Critics and Connoisseurs

Club Description:

First and foremost, I would like to make it clear that this is not an elitist club. Our goal is to come up a list of highly recommended quality shows that are exemplary either within genre or universally. However, everyone has different standards when it comes to this, so I have made up a short list of basic requirements with the goal of ensuring maximum participation from our members.

Entry Requirements:

Club Goals:

Activity Policy

Club Admins
Member Approval: Lightfellow
Activity Tracking: ShadowGentleman
Nomination Counting: Zaitengrate
Spotlight/You Decide Creation: Lightfellow
Vote Counting: Lightfellow
Old Spotlights Maintenance: Dr. Tokami
Resurrection Calendar Maintenance: Lightfellow
Review Team Management: Lindle
Events: Lindle

To express interest in an admin role in this club, please PM any active admin in this club with the role you are interested in and it will be put forward for discussion amongst the admins.

We are changing the way our voting works in You Decides. Votes are now being counted automatically so you need to type exactly as it is shown for the system to count your vote. Type #Yes if you want a title to be inducted, type #No if you don't want to see a title inducted, type #IDK if you are not familiar with the title, and type #Abstained if you don't want to vote. Hashtags are mandatory. Bear in mind, though, that your lists will still be checked manually. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation.

THIS Week's You Decides:
OPEN - Noein: Mou Hitori no Kimi e (Anime) (24/6)
OPEN - JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 1: Phantom Blood (Manga) (44/15)

OPEN - Subarashii Sekai (Manga) (19/10)

For Challenge:
OPEN - Legend of the Galactic Heroes (Anime) (110/22)

THIS Week's Spotlights:
Roujin Z (Anime) (1/1)
Gintama (Manga) (624/125)

Ga-Rei: Zero (Anime) (12/4)

For Challenge:

NEXT Week's Spotlights:
Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt (Anime) (4/2)
Imawa no Kuni no Alice (Manga) (87/22)

Jiraishin (Manga) (72/18)

For Challenge:

Double Advance Spotlight Notice:
In order to give everyone more time to get fully acquainted with these entries, we'd like you to take note in advance of the fact that both [...] (...) and [...] (...) will be spotlighted for the week starting on Saturday the 17th of December 2016.

Please note: each anime and manga entry is followed by a number denoting the total amount of episodes or chapters and the amount you must have watched/read in order for your vote to be legitimate.

Nomination Lists:
Nominate an Anime
Nominate a Manga
Resurrect an Anime
Challenge Nominations (CLOSED)

Resurrection Calendar

Old Spotlights:
Click For List

If you have any questions, comments, suggestions:
Open Discussion Thread
Ideas for Club Improvements

Feel Like Joining a Review Team?
Review Team Signup Thread
Editors and Proof-Readers Signup Thread

Need a Recommendation?
Anime Recommendations
Manga Recommendations

Want to just chat with fellow members?
Open Discussion Thread
You Decide - Afterthoughts
Your Favorite Scenes

Server: Critics and Connoisseurs


-------=====Club FAQ=====-------

If you are mistakenly kicked due to inactivity, please contact one of the admins and we will get it straightened out. We do make mistakes. Thank you for your patience in the meantime.

Club Members

Club Pictures

Displaying 5 of 3141 topics | See All
Club Discussion
Sticky: **Review Team Signup Thread**
Don_Don_Kun - Jun 29, 2013
16 replies by TeaKitteh »»
2 hours ago
Sticky: You Decide: Noein: Mou Hitori no Kimi e (Anime)
Lightfellow - Feb 26
38 replies by MojosGreed »»
3 hours ago
Sticky: You Decide: JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 1: Phantom Blood (Manga)
Lightfellow - Feb 26
32 replies by MojosGreed »»
3 hours ago
Sticky: Ressurected You Decide: Subarashii Sekai (Manga)
Lightfellow - Feb 26
27 replies by MojosGreed »»
3 hours ago
Sticky: Challenge You Decide: Legend of the Galactic Heroes (Anime)
Lightfellow - Feb 26
36 replies by MojosGreed »»
3 hours ago

Club Comments
CodeBlazeFate | 3 hours ago
Oh, well that clears things up, I guess. Thanks.

Scarlett_ryuken | 3 hours ago
and you saw my actual writing skills and it sucked, ;-; feelsbad for being so cocky with it

Lindle | 3 hours ago
@CodeBlazeFate: Your rejection was actually based on your reviews. Scarlett would have been but they said that the tone of their reviews didn't indicate their actual writing skill, so they posted a sample in there.

It's pretty clear from your reviews that you do actually take them seriously, which is why we didn't even bother going to that stage.

CodeBlazeFate | 3 hours ago
You are as far as I can tell. You weren't directly told that you were banned from trying. They just rejected the product of your attempt, meaning that you can come back and try again. lucky fu- Cheer up and keep da reviews comin'. I'll do the same (probably with Thunderbolt as my next target until the flurry of seasonal reviews I'll be doing).

Scarlett_ryuken | 3 hours ago
i dont even know if im allowed a chance lol, im just shameless enough to ask for a 2nd chance

CodeBlazeFate | 3 hours ago
Also, it was Lindle who brought it up. Too bad I know nothing about Jojo aside from the memes and the amount of current parts there are.

CodeBlazeFate | 3 hours ago
lucky bastard, at least you're allowed a chance, unlike meK then. Go ahead. With some of the shit (and non-shit) this season, we both have a lot of opportunities to do so.

Scarlett_ryuken | 3 hours ago
i will now also take this break to improve my writing skill and then ask to help in the reviews

Club Stats
Members: 142
Pictures: 6
Category: Schools
Created: Mar 7, 2008

Club Officers
8GaugeBrett (Creator)
DerMond (Admin)
Dr_Tokami (Admin)
ladyxzeus (Admin)
Lightfellow (Admin)
Lindle (Admin)
Lordwen (Admin)
Zaitengrate (Admin)

Club Type
This is a private club. Members must request access and be approved by an Officer before joining.

Anime Relations

Manga Relations