Sasami-san@Ganbaranai Episode 1 Discussion

Lelouch22 said:
That was an exceedingly bizarre introductory episode, and, though I’m slightly intrigued by several aspects of the show, the incoherent and largely uninteresting material, along with the highly inconsistent execution, detracts from the show immensely; to the point where this episode and, in turn, the show is derived solely from a conscientious tonal dissonance and an abundance of pandering nonsense. The excessively offbeat nature of this episode doesn’t particularly lend itself towards a favorable impression, as it’s far too needlessly fragmentary and essentially devoid of even a singular glimpse of narrative potential. Essentially, this was a thoroughly nonsensical tapestry of a plethora of disparate elements, lacking in a necessary cohesion within the story, which resulted in an episode that was disappointingly trite and largely mediocre.

The opening was easily the worst sequence in this episode, as it was disturbingly voyeuristic in nature, which, I suppose, applies to the entire episode, for that matter, unnecessarily lingering on Sasami and her brother’s seemingly incestuous tendencies. Sasami’s interactions with Paparin were definitely the worst element within this episode, as they consistently strayed towards fully establishing an unnecessarily creepy dynamic. This narrative flaw within the episode is largely due to the brother’s involvement, since he’s consistently the most irritating character in the show. Though surrealistic and considerably illogical, the action sequence towards the end was quite enjoyable and very well-animated, but alas, nearly every moment aside from those few were comprehensively terrible and worthless within the construct of the “narrative“. If only the thoroughly poor direction hadn’t partially squandered the potential for momentary brilliance.

Though expected, the numerous intonations towards a vaguely incestuous dynamic throughout the episode, and, in particular, the interactions between Sasami and her brother, was an unfortunate and highly uninteresting aspect, as it only detracts from the relationships between the characters. As such, Sasami’s seeming attraction towards her brother, though expected, is quite disappointing, since it heavily cheapens their interactions and will likely be detrimental to the story, especially if her affections become unmistakably romantic in nature.

The characters, so far, aside from Tsuguri and Sasami, to an extent, are very uninteresting and completely devoid of actual characterization. They are, for the most part, particularly soulless, lacking the subtly complex or engaging personalities that are necessary for the effectiveness of their interactions. Perhaps this thoroughly noticeable flaw will be remedied as the story progresses, but it seems distinctly unlikely at this point. The effectiveness of the comedic touches throughout was essentially non-existent and, at most, quite inconsistent, typically elevating towards it’s marginal best whenever Tsuguri was directly involved, as her personality complements the humor far better than any other character.

The direction was highly inconsistent and detrimentally poor, resulting in incoherent storytelling throughout the episode. The character designs are quite impressive, as they’re more individualistic than I initially expected. Musically, this episode was very good, as this particular aspect easily distinguishes itself as the best throughout, most evidently illustrated by the whimsical selection that accompanied the closing scene. The animation, as well, was great, particularly throughout much of the action sequence. The OP was decent, but quite forgettable in nearly every area. The ED was simply atrocious and offensively lazy.

All in all, Sasami-san is essentially devoid of any particular element that’s even remotely compelling, resulting in what is the most disappointing show of the season, as the first episode made it perfectly clear that it possesses little to no noticeable potential. Stylistically, the show is quite appealing, but, aside from that rather insignificant element, the first episode never exceeds beyond a disappointingly tiresome mediocrity, often resolving itself to a thoroughly uninteresting repetition of needlessly perverse antics and dull interactions.

shigeru212 said:


It is definitely true that you have put a lot of thought and effort into your comment. I disagree with you on a few points but the comment I disagree with most is that this show possesses little to no noticeable potential.

Your words are a little too harsh, especially considering the circumstances.

There are a lot of unanswered questions, which are begging to be answered. Who has the power that changed the world into chocolate and who controls that power? Why are the girls ages reversed? Why is the brother's face covered up? I could go on and on but you probably get the point.

I'm not here to convince you this show is great. I do think the first episode was awesome but that is besides the point. What I am saying is that this show does have potential. Dismissing a show like this after one episode blows my mind.

neontaster said:


The entire world turned into chocolate and Yagami's breasts turned into rocket launchers while Onii-chan did the Suzumiya Haruhi dance. Lighten up, Frances. I think you're barking up the wrong tree here.

Lelouch22 said:
I'm not going to refrain from critically analyzing what I just watched simply because it's largely nonsensical.

neontaster said:


So you think every story should have the same elements? Would you do a character analysis of a movie like Space Balls or Naked Gun? How about a dissection of the horrible non-existent plot in Disney's Fantasia?

I'm not saying that any of the things you said were wrong per se. I'm saying that in many cases that stuff doesn't matter. Is this one of those cases? Way way too early to tell, which is another reason why I don't understand your analysis. Do an analysis based on the first episode of Madoka, Ga-Rei: Zero, Berserk, Gungrave, Higurashi, and a myriad of other shows and chances are you will be way off what the shows are like or even about.

tl;dr: I think you're getting ahead of yourself. It doesn't mean you aren't right on the money, but at this early point, who the hell knows?

Lelouch22 said:
Not necessarily, but I do greatly prefer a noticeable narrative and interesting characters in the shows I watch, which Sasami hasn't displayed yet. As such, Space Balls, Naked Gun, and especially Fantasia all excel at what they're attempting to accomplish, when, IMO, Sasami doesn't come close to doing so. For instance, the Monogatari series possesses several of the same detrimental elements that Sasami has showcased so far, but it also has fantastic character dynamics and interactions that usually offset the flaws to an extent (Having said that, Nise was much worse than Bake, primarily because of the heavy prevalence of the vaguely incestuous antics).

I definitely understand that my criticisms can be considered premature, since, as you said, it's really early into the story, but, as the narrative and story begins to take shape (if it ever does), I'll change my analysis accordingly and will likely perceive the show to be much improved by the end. This was just a poor introductory episode, and my criticisms are entirely based on the current elements in place. If I were watching and wishing to review any of the other shows you mentioned, I'd by approaching their first episodes with a very similar attention towards it's various elements. Of course, any show can improve or deteriorate as the story progresses, which is why I practically never drop any show I begin.

Plus, I critically dissect the majority of shows that I currently review, so it's not as though I'm focusing all of this analysis on only one show.

niwasatou said:
Worst thing I've seen in a long time. Just bad. Terribad.

AndyWorck said:
This may be actually my first time dropping Shaft anime.

FastWheels said:


oh god what the fuck am i reading

Yumekichi11 said:
Allergies to the sun?

Weak to heat?

Delusional about those and just plain lazy so stays at home to avoid shit like sweating and dealing with the heat?

I though it was cleared up Sasami is hikkikomori?

niwasatou said:
Worst thing I've seen in a long time. Just bad. Terribad.