PoeticJustice said: mayukachan said: *snickers* link me i dont remember the thread. pretty sure it was that braininthejar guy tho i remember he saying he likes the characters of mirai nikki because they are very realistic and human,how can someone come to some opinion? |
PoeticJustice said: gabrielrroiz said: he knows what he is talking about most of the time and as far as analist of anime goes he is the best on youtube nah he makes sweeping generalizations and there are a lot of flaws in his arguments. also, his reviews are terrible, unreadable, and full of unnecessary info. of course he makes generalizations and puts unnencessary information like bashing the series in his reviews that is basically what his snob persona is all about and it is not like there is a lots of flaws in his arguments it is just that in most of the times he does not explain what are the reasons for his arguments |
| People here actually think TheAnimeSnob is good? Holy shit sasuga MAL... |
| Probably the most accurate answers would be something like Attack on Titan, Code Geass, Death Note, FMA:B, Steins;Gate, and HxH (2011). The ones with high ratings and a ton of viewers. Of course, MAL forum snobs will pretend to hate the first 2 even though they really loved them, giving them the illusion of being hated. |
 |
| Dragon Ball (original, not Z) |
| People hate ThatAnimeSnob for being offensive and bashful, but if he was like everyone else and sugarcoated all of his words and never said anything in a condescending way he'd probably be a lot more respected in the community. 'tis a shame people won't listen. |
 |
| If he was more fair with rating his anime and not just simply "it's shit because I hate it", he would be respected more as a critic. |
gabrielrroiz said: PoeticJustice said: nah he makes sweeping generalizations and there are a lot of flaws in his arguments. also, his reviews are terrible, unreadable, and full of unnecessary info. of course he makes generalizations and puts unnencessary information like bashing the series in his reviews that is basically what his snob persona is all about and it is not like there is a lots of flaws in his arguments it is just that in most of the times he does not explain what are the reasons for his arguments Not sure about the best he did got destroyed by Digibro on one of his pod cast. Actually funny to this day he is still quite salty about it and reminds everyone how Digibro likes K On. but I say he is one of the entertaining ones if you keep in mind he is acting on his Snob persona. Most of the time he has good points despite sounding ignorant. I guess he is one of the few people that trash some of my favourite franchises (like the Fate series and Gintama) but still Im fine with it and laugh. |
mayukachan said: His reviews state why they're shit.If he was more fair with rating his anime and not just simply "it's shit because I hate it", he would be respected more as a critic. |
|
Niddy said: I haven't watched most of his reviews but I've seen those episodes where he quickly reviews shows from each season.mayukachan said: His reviews state why they're shit.If he was more fair with rating his anime and not just simply "it's shit because I hate it", he would be respected more as a critic. "Haikyuu? It's sports so it's shit. Ping Pong? Same." |
royaldocks said: gabrielrroiz said: of course he makes generalizations and puts unnencessary information like bashing the series in his reviews that is basically what his snob persona is all about and it is not like there is a lots of flaws in his arguments it is just that in most of the times he does not explain what are the reasons for his arguments Not sure about the best he did got destroyed by Digibro on one of his podcast. Actually funny to this day he is still quite salty about it and reminds everyone how Digibro likes K On. but I say he is one of the entertaining ones if you keep in mind he is acting on his Snob persona. Most of the time he has good points despite sounding ignorant. I guess he is one of the few people that trash some of my favourite franchises (like the Fate series and Gintama) but still fine with it and laugh. he sure was but it dos not change that digibro is a awful critical that likes to overthink small details for the series he likes like making a hour video on a show like k on and in every review he spends half of the time talking about visual presentation and not about the actual content of the show |
Niddy said: mayukachan said: His reviews state why they're shit.If he was more fair with rating his anime and not just simply "it's shit because I hate it", he would be respected more as a critic. BobSamurai is basically a humble ThatAnimeSnob/Rori being his minion and all... |
Niddy said: mayukachan said: His reviews state why they're shit.If he was more fair with rating his anime and not just simply "it's shit because I hate it", he would be respected more as a critic. they are poorly written filled with too much shit. his madoka review and legends review were both trash. |
mayukachan said: Forget about his videos, they're often not adequate so you don't get the full picture.Niddy said: I haven't watched most of his reviews but I've seen those episodes where he quickly reviews shows from each season.His reviews state why they're shit. "Haikyuu? It's sports so it's shit. Ping Pong? Same." Disregard sports anime then, although I'm sure he has reviewed a lot of them too since he has over 800 reviews. It's fine if you don't think he's credible because of that but I personally don't care that much since it's just a bias of his. I still think his reviews on anidb are worth reading before you think he's full of shit when he says "x sucks because y" since that's just the basics, not the only thing that makes him not like it, if that makes any sense. |
|
PoeticJustice said: Could you provide examples, please?Niddy said: His reviews state why they're shit. they are poorly written filled with too much shit. his madoka review and legends review were both trash. |
|
watd said: Icollectpolyps said: the comedy overrides the dramatic scenesI've met many who said the story wasn't well paced and the comedy overrides the dramatic scenes. haha nah Maybe not "override", but some comedic moments were in fact very ill-timed. Especially in Brotherhood. |
PoeticJustice said: Niddy said: His reviews state why they're shit. they are poorly written filled with too much shit. his madoka review and legends review were both trash. his madoka review is actually pretty good he shows lots of inconsistences of the series |
| Sugarcoated or not, there's still bad reasoning at the core of Snob's being. I heard him say about 10 easily deconstructed bullshit points in the one review of his that I bothered listening to. The dude clearly suffers from brain damage, probably sniffs glue every day, and definitely should not be listened to. |
|
| There is no way anyone could hate Haikyuu |
 |
AltoRoark99 said: watd said: the comedy overrides the dramatic scenes haha nah Maybe not "override", but some comedic moments were in fact very ill-timed. Especially in Brotherhood. that is a minor problem before everything it did right |
Niddy said: PoeticJustice said: Could you provide examples, please?they are poorly written filled with too much shit. his madoka review and legends review were both trash. "So why is this show so famous anyway? - It was directed by Shinbou, the guy who practically “is” SHAFT and whose earlier Bakemonogatary anime was a great success for fan catering the watchers from tip to toes. It was also written by Uroboshi, a guy famous for his really bloody endings. - These two prepared the field for tens of thousands to love the show even before it airs and thus an easy way to drag along ten times more newbies to the hype machine. It doesn’t take much to be fooled into loving something just because many love it as well. If it’s popular, you want a piece of the action by being part of the hype. Ain’t popularity something? - It also helped how most watchers have no idea of what good series are out there as they refuse to watch anything older than 5 years and thus are blind to the retro goodies. They will just say “It is better than Pokemon” because that is what most casual fans consider to be an average anime. For the same reason, people who grew up with anive OVAs from the 80’s or good cartoon series from the 90’s will simply look at this show and scratch their heads wondering where the hell are all those awesome stuff they say about it. - With no prior knowledge of how the same formula was used before, the newbs were easily made to think it is an original and perfectly excecuted show. For example, most will start by saying that mahou shojo are boring and thus Madoka is great for deconstructing the genre in a way that makes it interesting. Well, guess what, it is not the first show that did that. But being blind to the older titles has that effect to the masses. " Attacking a fanbase is not part of the review. has nothing to do with anything. |
FloatingIdiot said: Again I can't really agree or disagree when all you use is ad hominem and no concrete reasons as to why that video was bad or why he shouldn't be listened to.Sugarcoated or not, there's still bad reasoning at the core of Snob's being. I heard him say about 10 easily deconstructed bullshit points in the one review of his that I bothered listening to. The dude clearly suffers from brain damage, probably sniffs glue every day, and definitely should not be listened to. |
|
PoeticJustice said: Niddy said: Could you provide examples, please? "So why is this show so famous anyway? - It was directed by Shinbou, the guy who practically “is” SHAFT and whose earlier Bakemonogatary anime was a great success for fan catering the watchers from tip to toes. It was also written by Uroboshi, a guy famous for his really bloody endings. - These two prepared the field for tens of thousands to love the show even before it airs and thus an easy way to drag along ten times more newbies to the hype machine. It doesn’t take much to be fooled into loving something just because many love it as well. If it’s popular, you want a piece of the action by being part of the hype. Ain’t popularity something? - It also helped how most watchers have no idea of what good series are out there as they refuse to watch anything older than 5 years and thus are blind to the retro goodies. They will just say “It is better than Pokemon” because that is what most casual fans consider to be an average anime. For the same reason, people who grew up with anive OVAs from the 80’s or good cartoon series from the 90’s will simply look at this show and scratch their heads wondering where the hell are all those awesome stuff they say about it. - With no prior knowledge of how the same formula was used before, the newbs were easily made to think it is an original and perfectly excecuted show. For example, most will start by saying that mahou shojo are boring and thus Madoka is great for deconstructing the genre in a way that makes it interesting. Well, guess what, it is not the first show that did that. But being blind to the older titles has that effect to the masses. " Attacking a fanbase is not part of the review. has nothing to do with anything. that is exactly what his persona is all about that is why he proclaims himsef thatanimesnob |
Niddy said: FloatingIdiot said: Again I can't really agree or disagree when all you use is ad hominem and no concrete reasons as to why that video was bad or why he shouldn't be listened to.Sugarcoated or not, there's still bad reasoning at the core of Snob's being. I heard him say about 10 easily deconstructed bullshit points in the one review of his that I bothered listening to. The dude clearly suffers from brain damage, probably sniffs glue every day, and definitely should not be listened to. I'm not trying to convince anyone. If you can't tell how completely full of shit he is from listening to 1 minute of him, you are not worth the effort. Especially when there are people in this thread already doing the work for me. |
|
Comic_Sans said: I ask myself the same. It boggles me that some people rate it 5 or lower, maybe the sometimes excessive violence turns out to be a strong factor to their dislike of the show.There are actually people who hate Baccano? |
| sic mundus |
Rastafa21 said: Comic_Sans said: I ask myself the same. It boggles me that some people rate it 5 or lower, maybe the sometimes excessive violence turns out to be a strong factor to their dislike of the show.There are actually people who hate Baccano? Some people are put off by nonlinear story telling. Also, the show is held in higher regard in the west due to it's type of humor. |
| No such thing exists. Anime_No_Jutsu said: Trigun and FMA have haters? Of course, i don't "hate" Trigun but i don't like it either but you will find people who shit in it like anything else made. You will find people who hate FMA because they liked FMAB more and you will find people who hate FMAB because they like FMA more, for example. |
PralandOct 29, 2015 7:54 PM
 |
| I've never seen outright hate for Mushishi or Natsume Yuujinchou. Most of the time people were either bored or it didn't click with them, but I've never met someone who outright "SAO SUXXX" tier loathes their existence. |
 |
codephat said: That's the thing, the nonlinear story was my favorite part of it together with the great cast of characters haha.Rastafa21 said: I ask myself the same. It boggles me that some people rate it 5 or lower, maybe the sometimes excessive violence turns out to be a strong factor to their dislike of the show. Some people are put off by nonlinear story telling. Also, the show is held in higher regard in the west due to it's type of humor. |
| sic mundus |
PoeticJustice said: Yes he likes to rant about "tasteless casuals with shit taste" that might not be fitting in a review, but it's his style and because everyone gets so ridiculously butthurt over this they refuse to overlook his "toxic" persona and realize that he isn't wrong all the time.Niddy said: Could you provide examples, please? "So why is this show so famous anyway? - It was directed by Shinbou, the guy who practically “is” SHAFT and whose earlier Bakemonogatary anime was a great success for fan catering the watchers from tip to toes. It was also written by Uroboshi, a guy famous for his really bloody endings. - These two prepared the field for tens of thousands to love the show even before it airs and thus an easy way to drag along ten times more newbies to the hype machine. It doesn’t take much to be fooled into loving something just because many love it as well. If it’s popular, you want a piece of the action by being part of the hype. Ain’t popularity something? - It also helped how most watchers have no idea of what good series are out there as they refuse to watch anything older than 5 years and thus are blind to the retro goodies. They will just say “It is better than Pokemon” because that is what most casual fans consider to be an average anime. For the same reason, people who grew up with anive OVAs from the 80’s or good cartoon series from the 90’s will simply look at this show and scratch their heads wondering where the hell are all those awesome stuff they say about it. - With no prior knowledge of how the same formula was used before, the newbs were easily made to think it is an original and perfectly excecuted show. For example, most will start by saying that mahou shojo are boring and thus Madoka is great for deconstructing the genre in a way that makes it interesting. Well, guess what, it is not the first show that did that. But being blind to the older titles has that effect to the masses. " Attacking a fanbase is not part of the review. has nothing to do with anything. |
|
Otoshiro said: stillapeep said: Wow, is this a joke? im srs good one |
Irrelative said: No such thing. |
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
Niddy said: Yes he likes to rant about "tasteless casuals with shit taste" that might not be fitting in a review, but it's his style and because everyone gets so ridiculously butthurt over this they refuse to overlook his "toxic" persona and realize that he isn't wrong all the time. sure some of the things he says are right, but that doesn't excuse his shit from being unreadable and most of the time, uninsightful. |
| Great Teacher Onizuka. |
 |
| I would say Diatron 5 http://myanimelist.net/anime/11357/Micro_Teukgongdae_Diatron_5 |
 |
| no anime survive when there're people who hate anime with passion. |
| Such a anime will never exist because people have such a wide variety in tastes and whatnot, but I will say if that does happen we will finally have a "Perfect anime" for the perfect anime is one everyone likes. |
  |
Praland said: No such thing exists. Anime_No_Jutsu said: Trigun and FMA have haters? Of course, i don't "hate" Trigun but i don't like it either but you will find people who shit in it like anything else made. You will find people who hate FMA because they liked FMAB more and you will find people who hate FMAB because they like FMA more, for example. that's the only plausible reason because gosh I can't see people hating on FMA "as a whole" (as the plot, characters and such). well I never saw people preaching shit against it. |
 |
hoopla123 said: Hi I'm a moe hating faggot, and I always hate on NNB :DNo such thing but the closest one is NNB. Only close minded shit taste moe hating faggots that don't know no moe = no animu hate NNB. Everyone else accepts it as the masterpiece it is and deserves to be. |
| Brace yourself. Soon as LotGH 2017 comes out. The anime community is going to become so cancerous you will need to take cover and hide. |
| Maybe stuff like Lupin III, or Karate Baka Ichidai, or Attack No.1 or Space Adventure Cobra cause half the youngsters in this community dont even know each of these shows. |
| I think the consensus of most famous and well received by fans and critics with very few haters (I personally haven't seen any) is FMAB |
 |
More topics from this board
» You guys should look out for those demographics on aniDBRyokoKakyoin - 1 hour ago |
3 |
by Nirinbo
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Why is elitism frowned upon? ( 1 2 3 )IdeDial - Dec 12 |
106 |
by Turn_A_Blum
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Maid Wars! (Final Round!) ( 1 2 3 4 )StarBloom_64 - Dec 11 |
166 |
by UberBat
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
» What anime cliches do you love or hate the most?RobertBobert - Apr 14 |
40 |
by Tressym
»»
17 minutes ago |
|
» Has MAL just become a low-key way to search for Anime answers that can be done just with a search engine?ColourWheel - Yesterday |
31 |
by ColourWheel
»»
22 minutes ago |