| Already planning my Yamato 2199 sig. |
 |
| +1 Space Battleship Yamato 2199 |
 |
| I'm 99% certain you voted for Yamato already, Corwin :D |
|
Ventris said: I'm 99% certain you voted for Yamato already, Corwin :D Yeah I was gonna say, why did Nagisa and Corwin only give their votes now? lol Not sure if you voted already though Nagisa. |
| I think there was some confusion over which Yamato entry should get nominated, and I may have voted then, or even nominated the show (or was it Jody?), I wouldn't know. This was just in case, if it didn't count then, then there is no trouble in voting again, and if it counts, there are people that keep track of casted votes, so no harm is done. |
corwinrSep 25, 2014 9:53 PM
|
| I believe this was the only time I gave a +1 to Yamato 2199. I just finished it this summer but I went back page by page to page 145 to make sure I didn't vote twice. I didn't see a +1 for Yamato 2199 (unless I missed something.) I'm giving it a +1 now because after some refection I think it deserves a place on the list. |
| Now that I've finished it, I'm giving a +1 to Yamato 2199 as well. |
| Alas! It appears that even a relative newbie like me can be born under the shining star of Anime Enlightenment, for it appears that fate wills it that my awful taste greatly coincides with the holy Parchment of Truth. Praise be to the RNG lord who led to this fateful encounter with this Sacred Club. It especially fills me with great joy that even the lowliest garbage I have watched is located on the anime affiliations. All jokes aside I am happy to have found this group and positively surprised at HxH's rapid acceptance into the lofty Circles of Anime Truth (oh, there I go again) |
Skychael said: Alas! It appears that even a relative newbie like me can be born under the shining star of Anime Enlightenment, for it appears that fate wills it that my awful taste greatly coincides with the holy Parchment of Truth. Praise be to the RNG lord who led to this fateful encounter with this Sacred Club. It especially fills me with great joy that even the lowliest garbage I have watched is located on the anime affiliations. All jokes aside I am happy to have found this group and positively surprised at HxH's rapid acceptance into the lofty Circles of Anime Truth (oh, there I go again) To be fair, this club seems quite active and popular, so it tends to show up as recommended clubs a fair bit it seems; that's how I found out at least. Also, -1 Brigadoon. |
Skychael said: Alas! It appears that even a relative newbie like me can be born under the shining star of Anime Enlightenment, for it appears that fate wills it that my awful taste greatly coincides with the holy Parchment of Truth. Praise be to the RNG lord who led to this fateful encounter with this Sacred Club. It especially fills me with great joy that even the lowliest garbage I have watched is located on the anime affiliations. All jokes aside I am happy to have found this group and positively surprised at HxH's rapid acceptance into the lofty Circles of Anime Truth (oh, there I go again) Do you believe in Love at first sight? |
| +1 Space Battleship Yamato 2199 certainly, my favorite from the 2014-2013-2012 years so far. Really great stuff. |
| +1 Ping Pong |
| -☾✩ |
baki502 said: Do you believe in Love at first sight? I do :') |
| Sora no Woto -1 Rescue Me -1 |
 |
| +1 Ping Pong |
| +1 Bartender |
Insouciance said: +1 Bartender :D |
| +1 Area 88 (the OVA, not the TV anime) |
Nei-sanOct 4, 2014 11:10 PM
| +1 Pong Ping. |
| Ping Pong +1!!!! Sora no Woto -1 |
| -1 Sora no Woto Definitely a good series but not that great. |
 |
EccentricBuggery said: Geez I love contradicting myself 5 pages ago I gave it a +1.-1 Sora no Woto Definitely a good series but not that great. I can see why though. Maybe I'm just dwelling on it too much. SO WHICH FUCKING ONE IS IT JODY!!! |
|
EccentricBuggery said: EccentricBuggery said: Geez I love contradicting myself 5 pages ago I gave it a +1.-1 Sora no Woto Definitely a good series but not that great. I can see why though. Maybe I'm just dwelling on it too much. SO WHICH FUCKING ONE IS IT JODY!!! Classic Jody. |
| Ping pong + 1 milion |
EccentricBuggery said: EccentricBuggery said: Geez I love contradicting myself 5 pages ago I gave it a +1.-1 Sora no Woto Definitely a good series but not that great. I can see why though. Maybe I'm just dwelling on it too much. SO WHICH FUCKING ONE IS IT JODY!!! So... uhh... which one is it, Jody? |
AlabastreAizo said: I'm back on the fence again with it. Give me a while.EccentricBuggery said: Geez I love contradicting myself 5 pages ago I gave it a +1. I can see why though. Maybe I'm just dwelling on it too much. SO WHICH FUCKING ONE IS IT JODY!!! So... uhh... which one is it, Jody? |
|
| That vote...it's just been revoked! |
| Well a month has passed, and since I have seen very highly uneventful support for my previous nomination. ;_; "Onii-sama E..."  If only people loved me... So I will just be sad inside with this next nomination cause it's just gonna happen again. I nominate "Ie Naki Ko" for the enlightenment list. Why you ask? Because it's drama killed me. |
JodyqtOct 15, 2014 10:42 PM
|
| Well there's still tons of time before a nomination gets removed, so no fear Jody. |
| +1 Onii-sama e +1 Ie Naki Ko +1 Akage no Anne My contribution for today, and now, back to lurking. |
|
corwin_r said: +1 Onii-sama e +1 Ie Naki Ko +1 Akage no Anne My contribution for today, and now, back to lurking. Nice! More hope for those classics I need to see lol. |
| Ashita no Joe will never make it to the e-list since nobody saw it ;_; I've been thinking about nominating it, but the only people I know that have seen it here are Corwin and LayedBack. What use is being among the best if you aren't popular Joe ;_; |
 "Your sight, my delight. Will you marry me?" |
| So did they finish subbing S1 completely? |
ForgoneReality said: I think they did.So did they finish subbing S1 completely? |
|
ForgoneReality said: So did they finish subbing S1 completely? The whole Ashita no Joe is completely subbed since June or July. |
"Your sight, my delight. Will you marry me?" |
| Only 10 days till the poll break ends. Time to schedule some, so that I know what to watch next week. |
|
Ventris said: Only 10 days till the poll break ends. Time to schedule some, so that I know what to watch next week. 10 days? I'm pretty sure that I set the break for four months. The hiatus ends in November. |
| You did indeed. Nevermind then. I had it wrong in my memories. (Though I'd be up for some polling again) |
|
| I'd like to get polls back up again, but I'm really busy right now (plus, I'm getting some frustrating internet problems.) Still, if starting earlier would mean we'd actually get more voters, then I'm down for that. But, somehow, I still think that very little people will vote. Also, dude, we have the same banner. It's comment after comment with Shichika's face. Power to Katanagatari. XD |
| Tbh, stuff like Erin and manga will always be a close call, wether we poll it now or in a month or next January. On the other hand, HxH or Ping Pong would propably go through even if we opened a poll right this minute. So I don't think it would really make a difference. But it's not my call to make and I could survive postponing for another month :D > It's comment after comment with Shichika's face. Power to Katanagatari. XD Damn right it is! Took us long enough to make it happen :3 |
|
| List update [*]Removed from Purgatory: Hyouka, Uchuu Senkan Yamato (Original), [*]Added to New Mentions: Onii-sama e..., Ie Naki Ko [*]Promoted to Purgatory: Sora no Woto, Rescue Me! [*]Ready to Poll: Erin, Gundam: War in the Pocket, Ping Pong, Hunter x Hunter, Uchuu Senkan Yamato 2199 |
| Bartender only needs one more vote! :D D: |
| I just realized that the chart of the E-list was actualized some months ago. So I was watching the new chart and now I have some doubts about it. First of all, Aria The Animation is Enlightenment? I ask this because despite not being on the list if it is in the chart and the otherwise case with Aoi Bungaku Series that is in the list and not in the chart. Also the season 2 & 3 of Hajime no Ippo according to the chart are Enlightenment but there aren't in the list. Also in the R.I.P. section of the chart I think Nausicaa is missing. |
 |
| Through discussion the complete series of Aria and Ippo were put on the chart. Ippo was the case where season 3 wasn't finished airing at the time of the poll. Aoi Bungaku is something of a mess from a while ago that needs to be sorted out and have an official poll. And Nausicaa is just my mistake, it should be in the graveyard section. |
| We should also considering the entire Mushishi series and adding the rest of Jojo to make it fit with the manga elist. |
| Jojolion anime when? |
| While Mushishi is just a continuation and the same story, isn't JoJo SC more like a different show? I think that all JoJo parts should be judged separately, as some are stronger and some are weaker. |
"Your sight, my delight. Will you marry me?" |
| JoJo is a bit tricky case, from what I can see. On one hand, I would definitely agree with Zeta that each part should be judged separately as they 1. have separate storylines, 2. have different characters for the most part, and 3. vary in quality. On the other hand, that may create problems in the future. Should we skip part 3 (which almost everyone agrees is not so strong)? But then what if we add part 4 in the future (provided that it gets adapted, ofc)? It definitely continues onto part 3, both in terms of powers and some characters. Basically, it is highly recommended to familiarize oneself with part 3 before getting into part 4. And if we already dismissed Haruhi movie because it's hardly able to stand alone (okay, among other reasons), that may create more than a bit of inconsistency with the way some titles are treated. I actually don't mind whatever is decided; I am only bringing this up to create further confusion because it might be used as a sort of precedent when someone brings up other sequels that are somewhat similar in nature. Well, I guess there aren't many similar cases, so that may be of little concern... |
metamorphiusOct 22, 2014 12:03 PM
 |
| I'll nominate Heartcatch Precure for e-list. Mahou Shoujo done very right, sporting excellent episodic writing and a great, fleshed out and likable cast. |
|
| +1 to Heartcatch Precure indeed. Let's get it on the list. |
| Jojolion anime when? |
More topics from this board
Sticky: » The New Manga Enlightenment Camp - All plebes and Untermenschen MUST attendExinqt - Aug 21, 2015 |
32 |
by Ducat_Revel
»»
Jul 17, 2024 5:02 AM |
|
» Anime/Manga Recommendation Thread Based on Your List ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )removed-user - Jan 25, 2013 |
1162 |
by LeonhartAugust
»»
May 13, 2024 11:17 PM |
|
» 10 Steps to Becoming an Anime ElitistDeago - Jun 2, 2023 |
2 |
by AaronRRedfield
»»
Jan 11, 2024 3:52 PM |
|
» Winter 2024 OverviewDeago - Dec 20, 2023 |
0 |
by Deago
»»
Dec 20, 2023 8:24 AM |
|
» Summer 2023 OverviewDeago - Jun 14, 2023 |
0 |
by Deago
»»
Jun 14, 2023 7:48 PM |