Report TapuChip's Profile

Whatever. I'll ask real questions then. You keep harping on and on and on about "layered characters" "decade-long." As if it wasn't rushed to shit. Any normal human can understand that that story ended terribly. Edgerunners absolutely destroys AOT in that regard. Three things have to be nailed down in order for a piece of entertainment to be considered good; the beginning, middle, and the end. I won't lie. I used to be an AOT fanboy just like you until I reached that ending. To say that his ending was controversial is putting it lightly; for good reasons too. It means the average person can see that he just didn't know how to end the story. This is endemic to nearly all pieces of entertainment, unfortunately. There were only a few negative reviews I could understand, but yours was not one of them. No, Death Note and Evangelion are not classics just because you consider them so lmao. I want to hear it from someone like you who treasures a manga that ended everything so terribly. What exactly were "superficial arcs" and "predictable tropes?" How are "predictable tropes" bad? Your favorite anime did all of that (Evangelion, Death Note). You couldn't write any of that down. All you relied on in your review were other people feeling the same way that you did with words like "superficial", "tropes", etc, etc. Their critique of the anime probably isn't even yours. How did the narrative lack depth? What do you need from a story to make the viewer invested into a narrative? How was it rushed? Even if a story were predictable, does that make it bad? Exactly what did you need from Edgerunners to feel all that? I didn't understand any of that from your review. With the tale that it wanted to tell, I think they did more than enough to nail their message. There is a multitude of things that any piece of medium needs in order to make liked. Environment, believable characters, understandable decisions, music (for auditory mediums), dialogue, "feelings," and more were all there. If the only favorite anime you had in your favorites was Ginga Eiyuu Densestu, then I would probably understand, but you having AOT and Death Note forced me to comment on your profile. I put in a lot of time into writing those insults

That ending didn't HAVE SHIT for all that "muh worldbuilding". BRUH. ISAYAMA FUCKED IT TO THE GROUND. Don't even get me started with that extra chapter and that tree. Look, you can ride, get up, clean it, suck it, and go back to riding on AOT, but that is absolute TRASH. You like EVANGELION? DEATH NOTE? All those endings were shit! Death note messed it ALL up after L's death. Evangelion is for sweaty nerds. The last person in this universe who should ever comment on "anime critique" is some guy who cites "CARDBOARD TROPES" as a case against Edgerunners. Look man, all that shit anime isn't going to clean that Palestinian blood from your palate. Do yourself a favor, and get that shit anime out of favorites. I'm almost getting an aneurysm just from looking at that. I sincerely hope you take my advice into consideration.

Damn. Israeli and shit taste? Four terrible anime lineup in your favorites. You criticize Edgerunners for that ending, but you have AOT? Bruh

Nice cyberpunk edgerunners review

ty 4 fr!!!

ive heard great things about it, will definitely watch it probably after aot ends cause ive heard aot is kinda inspired by nge oh and i would personally recommend watching hellsing ultimate since you havent seen it its amazing

thanks for the fr , you got great favorites too

Thank you!!

Replied for you on the post.

Let's just talk in one place (there) about it

Thank you anyway 🙂

Wil do

Hello friend, sorry for not responding so long.
I didn`t saw this anime yet. but i see you done a good job for review, so i give you a "Nice"

I just read the review after finishing Edgerunners, and I agree. The show really went down about halfway through. David was interesting at the beginning but became bland. Second half of it was just random action scenes. I liked the beginning much more, it was really grounded.

Anytime man!

hey bro, i haven't watched the show yet, but it is a well written review. I think you did a good job stating your case and backing it up!

Welcome to Critics and Connoisseurs. We don't currently have a FAQ as the club went through changes, if something is unclear feel free to ask me. We encourage all our members to be active in our You Decides and Spotlight Forums. Here is a link to our Old Spotlights to help you familiarize yourself with titles that have been nominated in the past. Also don't forget to turn on club notifications to get notified about the major club activities. Again Welcome!