Oh boy, Fate/Extra: Last Encore. I should say, right off the bat, that while I am a fan of the Fate universe, I am not a fan of some of their more recent adaptations. (I’m looking at you, Fate/Apocrypha) As a series that’s over the top like Fate/Extra Last Encore, it felt like a chance for me to take a wild ride, turn my brains off, and try to enjoy this for what it is. How did I feel at the end? Well, let’s just say that I want my time back if I had a holy grail.
When Shaft was announced as the studio for
...
production, I immediately raised an eyebrow and found myself wondering if this could ever work. As an anime adaptation of Fate/Extra, this became a plot that’s modified for the sake of anime storytelling. It sells its story similar to some of the other Fate franchise’s series if you’re familiar with the franchise. Jumping into this show was not easy for me despite my familiarity with the Fate universe.
So I decided to give this a shot anyway. Why not? It has an alluring premise and takes place in an alternate timeline to Fate/stay night. In this timeline, mana have disappeared and Wizards are forced to use virtual space for magic. Similar to some of the other Fate series, a Holy Grail War is set up by a computer that pits 128 Masters in a tournament. The winner will be chosen with a wish to be granted by the Moon Cell Automaton, a mysterious computer of unimaginative powers. Main male protagonist Makuno Kishinami gets caught up into this battle for survival and is clueless on why he is involved. Luckily for him, he gets a servant called Saber. (do note for the sake of avoiding spoilers, I’ll just refer her as “Red Saber” from now on)
Yes, this formula is definitely not something new despite some differences with the world setting and premise. What bugs me though is how the main plot is executed with Hakuno and Red Saber as the main characters. Don’t me wrong. They are highly entertaining to watch at first but after a while, you may wonder if it’s worth investing time into them at all. In particular, Hakuno is a very oddball character and seems to be only motivated to survive and avenge the deaths of others. In a way, the guy can be viewed as an anti-hero. My impression of Hakuno gradually faded more and more after seeing his development. In essence, he doesn’t develop much at all and his personality feels all over the place. It doesn’t help that Red Saber is incredibly one dimensional and behaves like a child. While she can be addictively cute to watch at times, Red Saber is hardly a character I would declare as well-written. We don’t know much about her and it’s hard to judge what her motivations are in the story. So yeah, watch this for the mindless character chemistry but if you’re watching for concrete characterization, look elsewhere.
If you’re hoping some of your favorite Fate character to show up in this series, then prepare for disappointment. Only a small handful of characters like Rin, Sakura, and Shinji appear and most of their roles are downplayed to get over the main cast. Some of the characters from Fate/Grand Order game also shows up although their roles are so small that you’ll likely forget them incredibly easily. Most of the minor characters have their roles minimized and episodes’ resolutions feel rushed. Oh and Shinji….what a bastard. I wish the series deleted him and never gave him a chance to show up for his abominable personality. But the series’ main story is not abominable. It’s actually much worse. For the majority of viewers, you’ll probably scratch your head on what the hell is going on. I know I did and feel like the series tries to do way too many things at once. Now, I know Shaft is known for their style to present this anime like a theatric thriller with avant garde cinematography. But wow, this show easily fell apart in the beginning and didn’t manage to salvage itself at all. With just 10 episodes, it became more of mindless popcorn entertainment than a creative story to tell.
I mentioned Shaft few times already but I’ll do it again. The studio’s ideas can easily be recognized by their artistic choreography and avant garde artwork. Running gags with violence and head tilts are also pretty easy to spot. The biggest culprit here is Hakuno as he gets his limbs tore apart, body impaled, and put into a position where he can easily die. Somehow, he survives and we see his reaction in a dark grimy way. I think Shaft wanted us to experience what they do best at and honestly, I think they went a bit overboard this time. The shock value in this anime feels impactful but serves little purpose besides amplifying Hakuno’s personality up to the 11. Oh and the fan service. It seems this show wants to milk Red Saber as an eye candy ever chance it gets. The camera always flirts with her by showing lewd body parts, poses, and try to make her as sexy as possible. Bath scenes occur several times in the show and Red Saber never seems to be uncomfortable being nude. It’s pretty shameless and easily distracting to the point where viewers may talk more about the fan service than the story. On the other hand, I think the battle cinematics is nicely made. It’s fast paced and captures an alluring style of fighting. While glorifying servants’ abilities to fight, it also doesn’t make us forget how badass Hakuno can be. Finally, I have to point out that both the OP and ED theme songs are quite attractive once you get used to the style. The charismatic movements of Red Saber is exceptional there.
After watching Fate/Extra Last Encore, I have to wonder what the hell the producers were thinking. Were they trying to make a show to get us viewers into liking the characters and story? Or was this another attempt for cash grab so fans can pour their money into their franchise. Either way, this show ended up being a disappointment for me. I can’t recall how many times I scratched my head. Oh and Red Saber's voice...she sounds like a kid stuck in an adult’s body with that infamous UMU. What a shame for a show that could have been something so much more.
Alternative Titles
Japanese: Fate/EXTRA Last Encore
More titlesInformation
Type:
TV
Episodes:
10
Status:
Finished Airing
Aired:
Jan 28, 2018 to Apr 1, 2018
Premiered:
Winter 2018
Broadcast:
Sundays at 00:00 (JST)
Licensors:
None found, add some
Studios:
Shaft
Source:
Game
Duration:
24 min. per ep.
Rating:
R - 17+ (violence & profanity)
Statistics
Ranked:
#84172
2
based on the top anime page. Please note that 'Not yet aired' and 'R18+' titles are excluded.
Popularity:
#1090
Members:
222,005
Favorites:
479
Available AtResourcesStreaming Platforms | Reviews
Filtered Results: 67 / 70
Sort
Your Feelings Categories Mar 31, 2018
Oh boy, Fate/Extra: Last Encore. I should say, right off the bat, that while I am a fan of the Fate universe, I am not a fan of some of their more recent adaptations. (I’m looking at you, Fate/Apocrypha) As a series that’s over the top like Fate/Extra Last Encore, it felt like a chance for me to take a wild ride, turn my brains off, and try to enjoy this for what it is. How did I feel at the end? Well, let’s just say that I want my time back if I had a holy grail.
When Shaft was announced as the studio for ... Mar 31, 2018
When it comes to what makes the Fate franchise what it is, some will might say it's the very well-made fight scenes while others will say it's the dark psychological tone that it has. While all of that is definitely true, what really makes the Fate franchise what it is; it's the interesting philosophical dialogues between the characters and that is really, what Fate/Extra Last Encore succeeded at most.
Fate/Extra Last Encore is a studio Shaft's adaption from a game and it serves as an alternative setting to Fate/Stay Night's. The concept of the story is pretty much the same as you can imagine, there are ... Apr 1, 2018
Fate/Extra is yet another installation in the popular Fate franchise. Being a fan of the series, I went into this anime with some expectations, especially considering the fact that Studio Shaft, the one who took on this project, is one of my favorite anime studios. Now I've never played the source material, so I came into this anime with no knowledge on what it would cover. Unfortunately, by the end of it, I still wasn't entirely certain on what it was about.
The biggest issue that I had with this anime was it's convoluted story. Now while I feel that Fate/Extra is somewhat underrated, I have ... Apr 1, 2018
“I am not a fake, I will forge my own identity”
There is a saying that goes between the Ufotable Fate series purists, that “Any Fate not made by Ufotable is shit” and that statement was usually right from what I've seen, Fate Loli was as mentioned all about Lolis, Fate Apocrypha was a laughable joke to most and then we have this anime, Fate Extra Last Encore that was made this time by Shaft. The Fate series is popular enough to be adopted by almost every studio and this brings either positive or negative results, and fortunately unlike other non-Ufotable Fate anime series, Fate ... Apr 2, 2018
Born directly from the father of Type Moon, Kinoko Nasu himself, Fate/Extra: Last Encore is a fascinating title in the franchise of Fate, and the Type Moon universe at large. Despite Nasu’s attempts to inform everyone about the intentions behind this anime and how everyone would be at an even playing field here, mass confusion broke out. It is only loosely based on the game, and due to the unique circumstances of the show’s narrative, it has been deemed unfit as a start. Perhaps this explains the disgustingly poor reception of this wonderful show.
Such a shame, since this anime is a sheer, flooring spectacle. It ... Apr 2, 2018
When I heard there was a Fate anime in 2018 done by SHAFT, one of the best studios out there, I was hyped with its weird pairing.
Now it's over and I'm here to give my thoughts. Story (2/10) The Fate series has always been slightly confusing at first but at the end, you'll understand everything and have fun. And it's always related to 7 classes of servants with masters fighting to win the Holy Grail. ... Oct 12, 2019
If you like Madoka, you like the style of the Monogatari series and you're at least familiar with the Fate/Stay story, then you'll probably like this.
The pace is good, the art and music are good and it's got a reasonably good, epic story. Perfect for non-sober viewing, I expect to rewatch it at least a few times. There are scenes that the show could benefit from having cut out though. As with Madoka, a condensed version would be great. --- MAL insists that reviews are long and drawn out for some reason, so I've had to add this just so it'll let me submit mine. Mar 12, 2018
UMU!
After episode 7 I felt the need to write a review about it. But First let me address something that I see happening a lot the Fate/Extra LE anime is not newbie-friendly so if you were not into fate.. like ate least have watched all the animes and plays Fate GO then you will prolly not understand much of it.. its the same as Buying FATE EXTELLA on steam without having played Fate Extra CCC on a PSP.. because stella is a direct sequel to CCC and so on... in case of fate extra le if you play FGO you are already familiar with the servants, ... Mar 12, 2018
While writing a review on a show that is more of a mystery more than anything is a bit foolish before the series has finished having seen seven episodes what I have seen is promising. The main problem most people have coming into this is that they are expecting a different kind of show, believing it to be primarily about action and what a "normal Grail War" is about. However Nasu's stories have always been at their best when they are about something else. There is always a element of mystery present in his works. From the question of the situation of the Tohno family,
...
Apr 2, 2018
What i want to say first is: DON'T LOOK THE SCORE ON MAL AND WATCH THIS MASTERPIECE!!!!!
Ohh man,i want to say that i didn't play the games (Fate/extra,Fate/Extra CCC) but i loved the show and i think shaft did more than ufotable would be able to do, i like the way that shaft play with your mind and after you watch a episode you are like "what the fuck?" and after a episode "owww that was, how could i be that stupid to don't think about that", if you want to understand the show you need to be careful on dialog and what happing on ... Apr 12, 2018
When first hearing Fate/Extra would be adapted into an Anime, I was excited for one of my favourite PSP games to finally have an anime form, right on Apocrypha finishing it’s spotty airing.
...right up until SHAFT reared its ugly head. Right from the start, you can tell this is a show made by SHAFT just by colours and composition alone, it almost feels as disjointed as a Wes Andersen movie without the humour as every introductory shot insists on bombarding the viewer with artsy stills and not getting to the point of the story. Failing that, SHAFT at least set up the story in the Moon ... Apr 17, 2018
I really enjoy Shaft animation, the Monogatari series in particular being my favorite anime series
I really enjoy the Fate series, having seen most of the main animated material and Zero being one of the first anime I ever watched. So why don’t I like Fate/Extra: Last Encore, a Fate installment animated by Shaft? In all fairness, many of the elements that make up smaller portions of the story work or present themselves perfectly adequately. Shaft animation might often appear in a trademark stylized way, but since the animation was fluid and reasonably detailed it certainly gains a pass. Some of the scenery shots and images from the ... Apr 2, 2018
The Fate franchise being one of my favorites;Fate Extra LE was an anime I was excited to see ,but I should have learned my lesson from getting hype for Apocrypha in 2017 and not jump on the hypetrain. I felt like my reasons were justified for LE though as it was being animated by Shaft, one of my favorite studios and also had Nasu himself writing the script. Before I get into my reasons for not liking Extra LE, I will say that I never played the game Fate Extra or CCC, I`ve only played Extella so my understanding of the anime is not as
...
Jan 1, 2022
So I an not the kind of person that writes reviews but I just have to do my best to correct the mistake that is happening here.
The rating that I see on this anime is simply wrong and I don't want it to make people avoid this anime like I did. All I see about this anime is great. The story and plot twists are actually some of the best fate has to offer and the characters are not half bad. Shaft did an amazing job as they usually do but I think that this is the reason why people are salty with this anime. It really ... Mar 13, 2018
And here we go again. Another Fate adaptation. Was I hyped? Of course, it’s Fate. If not for the story, Fate is at the very least worth watching for its amazing fight scenes. That’s what I thought till now. And then Shaft’s adaptation of Last Encore came out…
Story: 5/10 This is not your regular Fate story. In this world magic is more of a technological/scientific - phenomenon. Usually not really my cup of tea, but it has a potential to be an amazing and enjoyable story if done right. The 1st episode was confusing to say the least, but I was willing to give it the ... Mar 14, 2018
This is probably the first review i've ever made. Lemme start by saying this: I'm disappointed.
I was very much looking forward to this anime. The game has a cool story, but the actual gameplay is awful so i'd rather not play it if I could. So what better way to enjoy the story than through a beautiful anime, right? Wrong. This anime took what I knew of the story of Fate/Extra, and tossed it in a blender with some Shaft-ness and fanservice and let it go. Story: Almost no clue what's going on most of the time. They jump between backgrounds and settings, drop ... Jun 17, 2019
the story was a bit hard to follow and there wasn't the same action as other entrees in the series but it had a very cute and attractive art style that I was left wanting more of. Fate/Extra: Last Encore to most wouldn't feel the same as the rest of the series and it shouldn't and personally It was a breathe of fresh air with a very loveable characters with far better and more in depth backstories, and not to mention the most adorable Saber we have seen so far in my opinion.
I have seen all of the entrees to the Fate series so ... Mar 11, 2018
It is somewhat troubling that a review has to begin like this, but let me adress the elephant in the room: This is not Fat/Extra, this is Fate/Monogatari.
Many viewers seem to be turned off not only by the rather strange setting for a Fate series that we've been given in the first 2-3 episodes, but especially by how little this feels like it is Fate, if one were to compare it to the popular anime adaptations by UFOtable that is. As a fan of the franchise myself, I initially found it difficult to get into Shaft´s Extra, mainly because of how different the setting was from ... Feb 24, 2018
If an anime gets you to think, really cares about the character and ask questions, this is the one. There are so many questions in the show, why the earth is corrupted; why the holy grail system is built; instead of getting burnt, why dead body sort of like...disappeared in the incinerator; who is the glasses nerd; why is Rin disappeared... After a few episodes, I am sure if you really pay attention to every detail in the show, you will have so many questions and you really want to watch the next one. And maybe you will ask yourself this: if you not sure
...
May 18, 2018
The animation was okay at best, the plot was all over the place, scenes were shown out of order, the ending; while not as bad as Arcana Famigilia or Soul Eater, is a let down because while it doesn't piss you off the show just... ends. So why did I like it? Because it had Nero and Nero had umu. So I don't rate this a 7/10 I rate it am umu/10
Break it down a tad more: Story - all over the place Art - its no Ufotable but it does its job. Action is mediocre Sound - I mean it works... Character - MC is an edgelord, Nero ... |