skynet5c said: No, I did not give it a 10. If you are referring to my review, then that is a different case than my own ratings.cchigu said: Welp, at least from what I have watched until now, it is clearly the best show. Well, I am EXACTLY like you in this. I don't criticize anime for superficial things that self-proclaimed critics on this site do. But still, a matter of "10/10" is beyond the case of a show that can be simply labeled as "a good show", to me. And yet you gave Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san a 10/10. |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
| Does this mean that a lot of people have such low standards for an anime that anytime an anime gives them so much as just a smirk that it's so amazing that it gets a 10/10?? That kinda hurts ngl For me I just want to utilize the 1-4/10 range that is not used as much. An anime that I overall enjoyed will either get a 4 or 5 at the least. I'm not like "yeah I guess that was pretty good. TEN OUT OF TEN!!!!" |
  NYANPASU  5700XT |
skynet5c said: Because the score of the show was very low even though the show was very good from the perspective of an ecchi lover. Most of the ecchi shows here are underrated because people can't fathom the idea of giving these shows good scores. cchigu said: No, I did not give it a 10. If you are referring to my review, then that is a different case than my own ratings. But you write your own reviews. So why would you use a different scoring system? |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
skynet5c said: A particular distribution, correct, his particular distribution, not a chance. For the record I'm saying his scores are a troll, not that his comments/behavior are necessarily troll worthy, but his score is purposely designed to go up from 1-10, with 1 being the most frequent score, and there's no question of whether or not that's intentional. LostSpectre said: That seems awfully aggressive, playing dumb isn't really cute or interesting, your scores speak for themselves. I don't think having a particular score distribution means that one is trolling. There are multiple reasons why one might have an unusual score distribution: - Maybe I only list the shows on MAL that I either really loved or hated. - Maybe I have a different scoring system than the one that most people use. - Maybe I just have really unusual tastes. And so on. I agree that his insults were uncalled for though. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
BetaMaleUltra said: An anime that you "enjoyed" should get a 6 at the least, in objective terms, so are you trying too hard to use the lower scale? Does this mean that a lot of people have such low standards for an anime that anytime an anime gives them so much as just a smirk that it's so amazing that it gets a 10/10?? That kinda hurts ngl For me I just want to utilize the 1-4/10 range that is not used as much. An anime that I overall enjoyed will either get a 4 or 5 at the least. I'm not like "yeah I guess that was pretty good. TEN OUT OF TEN!!!!" |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
cchigu said: Let me get this straight, so you gave it a 10 when you really think it's a 4? What the fuck are you smoking?Because the score of the show was very low even though the show was very good from the perspective of an ecchi lover. Most of the ecchi shows here are underrated because people can't fathom the idea of giving these shows good scores. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
LostSpectre said: BetaMaleUltra said: An anime that you "enjoyed" should get a 6 at the least, in objective terms, so are you trying too hard to use the lower scale? Does this mean that a lot of people have such low standards for an anime that anytime an anime gives them so much as just a smirk that it's so amazing that it gets a 10/10?? That kinda hurts ngl For me I just want to utilize the 1-4/10 range that is not used as much. An anime that I overall enjoyed will either get a 4 or 5 at the least. I'm not like "yeah I guess that was pretty good. TEN OUT OF TEN!!!!" Yeah I agree that's how it SHOULD be my preference is to keep it at a 4 or 5. Just because I think there's more levels of good then there are levels of bad. Want to give more breathing room for the GOOD anime to make it more easy to differentiate between which anime I preferred over the other. If my base line is 6 then I only have 5 levels of good to choose from. But since my baseline is more like a 5 then I have more options to choose from when trying to show how much I liked said anime. If I have less options to choose from, I might have to give 2 different anime both a 7 even though I liked one slightly more. With a lower base line and thus more options, I can show that difference and give one anime a 7 and the other one an 8 for example. Like to me if it's bad, it's bad, give that shit a 2 or 3 or something |
NYANPASU 5700XT |
LostSpectre said: No, I gave it a 10 because it was easier to write a review just considering just all the positive points and I just wanted to write some bullshit so I couldn't care less. ¯\_(γ)_/¯cchigu said: Let me get this straight, so you gave it a 10 when you really think it's a 4? What the fuck are you smoking?Because the score of the show was very low even though the show was very good from the perspective of an ecchi lover. Most of the ecchi shows here are underrated because people can't fathom the idea of giving these shows good scores. @skynet5c Yeah, that is certainly a point I agree with you on. But at the end of the day, only the polarizing reviews are going to get attention anyway. Even if we had the upvote/downvote system just like before, the reviews on the top page were still rating the show either very low or very high. The reviews trying to show both sides of the coin are plenty on this site but it is very rare to see them getting traction. |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
BetaMaleUltra said: Oh, that's an interesting viewpoint, but I would think you would still run out of room at some point, I have a ton of 7's and could benefit from your approach, but I don't need them to be equal or anything like that, each show is rated individually, and can't be compared to any other with the same rating, unless they're very similar in scope, like 2 ecchi comedies.. LostSpectre said: An anime that you "enjoyed" should get a 6 at the least, in objective terms, so are you trying too hard to use the lower scale? Yeah I agree that's how it SHOULD be my preference is to keep it at a 4 or 5. Just because I think there's more levels of good then there are levels of bad. Want to give more breathing room for the GOOD anime to make it more easy to differentiate between which anime I preferred over the other. If my base line is 6 then I only have 5 levels of good to choose from. But since my baseline is more like a 5 then I have more options to choose from when trying to show how much I liked said anime. If I have less options to choose from, I might have to give 2 different anime both a 7 even though I liked one slightly more. With a lower base line and thus more options, I can show that difference and give one anime a 7 and the other one an 8 for example. Like to me if it's bad, it's bad, give that shit a 2 or 3 or something |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
cchigu said: Yeah, you didn't deny a single thing I just said, so I'm not sure why started off trying to do so, the situation seems to be exactly as I stated it. LostSpectre said: No, I gave it a 10 because it was easier to write a review just considering just all the positive points and I just wanted to write some bullshit so I couldn't care less. ¯\_(γ)_/¯Let me get this straight, so you gave it a 10 when you really think it's a 4? What the fuck are you smoking? |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| It really depends on what they consider a 10 and how they rate. Some folks in this thread are already mentioning their reasons, so I won't go deep into that. If they believe that almost every anime is good enough to be considered great or a masterpiece, then that's on them. I find it odd for others to assume that these people have no standards. The content on their list can already clearly show what they would want to watch/read or drop, and those ratings could still have some nuance to the users themselves. InspectorLunge said: There is no objective methodology of giving ratings; Yes; the scale is from 1-10 but most people don't really utilize the entire scale and that's theirs subjective way of rating which is not against the rules. And yes, exactly this. I'd also like to add that some people use the scale to compare between anime, while others use the scale at face value. There's no objectively wrong way to do it, so a 10 doesn't always have to imply that it's the gold standard. |
  |
| Its ok to be curious about how people rate their favs but to the people who insult or bring down people for it stop you need help. |
LostSpectre said: No, it is kind of a mixed bag tbh and I couldn't really be bothered to give an answer. I consider Yuuragi Yuuna a good ecchi, but the thing is that I hate ecchi anime. As for my review, it is definitely a low effort joke. cchigu said: Yeah, you didn't deny a single thing I just said, so I'm not sure why started off trying to do so, the situation seems to be exactly as I stated it. No, I gave it a 10 because it was easier to write a review just considering just all the positive points and I just wanted to write some bullshit so I couldn't care less. ¯\_(γ)_/¯ |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
LostSpectre said: skynet5c said: A particular distribution, correct, his particular distribution, not a chance. For the record I'm saying his scores are a troll, not that his comments/behavior are necessarily troll worthy, but his score is purposely designed to go up from 1-10, with 1 being the most frequent score, and there's no question of whether or not that's intentional. I don't think having a particular score distribution means that one is trolling. There are multiple reasons why one might have an unusual score distribution: - Maybe I only list the shows on MAL that I either really loved or hated. - Maybe I have a different scoring system than the one that most people use. - Maybe I just have really unusual tastes. And so on. I agree that his insults were uncalled for though. Everyone purposely designs their scoring system in a certain way. What really matters is the top or bottom %. For example, if someone rated 28% of the anime they watched 10/10, I would compare that with my top 28% (8-10) and not just with my own 10/10. I'd gladly lower all my 2-4 to 1 and scale the rest accordingly, in order to better distinguish various levels of "good" (and I don't care much about various levels of "bad"). The only reason I'm not doing it is that I still wanna comply to MAL's definition of 4=bad, which I translate as 5=something I'd never drop. |
 |
Nirinbo said: LostSpectre said: A particular distribution, correct, his particular distribution, not a chance. For the record I'm saying his scores are a troll, not that his comments/behavior are necessarily troll worthy, but his score is purposely designed to go up from 1-10, with 1 being the most frequent score, and there's no question of whether or not that's intentional. I'd gladly lower all my 2-4 to 1 and scale the rest accordingly, in order to better distinguish various levels of "good" (and I don't care much about various levels of "bad"). The only reason I'm not doing it is that I still wanna comply to MAL's definition of 4=bad, which I translate as 5=something I'd never drop. Yeah I can totally sympathize with that. If I saw a new anime that blows all the other anime I've seen out of the water, then I would rate it a 10 and lower all my previous 10s to 9s and scale the rest accordingly. |
| I literally have three 10/10s but I rate 75% on enjoyment and 25% on the other parts of it. The production side is usually my lowest priority unless it's distracting enough. My 10s are essentially the stuff I not only enjoyed the most, but also left an emotional impact on me and it's something I still think about to this day. It's been a while since I've been able to confidently give something a 10 without dropping it's score. |
 my life was made with mematic. |
Nirinbo said: I wasn't referring to a criteria or scoring peculiarity, I was referring to the fact they intentionally have their ratings going up from 1 in terms of most watched, with decreasing frequency. I would assume there's additional trolling with giving certain mediocre shows a 10 and more critically acclaimed shows a 1, but that's all secondary and besides the point, they're clearly manipulated and can't be taken seriously, even if some are legitimate scores, there's no way of knowing which is which. LostSpectre said: A particular distribution, correct, his particular distribution, not a chance. For the record I'm saying his scores are a troll, not that his comments/behavior are necessarily troll worthy, but his score is purposely designed to go up from 1-10, with 1 being the most frequent score, and there's no question of whether or not that's intentional. Everyone purposely designs their scoring system in a certain way. What really matters is the top or bottom %. For example, if someone rated 28% of the anime they watched 10/10, I would compare that with my top 28% (8-10) and not just with my own 10/10. I'd gladly lower all my 2-4 to 1 and scale the rest accordingly, in order to better distinguish various levels of "good" (and I don't care much about various levels of "bad"). The only reason I'm not doing it is that I still wanna comply to MAL's definition of 4=bad, which I translate as 5=something I'd never drop. |
LostSpectreMay 6, 2021 2:09 PM
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| I’m the type of person that just rates anime based on only my entertainment. |
| Bruh it's because I spend fucking days just browsing through what interests me, then I find the anime with good animation, and then I watch. I take my time to find what I really think will blow me away nowadays and I'm not disappointed. |
 |
| Everyone has the right to give whatever score they want but, in my opinion, the more 10/10 someone hands out the less meaning they have. If someone that has watched 500 shows considers 10 of them to be a 10/10 masterpiece and said someone recommends I watch one of those 10 I will value his recommendation more than I would if he had rated 100 shows a 10/10 because at a certain point if you consider everything to be a masterpiece then nothing really is. |
 |
| Because I mean everyone has different thought processes on it. It is their list so I mean why do you care how they score it |
| Because people feel like it. Rating stuff is all subjective anyways, it's Saul Goodman! |
Vivo in somno. Solitarie putresco in inferis. Hic dies meus obitus dies, et meus nativus dies. Te obeam. Mea anima immortalis. Autem mea futura necata sunt. Manes sum. Animam definire ambiguum est. Te odi, et te amo. Conveniamus in somnio ipso. |
| Cuz I only rate it based on enjoyment, ofc there are anime that are much better but share the same score, anime is just a hobby of mine and I really don't think that much about giving a score |
 "I want to show that woman the true Yoshikage Kira. I want her to hear how I feel deep inside. That I want to take your slender neck into these hands and strangle you to death." |
| There are just so many good shows man! Also it's whatever you shouldn't care too much about other people you know And another thing, those are personal scores and definitely not objective, not everyone is a critic in anime so handing 10 even though there are obvious plot holes, bad writing or whatever doesn't matter if the person felt a connection to a certain piece |
| we do a little bit of headbanging hereο»Ώ |
| not all the anime that got a 10/10 are in my favorites i only use it when i really loved the anime |
kiwixcoke said: It is certainly dumb because good shows are actually tough to come by for me.Idk, some people choose to watch good shows.. How dumb right? |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
| stop caring about other people's list only care if your distribution has 2 peaks |
 |
| Me handing out 10s easily?? Wow, how unheard of xDDDD It'd only look like I hand out a lot of 10s because I've watched literally 3k worth of stuff. |
 |
| I've only given out 13 10s while I've rated over 3000 anime in total. 10s have to connect with me on a deep level. |
  |
| Cause I can and I rate based on my enjoyment. I'm not a critic so I won't try to judge the anime through out the series...what's the point of watching sum if u know u are not going to enjoy it? I look/watch stuff that I know I will like. Sometimes I do watch random stuff but not always which is why I don't have a lot of low ratings |
| "he has it big as a cactus but he won't let go of my head and I puke on his cock bitch" - Boy by Fishball |
| Some people aren't super deliberate about their ratings. I say this because I used to be the same way. For me a 10 was basically = great, and it applied to a lot of anime. Basically a lot of people don't really care or try to be super logical or subjective about the anime they watch. They just throw that shit in there and give it a 10. It's all good tho. |
| The only anime that deserves 10/10 is Inferno Cop. Rest is debatable. |
 |
| I have never felt the need to justify my ratings to others so just assume I am my own person and rate things how I see fit. |
| I give 10s if I truly love it, one of my friends give it out so easily and it’s truly disgusting |
 |
| We get it dude, you're like an anime connoisseur or whatever I give 10's to shows, I feel like have truly earned it. Simple as that. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Does Old Anime age poorly or do people age poorly?Dragevard - 4 hours ago |
20 |
by Subarctic-Forest
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Anime powers you wish you hadST63LTH - Yesterday |
19 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Write your takes in anime and I'll prove you're incorrect. ( 1 2 3 )Gashadokur0 - May 21 |
115 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Do you think anime has ever negatively impacted someone's life?removed-user - May 10 |
30 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» Dumb narcissistic perverts is supposed to be funny? ( 1 2 )Ri-KoRin - May 21 |
50 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
9 minutes ago |