Move1 said: Just because an anime hurts you emotionally, doesn’t mean it’s automatically a 10/10. Bruh, it doesn’t hurt me emotionally… does that mean there’s no system in me? Like, do I just not have a heart? 💀 |
 center]  [/center] |
| While I really dislike threads like this being complacent about “overrated”, I do think there’s some valid discretion to be had considering the massive difference in ratings between the manga and the anime adaptation. Also it’s the kind of content people will gladly eat up, regardless of what objective qualities it constitutes of, especially when the visuals look hella good. That being said, this seems like a very needless discussion given that people are bound to have many various perspectives on shows with sensitive content like this, anyways. |
 |
| Wait for it to end. As someone who has read the manga, the start is very good at making you think it could be better than what it actually is. It's still a great story, but I am near certain it will fall of in score by the time it ends. |
| Also available at: YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCK8spdL1M_J-z0vO2C7jPLw Second Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@AshPolygonsDo/videos Twitter: https://x.com/APolygons2 Backloggd: https://backloggd.com/games/lib/rating?page=8 IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/user/ur107632777/?ref_=uspf_nv_profile |
| 10/10 anime, 10/10 manga. 1.4/10 ragebait |
| Y'ALL HAVE TO REALIZE!!! MY OPINION IS FACT AND I AM SO SMART - this fuckin bozo |
| All anime (nay, all fiction) depend on emotionally manipulating the audience one way or another. It's just whether or not you consciously or unconsciously fall for the tactics they use to manipulate you. Also, everything is subjective. Just because you don't think something is a 10/10 based on your arbitrary standards doesn't mean no one else can. |
| This person game both seasons of Solo Leveling 10/10. This man isn’t a clown, they are the whole goddamn circus Also they gave To Your Eternity S1 a 10/10, which also relies on “emotional manipulation”… |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Reply to AakBan_Pochi29
your entire post screams "I'm I'm privileged I have no clue how people react when faced with difficult times...oh no wait I don't even know how bad it actually gets for some people."
the plothole as you mentioned is absolutely not a plothole. the people took the dog away because shizuka's mother is never present and her being a prostitute makes them disregard them completely. also shizuka's mother was eventually called because they were together at the clinic.
adults not intervening is as ancient as anything. people love to watch the drama and many a times you'll see a person being killed and no one comes to help this was jist a dog biting a girl.
the emotions here are portrayed well and the storyline is realistic (apart from the alien thing). innumerable children are abused by people, eveey day, suicides among children is common, bullying is common, neglectful parents are common.
um not sure what you even mean when you say this doesnt portray things right.
are you really that privileged that you've got no clue what others go through??? sounds like you love in some golden palace dude lol.
haaaa...get a reality check it ain't all roses and sunshine out there.
and I guess you should stick to anime like Saiki K
the plothole as you mentioned is absolutely not a plothole. the people took the dog away because shizuka's mother is never present and her being a prostitute makes them disregard them completely. also shizuka's mother was eventually called because they were together at the clinic.
adults not intervening is as ancient as anything. people love to watch the drama and many a times you'll see a person being killed and no one comes to help this was jist a dog biting a girl.
the emotions here are portrayed well and the storyline is realistic (apart from the alien thing). innumerable children are abused by people, eveey day, suicides among children is common, bullying is common, neglectful parents are common.
um not sure what you even mean when you say this doesnt portray things right.
are you really that privileged that you've got no clue what others go through??? sounds like you love in some golden palace dude lol.
haaaa...get a reality check it ain't all roses and sunshine out there.
and I guess you should stick to anime like Saiki K
AakBan_Pochi29 said: your entire post screams "I'm I'm privileged I have no clue how people react when faced with difficult times...oh no wait I don't even know how bad it actually gets for some people." Your entire post screams "I am so triggered because someone has posted an opinion that I don't agree with and because he triggered me I must use ad hominem instead of actually making a meaningful argument." Very mature indeed. |
| it's ok to cry bro I'll lend you a shoulder |
| are you saying that dogs don't get put down irl? Russia killed 10 thousand during the world cup. In a rural japanese community? Chappy is gone. |
| "the anime had me emotionally invested" sounds like a good enough reason for me to believe that someone can give this show a 10/10. |
 |
Reply to Ryuseishun
While I really dislike threads like this being complacent about “overrated”, I do think there’s some valid discretion to be had considering the massive difference in ratings between the manga and the anime adaptation. Also it’s the kind of content people will gladly eat up, regardless of what objective qualities it constitutes of, especially when the visuals look hella good.
That being said, this seems like a very needless discussion given that people are bound to have many various perspectives on shows with sensitive content like this, anyways.
That being said, this seems like a very needless discussion given that people are bound to have many various perspectives on shows with sensitive content like this, anyways.
| @Ryuseishun Presentation is important. When i read jojo golden wind i thought it was by far the worst part, the anime came out and people were saying it was their favorite. If the animation is good, music is good, seiyuus are good, it turns meh manga into good anime. The inverse also happens, animes like tower of god s2 are unbearable |
| This clown actually has both seasons of solo leveling on 10/10 |
Reply to PettankoLover
are you saying that dogs don't get put down irl? Russia killed 10 thousand during the world cup.
In a rural japanese community? Chappy is gone.
In a rural japanese community? Chappy is gone.
| @PettankoLover That's not what the OP has said at all though, try to improve your comprehension skills. |
| Yeah no if an anime hurts me emotionally it's a 10/10 masterpiece for me. Not gonna debate it further. |
 |
| By your amazing logic, no 10/10 drama can exist since you can ALWAYS claim "drama moment #X" happened because of eMoTioNaL mAnIpUlAtiOn. Also by your AMAZING logic you can give flawed comedy shows 10/10 but others can't use same reasoning when grading drama shows??? Or are you seriously just salty about ratings, mr.expert psychologist? It's also funny how you criticize dog-bite scene. Apparently you watch half asleep to not notice Shizuka is always alone. Where she goes, there are usually no people around. Adults did intervene after Marina SCREAMED on purpose. Who do you think called services to take the dog away? They did talk to Shizuka's mom about the dog too. Again, if you aren't half asleep, you'd notice Shizuka is hopeless, bullied, insecure and doesn't seek help from others. Even if she said the girl agitated the dog and that's why she got bit, no one would care, especially since Marina is good actress and a good liar. What's more absurd and downright idiotic is saying there was no emotional reaction from Shizuka afterwards, which is a blatant lie. She had a devastated face ever since and didn't talk to Takopi entire night. Or were you upset she didn't hang herself that same night, again? |
Reply to JoeChip
@PettankoLover
That's not what the OP has said at all though, try to improve your comprehension skills.
That's not what the OP has said at all though, try to improve your comprehension skills.
| @JoeChip He said that the entire premise is based on marika making chappy bite her and that this is unrealistic because uhh no one talked to the dog owner? (which they did, they told shizuka's mom that they were killing it) |
I tried watching this and I honestly don't understand the high MAL score, I guess anime fans nowadays really love something traumatizing. |
 (っ◔◡◔)っ 𝓘 𝔀𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓸𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓯𝓾𝓵 𝓭𝓪𝔂 ♥ |
If I like it, I'll rate it 10 |
| Just watch whatever anime you like bro |
| I didn't give this a show a 10 (as I try to be selective on 10s and have fewer than ten 10 / 10s out of the hundreds of shows I've watched), but are we to assume that you're using AoT as an example of a masterpiece of story writing? Not sure I follow on that point then. The character writing towards the end of AoT was deeply flawed. Eren basically changes his entire personality and life's goals at the drop of a hat with a complete lack of solid explanation ever provided for the drastic change he undergoes. By the time they retroactively try to explain anything, it's too little, too late and a half hearted attempt. There is literally NO way he undergoes the changes he did over the events that happened. Not a single shot. AWFUL character writing; and all that just so the author can use Eren's change as the next big mystery of the series... all that just to have another "basement" mystery to hook people. If that's your example of solid story writing, I don't know what to tell you. I really enjoyed AoT as a whole (well, until the production and writing started coming apart towards the end), but it's not perfectly written either. Heck, even the start of AoT wasn't perfectly written. I can't even honestly claim to know a "perfectly written" anime without fault. Like you said though, I don't think there are many if any shows that can be a truely perfect "masterpiece." MANY people loved attack on titan and were more willing to forgive those flaws than I was, and as such it's become a classic series to them. In your mind, the "plot hole" in takopi original sin is poor writing (even if I could honestly see it happening), whereas most people don't see it that way and are willing to suspend disbelief for a series that has deeply affected them as AoT did you. Maybe this show's introspection on the sh*t other people have going on that leads to the deeply troubled things they do to one another hits for someone in a way that, to them, is a masterpiece. All in all, I wouldn't agree that the series is only succeeding on the merit of having a deep emotional impact on people. Point is, everyone's entitled to their own opinions, even an incredibly controversial one like "the end of AoT really isn't very good at all (even if I really respect the direction they ATTEMPTED to take, but failed to write well)" or, now, your opinion on Takopi's original sin. Entirely possible that this series falls apart by the end, don't get me wrong, but just saying that as of RIGHT NOW I don't agree at all (and that's totally fine on both sides). |
Reply to turtleinshell
I didn't give this a show a 10 (as I try to be selective on 10s and have fewer than ten 10 / 10s out of the hundreds of shows I've watched), but are we to assume that you're using AoT as an example of a masterpiece of story writing? Not sure I follow on that point then. The character writing towards the end of AoT was deeply flawed. Eren basically changes his entire personality and life's goals at the drop of a hat with a complete lack of solid explanation ever provided for the drastic change he undergoes. By the time they retroactively try to explain anything, it's too little, too late and a half hearted attempt. There is literally NO way he undergoes the changes he did over the events that happened. Not a single shot. AWFUL character writing; and all that just so the author can use Eren's change as the next big mystery of the series... all that just to have another "basement" mystery to hook people.
If that's your example of solid story writing, I don't know what to tell you. I really enjoyed AoT as a whole (well, until the production and writing started coming apart towards the end), but it's not perfectly written either. Heck, even the start of AoT wasn't perfectly written. I can't even honestly claim to know a "perfectly written" anime without fault. Like you said though, I don't think there are many if any shows that can be a truely perfect "masterpiece." MANY people loved attack on titan and were more willing to forgive those flaws than I was, and as such it's become a classic series to them. In your mind, the "plot hole" in takopi original sin is poor writing (even if I could honestly see it happening), whereas most people don't see it that way and are willing to suspend disbelief for a series that has deeply affected them as AoT did you. Maybe this show's introspection on the sh*t other people have going on that leads to the deeply troubled things they do to one another hits for someone in a way that, to them, is a masterpiece.
All in all, I wouldn't agree that the series is only succeeding on the merit of having a deep emotional impact on people. Point is, everyone's entitled to their own opinions, even an incredibly controversial one like "the end of AoT really isn't very good at all (even if I really respect the direction they ATTEMPTED to take, but failed to write well)" or, now, your opinion on Takopi's original sin. Entirely possible that this series falls apart by the end, don't get me wrong, but just saying that as of RIGHT NOW I don't agree at all (and that's totally fine on both sides).
If that's your example of solid story writing, I don't know what to tell you. I really enjoyed AoT as a whole (well, until the production and writing started coming apart towards the end), but it's not perfectly written either. Heck, even the start of AoT wasn't perfectly written. I can't even honestly claim to know a "perfectly written" anime without fault. Like you said though, I don't think there are many if any shows that can be a truely perfect "masterpiece." MANY people loved attack on titan and were more willing to forgive those flaws than I was, and as such it's become a classic series to them. In your mind, the "plot hole" in takopi original sin is poor writing (even if I could honestly see it happening), whereas most people don't see it that way and are willing to suspend disbelief for a series that has deeply affected them as AoT did you. Maybe this show's introspection on the sh*t other people have going on that leads to the deeply troubled things they do to one another hits for someone in a way that, to them, is a masterpiece.
All in all, I wouldn't agree that the series is only succeeding on the merit of having a deep emotional impact on people. Point is, everyone's entitled to their own opinions, even an incredibly controversial one like "the end of AoT really isn't very good at all (even if I really respect the direction they ATTEMPTED to take, but failed to write well)" or, now, your opinion on Takopi's original sin. Entirely possible that this series falls apart by the end, don't get me wrong, but just saying that as of RIGHT NOW I don't agree at all (and that's totally fine on both sides).
| @turtleinshell We're using Solo Leveling as an example of masterpiece story writing |
| You're entitled to rate it however you want, but trying to second-guess other people's reasons for doing so and implying that they're mistaken is just condescending. And obviously, as others have pointed out, there are many animes that you've rated 10/10 that are far more dubious than Takopi, so probably best just to jog on. |
| people have their own preferences and something relatable and enjoyable could be a 10/10 for them |
| 8/10 not enough dead younglings. But for real the reason why the show is so "edgy" in a way is because it's showing the worst of the worst when it comes to how children are effected by the environment around them. This is all contracted by the little pink blob that comes from a "happy planet" who doesn't understand human emotions, trying to help these children. So yeah it's a bit out there but that's the point. |
| Go read Berserk and One Piece they're the best thing ever |
| Get better bait lmao, you can't complain about people giving this a 10/10 because it's affecting them emotionally and then give Konosuba a 10/10 because it also elicited emotions in you |
"Most anime makers are basically autistic" - Hideaki Anno |
| Regardless, it is ridiculous to mock and bash someone for giving a 10/10 to anything they think or feel that is a 10/10. Like those who enter in petty arguments on mal (very common) and check up the person's profile to judge them based on the ratings they gave to shows and use as argument against the user. Some really do consider their ratings as a definitive proof of their "sophisticated", "high class" superior taste... right, the superior anime watcher... So, is this anime a 10/10? It will be to some, to others it wont. There is no reason to try to insist to others that it is not a 10/10 but there is also no reason to get worked up for you saying that it is not a 10/10 and judging your 10/10s just because you dont think this anime will be a 10/10. However, in the case of you OP, you are doing something similar so it fits that people like that are mocking your 10/10s. Also, anyone hellbent on arguing with someone because they consider something "objectively" the worst need to detach themselves more. I disagree with your criticism, i found the story messy later on the manga and that is my main issue with it (animation can make up for it), but it is fine that you dont like it. Though it is controversial and meh, atleast you are not making outrage over fanservice against an ecchi anime or just outrage over trivial matter that really shouldnt matter, even if you are objectively wanting to state that it is not a 10/10 which is meh anyway. Regarding the dog being put down, it entirely makes sense even in the real world when that happens because that does happen in the real world, i know tons of cases (there are tons of people that simply dont have boundaries when annoying a dog and kill them when the dog reacts, when it isnt a worse reason for killing the dog) unfortunately. I wish such situations were that extraordinary and unrealistic. At the end it is a funny thread bcs people got angry over it |
INoLuvJul 12, 1:11 PM
| Imagine, people like different things. How shocking. |
| I have no cock in this fight but I do know that no one writes all that simply to have an opinion. I'm sensing someone's deep wounds have been opened but that's just my opinion suga. My real purpose in posting is to get more engagement with this post, thus granting a wish. Semper Fi carry on |
 |
More topics from this board
» Hapiness is born through talking. (The real sin?)OziDB - Aug 2 |
21 |
by O_Danilo
»»
42 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Did you like the anime endingJoeChip - Aug 8 |
48 |
by eblf2013
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Takopii no Genzai Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KANLen09 - Aug 1 |
607 |
by Towerman6789
»»
Today, 12:08 AM |
|
» My only problem with the showJaokRnd - Aug 30 |
25 |
by Sigmar-Unberogen
»»
Sep 3, 2:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Takopii no Genzai Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )IzanaSolos - Jul 4 |
345 |
by BuskHusWoah
»»
Sep 2, 8:16 PM |