High School DxD (light novel)
| What is your opinion? I think is good, but people like to attack it bacause it has ecchi and harem. |
| In my opinion, it's not a bad show. But it's also not amazing. |
 |
| i mean not really compared to other shows, its garbagio for sure but not mars of destruction bad even tho thats so shit its good still, plenty of show like high school dxd and they're mostly popular |
| One of the best ecchi shows if not the best ecchi show ever made. ;) |
metalNakama8792_ said: What is your opinion? I think is good, but people like to attack it bacause it has ecchi and harem. it is not really my type of show because it is not intellectual like evangelion, but i see why some people like it. every anime has something for everyone |
| I liked it, it had some interesting lore to it and I enjoyed the transformations. Back when I was younger, would have said it was the best show that neared the boundary of ecchi and hentai. But, other shows have pushed past DxD in terms of ecchi. But, I still see it as one of the better shows that has ecchi and harem in it. |
"Perfection is perception. For me, humanity's imperfections is what makes it perfect"  |
| It's pretty average as a show but it's the best i've seen for it's genre |
 IT'S NEVER OGRE |
| For an ecchi series, which is generally what I choose to judge it as, I think it's pretty solid minus that last season... Fan service is pretty effective for me. If I were to judge it by it's other tags though...As a "comedy" it fails pretty hard for me compared to stuff like Saiki K. But I tend to be a harsh judge when it comes to supposed "comedy" anime in general though. As a "romance" anime...I'm not that big of a romance fan, but I'd say it fails on that front too, as most harem series tend to do... Basically, the "ecchi" tag is what saves if for me. |
FanofActionAug 11, 2020 5:38 PM
| it's ecchi over plot, not plot infused with ecchi making it cringe |
 |
| I think it's a great mesh of appeal. There's a lot of similar titles, but I think it's the most perfect by far in handling itself. Entertaining af for me. It can't be helped that people don't like it for what it is. It's nice that more people can say that it's just not for them, unlike some years back tho. |
 |
| The first two seasons were good. Season 3 onwards just got boring. |
 |
| I honestly really enjoy Highschool DxD but i couldn't see myself giving it anything higher than a 10 besides it's fanservice. It's nothing that special or GOAT worthy, but still an alright series. |
 |
| Season 3 was a disappointment but everything else is pretty fucking good as far as Im concerned People who say its bad because ecchi and harem are just blinded by their bias taste in the medium and dont stand on any objective grounding |
 |
| One of the best of its genre. People kinda just look upon ecchi and harem and especially when it's as blatant as DxD |
   I swear, I don't have a thing for blondes. |
| I wouldn't say outright bad - I could still have a good time with it, after I put myself in the right mindset (albeit the fact I had to do that on my own prerogative instead of it happening naturally should say something) - but I think its position as such a prominent gateway into ecchi due to its relatively accessible narrative structure/premise mixed with the fact that it has exceptionally safe and basic fanservice can cause people to stereotype ecchi as a whole pretty unfairly. I think a lot of the blame for that perception is shouldered by DxD and how it uses fanservice. And on that note, I also have a personal distaste for shows that can only make use of basic exposure shots. Just seeing a tit isn't very exciting or fun. Same with panty shots. A tit is a tit, panties are panties. No matter what, DxD will take any context that it builds up for an ecchi scene and turn that into a similar basic exposure shot every time. I really like to bring up how it turned a fucking tentacle scene into nothing but a series of chest zoom-ins. That's actually impressive to me in how reductive it is. It gets stale fast, especially if you're not watching it as one of your first ecchi and have seen a lot of stuff execute on these sexualization concepts infinitely better. I think it's a mediocre H&E. I wouldn't say bad, but I think it's very weak, soft, and safe, especially relative to contemporaries like To LOVE-Ru, KissXSis, et cetera. There are heaps upon heaps of better golden age ecchi to choose from if you're showing up for the ecchi. If not, well, have fun with the meh battle shounen-esque narrative, I guess? It does put a greater emphasis on that than a lot of other H&E series, but it's nothing really special if you've seen a couple of series like it already. DxD is baby's first ecchi. Always has been and always will be. It's good to have around due to how accessible it is, making it a good gateway series for ecchi. It places people in familiar territory with its narrative and won't do any fanservice that's too extreme with its sexualization, since it will live and die by simple exposure shots. On any level beyond that, it falls to pieces fast. |
ManabanAug 11, 2020 8:33 PM
 |
| Even though I had unknowingly watched other ecchis before dxd like Ranma 1/2 İ still consider it as my official entry to the genre so it still holds a pretty special place in my heart. As for the hate I think it's pretty stupid to judge a something for what it's not trying to be, as an ecchi it's still really good. |
| If you care about any of the qualities of the actual story, or if you care about how it is that the ecchi scenes come about, then DxD sucks. I only like ecchi when the characters bring about the ecchi scenes themselves. I derive no enjoyment from weird camera angles or paper clothes that fall apart in battles. I also don't find the character designs to be attractive in DxD, nor do I like their personalities. I am ready for all the hate you can send my way. Especially after I admit that I enjoyed To Love Ru a lot. |
Maenads said: . Especially after I admit that I enjoyed To Love Ru a lot. Finding DxD bland and TLR great is the correct opinion tho :> Hell, I consider To LOVE-Ru to be the gold standard for ecchi and still haven't found one that managed to be more fresh and consistently awesome with how it used fanservice. Mixed with Yabuki's art if you're reading the manga, it was fucking exciting. Every scenario pushed the limits. Every scene was at worst decently refreshing in how it handled it, and at best was the fucking pinnacle of what ecchi could be. If DxD is simple exposure to an extreme, TLR is context and scenarios to an extreme. Also, the difference in character writing quality is pretty drastic. I will 100% asser that the worst girl in TLR would be the best in most other harems. Either way, there's a reason that conservative parents in Tokyo tried getting TLR banned from being sold in the city and didn't give a shit about DxD during that whole push :P |
ManabanAug 11, 2020 8:43 PM
|
Manaban said: Maenads said: . Especially after I admit that I enjoyed To Love Ru a lot. Finding DxD bland and TLR great is the correct opinion tho :> Hell, I consider To LOVE-Ru to be the gold standard for ecchi and still haven't found one that managed to be more fresh and consistently awesome with how it used fanservice. Mixed with Yabuki's art if you're reading the manga, it was fucking exciting. Every scenario pushed the limits. Every scene was at worst decently refreshing in how it handled it, and at best was the fucking pinnacle of what ecchi could be. If DxD is simple exposure to an extreme, TLR is context and scenarios to an extreme. Also, the difference in character writing quality is pretty drastic. The worst girl in TLR would be the best in most other harems. Either way, there's a reason that conservative parents in Tokyo tried getting TLR banned from being sold in the city and didn't give a shit about DxD during that whole push :P I agree with you 100%, but I think we are actually in the minority for having this opinion. I have read about 30 chapters into the manga, although that was a while ago. The sad thing is after TLR (and nozoki ana was pretty great too...the manga) where the hell do I go? Nothing compares. And lol every country has their authoritarian conservatives huh? |
| The anime is alright (except for S3), and given how I just finished the first 25 volumes, I think the LN is great. |
MAL EMOJIS - Get your specially formatted emojis for MAL forums.        |
| I don't hate ecchi and harem, but I found DxD boring. |
"The Slave is the have-not, the oppressed one with nothing to spare. But because the Slave is in that despairing situation, having nothing, it can kill the Emperor !" |
| it's not lewd enough, I don't care for the story, and issei's fear of women made me cringe my eyes out. ashia is an annoying cockblock character. fuck obligatory tournament arcs. it was okay otherwise. |
| 馬鹿げた倫理 全部ガラクタで |
Maenads said: Manaban said: Finding DxD bland and TLR great is the correct opinion tho :> Hell, I consider To LOVE-Ru to be the gold standard for ecchi and still haven't found one that managed to be more fresh and consistently awesome with how it used fanservice. Mixed with Yabuki's art if you're reading the manga, it was fucking exciting. Every scenario pushed the limits. Every scene was at worst decently refreshing in how it handled it, and at best was the fucking pinnacle of what ecchi could be. If DxD is simple exposure to an extreme, TLR is context and scenarios to an extreme. Also, the difference in character writing quality is pretty drastic. The worst girl in TLR would be the best in most other harems. Either way, there's a reason that conservative parents in Tokyo tried getting TLR banned from being sold in the city and didn't give a shit about DxD during that whole push :P I agree with you 100%, but I think we are actually in the minority for having this opinion. I have read about 30 chapters into the manga, although that was a while ago. The sad thing is after TLR (and nozoki ana was pretty great too...the manga) where the hell do I go? Nothing compares. And lol every country has their authoritarian conservatives huh? Meh, probably with the masses, doubt with devoted ecchi fans. TLR talk typically dominates the H&E discord and both H&E and E/H advertise primarily with TLR for a reason. |
|
| I've dropped it at episode 10, but I think it's good for what it is. I guess I wasn't the targeted audience. |
| Nope, I think it's really good. Best ecchi show out there imo. Great characters, comedy, fanservice and even decent action. |
| it's a cliche harem and echhi , and prolly that's what make it bad |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I just watched the first episode and immediately lost all interest. Fanservice doesn't bother me (if it's funny/self-aware) but it's just kinda.... lame in this show. Also, Rias is boring and I don't like her hair color. I think I'm just not the audience lmfao |
sneakers-n-cakeSep 21, 2020 5:00 PM
 |
Black_Sheep97 said: sneakers-n-cake said: Rias is boring and you dont like her hair color? You have lost all validation.I just watched the first episode and immediately lost all interest. Fanservice doesn't bother me (if it's funny/self-aware) but it's just kinda.... lame in this show. Also, Rias is boring and I don't like her hair color. I think I'm just not the audience lmfao Lol why did you send me a friend request |
|
Black_Sheep97 said: I would argue that's part of the appeal the way it uses fan service so it doesn't get old. It is so over the top and exploitative that it becomes very enjoyable because of that laughable extremes. That's...literally the opposite of what I'm saying DxD is, though. I'm arguing that it's very milquetoast, mild and cautious relative to a lot of its contemporaries. A series that uses fanservice in increasingly over the top ways and plays around with the tropes of the genre in that fashion is To LOVE-Ru, or High School of the Dead, or Shimoneta. A lot of popular ecchi series use that formula. DxD is the fundamental opposite of that, though. It has an overreliance on one type of shot - basic exposure - and it doesn't push the boundaries or do anything interesting with that at all. It doesn't move forward with basic exposure shots. It doesn't push the envelope in any way. It's very, very circular with it. You see boobs. You see panties. You see boobs. You see panties. It's the type of fanservice that's only exciting or interesting if you're not used to anime fanservice. It's the very stereotype that a lot of outsiders *have* about what ecchi is and why they say they hate it so much. I mean really, most of the time it doesn't even deviate from using the same setup to each fanservice scene, i.e. clothes dissolution is probably 3 or 4 out of every 5 fanservice scenes in DxD. And unlike TLR with anime falls and how it handles that trope - progressively taking that basic trope and maintaining a consistent escalation of it throughout the series, where early on the anime falls are anime falls, and as it goes on we're hitting points where Rito is hitting his foot on a remote and somehow doing an anime fall on his entire harem as a result of that - DxD never escalates the trope it uses most. The first clothes dissolution shot is the same as the second, which is the same as the third, and the same as the 200th. That's not making it more and more absurd. This isn't being over the top. This isn't being extreme with its fanservice. It's basic exposure on loop, never actually doing anything particularly interesting with the same fucking type of shot. I think DxD is pretty limp-dicked about how it incorporates ecchi, if anything, but take that with a grain of salt. If you like basic exposure or if you like it kind of tame or soft like DxD handles it, that's all fine. But I don't think DxD even bothers trying to do anything interesting with its fanservice. It's 100% content resting on its laurels and being extremely repetitive and tame with it. Do I think less of it for that? Goddamn straight I do. Does that mean that the preference for how DxD does it is invalid? Nope. Also, Sora no Otoshimono. Trinity Seven. Dakara Boku wa, H ga Dekinai. Zero no Tsukaima. Majikoi. Is a harem MC with the type of personality Issei has *really* that special? It's an archetype that exists in fucking spades and yet people want to act like it hardly exists. Would also hard disagree that DxD's cast is better - or even just equal to - any of the series I'd mentioned prior. |
ManabanSep 22, 2020 4:00 PM
|
| I see thread still going so just going to drop gif for those who need moral support  |
|
Black_Sheep97 said: FanofAction said: what was bad about the last season?For an ecchi series, which is generally what I choose to judge it as, I think it's pretty solid minus that last season... Fan service is pretty effective for me. If I were to judge it by it's other tags though...As a "comedy" it fails pretty hard for me compared to stuff like Saiki K. But I tend to be a harsh judge when it comes to supposed "comedy" anime in general though. As a "romance" anime...I'm not that big of a romance fan, but I'd say it fails on that front too, as most harem series tend to do... Basically, the "ecchi" tag is what saves if for me. Honestly I don't remember. Probably something stupid and nitpicky that bothered me. Just remember not liking it as much. Maybe there was a character that bugged me or something.. |
| Not at all, I love it 😂 I enjoy the ecchi and harem aspects, and I do find the situations issei gets into amusing |
 |
| I think that it could have been more enjoyable. You are not supposed to take shows like this too seriously and I did not, its just that even as an ecchi comedy it's not all that amusing. |
More topics from this board
» Am I the only one who thinks Raynare was a wasted character?Leon888 - Sep 26 |
21 |
by Kaz2015
»»
Oct 4, 6:17 AM |
|
Poll: » Which DxD girl(s) do you want at your birthday party?IpreferEcchi - Jul 10 |
22 |
by KaranlikPasa
»»
Jul 31, 12:39 PM |
|
Poll: » Highschool DxD Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Yumekichi11 - Jan 5, 2012 |
281 |
by ENAGE69
»»
Jul 19, 2:24 PM |
|
Poll: » Akeno vs Rias ( 1 2 )IpreferEcchi - Jul 2 |
64 |
by -DxP-
»»
Jul 6, 9:30 AM |
|
Poll: » Highschool DxD Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Yumekichi11 - Jan 12, 2012 |
179 |
by ejleon
»»
Jun 30, 6:55 PM |