 Soy sauce made from hair after shaving |
MkimNov 3, 2019 11:11 AM
| gone bai bai |
I prefer watching shows either already rated 7+ or interesting plot if new seasonal show. Hence the high mean score. |
 |
| this isn't a bad categorization of the MAL ranking system. Even with shows I hate (below a 5/4) I still try to finish them out so as to give a good/balanced score. I'm not giving a show I dropped a score as maybe the ending redeemed its bad initial scoring in my head and could make it better. Though I'm not about to go back and try to stomach through the initial show if thats the case and better to just leave it dropped imo than to give it a final ranking on my list. |
the same as MAL, 5-1 not watch. 6-10 at your discretion. |
| If I finish it, it means I like it. No need to give it a number. |
| I mostly give a score depending on my enjoyment, but I noticed I started to give a few bad scores since I got aboard the seasonal anime train But I never gave any 1 or 2 yet, and I hope I'll never do I usually use a 7-10 rating system since I try to only watch anime I enjoy, and I don't mind giving a 10 either |
| 1:It was so horrible that I want to punch myself for giving this a chance. 2:I hate that I saw this. 3:I didn't need to see this. 4:I can live without this. 5:Whatever. 6:Issokay, we all make mistakes sometimes, like the producer of this for example. 7:Great stuff 8:Would kiss the producers and buy them coffee. 9:Amazing.Really liked it, recommended. 10:Cleaned my skin, made me loose 10 kilos, I grew wings and now I'm about to live my best life as a forest hybrid elf/angel because of this show.I'll probably sleep to this every night and eat breakfast with this show playing on TV. |
 |
| 1 = hate 3 = dislike 5 = meh 7 = like 9 = love fill in = tweaks from these base values 10 = currently unused |
| Avatar character is Gabriel from Gabriel DropOut. |
 ssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss |
 |
Basically, the more pantyshots and large breasts an anime has, the higher it's rated, like this: Edit: Just realized I didn't know how to read a graph |
removed-userNov 4, 2019 2:16 AM
| I use the good ol' german system, 1-6 scale, meaning 1 is the best thing ever and 6 being the worst. Serious answer: I gave 10 to my favs, 9 and 8 to the shows I like a lot, 7 and 6 to the so so stuff, 5 to mediocre stuff. And 4,3 and 2 to the boring bad anime. I keep 1 for that anime that will really be bad and ugly (flcl alt was close) |
    |
| Enjoymeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeent |
My Candies 2024:        My Bonus Candies 2024:  |
 Yeah that's how it is and if someone don't agree with me he/she is objectively wrong |
| 0: The Special type of garbage 1: Just garbage 2: Downright Bad 3: Boring 4: Mediocre 5: Decent 6: Could be better 7: Good 8: Awesome 9: Near Perfect 10: S-Class |
| Based on enjoyment because I'm a simpleton with no eye for objective quality |
| poop |
| i usually don't even pick up anime i don't think i'll enjoy, and i rate based on a feeling rather than an objective scale... so my ratings tend to skew higher. that being said, i have watched a few anime before i registered that aren't on my list purely because i disliked them... so ¯\_(γ)_/¯ |
 |
The way I rate is the exact opposite of this [/url] |
| I pretty much just go by how bad I think something is. I could factor in how boring I thought it was, but usually just use that to decide whether or not to drop something. |
| I try my best to evaluate both my enjoyment from the series and how good I thought the series was and give it a number. 10 means an anime that spoke to me on an emotional level and provided me with an amount of enjoyment per minute more than anything else could, 5 means an anime I thought was pretty par for the course, and 1 means an anime so awful it's hard to even call it an anime at all. The other ratings are in between those. Since 5 is what I give to average anime my mean score is also very close to 5. |
  |
| bleh I just stopped caring bout that. I no longer rate my anime. In my case, I just felt that thinking of a score kind of took part of the enjoyment. I feel better just watching them without having to think of what the score for it is. |
| Using the one that MAL provided, seems silly to use another one. |
 |
| Throwing a dart at a board while drunk and under the influence of the gods. |
 |
| I reserve 1 - 5 for characters I hate. The lower the number between 1 and 5, the more intensely I hate a single character or multiple characters. 6 is an oddball anime that has likable characters, but nothing else is consistent. 7 has likable characters and is consistent, but is full of missed opportunities. 8 has likable characters and is consistent, and fulfills almost but not all of my selfish desires, and it was made clear to me that it wasn't going to fulfill all of them. 9 is an anime that led me on and therefore I expected it to fulfill every selfish desire, but dropped the ball late in the game. 10 is an anime I expected to fulfill every selfish desire and it did. |
IpreferEcchiNov 3, 2019 9:26 PM
    |
| 1, Are for Yuri bait, rape trash And also for those so called Yuri that have to much heterosexuality in it, Or heterosexual kissing or to aggressive males in them!! And also for them that sexual shaming my waifus or if the waifu is getting lewd in front of a male,, They are MY females and I dont share!! Sexual shaming my girls and you get on the trash pile!!! Or over the top with the violence against my girls,, Take it easy with my angels!! 2-5 Shounen and other trash not very impressed but some fun can be gain from it!! 6-7. More trash but better trash,, Trash can be fun sometimes but its still trash! ,, And Impure Yuri that broke my rule but not to severely!!! 8-9 . For the highest of Shounen trash and other I like, But they are not Yuri's so no 10s. And also for the Yuri that are very good put still have some rule violation and therefor Didn't reach the high heavens!! 10,, Reserved for my lesbians angels,, Anime's with pure females that have gain my favour!! The once that have reach high heavens and won my heart,, My lesbian waifus!! My Goddesses rightful place next to me,,MY lesbian harem!!,, Only for the purest of girls!! My little favourites! My pure Yuri's!! Im a silly old man that love my anime girls!! If they play nicely they will get a 10!! Cant say no to them =P They are soo fucking cute!! =) And for that they deserves highest of points!!  |
Yuri-CrusaderNov 8, 2019 11:03 PM
 |
| You won't believe! As it is intended to be used. |
  |
| 8 is great 5 is average everything else is contextualized by these two numbers. I'm not losing sleep over whether or not an anime is a 3 or a 4. basically, I use it how mal intends it. none of this "I never give lower than a 7" nonsense |
 |
| 1 - I really really dislike it 2 - I really dislike it 3 - I dislike it 4 - I sorta dislike it 5 - neutral 6 - I sorta like it 7 - I like it 8 - I really like it 9 - I really really like it 10 - I really really really like it As you can see, my scoring system is quite intricate. |
FlowersInTheRain said: Heimur said: Using the one that MAL provided, seems silly to use another one. Agreed. I am the same. I don't get why people don't follow the standard. Because, 1. It makes no difference. Whether one only uses the high end, only the low end, considers 5 a good score, or considers 5 a bad score. In the end, one is going to be influencing the difference in ratings the same as long as they apply their score system the same way with every anime. And, most importantly, 2. Most people who follow the given system end up only using the high end for 90%+ of the anime on their list. And then give pretty arbitrary low scores to the occasional show they don't like. Someone will give every 7+ then give a 2 to something for whatever reason. If you ask me, that makes very little sense. You're basically cramming every you like in to 3-4 tiers, and then giving a random score about of 6-7 tiers that are mostly unused when you don't like something. I was like that too, but after a while I wanted my scores to have more meaning, so I spread out everything from 'it bored me' to 'life-changing best experience ever' from 3-10. Anime I consider 'bad' I only use 1-2. This fits better with my philosophy that there are very few truly 'bad' anime and most stuff people don't like it's just because those shows aren't for them. People need to be more humble and admit when it was their failure to appreciate something rather than the show failing them. So my system look like this: 10 - Groundbreaking Experience. Stuff which pushed to boundaries of what I thought I could experience from fiction/art. 9 - Complete Experience. Stuff which reached the peak of what is possible without breaking new ground for me personally in any way. For all intents and purposes this is my highest score - my 'masterpiece' tier. 8 - Almost Complete Experience. A 'flawed masterpiece'. It did everything right except for that one thing. Be it a poor ending or some other plot failing, a character that had potential but didn't quite hit the mark, or whatever it was, there was something that held it back. 7 - Exceptional. Something which stands out due to one or more elements which had the makings of a 9+ but there were too many little nagging issues or one big thing like a terrible ending. 6- Solid. There was nothing really amazing or stand-out, but the anime achieved what it set out to do well enough. 5- Alright. Enjoyable at times but mostly uninspired. I liked it as much as I like most anime. 4- Weak. Very uninspired. Rarely enjoyable. The opposite of 8s in that with these there was only one thing which kept me watching. Usually a cute girl with decent fan service, sometimes it's a case of anime which continually look like something interesting is going to happen but it never does. 3. Boring. Completely uninspired. Then 2&1 are punishment tiers for when I feel like something fundamentally fails as art. Usually a botched production on top of a completely uninspired concept or something which shouldn't even be on MAL like this: |
| “In individuals, insanity is rare; but in groups, parties, nations and epochs, it is the rule.” -Friedrich Nietzsche Aggregate scoring is bad for the anime fandom |
| Those fucking graphics are killing me, lmao. I love the internet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- My enjoyment is actually the biggest factor when it comes to scores: 10- Masterpiece: Basically all time favorites that had me excited about the story and art. 9- Excellent: Brilliant, I enjoyed a ton but it had something that I did not like. 8- Very Good: Can be that I enjoyed an specific aspect of the series, but it had some flaws (usually being 12 episodes hurts series for me, or not having a final per se). 7- Good: I would recommend it, but it might not be for everyone or did not met my expectations. 6- Regular: Most of the things I have watched. I kinda like it but just to a certain degree. 5- Mediocre: Same as 6 but it did not make a reaction on me, so most of my shows with a 5 are/were boring. 4- Bad: Nothing memorable besides animation, character designs or maybe an specific character. 3- Very Bad: Most of the bad anime I have seen but I enjoyed to some extent. 2- Terrible: Things that hurt or were a complete waste of time. 1- Basically Midori, Blood C and very few shows. |
| If i like it it gets a good score :) I use every score from 1-10, 9 being the same as a 1 the other way around. 10 is for the extra nutti stuff. I can enjoy a show that gets a 3 tho, trash can be enjoyable. |
-Mullerio-Nov 10, 2019 1:34 AM
 |
| 10 - Usual 9 - Usual 8 - Usual 7 - Usual 6 below - fail |
 |
| BAD SCORES: 1: Fuck off. The worst of the worst. No merits whatsoever, just pure trash. 2: Horrible. Some minor redeeming factors, but overall egregious. 3: Bad. I had no enjoyment, but there might've been some aspect I liked (such as music, art, etc). 4: Mediocre. Big "meh" for me. Either highly flawed and somewhat enjoyable or a decent show that I just didn't like for whatever reason. 5: Average. Pretty self-explanatory, but this is also the score I give to shows that I respect, even if I didn't like them. GOOD SCORES: 6: Good. The pros outweighed the cons, but it's not something I'd revisit. Still recommendable. 7: Very good. Thoroughly enjoyed these from start to finish. Maybe a dull moment here or there, but a solid watch. 8: Excellent. This score (or higher) means that I consider myself a member of the fanbase. These shows are typically the peak of my personal enjoyment, and I often find myself rewatching them on a whim. 9: Phenomenal. These made me feel a wide spectrum of emotions. All-time favorites of mine, and always possessing an outstanding amount of technical merit (quality of direction, writing, audiovisual aspects, etc). 10: Transcendent. Essentially flawless in my eyes, but what pushes these works the extra mile is the fact that I learned something valuable from them that I'll likely never forget for the rest of my life. This applies to any artistic medium: anime, film, literature, manga, etc. These are the kinds of works that inspire me on both a personal and creative level. I can see myself rewatching or rereading these for years and years to come. |
 "I am not sure that I exist, actually. I am all the writers that I have read, all the people that I have met, all the women that I have loved; all the cities I have visited." β Jorge Luis Borges [url=]Goodreads[/url] | [url=]Letterboxd[/url] |
| This is exactly what I would love to follow. Book_Lover said: 10: Masterpiece. While it might have some problems, those are so minor that they are hardly worth the mention. 9: Great/Fantastic: Great piece of anime that might have some problems or personal nitpicks that I can't ignore but still love it. 8: Very Good: Enjoyed the anime, had some more problems with it. But left me feeling satisfied in some way. 7: Good: Good, could have been better. Had some flaws; either personal issues with it or other flaws. 6: Fine: A nice little anime, enjoyed it but just didn't love it as much as I could. 5: Average: Had a lot of problems that I just couldn't ignore. But some stuff I did enjoy. Kind of meh. 4: Bad: Maybe a couple of characters I enjoyed, or some sort of character development or music or whatever I enjoyed, but the rest I didn't. 3: Very Bad: Got annoyed multiple times with the character(s) or certain scenes in the anime. 2: Horrible: Disappointed in the way that the characters, character development and/or the story happened. Might enjoy one or two things, but overall was severely disappointed. 1: Appalling: Ugh just awful. Where's the bleach? |
cianxanJul 27, 2020 5:32 AM
| i use the one on here, except on the old scoring system on MAL it was 4 is decent and i dont wanna change my scores |
| yum riceballs i just want a baccano! season 2 |
| Pretty much who it was intended, but I do understand why people get so frustated while tring to chose betwen close numbers I developed this method to help: Imagine a scale of 1 to 5 1 is "I Disliked it alot" 2 is "I disliked it" 3 is "I don't liked or disliked it" 4 is "I liked it" and 5 is "I liked it alot" Then after you chose a number you mutiply it by 2 and them think "betwen only the shows that I rated 2/4/6/8/10 does it feels like the better half or the lower half?" if it feels like the better half you keep the score if not you decress 1 |
| heh. |
| In my country grades are from 2(fail) to 6(excellent) so I thought it would be much easier to score animes on MAL like that: 2-fail, 3-poor, 4-good, 5-very good, 6-excellent, so I can then have to explain to people I know and don't know why and how I rate animes from 2 to 5 on a 10 point system. But because we also have halves, like good 3.5 is equal to good 4 it got really complicated and....you get it π Yeah I'm just using the MAL scoring as you're supposed to. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Which is the right way to look at your waifu?SgtBateMan - 5 hours ago |
8 |
by tchitchouan
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» Are 2010s Anime now considered "old"?Dragevard - Yesterday |
15 |
by Richard_drizzle
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
» What anime that got hype or huge budget that got flop.Kisaragi_Toka - 8 hours ago |
14 |
by Kisaragi_Toka
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» Vegeta is a damn jobber! I can't take it anymore!Polatrix - 1 hour ago |
4 |
by Prideful_Lion
»»
31 minutes ago |
|
» What are your New Year Anime Goals?AllAlone8 - Yesterday |
25 |
by Coaghim
»»
59 minutes ago |