Choose the best in your opinion
| Thread Moved |
| Marineford, that's why they call it WAR OF THE BEST. but Dressrosa is very good too, the Manga it is, but the anime not yet, if there are people who already fall in love to Dressrosa arc in the anime, well prepare to get shock from future event. |
 |
| Water 7 for me even if there are a bit too many chapters where nothing happens during the Enies Lobby part. Alabasta, Jaya and Marineford were really cool too. |
| Marineford! Definitely! It's the arc that left the most impact on me so far. Can't wait to see more epic arcs~ |
 |
| Marine ford was was basically fanservice of power ups and devil fruits, I would say Arlong Park, back when it was good. |
| Enes lobby Much love for Robin :),.. and then Marineford and Arlong park arc .. |
 |
| It's pretty difficult for me to chose a favorite arc. Almost all of them had very enjoyable parts/elements to them. I loved Sabody (1st trip to Sabody with supernova shit + Raleigh + Celestial Dragons + Pacifistas + Kizaru+ Kuma) and Arlong Park. Each were my favorite arc when I had only reached those arcs in the anime (and not read/watched anything beyond them). But more recently, I thoroughly enjoyed the whole Impel down-marineford-luffy flashback arc. If you could treat all that as a whole it would probably be my favorite so far. Its like the Rising Action, Climax, and Falling Action of one arc if you can think of it that way. I think Water 7/Enes Lobby is a little overrated. It tends to be most One Piece fans' favorite arc it seems. I thought it was fun for the most part (specially Robin's flashback and Luffy vs Lucci) but still too many other arcs I enjoyed more. Dressrossa has been very good (Far and away best arc of the New World so far, Fishman Island + Punk Hazard don't even come close as they were riddled with serious flaws to me), because its feels unique, fun, introduces a lot of interesting and important characters, and most importantly But it could be amazing if not for |
midnightbladeJul 11, 2014 9:16 PM
 |
| The post Marineford arc. I view One Piece more as a whole journey than as separate arcs and that arc really drove it home or brings together what they've been through on their journey and how close they've grown. Starting off with the much needed flashback of Ace and Luffy's childhood. It went to show the crew, how they were dealing with being separated and what happened at the war. Reflected on what the journey and what Luffy means to them and what they're going to do to better themselves to achieve theirs and Luffy's goal. It also showed the potential of the story and things promised later. Meeting Shanks, the rio poneglyph, the waiting adventures, etc. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| I voted for Skypiea and I am so glad to see that a lot of people agree with me! I think it was one of the most shonen arc of this manga. I really enjoyed it. I would have gone with Dressorsa cause it's an epic arc, but all these filler with sidefights and sidestory is just killing the climax D: |
| Another for Water 7/Ennies Lobby from me. I didn't actually start reading and catch up to One Piece until they met the Flying Fish Riders, so that whole arc was wonderful to read through at once. That being said, I love Dressrosa so far. I know a lot of people are frustrated by how much it jumps around, but I think it's needed for the scope. Can't wait to read it through once it's actually finished, too. Reading One Piece in volumes always feels better when so much is happening. |
 |
| Water 7 |
| Water 7/ Ennies Lobby. Then Arlong Park. And Dressrosa is going to be one of the best arcs too. I liked all arcs. |
| Marineford Hands down... u-u |
| Water 7/Enies Lobby is a bit overrated. Remember the thing with Foxy in the beginning? Yeah, it was fun, but all we got out of it in the end was meeting Aokiji. The whole thing was 20 chapters. And the bloat didn't stop there. The whole thing was around 30 chapters longer than the entire Summit War saga. That's Saobody, Amazon Lily, Impel Down, Marineford and the post-war arc as well. It was very good, and Luffy vs Lucci is the best 1-on-1 fight in the series, [Edit: Forgot about Luffy vs Arlong. That one could be better.] but there were flaws that people tend to ignore. Worst arc is Fishman Island, by far. So, so bad. Harder to say what the best arc was. Maybe Arlong Park? Been a while since I read it. |
PolyphemusFeb 23, 2015 5:56 PM
| I am important. I have a girlfriend. Check out my podcast |
| I like Skypiea and Water 7/Ennies Lobby a lot. |
 |
| Hmmm... for me it's Impel Down. Dressrosa is my second fav. It had probably been my favourite if it wasn't so dragged out (especially in the anime). But there's a lot of good arcs in One Piece :) |
| Definitely Water 7/Enies Lobby. Impel Down and Marineford were great too. Pre-timeskip OP was just great in general. Hopefully current OP will come something close to that sooner rather than later. If they reach 70% of Water 7/Enies Lobby quality then great, if more than that, even better! |
Polyphemus said: Water 7/Enies Lobby is a bit overrated. Remember the thing with Foxy in the beginning? Yeah, it was fun, but all we got out of it in the end was meeting Aokiji. The whole thing was 20 chapters. And the bloat didn't stop there. The whole thing was around 30 chapters longer than the entire Summit War saga. That's Saobody, Amazon Lily, Impel Down, Marineford and the post-war arc as well. It was very good, and Luffy vs Lucci is the best 1-on-1 fight in the series, but there were flaws that people tend to ignore. Worst arc is Fishman Island, by far. So, so bad. Harder to say what the best arc was. Maybe Arlong Park? Been a while since I read it. I too feel Water 7 & Ennies Lobby arc is overrated. I mean, it's very good but has its flaws, especially at the beginning. While there are brilliant moments (like the CP9 reveal), the whole assasination plot is confusing and the first encounter with CP9 is too one-sided (Luffy could have been killed twice with little effort). As the story progress, however, both the plotlines and the Straw Hats get stronger. Archadian said: Marine ford was was basically fanservice of power ups and devil fruits, I would say Arlong Park, back when it was good. I rather choose Marineford arc because IMO it's an excellent synthesis of the first half of One Piece. Also for its non-stop action and, yeah, for having tons of fanservice despite the chaos (it's a war, after all). I bet there will be a similar gathering of superpowered people in the future. |
VenariStrigasFeb 20, 2015 6:30 PM
| MF, W7, EL, AP and SA are the best. FI, PH and DBF are the worst. |
| The Water 7 saga or Sabaody. |
| east blue. Arlong park to be precise. |
 |
A_Fat_Man said: The Water 7 saga or Sabaody. Yeah, Sabody was pretty damn good as well. One Piece has had many good arcs, it's almost hard to pick. XD |
| Arlong Park blows every single other OP arc out of the water. There was no bullshitting back then. And after the time-skip, absolutely none of the arcs has been anything above average. |
 |
yhunata said: Arlong Park blows every single other OP arc out of the water. There was no bullshitting back then. And after the time-skip, absolutely none of the arcs has been anything above average. Quoting the truth. Even before the time skip the Thriller Bark arc or the later half of the Water 7 arc were very dry and dull. |
| I sometimes watch chinese cartoons/stuff and share unsolicited opinions. |
| Tough choice, but the Alabasta arc has somehow always been my favourite and the most nostalgic But all the other arcs pre timeskip are also incredible Honorable mention to the Punk Hazard arc, just because it has my 2 favourite characters in it (Smoker and Law) |
| Water 7/ enies lobby I mean from luffy vs ussop, to robin's backstory, to the stare down between the strawhats and CP9, to luffy vs lucci, to the death of the merry. It literally had some of the best moments for any strawhats, as much as I like marineford and cared for ace and whitebeard, none of their moments compared to luffy's struggle fighting one of his best friends, to ussop not being able to let go of the merry, to robin's pain and her finally accepting to live, to ussop crying his heart out at luffy to get up and the merry's last words, there is just no contest. |
| Jaya and Skypeia storyline is top 1 until Wano ends with a mindblowing ending. |
| 2 years training arc is the best. Although it is canon but at least we know the logic behind those power and abilities |
| Signature removed. Check your inbox |
UnipolarUnicorn said: Saurian_X said: Whole Cake Island. The Charlotte Family's easily my favorite cast of antagonists in the series so far. Excellent choice! The "Hey, Mother" chapter made me get all emotional too, haha. Love how Oda can manage drawing emotion out of his audience while still writing a funny/silly story... Can’t believe Oda managed to make such a diverse cast with 85 children,really shows how creative he can be.Plus,Katakuri absolutely deserves the hype he gets,a badass that has a soft side.The rest of the family were really entertaining to watch as well.Wholecake island is my candidate for best and most underrated arc. |
SummerynJan 6, 2020 1:46 AM
 |
| This poll needs an update. I remember seeing it almost 3 years ago when I was still getting through the East Blue saga. Fun memories. |
| wano don't argue with me |
  |
| Enies Lobby, bcuz Luffy vs Lucci is the best fight ever~ |
  Wandering Witch is the best light novel ever! |
| Dressrosa was phenomenal. I'm only 34 or so chapters into Wano, but it's already a close second to Dressrosa. The timeskip has been phenomenal all around in my opinion, and much as I love the pre-timeskip, I love the timeskip way, way more. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1163 DiscussionFMmatron - Yesterday |
0 |
by FMmatron
»»
Yesterday, 1:52 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1000 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )SuperRed - Dec 26, 2020 |
141 |
by WaffleMaster89
»»
Yesterday, 10:15 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1162 Discussion28012001 - Oct 6 |
49 |
by Aayush69
»»
Oct 18, 2:50 AM |
|
» How do they get back28012001 - Oct 16 |
6 |
by faisaljxmil
»»
Oct 16, 6:06 PM |
|
» The Worldstrawhatlucas - Oct 10 |
9 |
by Wematanye
»»
Oct 16, 3:10 PM |