Do u prefer watching anime over reading manga?
| I mainly use MAL to keep track of the anime i watched, i'm an anime watcher and never enjoyed reading manga. I dont know why, probably the same reason i dont read Lord of the Rings or Game of Thrones books, and prefer watching the show instead. I've watched One Piece since it started airing, but the anime became so bad lately that i dropped it at episode 730. People advice me to read the manga, but as i said before, i really dont enjoy reading manga as much as i like to watch an anime, so i simply dropped One Piece. I feel like i'm one of the few people here who never reads manga. Did u start reading manga before u started watching anime? Do u prefer manga over anime? Are u the same as me, and only enjoy watching anime? |
 |
| Tons of people here don't read manga/source. In fact, based on user comments, it seems that us readers are actually a minority. |
| Well,before joining Mal I actually read more manga than watching anime, mainly long runners and Shounen Jump stuff. But thanks to Mal I found a lot of awesome shows and I'm definitely more of an animeman now. So my answer is yes, I prefer watching. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| I can't get into manga no matter how much I try No sound no animation ... Vn is better than both of them |
 |
| Although I spend more time on anime than manga, I prefer manga because the story is original and much more detailed. And you can't truly appreciate the artist when you see their works animated; they really shine through their manga. |
 |
| If i find the manga first ill probably read it. but i rarely look up new manga to read, so i tend to watch way more anime. but i tend to enjoy manga more than the anime adaptation. |
| I prefer anime over manga/novel... |
 |
| i prefer manga... my list should show it already... |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
| I've always preferred anime but it's usually not a problem for me to read manga, especially when there's no anime adaptation at all. If I can choose anime vs manga I'll choose anime, but if the adaptation was incomplete and I really liked it I'll check out the source. But if the adaptation was accurate then I won't read the manga. For example, I tried reading SnK but I just can't, I'd rather wait for new seasons of the anime. |
fuyukiJul 19, 2017 5:44 AM
 |
Nickgie said: I feel like i'm one of the few people here who never reads manga. Did u start reading manga before u started watching anime? Do u prefer manga over anime? Are u the same as me, and only enjoy watching anime? No you're not alone, I don't read them either. Nothing against them, but they're just not appealing to me. And I still have to figure out why not, since it's not that different from reading books, which definitely interests me. I guess it has to do with the fact that if I see some drawings with text on them; my brain tells me they have to be animated and emit sounds in order to be stimulating. Since this does not happen to be the case, all I get from reading them is a soulless experience, which then induces me to just be an anime-only consumer. And I see no problem nor sin in that. |
| Both are equally good as long as you're able to get fictions developed specifically for each form. "Developed countries" people should realize how lucky they are to be able to read and write. |
| I prefer reading some doujins /one-shots than wasting my time watching utterly tons of series >It suits myself |
 "Think about that glowing dust That destroys the night sky's dream of Just being nothing"--  -- |
| I kinda want to learn towards saying I prefer anime but I'll say I like them equally. I enjoy them both the same, it's just I don't really spend as much time with manga. When I do sit down though and read through some chapters, I enjoy it just the same. I don't really like fighting in manga form though (So I wouldn't read like DBZ for example), I'd rather see it animated. |
 “Don’t just mindlessly judge people as you please.” – Rin Okumura “Your past shouldn’t stop you from achieving your goals and dreams.” – Rin Okumura |
| Well, anime is more passive and has more aspects to it (color, music, movement etc..) so I generally prefer to consume stories like that since I'm lazy. But I do think manga as a medium has the better titles, more variety and is most likely generally superior just because of how much bigger it is. I also started manga before anime, bought my first manga (VOlume 1 of Akira) in 2001 and only started to get into anime (aside from stuff on TV) in like 2004-ish. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| I like them both equally but I watch way more anime than I read manga. The main reason for that is, I enjoy watching anime while doing other things whereas with manga I cannot really do that. Additionally, anime has been more helpful to me while learning Japanese. Once I learn most of the characters, I'll probably start reading more manga, specifically in Japanese. |
| If it's about action or adventure, I prefer anime over manga. I think anime gives move emotion because we can actually "live" the action but manga only show some picture. But if it's more about the story than the action then I like both equally. |
 |
| I absolutely love both but if i had to pick i would pick anime over manga. |
| I prefer manga cause I can read it anywhere I go and my mind won't wander off if it gets too boring. |
| While I absolutely love reading manga, I'd have to say I much prefer anime over it in every single way, even if the manga might be "better" so to say, mainly because I just love hearing the character voices, I love seeing them move about, I love seeing animators have fun with a series, it's just so entertaining. Plus, there is a downside for me when reading manga. If it's not one of the long ongoing Shounen series like D.Gray-Man, One Piece, Hunter x Hunter, etc.. then I have an incredibly hard time reading it. I need to read it in one sitting or just be constant with it. I can't take a week after week break. I need to get in, read, & get out, so I look for series that are complete. |
 |
This is the only answer. But I prefer anime over manga since most of the time I have a hard time discerning some scenes in mangas because of no sound/black&white but I guess this is mostly due to my inexperience. |
 "... Because when you live in this world of my closed eyes... ... Being alone is very lonely...". |
| Well considering this is in anime discussion the results of the poll aren't surprising. |
 |
| I like to see my anime tiddies in motion, and it's much better fap material than a still image, especially a bnw image |
   |
Furnixx said: Well considering this is in anime discussion the results of the poll aren't surprising. I had no idea where else to post this topic. I didnt have much choice, it was either here or in the manga discussion group. I hope manga readers also enter the anime realm once in a while. |
|
| I prefer anime over manga/novel, I easily get bored of reading. I only read something that really picked my interest and doesn't have an adaptation. tragedydesu said: Vn is better than both of them This is the correct answer. |
Nickgie said: Furnixx said: Well considering this is in anime discussion the results of the poll aren't surprising. I had no idea where else to post this topic. I didnt have much choice, it was either here or in the manga discussion group. I hope manga readers also enter the anime realm once in a while. Oh yeah I guess there isn't really a general discussion for both or anything. Sorry if I came off as a bit of a dick. |
|
| I prefer anime over manga because of the animation & sound. Manga just seems boring to me... |
 |
| I did liked anime first so my vote is I liked them equally for their respective attributes; stories and artistic drawing for manga. Animation, Backgrounds, Visual effects and Ecchi for anime. You might as well post a copy of this thread in other forum site, just saying if you're actually trying to gather data. |
 |
| I watch anime from most genres, but I only read yaoi manga, for the most part. |
  WORK IN PROGRESS ~The frog leapt forth to my lilypad memory.~ I was indoctrinated by an inamorata rabbit, Adenomata affronted. It was the verecund, dismissed creatures That I jubilated in most. This rabbit I would nurture, At the aiguille of esse, The anneal of noblesse. ❤️ Birdie ❤️ |
| Prefer anime because I love hearing the original japanese lines and seiyuu, not to mention it's animated, with sound and music and all. Reading manga only when: 1. The anime pulls an anime original ending. 2. There is no news on the sequel for years. 3. The anime pulls a Tokyo Ghoul Root A. 4. I love the anime so much I usually go reading the manga too (but not go past where the anime is) |
 OTP: KidLaw | IzuKatsu | GureShin | EruRi | AoKi | See more!» My art » My translation » Doujinshi collection » Favorite Kurobas doujinshi BISHIES X RAP |
| Both have their pros and cons. I'm more of an anime guy, because things like sound/music, motion and colors add a lot more to the experience and make it more enjoyable. In the other hand being limited to a specific timeframe (episode length and number) might be bothersome, especially in adaptations. Mangas however are more mobile, aren't bothered by things such as slow internet connection (if read on paper) and I just like having them on my shelf :3 Though in that case you have to pay for every book individually... |
otaku3125 said: Swagernator said: I prefer anime over manga/novel... If you read Fate/apocrypha light novel I believe you will enjoy it more than anime. Well anime has effect and waifu is in "motion" of course i'll enjoy anime more... There was no Sakamoto, Maaya sexy voice of ruler in Novel when i read it so... I read Kara no Kyoukai novel, Zero novel but i'll always say that i prefer their anime adaptations more. |
|
| Manga/Anime > Novel/Visual Novel I constantly shift from manga to anime as to not get bored with either one, and it works for me. |
| i like reading manga cuz its faster than watching anime LOL |
| Nah not really. But if I had to choose one over the other then it'd probably be anime. |
 |
| I always reading manga every single day, but if there's an anime i found Interesting, then i will focus on that anime without reading any manga |
| I prefer the original source of the media, which are usually manga, vn, or ln. Sometimes I see anime as just the promotion for the original ver., different case with original anime tho. |
 **☾** |
| Normaly i'm an Anime person, but lately i started to get into Manga and really enjoy it ^^ but have one rule don't read sources of what i've seen "anime" or i'm planning to watch |
| I definitely am more of an anime person, in 20 years I've only read around 170 manga vs 1,970 anime. |
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97"  |
| I prefer watching anime as there is likely potential to get the most entertainment per second since there are a bunch of things that anime offers vs manga (sound, music, animation, voice acting, color, etc). This is especially true for any action anime. Another thing is that there are huge amounts of various manga available. I'm very flexible and open to reading anything (just like watching anything) which is a problem in this regard because there's just too much, My line of thinking is, if producers are willing to make an anime adaptation out of the source for profit, chances are, I'm going to be assume the manga is good (of course the anime could fail), but since there is going to be an anime, I can watch that instead. It's a filter system. I realize that some great manga hasn't ever gotten an anime adaptation yet, but when I go down the road of running out of things to watch, I'll consider reading them. Also, in the case for eating, watching is much more convenient than reading, especially if it involves "hand" related foods. One more thing, waiting a week for an anime episode to be out >>> waiting for 1 chapter. If I kept up with Berserk manga, I might have suffered with that hiatus news |
MechKingKillbotJul 19, 2017 8:38 AM
 |
| I enjoy them equally honestly, but sometimes I like the manga over the anime, that's usually when the anime adaptation is shit. Sometimes I just read the manga for series as well and don't even check out the anime. |
 |
| Personally I think manga is easier to get into, it doesn't really require a lot of effort to read a manga, as well as reading manga doesn't take that much time. however I have watched more anime than I've read manga though lol but idk at the end of the day I like them both equally |
 |
| I used to prefer anime but then I experienced some stories like Holyland and Vagabond then looked at the upcoming lineup of newer anime and decided to start reading manga instead. |
 |
| This one is tough to answer..., I started from dragon ball manga though. I would say... I actually enjoy reading manga more than I do watching anime, if we are just talking on average. But a well executed scene in anime gives me a greater high than a manga high ever could, simply because of music, animation, time spent building up a climax, etc. Unfortunately experiencing that high is not common, so on average I enjoy manga more overall. For ex: something like shokugeki no souma. Both are solid (anime and manga), but in the manga I can simply skip all the cooking aspects of the show (when they go into depth about the specialty of the dishes created). I can appreciate the amount of effort they put into providing actual cooking content that might appeal to those that like that aspect, but I don't care about that stuff nor am I trying to learn it. I cook sometimes, but I'm not reading the manga to learn cooking tips or be fascinated by the dishes created. It's mostly for the characters and shounen aspects. It takes me a couple of seconds to skip that stuff, but when you watch the anime it might take like an entire episode or two, or 3, or 6. Manga allows you focus more on the aspects you enjoy in this case, simply because it's faster and easier to skip the stuff you don't care about. This also allows for a more complete first impression, where as with an anime that doesn't quickly appeal to me, the pacing is simply out of my hands and my patience wears thin. Manga is usually less censored as well and kinda leaves me with a sense of a more genuine and accurate interpretation. It feels like there is less restrictions and more freedom, even if this simply is not true (I can't really say because I don't know the process of printing this stuff, but it does feel that way as a reader). |
More topics from this board
» Who is your favorite Gyaru in anime?Duado - Oct 11 |
27 |
by AcD4c
»»
49 seconds ago |
|
» Is it bad to raw-dog seasonals?thewiru - 2 hours ago |
16 |
by WaffleMaster89
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Anime characters that used to be older than you, now you're older than themComeInReiAsuka - Yesterday |
18 |
by Zayvex
»»
14 minutes ago |
|
» Which anime have you almost ruined for yourself?Rally- - Oct 10 |
17 |
by phokingbeast
»»
23 minutes ago |
|
» Anime musicnishant0 - Today |
25 |
by jacobPOL
»»
24 minutes ago |