YoyoIsMyNickname said: It was a joke really. I cant believe you guys got so sensitive about it. So what if that hentai meme got 1# Lmao it would have probably boosted this sites views, and its not like the ratings even matter here as most reviewers just review subjectively. No one asked nor cared about a random dude boosting the site's views when even the random dude said in his videos that MAL is already having massive views. So what's the point in playing the good Samaritan and then the victim? |
Fortune favours the bold!  |
Damuzen said: Did Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu get re-evaluated again ? After the first fix, it was at 9.07, and I just noticed it's now at 9.12 (which is great, and it deserves to be even higher) I thought it was a glitch at first becuz it suddenly got this much higher but now I think this might be a case why it got higher |
 |
| finally LoGH nearly at the top puting trash anime where it belongs all hail MAL mods |
moeslasherFeb 28, 2020 12:13 PM
| Still shocked that Ashita no Joe got its fix by jumping to 8.66 but Aria is still at 8.58 o_õ |
 |
| Nice move. Hopefully MAL scores are going to be more reliable in the future. |
webM-guy said: If the account is legitimate why would they meme-vote? Because they have an account that they use regularly but still want to join in on the meme. Being a normal user and joining vote brigades aren't mutually exclusive. For the rest of your concerns, I think the section "Vote Brigading" in the first post answers it, particularly this line: "When an individual leads an organized voting raid on a website, instructing his followers to vote yes/no/10/1/5/green—and 15,000+ votes of that specific value come in less than 12 hours, the entry's score has been compromised due to vote brigading." Simply put, if your own score didn't come in the same time frame as all those (or it wasn't a 10/10), it likely counted as normal. The second algorithm is only meant to be used in extreme cases such as this one where it's extremely clear that there was a vote brigade, not for a sudden - but comparatively small - surge in viewers/scores. Besides, the example you posed (binging an anime off a random YouTube video), while it may certainly create a surge in viewers, it's incredibly unlikely they'd all score it the same, so such an event wouldn't even be on the radar. |
Nostalgik said: Still shocked that Ashita no Joe got its fix by jumping to 8.66 but Aria is still at 8.58 o_õ Aria the origination score jumped from 8.51 to 8.60 when they fixed it, but yesterday the score drop to 8.58 |
| Good news...Glad you guys went for all that trouble. |
HaChiiman said: Yeah but i definitely thought it would go further than that. i remember its score being 8.65+ before the 1/10 nation attacked. and now its just going further down again Q.QNostalgik said: Still shocked that Ashita no Joe got its fix by jumping to 8.66 but Aria is still at 8.58 o_õ Aria the origination score jumped from 8.51 to 8.60 when they fixed it, but yesterday the score drop to 8.58 |
|
Nostalgik said: HaChiiman said: Yeah but i definitely thought it would go further than that. i remember its score being 8.65+ before the 1/10 nation attacked. and now its just going further down again Q.QAria the origination score jumped from 8.51 to 8.60 when they fixed it, but yesterday the score drop to 8.58 I thought it would enter the top 10, as it is in RAL ranking http://www.redditanimelist.net/ |
HaChiiman said: oh damn, that's amazing! ashita no joe has 8.81 over there, that's cool. I wasn't expecting it on the top 10, that's pretty hard still xD but i was counting on a rise to the 8.80s~ at least :sNostalgik said: Yeah but i definitely thought it would go further than that. i remember its score being 8.65+ before the 1/10 nation attacked. and now its just going further down again Q.Q I thought it would enter the top 10, as it is in RAL ranking http://www.redditanimelist.net/ (*inner fanboy cries*) |
|
| So from looking at the Visible Changes thing, I get that the Rank and Score are the ones to be changed to discount illegitimate votes, and that the Members count and the Statistics are not. But I have a question: is the Popularity Rank affected one way or another? I know it wasn't mentioned since it had little to do with the main issue of this, but I'm just wondering cuz I like to track that data. |
| Yep, more visible changes these last hours/days Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood : 9.23 -> 9.24 Steins;Gate : 9.14 -> 9.13 Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu : 9.07 -> 9.12 Gintama' : 9.08 -> 9.10 Your Name : 9.09 -> 9.08 Aria the Origination : 8.60 -> 8.58 Some other series changed too Made in Abyss 3rd movie was at ~ 8.60 before the fix, fell down around 8.00 right after that and now is back at 8.50 I was surprised to see that change, I thought they were done with fixing the scores, guess I was wrong |
YoyoIsMyNickname said: DeathTheKid4 said: No one asked nor cared about a random dude boosting the site's views when even the random dude said in his videos that MAL is already having massive views. So what's the point in playing the good Samaritan and then the victim? The point is, is that it’s a joke, there is no point behind a joke and to honestly get angry at that is sad. No, no, no, you can't twist it anymore. I heard it all, from being a joke, to being a goodwill act, to being a protest, to being a joke again and so on. All that Nux, Hero Hei and their fans are doing is twist their statements again and again and again, going in circles and never having a final statement. |
Fortune favours the bold! |
| Congratulations to everyone involved!👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏 Hopefully, now, the trolls will be restrained! Also, Chihayafuru 3 finally has the score it deserves! 🥰 I really do expect this will be last of these trolls. You need to be seriously messed up to meddle with a series' score due to your personal tastes. |
| An easier and better job would be to require a social number to prove identity, and don't try to tell me that FMA:B is better than One Piece, sales prove otherwise. |
| -And the lord poked his head out from the patron clouds, to look down on his followers in chaos and anarchy as the world was already aflame, out he tossed a canister of gasoline, and out from his mouth his words were: "Screw it." |
tonytakitany said: Will one day the ability to create Lists will be available,,, here... on myanimeLIST .... you know like top 100 suspense animes best animes of 80's etc... I really wish that too |
| Thank god this is finally in place, the chihayafuru score in particular was very upsetting, I was real worried that it would permanently scare the score, since it's not like these people ever go back and remove their bullshit scores once they no longer care, they just let it sit. The past few seasons have seen a real rise in this kind of behaviour so I'm glad it's getting fixed, people should try to praise the things they like correctly and dislike the things they dislike correctly to get their points and views across and not just try and spam the system into oblivion to try and trick others into avoiding or looking for different shows. |
| LOL, your opinion is wrong! |
Blindruler said: Harucchan said: Congratulations to everyone involved!👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏🎉👏 Hopefully, now, the trolls will be restrained! Also, Chihayafuru 3 finally has the score it deserves! 🥰 I really do expect this will be last of these trolls. You need to be seriously messed up to meddle with a series' score due to your personal tastes. Meddle with a series score due to personal taste? You mean like voting a show highly? Isn’t that kinda the whole point of the site? I get that you shouldn’t make multiple accounts or anything but I know there are a lot of shows that I like that people don’t rate highly here (IE the .hack// series) and personally I think gintama is HIGHLY overrated. Is it messed up that I voted a low rated show highly and a high rated show low? Honey, read what I wrote. I didn't say you can't rate the shows based on your personal tastes, I said it's messed up to meddle with the scores based on your personal tastes. One individual scores makes no difference... By meddling, it's implicit I'm talking about the trolls. Instead of trying to pick a fight, I advise you to read a second time or to improve your interpretation abilities. Passar bem, amadah |
FullyCharged said: YoyoIsMyNickname said: The point is, is that it’s a joke, there is no point behind a joke and to honestly get angry at that is sad. Leave that loser alone. He's crying on the forums, twitter, anywhere possible, since this thing started. Stop stalking me, thank you |
Fortune favours the bold! |
| Something I noticed when checking the score for Skelter Heaven is that this process has dropped some titles underneath the 50 user limit to have a weighted score. Skelter Heaven is currently at 10105 on the chart, but before the change rolled in it was at 10291. While it is unlikely to actually matter in the long run due to their low popularity, it is curious to note this unintended side effect. |
on 
| LoGH now back up to where it belongs, 9.12. Very satisfied, thank you Kineta and crew. |
| Aaaand say hello to Gintama°, suddenly bursting into the 2nd place Wasn't expected, but I'm pleased |
| Happy to see Gintama° in 2nd. Unfortunately seeing a lot of 1 votes when looking at its stats though. |
| This recalibration has screwed up the whole system. We were getting close to having all of Gintama out of the 9 star range, but now one of the 5 million seasons is #2. Gintama is trash. If I had 2 wishes, first would be the deletion of Hunter x Hunter from all of time and space, and second would be the same for Gintama. Gintama is trash. |
| Hunter x Hunter is a 1/10 |
winfoharso said: This recalibration has screwed up the whole system. We were getting close to having all of Gintama out of the 9 star range, but now one of the 5 million seasons is #2. Gintama is trash. If I had 2 wishes, first would be the deletion of Hunter x Hunter from all of time and space, and second would be the same for Gintama. Gintama is trash. So much salt in here |
Fortune favours the bold! |
winfoharso said: This recalibration has screwed up the whole system. We were getting close to having all of Gintama out of the 9 star range, but now one of the 5 million seasons is #2. Gintama is trash. If I had 2 wishes, first would be the deletion of Hunter x Hunter from all of time and space, and second would be the same for Gintama. Gintama is trash. LMAO, this is too salty. |
 |
winfoharso said: This recalibration has screwed up the whole system. We were getting close to having all of Gintama out of the 9 star range, but now one of the 5 million seasons is #2. Gintama is trash. If I had 2 wishes, first would be the deletion of Hunter x Hunter from all of time and space, and second would be the same for Gintama. Gintama is trash. I do agree Gintama is heavily overrated. I haven’t watch HxH so I wouldn’t mention my opinion for that. |
| The MAL team is working pretty hard. Thank you guys for your time and hard work! 🙂 |
| While I do appreciate the effort, a couple of years ago I did think about writing a crawler that would run a similar analysis, and then I understood why it is completely useless: all a fake account needs to do is to clone a genuine account before adding the troll scores. This makes them completely undetectable, and this is the reason why anime like HxH and FMA didn't get hit hard (if someone remembers back in 2014 before the vote brigading started, HxH wasn't even in top 10: below Clannad, below Gintama, below Code Geass) So there are still a lot of fake votes counted, and more will start coming as soon as people realize they just have to make their fake account indistinguishable from the real ones... |
| Humans are suspicious and jealous creatures. When they see something perfect, they wanna find a flaw. Ratohnhaketon said: You have much to learn if you have not joined the witch hunt to down vote every anime that rises above our underrated favorites. I am currently on a campaign to get Training with Hinako into the top 12. Shit taste is hard to fight though, it's like trying to talk sense to an army of hallucinating loonies. Ty-Ki said: It's hilarious to see morons wasting more time with the series they hate so much than the fans of it. |
| They said that the recalculation of scores will continue for a 7 days, but I still notice some clear changes and this is good, but how did Violet Evergarden up from 8.62 to 8.80 only this morning !! |
HaChiiman said: They said that the recalculation of scores will continue for a 7 days, but I still notice some clear changes and this is good, but how did Violet Evergarden up from 8.62 to 8.80 only this morning !! back then VEG got downvotted a lot by sora yori boosters,maybe the bots account got detected now? |
noregretmyman said: HaChiiman said: They said that the recalculation of scores will continue for a 7 days, but I still notice some clear changes and this is good, but how did Violet Evergarden up from 8.62 to 8.80 only this morning !! back then VEG got downvotted a lot by sora yori boosters,maybe the bots account got detected now? I don't think so, it has just 0.3% of 1, even if you removed them all the score will not increase with +0.18 |
| Violet Evergarden went from 8.62 to 8.80 Never thought it was down voted that heavily |
 |
winfoharso said: This recalibration has screwed up the whole system. We were getting close to having all of Gintama out of the 9 star range, but now one of the 5 million seasons is #2. Gintama is trash. If I had 2 wishes, first would be the deletion of Hunter x Hunter from all of time and space, and second would be the same for Gintama. Gintama is trash. Saltier than the oceans. |
|
| Salty but right, though. Gintama is highly overrated, indeed. I'd understand entries being maybe part of top 200, but having 3 ones at the top 10? Better ranked than classics like Cowboy Bebop, Ghost in the Shell or the best of Miyazaki's best? * sniff * * sniff * odor of dog poo poo in there. |
 |
| This should include banning multis. |
-Aincrad- said: winfoharso said: This recalibration has screwed up the whole system. We were getting close to having all of Gintama out of the 9 star range, but now one of the 5 million seasons is #2. Gintama is trash. If I had 2 wishes, first would be the deletion of Hunter x Hunter from all of time and space, and second would be the same for Gintama. Gintama is trash. Saltier than the oceans. Salty maybe but he is entirely right. |
More topics from this board
» MAL Secret Santa 2024 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kineta - Nov 17, 2024 |
267 |
by DeadlyRaven
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» Export Manga List (Anime List too). ( 1 2 )Xinil - Sep 19, 2007 |
52 |
by Mari_Marx
»»
Yesterday, 7:46 AM |
|
» MAL Yearbook 2024: Brainstorming Session ( 1 2 )tingy - Dec 23, 2024 |
99 |
by RED-clover12
»»
Dec 30, 2024 12:55 PM |
|
» New Page! Manga Adapted to Anime ( 1 2 )Kineta - Dec 9, 2024 |
55 |
by cpebora
»»
Dec 26, 2024 2:15 AM |
|
» MAL Game "Fantasy Anime League" Opens for Fall 2024 ( 1 2 3 4 )Kineta - Sep 12, 2024 |
157 |
by tokomata
»»
Dec 26, 2024 1:40 AM |