Kirakira Joust ✨

For this part please evaluate appearances of the aforementioned characters on a 1-10 rating scale where 10 is "the prettiest" and 1 "not pretty at all/doesn't fit an idol image".

@Piromysl @Szczelajo @NightVampire @rohan121 @WaterMage @MinakoBestGirl @CrimsonWanderer @Cielord @AkeZZZ @nirererin @six20 @Coaghim @juanlqr @Memore @TheMinkalex @Yonahim_Zz @StephAlice @MitsukiHimeka @stickyfingersx @machy871 @Zarutaku @Sophithia @Auti_ @TitanOfPlasma @Jackson1333 @erotardation @Grecefar @KittenCuddler @JaniSIr @DevilishHeart @SouthRzVa

@Zarutaku You are being so evil >:( .

No ranking? So if you want, you can rate everybody a 10/10?

List of characters in text format.

❤︎ Aino Minako
❤︎ Arima Kana
❤︎ Hoshino Ai
❤︎ Hoshino Ruby
❤︎ Kisaragi Chihaya
❤︎ Kuon Nanami
❤︎ Minato Yukina
❤︎ Nishikino Maki
❤︎ Ohara Mari
❤︎ Renjouji Bell
❤︎ Sonoda Umi
❤︎ Takamatsu Tomori
❤︎ Tsushima Yoshiko
❤︎ Yazawa Nico

@dazedcowcow62 @tchitchouan @Mindnight @Eldinis @Adnash @Neengen @StyxParadise @FZREMAKE @Dazonwraith @Little_Sheepling @Saeryen @Serfort30 @Barrycade @RainyEvenings @LeonhartAugust @Vaturna @DesuMaiden

❤︎ Aino Minako - 5 / I don't really know her, despite knowing she's from a popular older show. So out of respect, she gets a 5.
❤︎ Arima Kana - 10 / I really like her, despite liking Akane aswell, Kana remains a toptier character.
❤︎ Hoshino Ai - 5 / she dead, why she so popular?! lol Her eyes always bugged me, so yeah not a huge fan BUT she did have a huge impact on the show and presented a rather good lenghty first episode. Out of respect another 5.
❤︎ Hoshino Ruby - 6 / S1 nothing much worthwhile, S2 barely had screentime, S3 she better knock it out of the park! I expect greatness!
❤︎ Kisaragi Chihaya - 10 / These blue haired girls are killing it, I don't know her, but she's pretty, cute and has some nice pictures. I have never seen Idolmaster, but I'm willing to give it a try.
❤︎ Kuon Nanami - 4 / Don't know her, haven't seen her show either and those pictures for an idol are pretty boring, fail.
❤︎ Minato Yukina - 10 / absolutely loved all her pics, motivated me to watch the show, 2 bad she's just a supporting character, insta watch if she was main character. Extremely cute & very photogenic. I want to recruit her into my harem.
❤︎ Nishikino Maki - 6 / She's really trying hard, she has a variety of pictures, but it's not for me. Maybe her personality would demand a higher score, but I don't know her. A solid 6 feels good/justified.
❤︎ Ohara Mari - 6 / Same reasoning as the previous one, blondes are overrated in anime world, it's all about green, blue, red and white lol
❤︎ Renjouji Bell - 6 / At least the previous 2 had a variety of pictures and are trying really hard. I have to fail her.
❤︎ Sonoda Umi - 10 / Very cute, very photogenic, would watch her show just for her, but she doesn't have a show?! Was she promotional material or something?
❤︎ Takamatsu Tomori - 4 / boring pictures, not enough emotions, if you would tell me she's an android, I would believe it, 2 bad cause she does have that certain 'je ne sais quoi' For an idol, she needs a lot of work. Failing her for now in the hopes she wakes up and steps up her game. Learn something from Minato Yukina please.
❤︎ Tsushima Yoshiko - 10 / another blue haired goddess, like mentioned before these blue haired ones are killing it, nice pictures, very photogenic. I'm not able to choose between these blue haired goddesses so they all get an easy 10.
❤︎ Yazawa Nico - 9 / she's cute and has nice pictures aswell, but she's not on the level of the blue haired horde nor Yukina and Kana, so a solid 9 is all she'll get from me.

Shizuna, I dunno why you decided to do it like this but I F love it. Good work! This has been very fun and fresh.

@Coaghim Someone has discovered his blue hair fetish OwO



Glad you love Yukina. Roselia unit actually has a standalone anime if you want to watch only that. Here are the two movies:
https://myanimelist.net/anime/41780/BanG_Dream_Movie__Episode_of_Roselia_-_I__Yakusoku
https://myanimelist.net/anime/41781/BanG_Dream_Movie__Episode_of_Roselia_-_II__Song_I_Am



@Barrycade I knew Bell from screenshots before the contest, i'm not inclined to watch the series but yea she's very nice ♪

❤︎ Aino Minako - 5 / I don't really know her, despite knowing she's from a popular older show. So out of respect, she gets a 5.
❤︎ Arima Kana - 10 / I really like her, despite liking Akane aswell, Kana remains a toptier character.
❤︎ Hoshino Ai - 5 / she dead, why she so popular?! lol Her eyes always bugged me, so yeah not a huge fan BUT she did have a huge impact on the show and presented a rather good lenghty first episode. Out of respect another 5.
❤︎ Hoshino Ruby - 6 / S1 nothing much worthwhile, S2 barely had screentime, S3 she better knock it out of the park! I expect greatness!
❤︎ Kisaragi Chihaya - 10 / These blue haired girls are killing it, I don't know her, but she's pretty, cute and has some nice pictures. I have never seen Idolmaster, but I'm willing to give it a try.
❤︎ Kuon Nanami - 4 / Don't know her, haven't seen her show either and those pictures for an idol are pretty boring, fail.
❤︎ Minato Yukina - 10 / absolutely loved all her pics, motivated me to watch the show, 2 bad she's just a supporting character, insta watch if she was main character. Extremely cute & very photogenic. I want to recruit her into my harem.
❤︎ Nishikino Maki - 6 / She's really trying hard, she has a variety of pictures, but it's not for me. Maybe her personality would demand a higher score, but I don't know her. A solid 6 feels good/justified.
❤︎ Ohara Mari - 6 / Same reasoning as the previous one, blondes are overrated in anime world, it's all about green, blue, red and white lol
❤︎ Renjouji Bell - 6 / At least the previous 2 had a variety of pictures and are trying really hard. I have to fail her.
❤︎ Sonoda Umi - 10 / Very cute, very photogenic, would watch her show just for her, but she doesn't have a show?! Was she promotional material or something?
❤︎ Takamatsu Tomori - 4 / boring pictures, not enough emotions, if you would tell me she's an android, I would believe it, 2 bad cause she does have that certain 'je ne sais quoi' For an idol, she needs a lot of work. Failing her for now in the hopes she wakes up and steps up her game. Learn something from Minato Yukina please.
❤︎ Tsushima Yoshiko - 10 / another blue haired goddess, like mentioned before these blue haired ones are killing it, nice pictures, very photogenic. I'm not able to choose between these blue haired goddesses so they all get an easy 10.
❤︎ Yazawa Nico - 9 / she's cute and has nice pictures aswell, but she's not on the level of the blue haired horde nor Yukina and Kana, so a solid 9 is all she'll get from me.

Shizuna, I dunno why you decided to do it like this but I F love it. Good work! This has been very fun and fresh.

@Coaghim hey just wanted to let u know that the pictures of bell in mal database doesn't do justice to her. i have put some images of her from the anime in few post above, if u care enough to take a look at it, though its entirely on you how u rate her

@Coaghim I haven't been counting the votes yet so it's OK to adjust them.

@Barrycade Yeah after making the vote, I took a look at what others might have said in their voting process and I bumped into your PR campaign :D

However...

1. I'm not sure if I can still adjust the score, in case Shizuna has already being doing calculations behind the scene & I don't want to burden him with extra work.

2. Is it fair for other candidates like Kuon Nanami? This 1 time during best girl contest we were allowed to post an official picture of your chosen candidate. Later this neat feature got removed for it was decided to just stick to the MAL picture.


I'm not sure who decides in MAL database for Bell to only have 2 bland pictures, while others like Yukina have a mini album full of great pictures.
I once submitted multiple pictures of characters of the manhwa Overgeared, I got denied due to certain rights that impeded MAL to post any pictures. Then a couple of months later I was surprised they all suddenly had pictures in MAL database.

If Shizuna allows, I'm willing to bump her up to a 6, on the same level as Mari & Maki.

Kana 1
Minako 8
Ruby 1
Ai 3
Chihaya 6
Nanami 6
Yukina 7
Maki 8
Mari 9
Bell 10
Umi 8
Tomori 7
Yoshiko 7
Nico 8

I wanted to give only one 10/10 and not gonna lie, gifs posted by @Barrycade earlier made it simpler. Bell fits the idol image the most from all idols available in this round, at least in my opinion. Too bad that most likely Oshi no Ko will dominate the highest places anyway, lol.

@Adnash hehe thanks for rating her so high! i think u get her charm :D though i think love live perfectly defines the typical idol culture also oshi no ko is somewhat up there too but pretty rhythm series takes a different approach by combining idols with ice skates, so it's not your usual idol anime

@Barrycade I think it's lovely how you tried to show everybody here Bell's charm. Maybe I should've posted some Umi pics too.

@Barrycade I think it's lovely how you tried to show everybody here Bell's charm. Maybe I should've posted some Umi pics too.