Rokka: Braves of the Six Flowers (light novel)
Available on Manga Store
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Aug 16, 2015 11:23 PM
#251
nogitsunechaos said: He is far from just being annoying. He actually is pretty smart himself and he will soon stop saying it that often.Adlet...please someone kill him. I love his actual design and look but everytime he talks.."Im the strongest man" BS....I just want him to die. |
Aug 16, 2015 11:29 PM
#252
@Tylaen >that's is why it's kiddy. am not gonna elaborate more. I get a bad omen from your post and profile pic. >obviously @Ugoki >my intent. ya too serious. @Pat_To_Do-List > but for a wise adlet to face, half-ass, a killing, murdering assassin seems not so wise. > My fault, am not obvious. i referred to the way the writer turned the series on the 7th thing instead of the goal introduced by the early ep. I read some post here and sensed there are 2 different sides, probably why the discuss. is lively, not 'cause the ep. is well received. |
Aug 17, 2015 12:18 AM
#253
animeBee1ver said: @Pat_To_Do-List > but for a wise adlet to face, half-ass, a killing, murdering assassin seems not so wise. > My fault, am not obvious. i referred to the way the writer turned the series on the 7th thing instead of the goal introduced by the early ep. Firstly, Adlet is not a wise man in the first place. It's never established by the anime that he is wise. Secondly, right when he's accused as the 7th Brave, he's never thinking about taking revenge on the other Braves because of the false accusation. And in this episode it's established that he's not trying to kill any Brave, hence he's not focusing on defeating one of the Braves & focusing more on finding out who's the 7th & 8th Braves without harming anybody. And that's why when he did face Hans, he's trying to escape & not harming him. That's still the main conflict of the show, to defeat the Demon God. It's not going anywhere. The 7th Brave conflict is more of a mini arc that set in a greater arc about defeating the Demon God. It's apparent in many shows & not a new thing. |
I like anime. |
Aug 17, 2015 12:58 AM
#254
animeBee1ver said: I read some post here and sensed there are 2 different sides, probably why the discuss. is lively, not 'cause the ep. is well received. >Poll votes and most comments are very positive >Not well received Yeah sure whatever you say buddy. |
Aug 17, 2015 1:08 AM
#255
@Pat_To_Do-List > hm.. we'll just have to agree to disagree. I got the impression the he was shown that way. and even if he isn't, no harming anyone is too "kiddy", like I posted before > I worry, with only 12 ep. @Jagd84 > aint nothing but a thing. |
Aug 17, 2015 1:34 AM
#256
If you were expecting an action heavy anime about defeating the demon lord, then you mistook the anime. Which was an easy enough mistake to make, but could have been avoided by reading the synopsis or the trailers. It's the same for gakkou gurashi for example. If you were expecting moe slice and life, that wasn't it. It's not especially rare for a story to play a bit with the reader by surprising him/her on what the story is about. Heck like I said just now, even in this season we already have 2 shows like that. The only problem with this is that for peoples who don't like detective stories well, this series is not for them anymore. So well can't help it if you think it's not for you. |
Aug 17, 2015 1:50 AM
#257
animeBee1ver said: @Pat_To_Do-List > hm.. we'll just have to agree to disagree. I got the impression the he was shown that way. and even if he isn't, no harming anyone is too "kiddy", like I posted before > I worry, with only 12 ep. Oh, really? You got the impression that he's a wise man? Why's that? Was there any specific scene that made you think like that? With 12 episodes, of course the main arc will not be finished. But again, it's not a new thing in the anime industry. There are so many anime shows that do not finish the main arc within a season. What would be finished with this 12 episodes is probably the 7th Brave arc. I think you need to understand more about arc, storyline, plot, & many more. Your criticism is mainly directed towards the fact that it's not going to finish the main arc about defeating the Demon God in one season, which is not a valid criticism in any way. I understand that you are disappointed by that fact, but that's nothing more than one of many ways to structure/compose a narrative. It's like saying an anime is bad because it's structured as episodic type of show. |
I like anime. |
Aug 17, 2015 2:24 AM
#258
Well, I'm finding this really funny how the 'critics' here are trying to find flaws to the show but are only finding the wrong ones due to not paying attention to the dialogue/scenes, mistaking Rokka as a pure fantasy/action show and thereby using the incorrect criteria to judge the show, or simply subverting criticism with opinion. Don't take these as ad hominems, just observations of the comment section. What's even more interesting and the biggest whoop to all of this, is that all these said 'criticisms' contradict each other. Let's take some examples shall we? GSupernova: "this episode was irrelevant to the mystery due to unrelated character development." Zen (from RandomC): "Right now, the story and the characters lack depth as we haven't got any insight into the backstory/motives of the main characters" (episode 6) Really? How paradoxical can you get? So now, Zen's false criticism is now debunked this episode due to complex character development of Fremy and Adlet and their motive for becoming a brave yet someone else disagrees with him and says that they could have spent more time on the mystery. Who am I meant to listen to? And don't get me started on how many people -somehow- have completely misunderstood some of the characters and resort to using buzzwords like 'cliche' and 'annoying' to support their arguments, you can't get anymore vague than this. |
Aug 17, 2015 2:30 AM
#259
@Pat_To_Do-List > wise = having or showing experience, knowledge, and good judgment. How he fights, and trained. and handled probs. in early eps. don't ask specifics man. > that was the response of your "That's still the main conflict of the show...". but I doubt it is main if its unfinished. and just 'cause there are many like it doesn't mean it's not a fault. it's a fallacy. |
Aug 17, 2015 3:12 AM
#260
animeBee1ver said: > that was the response of your "That's still the main conflict of the show...". but I doubt it is main if its unfinished. and just 'cause there are many like it doesn't mean it's not a fault. it's a fallacy. Wait. So because adaptation doesn't finish it's story in one season it's fault? Do you like watch anything on TV? Because by you logic anything that seasonal series is bad because it's has a continuous plot that can't be told in one sitting. Who's making ridiculous fallacies just to sit ones own opinion now? At this point you might as well watch only original works. animeBee1ver said: > but for a wise adlet to face, half-ass, a killing, murdering assassin seems not so wise. > My fault, am not obvious. i referred to the way the writer turned the series on the 7th thing instead of the goal introduced by the early ep.. You're first point has nothing to do with wisdom. He's fighting with Hans because he has no choice and even then he's still thinking of escaping. You act as if Adlet has to kill him anyway. The second, the series was always mystery from the start. Even the whole 7th thing was in synopsis and the trailers. And it was formally introduced in ep 5 which was plenty early and still has to do with Demon God. |
Iron_MawAug 17, 2015 3:22 AM
Aug 17, 2015 3:25 AM
#261
Aug 17, 2015 3:30 AM
#262
animeBee1ver said: @Pat_To_Do-List > wise = having or showing experience, knowledge, and good judgment. How he fights, and trained. and handled probs. in early eps. don't ask specifics man. > that was the response of your "That's still the main conflict of the show...". but I doubt it is main if its unfinished. and just 'cause there are many like it doesn't mean it's not a fault. it's a fallacy. among the 5 series of this seasons you were watching (if I didn't miss one) 3 of them are like that including RnY. that's 60% of what you choose to watch. From starter, you're using MAL, so you have access easily to that type of info. If you want to start a series and be sure it's not going to end in a "read the manga/novel" then just look in the relation line if it has adaptation... Ushio to Tora is a 33 volumes long manga, Overlord and RnY are novels still running, so that was obvious from the start you would not see an end to the main novel/manga plot but only an end to the plot of some arcs. you can't accuse an anime to do that when most of them do AND that you could know that before selecting what you watch. If it's really important to you to have conclusive ending, not doing that simple check that take like 10sec before selecting what you want to watch isn't logical. Especially when more than half of the series are adaptation, you're just asking for it. |
Aug 17, 2015 3:53 AM
#263
Hi @Zefyris (like you profile pic btw) > some anime do that. and it is an unattractive feature, w/c means it is a fault, which means it is subject to criticism against anime as a whole. (ey before you object, I checked the dictionary for that logic) > unless you think it is not an unattractive feature? > But like liking someone, it is one of the many things. |
Aug 17, 2015 5:12 AM
#264
animeBee1ver said: @Pat_To_Do-List > wise = having or showing experience, knowledge, and good judgment. How he fights, and trained. and handled probs. in early eps. don't ask specifics man. > that was the response of your "That's still the main conflict of the show...". but I doubt it is main if its unfinished. and just 'cause there are many like it doesn't mean it's not a fault. it's a fallacy. He's far from wise then. He's experienced in fighting, yes. But does that mean he's a wise man? No. I think he's more of a brash person. Remember how he joined the tournament without an invitation & fought the warriors who supposed to compete with each other? And so far, we have been shown that he was trained by his teacher for fighting & to be strong physically, not becoming wise. And I think it's pretty clear he's not the kind of wise character. I think you really should learn more about narrative & how arcs/plotline work. You seem to confused about things & blame the things that you do not understand. I understand where you're coming from, you're expecting the main arc to be finished in one season yet it does not seem to be like that. And it's understandable that you are disappointed. But to make your disappointment as an argument to say that's a flaw, now that's unwise of you. And you have no argument in saying that this kind of narrative structure is a fallacy. If you have, then please let me know & make me understand why it is a fallacy. |
Pat_To_Do-ListAug 17, 2015 5:16 AM
I like anime. |
Aug 17, 2015 5:44 AM
#265
KamSung said: And really though, when are we gonna see the saints use their powers? Up till now only Nachetanya has been using her powers frequently, do the Saints even have any powers? We've seen Fremy use her powers these two episodes. Since her power is just "creating gunpowder", it's easy enough to miss, but she has created that "firecracker" for Adlet in front of our eyes, and it defies the way normal firecrackers work. Dead_Walk said: woghhh Hans vs Adlet and Chamo...absolutely totally insane little creepy innocent scary psycho KID what is exactly her abilities anyway guys ? i am confused here, knowing she is saint of swamp Playing with glowing snakes? Either those snakes are her power, or that's a random demon she has caught and blasted with her power till it started glowing. I'm pretty sure snakes don't normally glow like that. It's Mora's powers that we haven't seen yet, except in the opening. That "punch people really hard" power looks like she could be a good shounen protagonist. @Mora calling the shots That's because she's used to ordering people around, as a leader of saints. Adlet, Fremy, Hans and Chamo definitely aren't. Goldof probably isn't too, but he might have commanded a band of knights at some point. Nashetania could have taken charge too, being a princess, but she doesn't want to hunt Adlet. Still, if she is the 7th, she might do a lot of harm hlubkoj2020 said: So here is my question again: Why did no one suspect Nashetania? 1) Because they don't know they are in a detective story. Most of the suspicions about her on these forums are based upon the fact that she is one of the least likely culprits, thus is likely to be one - the same reasoning that makes heroes facing 1 to million chances likely to win. That makes a story interesting, but is not a good way to solve actual crimes. 2) Because Nashetania is the heir to the biggest and strongest country in the world. There just isn't much the demons can offer to tempt her, provided they can get to talk to her at all. It's not like Tgurneu can just walk into the palace, greet the guards and ask to speak with the princess. She doesn't even have enough surviving relatives to take hostage (well, there's the king who tried to kill her, and some really distant relatives that she doesn't even know). 3) Because to them, Nashetania is much the same as Chamo - mentally unstable and spoiled, but really powerful Saint who was probably chosen for her sheer destructiveness, not for her brains. Just compare Nashetania's rain of swords to Fremy's puny bullets. Comander-07 said: I feel sorry for the goddess of fate. She has to choose between psychos, spoiled bitches, and dumb kids. like this. |
Aug 17, 2015 5:58 AM
#266
Pat_To_Do-List said: animeBee1ver said: @Pat_To_Do-List > wise = having or showing experience, knowledge, and good judgment. How he fights, and trained. and handled probs. in early eps. don't ask specifics man. > that was the response of your "That's still the main conflict of the show...". but I doubt it is main if its unfinished. and just 'cause there are many like it doesn't mean it's not a fault. it's a fallacy. He's far from wise then. He's experienced in fighting, yes. But does that mean he's a wise man? No. I think he's more of a brash person. Remember how he joined the tournament without an invitation & fought the warriors who supposed to compete with each other? And so far, we have been shown that he was trained by his teacher for fighting & to be strong physically, not becoming wise. And I think it's pretty clear he's not the kind of wise character. Adlet is strong in a fight (and even stronger when he has gadgets to use), intelligent, well-educated and fights for a good cause, but he is not wise by any measure. He got all of his skills from his teacher (not from walking the world and facing random dangers and situations), his choices are often rash, and so on. |
Aug 17, 2015 5:59 AM
#267
@Pat_To_Do-List 👏👏👏👏 👍👉🍺 |
Aug 17, 2015 6:11 AM
#268
esket said: Farabeuf said: Hans interested before, but now he's walking smug and irritating clichee. I cannot wait for him to be owned by Adlet or someone else. Having said that, it'd be too obvious if he's the 7th. I think the princess is the one. I agree. At first I liked him but this episode every time he opened his mouth I just kept saying shut up. This episode we got Bunny Girl ignoring the sound and putting blame on Hans By now i'm convinced that she has done it on purpose, to not let Goldof and Hans overwhelm Adlet (since she thinks that Adlet isn't the real 7th, and those two are the ones who tried to kill him outright). esket said: and Chamot doing some suspicious shit in the forest. Is she really supposed to be 14 because she acts like a 6 year old and is irritating me. Chamo definitely acts too young. I'd bet they inflated her stated age in the anime to make past some censorship (kinda like in hentai all the schoolgirls are definitely 18 or older), but the novel states the same. She's only 2 years younger than Goldof, right? CaptainKatsuura said: Zefyris said: CaptainKatsuura said: Zefyris said: Malise said: Shrimperor said: What the Hell is the loli doing? she suddenly jumped very high on my suspicous list. What where those things under her? Don't worry about Chamo. Chamo just playing with glowing snakes. lol xD Creepiness is over 9000 there~ What? She's just an adorable little loli who wants to torture and kill people... nothing creepy about that. Bu-but she's just a little girlplaying in the forest right? With glowing snakes. Well she wanted to kill /torture someone who tried to assassinate her lol. And her proposition about torturing adlet was actually more reasonable than Hans and Goldof's option and by far the most logical choice at that time. x) While that's true I still maintain that a little girl (I mean how old is she? 10? 12?) wanting to kill and torture people is just a little bit creepy. Just a little bit though. Apart from the killing and torturing she's positively adorable (and I don't care what anyone says, glowing snakes are awesome). Chamo says she is 14. Ordinary people become teenagers by that age, but not Chamo. Maybe it is because she is an evil shapeshifter demon? But she has no problems entering the temple... |
Aug 17, 2015 6:36 AM
#269
flannan said: 1) Because they don't know they are in a detective story. Most of the suspicions about her on these forums are based upon the fact that she is one of the least likely culprits, thus is likely to be one - the same reasoning that makes heroes facing 1 to million chances likely to win. That makes a story interesting, but is not a good way to solve actual crimes. 2) Because Nashetania is the heir to the biggest and strongest country in the world. There just isn't much the demons can offer to tempt her, provided they can get to talk to her at all. It's not like Tgurneu can just walk into the palace, greet the guards and ask to speak with the princess. She doesn't even have enough surviving relatives to take hostage (well, there's the king who tried to kill her, and some really distant relatives that she doesn't even know). 3) Because to them, Nashetania is much the same as Chamo - mentally unstable and spoiled, but really powerful Saint who was probably chosen for her sheer destructiveness, not for her brains. Just compare Nashetania's rain of swords to Fremy's puny bullets. 1 - This is definitely a factor, but it's more of a catalyst by which the illusion surrounding her actions is dispelled. One might not suspect her at all, and she'd fly under the radar forever, but any consideration towards her being the 7th would reveal a rather convincing case against her. 2- Two things, first I would reason a guess that at least Mora is aware that her kingdom is being ruled by a despot. If she doesn't, that would be very odd to me. Secondly, she spent a time away from the palace when she waged civil war, which is more than enough opportunity to be approached. We know that the fiend(whom is apparently called Tgurneu?) was active at least since Adlet's childhood. 3 - Nothing presented in the anime suggests that this is the case as far as I can tell. |
Aug 17, 2015 6:38 AM
#270
Aug 17, 2015 6:44 AM
#271
Aug 17, 2015 6:55 AM
#272
animeBee1ver said: Hi @Zefyris (like you profile pic btw) > some anime do that. and it is an unattractive feature, w/c means it is a fault, which means it is subject to criticism against anime as a whole. (ey before you object, I checked the dictionary for that logic) > unless you think it is not an unattractive feature? > But like liking someone, it is one of the many things. Well I wouldn't ask better than seeing anime adapting until the end rather than stopping at some point. WHat I'm seeing here isn't that. If no one buy those there is no money for it. RnY wasn't selling a lot, it's still not selling a lot, the publisher is new (they took RnY which was published by another small publisher before) and it's their first try to advertise one of their novels as an anime, the anime studio is new and has probably very little money too, and the previsions for the BD sales (which usually are frightening accurate) are displaying very low sales for the BD/DVD. It's a problem with the whole anime market here. The way the animation in RnY is going bad is clearly that they're cutting cost to avoid going in the red after seeing the sales previsions a few weeks back, but even without talking about RnY precisely, as long as making anime has almost no money gain from it, you're only going to see most anime adaptation being ordered by the publisher as an advertising. And an advertising has no reason to adapt a series already finished since it doesn't work well, and no reason to make several seasons to achieve the advertising goal, except if the effect was especially big. So yeah, blaming specificaly a problem that apply to the whole anime industry to a specific anime isn't really going to prove anything. Of course you can dislike that kind of thing. Who would not. I personally gave up about seeing one day anime as a full fledged media rather than a media completely dependent to other medias to survive. If yo uwant a media which usually tells you the story until the end, anime is the worst possible choice. Going for novels and manga would be better. Well thanks. That's also for a novel but this one never got an anime adaptation (not like it could anyway, far too twisted and gruesome for that) |
Aug 17, 2015 7:07 AM
#273
I beg your pardon? |
I like anime. |
Aug 17, 2015 7:27 AM
#274
I like the pacing in this show a lot. What I'm concerned with is that if this is only 12 episodes, how are they going to end the show since it doesn't seem like we are going to see the fight with the Demon God. I really hope there is a second season or this might end up like Berserk by ending right when it felt like the main part was starting. |
Aug 17, 2015 7:40 AM
#275
Zemroid said: I like the pacing in this show a lot. What I'm concerned with is that if this is only 12 episodes, how are they going to end the show since it doesn't seem like we are going to see the fight with the Demon God. I really hope there is a second season or this might end up like Berserk by ending right when it felt like the main part was starting. Well, it's improbable that it will get another season, though that would be awesome. Also, the ending will feel like it's the beginning of the main part, but at the same time it will be a good finish for this arc and it should get some people to continue the story in the novel. ^^ Btw. I also like the pacing. |
Aug 17, 2015 9:21 AM
#276
Inugirlz said: CodeKirugin said: I have a theory. During the few episodes ago. Mora said if one of the braves dies, one of the petals on the flower crest thing will disappear right? So, what if, they decide to kill one of them, that braves dies and the rest of the braves flower crest would be missing one petal out of six petals. Then the one who still has six petals would considered to be the "fake" one right? thats a good theory, let's hope someone like Chamo is killed to prove this theory. (of course she could be the fake too but i don't think so) I've already read the LN up until this episode and it pretty much confirms that 2 out of the 7 is innocent, but its the same info we already know just presented more clearly because of 3rd person writing and all. I want character deaths and if someone's gotta die make it be Chamo! (Or the princess cuz she's annoying, idc if she's innocent or not i don't like her) But the thing about this theory is if they're willing to bet that brave to be killed unless they're lucky to killed the traitor, I mean who knows how strong the traitor and especially the Demon God this time is?What I'm trying to say is that that theory of yours is kinda risky but effective in a way. |
Aug 17, 2015 9:40 AM
#277
So with everything that happened and with how the show is pacing itself, we can assume that by end of the season they will finally start their journey to the demon king? Would have preferred to see a backstory on the fiends and how they came about. Creation, purpose and overall goal because so far they seem like the stereotypical boogie man. |
Aug 17, 2015 9:52 AM
#278
Aug 17, 2015 10:35 AM
#279
pffft chamo aint suspicious AT ALL, neither is hans adlet dont die bby ;-; |
Aug 17, 2015 10:40 AM
#280
Gov said: So with everything that happened and with how the show is pacing itself, we can assume that by end of the season they will finally start their journey to the demon king? Would have preferred to see a backstory on the fiends and how they came about. Creation, purpose and overall goal because so far they seem like the stereotypical boogie man. If you mean it becomes a stereotypical action adventure story again then no. The entire series consists of one mystery after another which advances the plot taking places in different location and battles in each novel much like this adaptation. They all involve everything from the developing the characters to expanding the history of the Fiends and past wars. There six books out already and still ongoing. Basically Rokka is best described as an action mystery story/ |
Iron_MawAug 17, 2015 11:02 AM
Aug 17, 2015 11:28 AM
#281
fredchickens said: Inugirlz said: CodeKirugin said: I have a theory. During the few episodes ago. Mora said if one of the braves dies, one of the petals on the flower crest thing will disappear right? So, what if, they decide to kill one of them, that braves dies and the rest of the braves flower crest would be missing one petal out of six petals. Then the one who still has six petals would considered to be the "fake" one right? thats a good theory, let's hope someone like Chamo is killed to prove this theory. (of course she could be the fake too but i don't think so) I've already read the LN up until this episode and it pretty much confirms that 2 out of the 7 is innocent, but its the same info we already know just presented more clearly because of 3rd person writing and all. I want character deaths and if someone's gotta die make it be Chamo! (Or the princess cuz she's annoying, idc if she's innocent or not i don't like her) But the thing about this theory is if they're willing to bet that brave to be killed unless they're lucky to killed the traitor, I mean who knows how strong the traitor and especially the Demon God this time is?What I'm trying to say is that that theory of yours is kinda risky but effective in a way. That idea is for one thing, chancey because an innocent brave could die. For two, we dont know the nature of the crests. Its possible its some magic that could copy all the other crests, so that solution may not be full proof. |
Aug 17, 2015 12:17 PM
#282
Well, this episode established a good bond between Adlet and Fremy (RIP first ship but whatever romance is not the main here) and I think I heard Akira Ishida (the fiend from Adlet's backstory) Man man they builded now a lot of things, I can't wait for the Seventh Brave reveal (its not Adlet i swear) |
The world shall know the truth soon. |
Aug 17, 2015 12:21 PM
#283
SweetCoconut said: and I think I heard Akira Ishida (the fiend from Adlet's backstory) You heard well, that was him indeed. :] |
Aug 17, 2015 12:58 PM
#284
fredchickens said: Inugirlz said: CodeKirugin said: I have a theory. During the few episodes ago. Mora said if one of the braves dies, one of the petals on the flower crest thing will disappear right? So, what if, they decide to kill one of them, that braves dies and the rest of the braves flower crest would be missing one petal out of six petals. Then the one who still has six petals would considered to be the "fake" one right? thats a good theory, let's hope someone like Chamo is killed to prove this theory. (of course she could be the fake too but i don't think so) I've already read the LN up until this episode and it pretty much confirms that 2 out of the 7 is innocent, but its the same info we already know just presented more clearly because of 3rd person writing and all. I want character deaths and if someone's gotta die make it be Chamo! (Or the princess cuz she's annoying, idc if she's innocent or not i don't like her) But the thing about this theory is if they're willing to bet that brave to be killed unless they're lucky to killed the traitor, I mean who knows how strong the traitor and especially the Demon God this time is?What I'm trying to say is that that theory of yours is kinda risky but effective in a way. Didn't say safe way, lol. But there's are times yo gotta take a risk and pray nothing bad happens, but then again it is a anime. Everything always goes wrong. |
Aug 17, 2015 1:01 PM
#285
NowOrNever88 said: fredchickens said: Inugirlz said: CodeKirugin said: I have a theory. During the few episodes ago. Mora said if one of the braves dies, one of the petals on the flower crest thing will disappear right? So, what if, they decide to kill one of them, that braves dies and the rest of the braves flower crest would be missing one petal out of six petals. Then the one who still has six petals would considered to be the "fake" one right? thats a good theory, let's hope someone like Chamo is killed to prove this theory. (of course she could be the fake too but i don't think so) I've already read the LN up until this episode and it pretty much confirms that 2 out of the 7 is innocent, but its the same info we already know just presented more clearly because of 3rd person writing and all. I want character deaths and if someone's gotta die make it be Chamo! (Or the princess cuz she's annoying, idc if she's innocent or not i don't like her) But the thing about this theory is if they're willing to bet that brave to be killed unless they're lucky to killed the traitor, I mean who knows how strong the traitor and especially the Demon God this time is?What I'm trying to say is that that theory of yours is kinda risky but effective in a way. That idea is for one thing, chancey because an innocent brave could die. For two, we dont know the nature of the crests. Its possible its some magic that could copy all the other crests, so that solution may not be full proof. That is true, but magic simply somehow copies the Six brave flower crest to the full extent could be hard or even possible, but again it's anime anything goes. |
Aug 17, 2015 1:55 PM
#286
@Zefyris > thanks for the info (interesting). Still unappealing though, for the entire anime industry. > it is worrisome, like I said. but among its cohorts, most are published for advertising (ref. only from you, 'tis new to me, but it's like a lawyer's response, "most, some, few"), few don't, some, already ended/finished, so it is unavoidable to start an anime with that criterion. but it is not the only reason. @Pat_To_Do-List > it's what it looks like. People clapping, me bowing, offering you a coke. |
Aug 17, 2015 4:06 PM
#287
Wait did the princess pretend not to hear anything in order to bait Goldof? Sure looked that way. And how does she intend to 'find proof that Hans is the 7th" by randomly walking around? Poor Goldof I hope he doesn't get killed. |
Aug 17, 2015 4:09 PM
#288
Aug 17, 2015 4:20 PM
#289
Andromalus said: Wait did the princess pretend not to hear anything in order to bait Goldof? Sure looked that way. And how does she intend to 'find proof that Hans is the 7th" by randomly walking around? Poor Goldof I hope he doesn't get killed. Wasn't that to save Adlet? what do you think would have happened if Goldof went back while Adlet was fighting Hans? |
Aug 17, 2015 4:44 PM
#290
Well, I would understand if she said something like "let's keep going" but "let's hurry up to prove Hans is the seventh" is way too suspicious to me. Not to mention her 'panic attack' from episode 4. Also the way they animated her when she said it is extremely suspicious because they didn't show her face. This screams GUILTY to me, might be overthinking it. Saw it a couple of times which only made me think she's the 7th even more. Just, Goldof don't die plz cause: Tylaen said: We will miss his exposed abdomen if he bites the dust. |
Aug 17, 2015 5:49 PM
#291
Tylaen said: We will miss his exposed abdomen if he bites the dust. RIGHT? Dem abs~~~~~~~~~~~ |
InugirlzOct 21, 2017 3:23 PM
Aug 17, 2015 6:32 PM
#292
animeBee1ver said: @Pat_To_Do-List > it's what it looks like. People clapping, me bowing, offering you a coke. Your point is? |
I like anime. |
Aug 17, 2015 6:33 PM
#293
Adlet really is an idiot, because he hasn't realised that he's already proved his innocence back in episode 4. As Mora said in episode 5, there are two ways to release the seal, either the caster dispells it themselves or die. Adlet attempted to dispell the fog back in episode 4 with Nashetania and Goldov as his witnesses. If he only pointed this out to the rest of them, this situation wouldn't be happening right now. |
Aug 17, 2015 6:40 PM
#294
Bored.... here's my theory: The imposter has to be Nachetania. Why? Lemme explain!! First I'm going to explain why the others either can't be an imposter or aren't as suspicious as Nachetania. First off Adler Mayer has been almost 100% confirmed to not be the imposter as his past with fiends has been displayed this episode. Hans is the most suspicious out of the whole, he's an assassin, he's got a creepy smile, he kills for a living and he just seems down right evil as well as being the one who brought the suspicion on Adlet in the first place. He's even been drawn to look suspicious and is shrouded in mystery. That's exactly why he's the least likely to be the imposter after the protagonist. You have to remember this is a fictional story made by manga artists, and this particular author needs a character that can pull our suspicion towards him/her and further away from the real imposter, so basically Hans has been hinted towards too much, any smart person with thorough analysis will notice this. Flammie is the same as Hans in my opinion, she was also created to distract the audience from suspecting the actual imposter and she did a better job than Hans for a small amount of time. I say this because as soon as Flame mentions the fact she is half fiend and that she was raised by fiends, it is almost inevitable to raise your suspicion on her because I can tell you that it sure got me thinking she was the one until she told her story. Although when she told her story we didn't see her flashbacks, which means she could've lied about it, and it would explain why she was killing other braves even afterwards, but her personality tells us straight that she's not lying or at least that she's not the one, and that's because she doesn't trust anyone even after all Adlet did for her, showing that this is the result of her mother betraying her and ruining her trust in others. Chamo is the next to be least suspicious and this is because she's said to be the "most powerful". The most powerful warriors are chosen to be braves and Chamo is meant to be the strongest regardless of her age because there were no restrictions or other requirements to be a brave than to be one of the strongest, which Chamo obviously is. Maro seems to be the next least suspicious. Although she is the third most suspicious to me. She is the head of the All Heavens Temple, and a saint, and judging by the fact she has tamed and has the respect of Chamo, she must be strong enough to be a brave, although the author has only slightly hinted towards her being the phony by her quick agreement to Adlet being an imposter but it's understandable because he was the most suspicious at that time for everyone else. Next is the loyal Guldof, he is shown to be a very loyal knight and servant to the Princess although I've seen many anime that have took this route where the loyal dude turns out to be some super bad guy and honestly Guldof has the dark hair, eyes and attitude to fit it. He doesn't believe in the Princesses words that Adlet is not the imposter and his story was vague as well as not being seen by Nashitania for a long time, which means he had time to plot something, but although Guldof does seem very very suspicious but yet unsuspicious due to his low screentime , I cannot come to the conclusion that he is the imposter because the author will assume he too will have quite a good number of people who will think he's the imposter, plus if he was bad he wouldn't have "gone easy" on the princess in that fight and he wouldn't have saved her, although you could say it's an act to gain trust but I think it can't be because we would get given hints in his facial expressions or voice if this was true. Now finally to why I think Nashetina is the imposter. First off she is automatically thought to be some sort of second protagonist of some sort, or at least important. This makes most people put her into Adlet category of "a main character, therefore can't be the imposter". Second is that she's pretty. Wait a minute, don't get me wrong I'm not saying pretty girls can't be bad but her character is very positive and funny. She teases Adlet and laughs. This makes her all the more less suspectable, positive and funny. The fact that she is inexperienced is another reason, she shows obvious signs of being the weakest of the whole group as well as the most inexperienced, getting worried before fighting and over reacting and showing inexperience during battle. This means that if she is the weakest she is the least likely to be a brave. Nashitania was also one of the first three people to reach the temple with Adlet and her saint ability may have allowed her to activate the seal or the whole "freaking out thing with the sword" was a way to hide her identity. I think this because she calmed down too quickly and her character isn't the type to rage like that. Although I think she's an imposter I don't think she's bad because that's what the anime wants you to think. A character said the imposter has to be bad but that isn't true at all, it doesn't make any logical sense. If the goal of the imposter was to eliminate the six braves why did they not plant traps and bombs or do it? It could be that she plans to let everyone fight it all out and let everyone kill each other, but then why does she defend Adlet? You might argue with she may love him, which is a reasonable answer, but it's too early to say that because she hasn't shown signs of blushing or not much at least. If anyone has been blushing between the two it's Adlet. I forgot to mention that her being a princess further hides the fact she is most likely the imposter. To me the princess just seems to not be suitable to change into a bad character, you could say she wanted to avoid anyone under suspicion getting tortured, but she did want to put the blame on Hans, which is understandable because he is a killer who has took the lives of others, he is only helping for the money, which shows greed and no kindness and she obviously doesn't like him especially because he's to blame for Adlet getting called the imposter. Even still, she's a positive character, she's been drawn to look like a typical cute princess who needs protection and honestly this time I don't think it's to trick us, it would ruin AdletXNashitania shippers and as I mentioned before she didn't want Adlet to die, she even pretended not to hear him fighting for his sake. If you ask me this all leads to one conclusion: she's the Naruto. She doesn't want war like a naive typical Princess and she thinks things can be solved peacefully so she locked up all the braves while someone else will go to the awakened demon king or whatever it is to negotiate during the meantime. I mean why else are they still alive and why was she defending Adlet if he's trying to kill the demon king. She's a good imposter. :D This is all theory by the way, you don't have to believe this or agree with it, it is merely my conclusion after collecting currently available data. Wow, long rant, that was fun, bai . |
Aug 17, 2015 6:59 PM
#296
Can't bother to quote that text, but if you go by "made by manga artists" then why the f does Adlet have red hair? Red being a symbol of demons, I'd say it's possible he is the fake, although he might have had his memories altered or something. Imo he or the annoying princess is the fake , but that leaves Adlet's 8th theory. There's probably someone left to be introduced. Also, couldn't they make Hans the most suspicious one because they knew people would think that rids him of suspicion? Although I doubt it, it's definitely possible if they considered how much people want to play smart. (nothing against those people <3) As for others, I can't really make out what you said, but Adlet's red hair might not have anything to do with anything and Nashetania might just be retarded and the little child might be the mastermind behind everything. Haters may say she has had chances to kill everyone, but where's the fun in that if she's a psycho? |
Aug 17, 2015 7:12 PM
#297
Zetsubo667 said: Adlet really is an idiot, because he hasn't realised that he's already proved his innocence back in episode 4. As Mora said in episode 5, there are two ways to release the seal, either the caster dispells it themselves or die. Adlet attempted to dispell the fog back in episode 4 with Nashetania and Goldov as his witnesses. If he only pointed this out to the rest of them, this situation wouldn't be happening right now. Adlet attempted to deactivate the barrier back then, but what he did was only an attempt without any knowledge on how to deactivate it. He's just trying the methods to deactivate it that he had heard of(some kind of rumors). It's also been established in episode 5 that none of them know exactly how to deactivate it. |
I like anime. |
Aug 17, 2015 8:50 PM
#298
MasaneX said: yuliyana29 said: MasaneX said: ThreePointer said: This show better get a second season. Japanese don't know what's good. Sales aren't going well. :/ In that case, why even bother to adapt the LN into anime? So CRUEL T_T Well they couldn't have known how it would sell. And I wouldn't find such a gem of a lightnovel if they didn't make it the adaptation. ^^ yUuRi_03 said: So basically, this season's story will be just about seven people, trapped in a certain location due to a spell and will put their wits out to determine a fake hero and try kill to kill him or her. meh.. sheesh..pretty slow development and not going to be surprised if the last episode, they still won't be able to get out from that trap. The fiend though...disturbing. Yeah, it will be about the Illusion Barrier, though I wouldn't say ''meh'' to it, I think it's an awesome arc. Also, the Illusion Barrier issue will be solved this season. If the entire season will be spent on that barrier, hopefully it will get another season... |
Aug 17, 2015 10:17 PM
#299
@Pat_To_Do-List “There are no coincidences in life. What person that wandered in and out of your life was there for some purpose, even if they caused you harm. Sometimes, it doesn’t make sense the short periods of time we get with people, or the outcomes from their choices. However, if you turn it over to God he promises that you will see the big picture in the hereafter. Nothing is too small to be a mistake.” ― Shannon L. Alder |
Aug 17, 2015 10:18 PM
#300
CodeKirugin said: NowOrNever88 said: fredchickens said: Inugirlz said: CodeKirugin said: I have a theory. During the few episodes ago. Mora said if one of the braves dies, one of the petals on the flower crest thing will disappear right? So, what if, they decide to kill one of them, that braves dies and the rest of the braves flower crest would be missing one petal out of six petals. Then the one who still has six petals would considered to be the "fake" one right? thats a good theory, let's hope someone like Chamo is killed to prove this theory. (of course she could be the fake too but i don't think so) I've already read the LN up until this episode and it pretty much confirms that 2 out of the 7 is innocent, but its the same info we already know just presented more clearly because of 3rd person writing and all. I want character deaths and if someone's gotta die make it be Chamo! (Or the princess cuz she's annoying, idc if she's innocent or not i don't like her) But the thing about this theory is if they're willing to bet that brave to be killed unless they're lucky to killed the traitor, I mean who knows how strong the traitor and especially the Demon God this time is?What I'm trying to say is that that theory of yours is kinda risky but effective in a way. That idea is for one thing, chancey because an innocent brave could die. For two, we dont know the nature of the crests. Its possible its some magic that could copy all the other crests, so that solution may not be full proof. That is true, but magic simply somehow copies the Six brave flower crest to the full extent could be hard or even possible, but again it's anime anything goes. LN reader hint: The method is already mentioned. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Rokka no Yuusha Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 19, 2015 |
986 |
by Heertx
»»
Jun 5, 6:32 AM |
|
» Amazing untilRealityChanges - Jun 10, 2024 |
15 |
by JCDRANZER
»»
Apr 28, 4:14 AM |
|
» TerribleDiznyOrdiz - Nov 15, 2024 |
12 |
by JCDRANZER
»»
Apr 28, 2:52 AM |
|
» I need SPOILERS from the novel ( 1 2 )-Bo0O- - Aug 1, 2015 |
69 |
by DrakoakAnime
»»
Apr 19, 8:12 PM |
|
Poll: » Rokka no Yuusha Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jul 25, 2015 |
305 |
by Rexnihilo
»»
Jun 14, 2024 6:10 AM |