemme elaborate you the context and explanation behind the reason for his *crying moment*. *jotting down the details on why X character was crying and suffering in the first place* Person A & B: Pffft~ Bad writing! You're just presenting an excuse! I'll bring up my own review as an example. One Piece Dressrosa arc spoilers ahead: The bad drama doesn't make me more engaged with the plot. It makes me feel disgusted and dirty for watching such poorly written exploitative drama. It lacks nuance. It lacks importance in the story, as if the plot could have carried on without it. It's practically
And it literally does not matter that he wrote a reason into it, because it's a shit reason, the events were constructed in an unbelievable way, the direction was too forceful and lacks nuance, it plays on the most base of emotions, and it's the consequence of all the protagonists' own stupidity. That's basically what I mean on the message below my aforementioned example. If you know the context and reason in a proper sense behind it, for sure, that certain drama is understandable based on each character's background that applies to the most extent. Stupidity can be considerably absurd if he/she already realized the effect in the first place, and also stupidity can be natural if a character doesn't know anything what's going on in the first place... but only the audience can identify the context behind the face value. Human experiences are complicated, and the audiences can indicate every context in relation to a certain occurrence. With that, it's up to us when a certain character did a right or wrong thing to match up his/her motive and goal behind it. That's how most Disney movies (such as Alice in Wonderland, Mulan 2020, and Cinderella) failed at making drama more meaningful. It's because it lacks the development of each character and their interaction which fails to challenge the characters more. It has logical sense, and yet the characters themselves are dull. The substance is there, but the charm dims it. There's no sense of balance on most Disney movies because it doesn't deliver the emotional weight well. |
HanashiD4Oct 6, 2020 2:54 AM
 "You don't get it, a million sorry's is not equal to one thank you." — Emilia |
Unowen said: HanashiD4 said: Pretty bad example, the positions of the aforementioned can also be reasoned out and detailed. People like C needs to understand people not liking what he likes ≠ they didn't understand it. Person A: Man, this X show is for cry and misery porn because... ( blah blah blah)... logically speaking. Person B: Yeah, this X show is a melodramatic shit. I can't feel anything because of how "illogical it is". Person C: Hold on! Lemme elaborate you the context and explanation behind the reason for his *crying moment*. *jotting down the details on why X character was crying and suffering in the first place* Like I said, it depends if the context makes sense or not. If a certain character has sensible motives and goals behind it, then it's up to a certain character on how he/she must explore and tackle it in the first place. Most humans are imperfect on their own ways, and it's up to them if it's either lucky or not. But I doubt luckiness will do the justice since it can be a bad Deus Ex Machina thing. |
"You don't get it, a million sorry's is not equal to one thank you." — Emilia |
like HoTD... lol... however, ecchi isn't even really a genre anyway, so theres technically no such thing as an ecchi anime |
|
| For me it's when people put to much emphasis on the plot for an episodic type show. Sometimes it's about the journey vs the destination. Even for naruto and people complaining about fillers, it's not a big deal in the grand scheme of things -Ryu said: I remember when I literally showed someone how the ending of Angel Beats doesn't have this so-called "plot hole" people with low attention span like to point out, how that twist was actually foreshadowed and built up to in the last few episodes, their answer was something like "Well it's still a plot hole to me because I didn't catch that stuff when I was watching" and people wonder why deep, nuanced anime isn't made anymore lol |
I'm level  on mal-badges. View my badges.  |
TheFireNinja said: I thought it was kind of weird that someone called Naofumi from the Rising of the Shield Hero an "incel." Nothing about Naofumi's situation suggested that to me. Spoiler alert: |
jal90Oct 6, 2020 2:29 AM
| "Sailor Moon is bad because it's not believable that there was a kingdom in the moon and astronomers never knew about it" |
| "Ecchi: it has too much fanservice" I mean, really, what else could it be? The sheer uselessness of this criticism and the overall redundancy of it makes it pretty much a given. How incredibly incestuous and assembly-line these reviews are in the MAL community makes the rest of the general criticisms against ecchi seem hollow, but just complaining about the existence of it takes the cake for wasting my time. Worthless. |
ManabanOct 6, 2020 3:11 AM
 |
| "The characters are stupid" - Re:Zero, a story where Subaru is intentionally stupid. |
 my life was made with mematic. |
ag_ said: That's a good one. So if I make an intentionally stupid anime, then everyone is forced to rate it 10/10 because it does what it intended, right?"The characters are stupid" - Re:Zero, a story where Subaru is intentionally stupid. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
| "I hate One Piece because it's long" "I hate Naruto because Sakura is useless and it has so many fillers" "I hate Boruto because it has fillers" |
 |
katsucats said: ag_ said: That's a good one. So if I make an intentionally stupid anime, then everyone is forced to rate it 10/10 because it does what it intended, right?"The characters are stupid" - Re:Zero, a story where Subaru is intentionally stupid. That's not the point. I get not enjoying an anime because you don't like the characters, but saying that it's objectively bad because the characters are purposely stupid is wrong. |
| my life was made with mematic. |
katsucats said: ag_ said: That's a good one. So if I make an intentionally stupid anime, then everyone is forced to rate it 10/10 because it does what it intended, right?"The characters are stupid" - Re:Zero, a story where Subaru is intentionally stupid. Nah, Subaru is clueless, but not stupid. Stupidity is nature to him at first, but he gets better at Season 2 in terms of character development. Hence, your “good one” is wrong and asinine. It sounds like you haven’t finished the anime yet lmao. If Subaru is smarter at first, he will become a generic Gary Stu isekai protagonist with cooler style. However, the original Subaru feels human even though he can be stupid sometimes, so I will disagree with your take. |
HanashiD4Oct 6, 2020 4:17 PM
"You don't get it, a million sorry's is not equal to one thank you." — Emilia |
| when your in the middle of the season and not even close to the end of the series and some one makes an asinine comment like "I don't like that [insert main character name] didn't die." if they died the series would be over seriously if you don't like the series and want it to end find a better reason for not liking the series other then it hasn't ended yet. |
| "among monsters and humans, there are only two types. Those who undergo suffering and spread it to others. And those who undergo suffering and avoid giving it to others." -Alice “Beauty is no quality in things themselves: It exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty.” David Hume “Evil is created when someone gives up on someone else. It appears when everyone gives up on someone as a lost cause and removes their path to salvation. Once they are cut off from everyone else, they become evil.” -Othinus  |
| The top review for the Dragon Dentist is pretty bad lol. Pretty much a guy getting mad at a fantasy series for having magic and unique world building stuff in it. Here's some funny quotes from it "is that dragon God? How in the fk can it bring people back from the dead?" "People getting their asses pulled out of dragon teeth?" "disgusting french kiss scene" "Pathetic dialogue" no elaboration lmao "A big problem with the show is that I did not connect with the characters...They could have all been raped then butchered and I still would not give two shits about their demise." Oof I don't know what about the show made him and the people who marked the review as helpful so mad at it lol. |
Ferien said: "Sailor Moon is bad because it's not believable that there was a kingdom in the moon and astronomers never knew about it" I wonder how this was his problem when there are way bigger logical problems lol. |
 |
| "I hate Oregairu because my favorite character didn't get shipped w Hachiman" |
   |
DaijoubuKirameki said: Pretty much anytime I hear this I always think that person is lacking brain power.I hate (insert name of anime) because the fanbase is toxic |
HanashiD4 said: This comment was not about Subaru, nor do I want to argue with you about Subaru, but no he does not get better. And yes he is stupid. But you're entitled to your own opinion. And no, having an intentionally stupid main character does not make it less stupid.katsucats said: That's a good one. So if I make an intentionally stupid anime, then everyone is forced to rate it 10/10 because it does what it intended, right? Nah, Subaru is clueless, but not stupid. Stupidity is nature to him at first, but he gets better at Season 2 in terms of character development. Hence, your “good one” is wrong and asinine. It sounds like you haven’t finished the anime yet lmao. If Subaru is smarter at first, he will become a generic Gary Stu isekai protagonist with cooler style. However, the original Subaru feels human even though he can be stupid sometimes, so I will disagree with your take. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
katsucats said: HanashiD4 said: This comment was not about Subaru, nor do I want to argue with you about Subaru, but no he does not get better. And yes he is stupid. But you're entitled to your own opinion. And no, having an intentionally stupid main character does not make it less stupid.Nah, Subaru is clueless, but not stupid. Stupidity is nature to him at first, but he gets better at Season 2 in terms of character development. Hence, your “good one” is wrong and asinine. It sounds like you haven’t finished the anime yet lmao. If Subaru is smarter at first, he will become a generic Gary Stu isekai protagonist with cooler style. However, the original Subaru feels human even though he can be stupid sometimes, so I will disagree with your take. In other words, you literally spelled out your own message as "objective" take with ignorance, but okay... just like us, Subaru can be stupid at first, but he develops way better in Season 2 lmao. This is really an asinine take from you, and avoiding "arguing with me" is the point of your ignorance. |
"You don't get it, a million sorry's is not equal to one thank you." — Emilia |
HanashiD4 said: I didn't say anything about objective anywhere in my post.In other words, you literally spelled out your own message as "objective" take with ignorance, but okay... HanashiD4 said: lol not even. He's still the same Subaru that got mad at a random person that forgot about Rem in the first episode. He's still the same Subaru that refuses the divulge important facts to his allies to his aggravating self-importance. He's still the same Subaru that causes his own allies to get killed because he refuses to kill the enemy. He's still the same Subaru that gets triggered by every little thing someone says instead of focusing at the goals ahead. He's still very much the same Subaru that took half the entire season to tell Beatrice what Roswaal tells him to tell her at the beginning of the fucking season. And none of this is even spoiler because anyone who was paying even the modicum of attention already knows.just like us, Subaru can be stupid at first, but he develops way better in Season 2 lmao. HanashiD4 said: Oh really, so who thinks their opinions are objective?This is really an asinine take from you, HanashiD4 said: Yes, because you're the center of the universe, right?and avoiding "arguing with me" is the point of your ignorance. Don't even try to get me banned with this petty trolling. I think we all know how this tactic works by now. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
katsucats said: HanashiD4 said: I didn't say anything about objective anywhere in my post.In other words, you literally spelled out your own message as "objective" take with ignorance, but okay... HanashiD4 said: lol not even. He's still the same Subaru that got mad at a random person that forgot about Rem in the first episode. He's still the same Subaru that refuses the divulge important facts to his allies to his aggravating self-importance. He's still the same Subaru that causes his own allies to get killed because he refuses to kill the enemy. He's still the same Subaru that gets triggered by every little thing someone says instead of focusing at the goals ahead. He's still very much the same Subaru that took half the entire season to tell Beatrice what Roswaal tells him to tell her at the beginning of the fucking season. And none of this is even spoiler because anyone who was paying even the modicum of attention already knows. just like us, Subaru can be stupid at first, but he develops way better in Season 2 lmao. HanashiD4 said: Oh really, so who thinks their opinions are objective?This is really an asinine take from you, HanashiD4 said: Yes, because you're the center of the universe, right?and avoiding "arguing with me" is the point of your ignorance. Don't even try to get me banned with this petty trolling. I think we all know how this tactic works by now. Lol, I can notice already that you're seething about this since your criticism is far for him from being stupid of himself, and I understand that. However, you have to understand his stimulus response before receiving the information and reaction from someone whom he interacted to, and his psychological attitude corresponds to Operant Conditioning when he started not to gain trust from anybody else because the one who triggers the Witch Cult incident is among Subaru's ally too, or rather... Unlike any other generic boring isekai protagonists, Subaru's behavior isn't really easy for him to snap it out, and say, "Oh, okay. I got it." in such a straight and boring way. He instead presses the question harder in order to not let them catch him off-guard by their possible manipulation. Just like talking to friends with selfish desire to steal from him as a particular method of closet bullying, Subaru competes against those type of people to back them off away from his pocket. This is why I appreciate his self-importance because the majority/minority within the world around him is no longer trustworthy for him even though he can casually trust them at the first sight. Yes, I agree that he can be stupid sometimes, but he isn't the type to be fragile from forcing the trust into him as always. You can't just write a "perfect" character who should do as someone says, but you can just write how a character behaves in that way without immediately proceeding the decision if either it's true or false... and that's pretty consistent with impression, reaction, and decision of moral hypotheses. Cognitive development is what I specifically meant, and that's how Subaru felt human-ish to me, and I can appreciate his stupidity because of his cluelessness. You can't just conclude the supposed logic in such straight manner, but you have to understand the stimulus response around Subaru because Subaru really doesn't understand the purpose of his abrupt existence, and that's how he feels so lost and clueless since he doesn't fully know and understand about the alternate world he is in right now. |
HanashiD4Oct 7, 2020 8:58 AM
"You don't get it, a million sorry's is not equal to one thank you." — Emilia |
| Yesterday one elitist high iq stud made a forum where he ceitisized every aAnime and Anime fan for not being MATURE |
 |
DaijoubuKirameki said: I hate (insert name of anime) because the fanbase is toxic Boku no hero academia suits perfectly. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
More topics from this board
» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 )nirererin - Oct 9 |
148 |
by jh666
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
» What MMORPGs are VRMMO/Isekai anime based on?thewiru - 6 hours ago |
7 |
by tchitchouan
»»
20 minutes ago |
|
» Do you actually want to marry your favorite VA?Dragevard - 7 hours ago |
10 |
by tchitchouan
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
» Outdated anime tropes and slang you don't really see much anymoreTheBlockernator - 11 hours ago |
8 |
by Nirinbo
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» Do you iss the Femme Fatale trope?VabbingSips - 7 hours ago |
4 |
by tchitchouan
»»
22 minutes ago |