ex_necross said: and how are u gather that information? my guess is that its common from thin air.Swiggy said: @Gender: Love you too, MAL! <33 I understand the reason why the 'About Me' section was placed on top, but I feel it's there at the sacrifice of something the MAL community valued more.;; We've lost the ability to see our stats without having to scroll or click. This only goes for narcissists with obnoxiously long About Me sections, or people who post huge images. For the majority of users it's a non-issue. |
moodie said: ex_necross said: and how are u gather that information? my guess is that its common from thin air.This only goes for narcissists with obnoxiously long About Me sections, or people who post huge images. For the majority of users it's a non-issue. Most people I've come across don't have huge "about me" sections. If anything, they had a few sentences or an image. Your "about me" is top tier though. |
shuryukan said: ex_necross said: I think they compare scores of anime of the same type of genre or just similar in general, at least from my experience...but ofc it won't be too accurate since genre alone doesn't dictate anime at allThe compatibility thing was complete nonsense. I had a very high compatibility rating with several people who I was basically the complete opposite of. They didn't like any of the shit I like, and all of their high rated anime were stuff I hated. Then I'll come across people who I strongly agree with, they like all the stuff I like, the same genres, or similar, lots of anime in common, etc, and I'll have a low 60% with them. Whatever formula they use is wrong. It doesn't make any logical sense. http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=5645&show=0 |
The only thing I don't like is the way the favorites are displayed, with the mini pictures and the  |
| This new update sucks go back to the old version... |
 |
zachfoss said: RedUbs said: I support this design! |
 |
| I want an ETA of when this will be reversed. |
   I envy your delusion; I wish I could live in it  |
Protaku94 said: seeing as how the review system is butchered for good i doubt they will comply with our wants and needsI want an ETA of when this will be reversed. |
Protaku94 said: I want an ETA of when this will be reversed. The same day that Youtube reverts back to it's old theme. |
| The new version is info too much, the bars make even less sense now - I want my simple number back. Also the way you handle the character list. Its just feel out of place and looks bad. In general the whole page feels now overloaded and cheap. The only good thing is that that your "profile" is at top. But that was about it. PS: stop deleting my posts, mr forum admin. Only because you don't like my opinion gives you no right to delete it, when I don't insult anyone or anything. |
| It's so entertaining reading all the butthurt opinions. No worries Xinil, you did well. |
 |
| Gonna take some time to get used to, especially the Anime/Manga progress bars gotta say I prefered the older bars for those. I do like change though, and this is definitely a step in the right direction. |
Axernea said: It's so entertaining reading all the butthurt opinions. No worries Xinil, you did well. *tips fedora* Part of me thinks this change is to be more friendly to mobile and tablet users.. that cancer has ruined the design of several sites I used to frequent. |
| When's the rollback? |
OPCKOA said: I've puked all three times I've gone back to my profile. I'm dehydrated and not going back until it's fixed. Okay, bye! |
| I have to agree with what a lot of people are saying. The About Me section being at the top of the page and the stats at the bottom is not a good move. I don't like it! I'd rather have people look at my stats first than read about who I am and stuff. =_= Hmmmm, I don't really know what to say about the favorites. I love that I can add more but it's kind of taking a little too much space and takes scrolling down even longer. Pros: * I like that the reply button for comments is not there if someone disabled the comments section on their profile. Saves me the time in typing a message when it can't be sent. * I really like how the anime and manga updates are separated. * The completion and status bar of the anime and manga updates, I like. * Like that we don't have to scroll all the way down to type a comment. - For when you guys are going to make the option of showing and hiding the number of reviews and recommendations, can you do that for blog posts also? - Is it just me or is the profile taking longer than usual to load? Like pictures. It's been happening to my profile, including others, and the avatars at the forums. For the most part, I like how you guys are approaching the design of the profiles. Definitely improvements need to be made. I kind of feel bad that you are getting bashed a whole lot when you guys are trying to make this better for us to use. So I thank you for trying to improve this site and are willing to read and listen to our problems and try to solve them. Good luck and thanks for your hard work. |
  |
| the new design is extremely confusing (impractical) for me, I'm not against a new design but this one... is much worse than on some other anime list sites *coughs* also, everything takes ages to load... o.o |
| Still no option to revert back. Typical incompetent mal staff. Inb4 thread locked cuZ they'll be butthurt. |
| :3 |
Xinil said: Future Design Considerations More convenient way to update watching/reading series through the panel, not the profile. Rip edit buttons on the panel too ?... |
ZeandoOct 17, 2015 12:59 AM
 Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
Zeando said: Xinil said: More convenient way to update watching/reading series through the panel, not the profile. Rip edit buttons on the panel too ?... wait wtf... who updates through panel??? I go to my profile every time. No to this pls |
 |
| wonder how can they make it more "convenient" than what it is now :/ currently you can just click the myList links and go directly to the serie you want to update, or use the edit buttons if it's so recent to be still visible in the last updates.. what are they trying to add this time?... |
Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
| Look nice, but pretty confusing. It takes time for me to use to it anyway. |
  |
| Look nice , i love it :3 |
Cnon said: zachfoss said: I support this design! Yeah this is awesome. Again though, I don't read manga. So it's kind of annoying to have that huge chunk taking up space. |
 |
| Looks a lot more modern, yet simplistic. I like it. |
 ♥ "Love is the resolve to create an illusion that accepts this reality" ♥ Tehqo said: I have no clue what The Devil is a Part-timer. But I'm guessing it has to do with a devil, being a part timer. xd You can watch Hataraku Maou-Sama! It's about the devil Satan, who is a part timer in Mcdonald... |
| Looks fine. I loved the previous one too, but oh well. I guess i'll get used to the new Design.=) |
| A true man never dies. |
Cnon said: zachfoss said: I support this design! Wow, I love that design. |
| |
M00ner said: Yeah that looks perfect reallyCnon said: Wow, I love that design. |
  |
| I really like the statististics this way. Reminds me to finish the stuffs on my watching and on-hold list. Also imo the location for About Me is better both for people who already wrote/decorated them and the ones who didn't (me!). Looks less boring with those colors. |
| there isn't really much "new" added to the profile, it just changed the looks, so I think that's why it seems so outrageous to me, cause there's no merit to it looking this way xD would be nice to let us customise the profile like we can do with the panel, I mean, move things around xD |
 ~by baba <3 |
HaXXspetten said: M00ner said: Yeah that looks perfect reallyWow, I love that design. Now this is better! But,favorite names :( Either way, much better than the current |
 |
| I kind of like the new layout |
 |
toph-bei-fong said: for now they only plan to allow to hide some parts, not choosing the position yet :(there isn't really much "new" added to the profile, it just changed the looks, so I think that's why it seems so outrageous to me, cause there's no merit to it looking this way xD would be nice to let us customise the profile like we can do with the panel, I mean, move things around xD Xinil said: Future Design Considerations
|
Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
| Not liking the update that much aswell but why even update the profile when you could at least try to fix some technical issues that the site has been having a long time like site failing to load images for some users or even update the profile pictures. This seems like something that needed the least attention on this site to me, profile page update..... |
 |
| I'm liking this change actually, there are really no major differences but still feels like an upgrade. Kind of. |
| 5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
modern dark theme download if someone is interested |
   |
RedUbs said: I like this! I hate the Fav section under the stat and stat under the profile. Better put it like old days. Since this place where people love to stalking other stat not how beautiful profile you can pull. ;A; I want this...at least.... pls... |
AoiMizuOct 17, 2015 4:28 AM
 |
| I'm actually enjoying the changes! |
 |
| They just have to ruin everything I like. |
 |
| Anyone know why I can no longer see the images on my profile page? It's like the bbcode no longer works.. Aside from that, the change is just change. I see no benefits to the new layout, or real issue either ( I would like my images back though ofc). Someone in web design just justifying their job by moving things around. |
 |
RedUbs said: Nice! Taking this a step further... |
Hederick said: In that case you are obliged to delete every single positive comment because none of them have any arguments. If you dislike reaction images, you should be fair and delete all the "looks good" trash posts.ExTamplier said: Feedback is used as a basis for improvement. So no, simply linking reaction gifs in your posts without anything else is not feedback. It's spam.Reaction gifs are a negative feedback as well. This thread has several examples of "feedback". |
| It's quite weird for now, but the extended favorite list is nice. Probably going to get used to it...eventually. |
 |
Tyrel said: Thread was hitting 34 pages and was going backt to 33 pages twice yesterday. Don't talk if you don't know anything. You should remain humble instead of being an ass throwing "lmaos" at everyone while in fact you're the one who is wrong.TsundereHeart said: Stop making assumptions lmao. If you think that's the case, then there would be way less pages than it currently is.Do you have some better metric? I'm sure more than 70% of the feedback posts in this thread are telling Xinil how much it sucks, and this is with the mods deleting some of the negative posts. I don't really think there's any indication that more people like this than don't while we have a strong indicators for the opposite. |
| I don't like this at all...... Favorites in the middle of my about me, and everything is also harder to find. No longer I hide comments etc. Just overall I extremely dislike it and would like to have the option to choose if possible, I miss the old layout already.. |
 ♠ Profile ↔ Anime List ♠ |
Snappynator said: It isn't extended though. Less characters and people are displayed. Do you really want to click the arrow every single time? This shit isn't even stored in cookies, so whenever you refresh the page, you have to click all the goddamn arrows once again.It's quite weird for now, but the extended favorite list is nice. Probably going to get used to it...eventually. geralt said: Typical positive feedback. Doesn't even know what changed but will spam "I like it".I'm liking this change actually, there are really no major differences but still feels like an upgrade. Kind of. Sol-Air said: What is simplistic about having multitude of colors all over the place and everything taking up twice as much space? Are you sure you used the word you wanted?Looks a lot more modern, yet simplistic. I like it. |
ProgeuszOct 17, 2015 3:54 AM
| I can't see how many "anime/manga list" viewers some1 have anymore ;_; It sucks.. |
 |
Progeusz said: The best part is they deleted some negative feedback that actually had valid points, and were contributing to the thread. When I confronted one of the mods, I was told I was "spewing nonsense"Hederick said: In that case you are obliged to delete every single positive comment because none of them have any arguments. If you dislike reaction images, you should be fair and delete all the "looks good" trash posts.Feedback is used as a basis for improvement. So no, simply linking reaction gifs in your posts without anything else is not feedback. It's spam. This thread has several examples of "feedback". Tsiox said: thank you for this. I enjoy the darker background modern dark theme download if someone is interested edit: seems some stuff on forums is misaligned with the theme though. |
210125Oct 17, 2015 3:59 AM
|
More topics from this board
» [Challenge] You Should Read This Manga 2024 ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Kineta - Feb 23 |
218 |
by httplatte
»»
11 hours ago |
|
» Moderators Wanted! Accepting applications for all positionsKineta - Apr 26 |
0 |
by Kineta
»»
Apr 26, 6:46 PM |
|
» Try MAL's New Mobile Site! ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Xinil - Feb 15, 2015 |
423 |
by RED-clover12
»»
Apr 24, 10:19 AM |
|
» Planned 5hr Maintenance, Thursday April 25 @ 1am-6am PTKineta - Apr 22 |
0 |
by Kineta
»»
Apr 22, 8:10 PM |
|
» New Site Update: Peak Anime 🗻 ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Kineta - Mar 31 |
213 |
by Lancelot73
»»
Apr 21, 4:28 AM |