In/Spectre is the type of series that tests the notion “how far are you willing to stretch a good idea?”
Conceptually, this is a brilliant idea for a story and overall, I think the execution is at least good. While so many mystery stories, anime or otherwise, tend to focus on purely the truth, characters getting to the bottom of how events actually happened, never have I seen creating a convincing LIE to factor into that. A lot of ins and outs are explored in the show’s attempt to qualify this point, so it keeps a unique source of engagement in a way unlike many
...
other shows of its type. The focus on one larger tale rather than many smaller stories also has the perk of trying to explore the types of angles other supernatural mysteries don’t have time for, in terms of implications. But it’s worth exploring the vibe of this series regardless.
In/Spectre has a very odd start, one that had me baffled as to what kind of show it was going for. It featured characters talking super seriously about serious events, but also mentioning a crush in the same breath and seeming to end out on an action scene. From Episode 1 I had no idea what In/Spectre was trying to be. Comedy? Drama? Romance? Supernatural? It’s a weird mix of all of those types, but Episode 2 seemed to plant things slightly more. Trying to explain and dissect a whole scenario in a mere 22 minutes with relation to supernatural elements devoid of emotion wasn’t very interesting with how little there was too it, better positioned the series as a Monogatari-lite, a mystery series involving supernatural phenomenon and their impact on the real world.
To its credit, the show is one of the better examples to follow up the genre. Unlike Rascal Dreams of Bunny Girl Senpai, it doesn’t get scared partway through the “subversiveness”, scurrying back to the comfort zone of LN anime clichés and cheap emotional manipulation. In/Spectre never feels cloying or dishonest, with even the supernatural elements fitting naturally into the setting, but it can drag its heels a lot with the emotionally distant first two episodes and trying to go through every minutia of a point for 9 episodes straight.
The writer of In/Spectre, Kyō Shirodaira, also wrote Blast of Tempest which received an anime about 8 years ago. That anime featured very high stakes, almost apocalypse level, yet still decided to have all that anarchy in the background while four characters discussed various topics for 5 episodes straight! The intention was earnest, but the tone and stakes of the series didn’t complement that style of writing at all.
In this show’s case, the stakes are lower, so the use of dialogue fits more. Its characters are few, but their archetypes and interactions do something to keep investment with what’s going on. Kotoko is really the star of the show, a cute “slightly older than she looks” girl with worldly knowledge from her spirit background. Her time is often spent explaining various different points, so investment can waver on her, but the comedy bits featuring her are welcome. They take advantage of some light little jokes and the animation can give her some adorably different facial expressions, and that dorky innocuousness is shown well through both her seiyuu and her English voice with newcomer Lizzie Freeman. Kuro appears as though he could be the standard boring “self-insert” protagonist but he isn’t around in prominent enough to really hurt the show for it. It takes a rare approach; an approach I haven’t seen since Kaze no Stigma, where that type of character appears as relevant but with seemingly his own motives and origins in mind. His OPness isn’t used to doubt the power of those around him, but more to effectively gauge the strength the imaginary ghost gets from belief. There’s that same issue of detachment you could view in a lot of the series, but his status doesn’t hurt the series like other MCs he could be related to since it isn’t forcing you to like him.
There’s also Saki Yumihara, who works acceptably well as a straight girl to bounce off both of them, respectfully passing the Bechdel test extremely often when she tries to help Kotoko with a point or attempt to validate her: actual chemistry. Again, nothing special but the anime doesn’t necessarily do wrong with her either. Lastly there’s Karin Nanase, the source of the debate and origin of the ghost driving the conflict. Some might call her busty and striper-like appearance lazy fanservice, but it actually works pretty well for the conceptual plot. Her alluring appearance better helps draw attention to the rumors that create her in the first place and exploits the public perception on sexuality versus identity that clouds a lot of the debating.
The worst character in this show is the Internet itself. Really, it’s an uphill battle when trying to portray the Internet in any way without being laughed out. Although there proves a human force to subvert the idea of a strawman (someone who exists specifically to make points proven wrong) by actually being correct, to counteract the wrongness Kotoko is trying to present, any additional nods to the internet are purely to create strawmen for the show’s chat forum debating. Perhaps one could argue that the Internet not ever agreeing on any particular point is a major reason why the conflict has to drag for over 3 hours, but it’s still a slippery slope I don’t think the show ever quite manages.
As for the presentation, it’s acceptable if bland. The show features a lot of washed out beiges and blues for the aesthetic, with the occasional purple focus when Nanase’s spirit appears and a brief showing of a comment web space which looks worse than Ghost in the Shell SAC nearly two decades earlier. But to be fair, it’s not an action show, so lack of visual polish isn’t as insulting as other series. There’s some fun faces for the brief bits of comedy featured but otherwise it doesn’t speak for much visually. Same for the audio, although the ED is actually pretty fun despite the lack of animation.
It’s truly rare you get an anime series nowadays where the storyline is actually the BEST part of an anime, but here we are. With the unremarkable audiovisuals and simple characters that grow into decency mainly through dialogue interactions, the plot is what will really carry the anime and make or break it. It’ll inevitably captivate some with the thorough exploration and turn off others for how uncompromising it is. For my part, even with a certain suspension of disbelief regarding the show’s portrayal of the internet that never REALLY agrees on anything, it was still decent entertainment that benefited from its lower stakes setting, unique premise and earnest character take. But where do you really take things from here? Would the next season also be about mysteries like this, or would it veer in a more action or comedy focused direction? What supernatural elements would factor into anything further? Would it even try to feel emotional? The odd genre mix of In/Spectre made for a decent watch that stood out among the crowd, but not one that’ll last beyond interest of its unique story premise.
Alternative Titles
Japanese: 虚構推理
More titlesInformation
Type:
TV
Episodes:
12
Status:
Finished Airing
Aired:
Jan 12, 2020 to Mar 29, 2020
Premiered:
Winter 2020
Broadcast:
Sundays at 01:30 (JST)
Producers:
Nihon Ad Systems, Kodansha, KlockWorx, Docomo Anime Store, King Records, Crunchyroll, GYAO!, BS NTV, Marui Group
Licensors:
VIZ Media
Studios:
Brain's Base
Source:
Manga
Demographic:
Shounen
Duration:
24 min. per ep.
Rating:
R - 17+ (violence & profanity)
Statistics
Ranked:
#47852
2
based on the top anime page. Please note that 'Not yet aired' and 'R18+' titles are excluded.
Popularity:
#475
Members:
475,945
Favorites:
1,371
Available AtResourcesStreaming Platforms | Reviews
Filtered Results: 34 / 120
Sort
Your Feelings Categories Mar 28, 2020
In/Spectre is the type of series that tests the notion “how far are you willing to stretch a good idea?”
Conceptually, this is a brilliant idea for a story and overall, I think the execution is at least good. While so many mystery stories, anime or otherwise, tend to focus on purely the truth, characters getting to the bottom of how events actually happened, never have I seen creating a convincing LIE to factor into that. A lot of ins and outs are explored in the show’s attempt to qualify this point, so it keeps a unique source of engagement in a way unlike many ... Feb 25, 2020
I'll start by saying I had high expectations for this show, and am an anime only viewer. I speak nothing of the Manga here, It is probably paced differently there, as it is a different medium entirely.
Unfortunately, I have to say watching this show is like reading a really wordy book where you already know what the characters are thinking. It starts with a really strong first episode, and the background for the main characters was very interesting, but everything else in this show moves at a snail's pace. Every option must be explored and explained. This show regularly wastes half of an episode talking ... Mar 28, 2020
Japanese youkai lore has been a fascinating subject in the realm of anime, manga, and video games. Every year, we are graced by media related to these supernatural entities, based on the Shinto religion. And while Kyokou Suiri (ln/Spectre) certainly isn’t among the first to explore such themes, it does embark on a supernatural quest with a lovely little oddball named Kotoko Iwanaga.
Let’s allow reality to hit us first. Kyokou Suiri has a fair amount of volumes but the anime allows the show to be only 12-episodes. To make things more complicated, the early chapters (manga version at least) are fairly long, some expanding well ... Mar 3, 2020
I went into Kyokou Suiri (In/Spectre) excited and came out bored. In/Spectre isn't a bad anime. I love the art style, the character designs and concepts, the romance, the soundtrack and lastly the voice work. The problem lies entirely with supernatural "mystery" element. And I use mystery loosely. A good mystery tries to get the audience actively engaged in trying to solve the crime (e.g. Poirot) and a bad one makes the audience passive by having some Deus Ex Machina solution (e.g. CSI, Bones). Kyokou Suiri does neither. Instead its like having someone explain to you a Mystery novel they recently read. This is
...
Apr 25, 2020
Rating (My opinion) 6.5/7*
A lot of Talking, TALKING, TALKING, NONSENSE, TALKING, TALKING AND MORE TALKING. If you are the type of person that enjoy mystery and a lot of dialog instead of action, then this anime is for you. Kyokou Suiri is an anime that is mostly focused in a mystery plot that doesn't make sense, I tried liking the show at first, I really did, but by the time I got to Episode 7, I was wishing for the show to end, it was boring, I couldn't stand it. I don't know how it got to the point of the whole 'Last Boss' but ... Mar 9, 2020
This anime has more water than the Pacific Ocean.
First episode tricked me with Bakemonogatari style's dialogues and youkais and I believed that it would be similar to Bakemonogatari. Haha, it is more similar to my diploma. In russian title is 'False Conclusions' and its really true. Firstly I thought we will get some stories which include a murder and yokai, but, we got like 1 introduction story about turtle, and then infinitive Steel Nanance arc. Protagonists saying same thoughts in different words for 4 series in a row. And even 'action' in 9th episode is just saying boring things. Iwanaga and Kuro are cool ... Feb 27, 2020
This is getting very high scores so i thought i'd take the time to toss my opinion out there.
This is a fast paced show that assumes you are an idiot. Well, maybe not...but boy does it beat a point to death! It isn't terrible...and the beginning had me there for a good few episodes...you will find yourself feeling "ohh, wait so thats where we are go---oop. nope we aren't okay"......or those super cringe moments where you suck on your teeth and hope the scene fades. I guess I just couldn't believe the characters. I understand this show doesn't need to be realistic....i actually am ... Mar 17, 2023
In/Spectre as a concept could not be more fitting in what's been called the "post-truth" era we find ourselves in. At the crux of the drama behind In/Spectre is essentially a PR/political campaign. Iwanaga utilizes elements of social-psychology to spin narratives that find their grounds in the believable but often not real. It's as much a picture of how PR & political campaigns work as it is a grim look at the state of public discourse in a world full of actors wielding narratives. In the above regard, In/Spectre explores substance that has yet to be dealt with in the anime medium. But while the
...
May 12, 2020
I started to follow at the time of its release, at first the anime has a very good premise and seems to have a lot of potential, but with the passing of the episodes it is clear that the quality will drop with time. The story is lukewarm, decent art, a little weak soundtrack and only the main characters deliver anything.
Overall it is an anime below average to pass the time, it had everything to work out, but unfortunately they delivered another ordinary anime, lackluster, with massive dialogues, not that this is a problem, I love a good storyline, but we are not talking about ... Mar 29, 2020
I'll start by saying that I reasonably enjoyed this anime. What I'll write next might make it seem like it's not worth your while, but that's not necessarily true. It's a show that will have a particular audience and if that's you, great.
The first few episodes did the job of grabbing my attention with interesting characters and dynamics. For the rest of the series, I felt switched and baited. I might have enjoyed it more if I had not expected something different from the first few episodes. This show is about a girl who uses logical (if far fetched) arguments to ... May 12, 2020
So, Koykou Suiri is very bad, but you can pass the time.
The female protagonist is so cool and even then there was no better use of her. The first episode is incredible, I seriously thought it was going to be a good anime based on it, but as we can see, the episodes that have passed have shown how they can end up with a good plot in minutes. The male protagonist does not speak or show so much charisma, shallow and meaningless secondary characters. Worst of all is spending 4 episodes listening to the girl talk about hypotheses that don't make any sense, so, as ... Mar 28, 2020
You ever feel conflicted while rating a series because even though you enjoyed watching it, you know it's badly written and has many flaws?
I wasn't conflicted while rating Kyokou Suiri, just wanted you to understand why I'm going to rip it apart despite giving it a decent rating. There are 3 characters worth talking about in this show, Kotoko (the female protagonist), Kurou (the guy Kotoko has a crush on), and Saki (Kurou's ex-girlfriend). The story is about Kotoko and Kurou solving paranormal mystery cases, or at least that's what it's supposed to be. Stories like this usually go one of two ways, either get into a story ... Mar 29, 2020
This anime rides HARD on the back of Bunny Girl Senpai, which already was riding hard on the back of Bakemonogatari. The first few episodes are enjoyable because of this, but for some reason despite being obviously inspired by these two dialogue heavy supernatural series, it chose to continue one entire story arc for all 12 episodes.
Part of the reason the dialogue heavy Bakemonogatari is tolerable is because each story only lasts 3-5 episodes, and they eventually intertwine here and there. The same goes for Bunny Girl Senpai. I was alright with Bunny Girl copying a bit from Bakemonogatari because it was at least still ... May 24, 2020
Why do you have to complicate things. The story would have been good if not great if unnecessary things were not included. And if you had to do so, it should have made connections in the story. The first episode was good and the expectations were set based on it. The whole steel whatever would have been fine too unless there weren’t plot holes. Nothing connected. So many options and the author couldn’t settle on one thing. Make up your mind. I was in a good mood, now I’m just taking out my frustration. See this is exactly what should not have happened. If it
...
Mar 11, 2020
I came for Kuro the sociopath and action, and got an annoying Loli. This show is a wannabe professor Layton, wannabe Sakura card captor, but doesn't provide an interesting narrative for the investigations nor cute & fun action.
The characters spend SO MUCH time talking just to say nothing, with the exact same tone. It's incredibly boring. But the art is pretty good, and the characters (when they aren't just talking and talking) are really cute and interesting. I just seriously wish there'd be less pointless talks repeating the same things and basically praising themselves for the supposed complexity of their thinking (especially since it's ... Mar 17, 2020
I tried to hold on with this one hoping it would get better, but the story is just a bit all over the place, with characters that are mysterious, yet boring and I don't feel any particular attachment to them, in fact I could say that I don't particularly like some of them.
I feel like this had potential to be good but just lacked any kind of depth and tried to keep stringing along it's audience with 'mystery' but it's just the same character elements over and over.. Might pick this up again after some time off it.. but it was just too much of ... Mar 16, 2020
This show is probably the least interesting out of the "person solves problems involving spirits" shows I've seen. Unlike similar shows like Natsume or Monogatari or Mushihshi, or even Hanako from this same season, this show seemingly has no flare of its own. The show is mainly talking, which would be good if the series had interesting art, characters, or direction to make all the long winded talking bearable.
Like in monogatari mentioned above. The entire show is 80% dialogue, but the series is still interesting because each character is unique in the ways the interact with the main protagonist, and there's interesting art and scene ... Apr 12, 2020
6 - I liked it. Didn't regret watching, but probably wouldn't watch a 2nd time if nostalgia bias didn't exist. Probably had a good message, was a guilty pleasure, or the story was solid.
This anime has the real potential to being a long running anime. All it really needs is a cute spirit mascot to sell merch. This is legit. However, it's only 12 episodes with possibly no anime sequel. Not that it's bad that it is only 12 episodes. But it does have the ability to become a 50+ episode long anime if the OP/ED was better, and there was a cute mascot to ... May 24, 2020
Let me just say, this show lost some points to me once I watched the 1st episode when it came out and decided to wait to binge it all. When you wait to binge something, it either means you don't have time on your hands, or you would rather watch a bad show in one setting than drag it out for weeks. I am both. But, enough jibberjab and lets get down to a simple review.
Story: 5/10 The story just did not feel...great. As others have said, the pacing is off. The first episode is devoted to meeting the 2 people on the cover of the ... Apr 7, 2020
I start by saying that I overall enjoyed this anime. However, there are some annoying things about it.
At first I only watched it because my all time fav VA was casted and I enjoyed the first episodes a great amount.. But, for me at least, it kinda went downhill from there. Although people say that the first 3-4 episodes are not canon so they make no sense, I quite enjoyed the story with the snake more than the next one which took about 75% of the anime, when it could have been condensed in less episodes. It is a mystery anime, but not the average ... |