DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Berserk is Berserk. Nothing new content wise from 1997 I don't really remember if the 3D parts were in the movie, is kinda bad still, but a little better than the after Eclipse anime. Berserk anime need to stop thinking on the Golden Age and move on. |
 |
| 7 silver coins and the blood sprouts! kekeke I liked the characters style animation!! |
| The 3d isn't that bad, but the fps is terrible. If Studio 4C fix the fps in the cgi and kept mixing with the 2d scenes which are pretty as hell, I would be more than satisfied. StaleNut said: I think the countdown may be for the eclipse. I wouldn't be too hopeful for new content tbh. They didn't even try polishing the animation in the first episode. Let a man dream and be disappointed again, my friend. |
| Well I always avoided the 3D Berserk so I did the same for the movie trilogy since I saw this arc in the 1997 version obviously but I decided to give it a try since they're doing it in TV version, I can't say I'm really used to this 3D animation but still nice to re-discover the beginning and especially the legendary fight between Guts and Griffith |
 |
| berserk Manga is 10/10 berserk 1997 is 10/10 but this is 7/10 |
 [jmg align=right]https://i.imgur.com/XLRDPsi.png?1[/img] anime list manga list blog posts |
| i never really bothered watching berserk movie triology so that makes me a first timer however i gotta say it was a good experience though they could have toned down cgi a bit but it was okay i guess seeing how complex miura's art is to replicate and griffith vs guts fight was very well animated...as i am seeing that some guys are complaining that they added nothing new to first episode but be patient guys i read they are going to add a whole ass new episode dedicated to bonefire of dreams segment and we are getting a new announcement in dec which might be continuation of this arc so yeah dont loose hope because this might be type of an experiment to analyze if berserk fanbase is still alive or not. |
 |
| Is this going to lead into an adaptation of the arc after golden age? |
| Interesting episode. But the low frames are really hurting my eyes :D |
| more berserk is always good the start of one of the greatest arcs in animanga good to see guts, Griffith, Casca and the rest of the band of the hawk again I had forgotten how much of a bitch I thought Casca was at the start of this arc even though I watched the 90s version and the movies I'm still enjoying this |
Homura24Oct 2, 2022 12:50 AM
 |
| Been a long time since I've seen the movies. The CG hasn't aged well. I remember not disliking it when the films were originally released, but it looked rough in this episode. Whatever... I enjoyed this nonetheless. Looking forward to seeing the new content although I likely won't be able to recognize anything new unless it's post-eclipse material or Wyald since it's been a long time since I have seen these movies. Hopefully Wyald is in here as it would greatly benefit this memorial edition. And if the countdown is for the Black Swordsman arc and Lost Children that also would be incredible. |
| I kinda fell asleep while watching the first two movies of the trilogy, watching these is something I own to myself. |
 |
| I can't believe I'm submitting myself to this suffering yet again. |
| I'm hopeful that they might still put Guts' childhood, but at a later point. Because that is one of the most important parts that didn't make the cut for the movies. |
Rest in Piece, Miura. |
| It would be unfitting to put this so early in the show for newcommers and series pacing. |
 |
| Yeah, no. I forgot how bad the pacing was in the movies. It feels even worse here for some reason. They toned down the CGI, which is a good thing but overall, not much improvement (is it me, or is ost different?). One can only hope next 2 episodes actually add scenes from manga that were omitted from the movies like First battle and fucking character interactions. TekTation said: just give it to OLM to make it and stop making it 3D... such a good manga being all messed up... Yeah, agreed. OLM probs is the best choice. They did way more with less. Give them normal budget and they'll make a masterpiece. |
SaphiranOct 1, 2022 3:50 PM
Stardrake said: Yeah, no. I forgot how bad the pacing was in the movies. It feels even worse here for some reason. They toned down the CGI, which is a good thing but overall, not much improvement (is it me, or is ost different?). One can only hope next 2 episodes actually add scenes from manga that were omitted from the movies like First battle and fucking character interactions. TekTation said: just give it to OLM to make it and stop making it 3D... such a good manga being all messed up... Yeah, agreed. OLM probs is the best choice. They did way more with less. Give them normal budget and they'll make a masterpiece. people talk as if OLM is still the same as they were back in 1997. |
 |
| Although the story of the comics went astray, it's still good in this stage. The arc shot (360 degree shot) for the protagonist was not a bad idea, since it's an advantage of 3D. But somehow the scene seemed jerky. The anime team may have used 2D background with 3D human models. |
| they didn't bother changing with the screen resolution, but i guess it's better than nothing. |
 |
| Why did this need to be made? Wasn't the 97 one good enough? Even the movie trilogy seems pointless when they could have continued from the eclipse where the 97 anime left off. But no, we gotta milk the same arc over and over again instead of progressing the story. |
| such a refreshing feel! Berserk like a gaiden! awesome ep! 5/5. |
 |
| I have never seen a bigger disappointment than this, you can see everything in the lag, honestly it was better with that game animation than this one, why don't they use the old one from 1997 and put it on this nasty one without any humor, the characters they move wildly, their mouths are REALLY from a game, embarrassing. And on top of that, the worst thing he could do, DID THE ACTORS CHANGE THE VOICES OF THE CHARACTERS, REALLY? Why are they re-adapting these scenes if there is already the first season from 1997, which is MUCH better than this, much is little said, it's the difference from earth to heaven. |
As someone who has never seen the movies,I'm impressed by the cgi,but on the story side od things,some scenes feel less impactful and shorter,but still,the episode is greatly paced,wish they would animate the black swordsman arc too,cause I heard they would add more scenes,but I guess we'll see.Also I don't like the 3 fps flashbacks. |
Derfel10 said: The 3d isn't that bad, but the fps is terrible. If Studio 4C fix the fps in the cgi and kept mixing with the 2d scenes which are pretty as hell, I would be more than satisfied. StaleNut said: I think the countdown may be for the eclipse. I wouldn't be too hopeful for new content tbh. They didn't even try polishing the animation in the first episode. Let a man dream and be disappointed again, my friend. Highly agreed, I find most 3d animation in anime looks very stiff with cheap models which result in being unbearably horrible, Berserk 2016 has both but Berserk 2012 has decent models, the only problem is just felt too laggy and unnatural, if they could fix this it sure be as good as Orange works |
 |
Hydra112 said: Same goes for me,I just gave up on a faithful adaptation that is gourgesly animated and just want to have a good enough adaptation,which is really sad. yeah berserk it's really good but the CGI |
| [jmg align=right]https://i.imgur.com/XLRDPsi.png?1[/img] anime list manga list blog posts |
Shioneri said: Highly agreed, I find most 3d animation in anime looks very stiff with cheap models which result in being unbearably horrible, Berserk 2016 has both but Berserk 2012 has decent models, the only problem is just felt too laggy and unnatural, if they could fix this it sure be as good as Orange works And from the preview of the bonfire scene you can see that the models are even better now. Berserk 2016 not only looks stiff, but they also had that horrible shading going on, trying to simulate a 2d animation. There's nothing good about this sin of anime, apart from the soundtrack. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Berserk: Ougon Jidai-hen - Memorial Edition Episode 12 DiscussionHomura24 - Dec 17, 2022 |
31 |
by chinesecartoonz
»»
Jul 16, 4:37 AM |
|
Poll: » Berserk: Ougon Jidai-hen - Memorial Edition Episode 8 DiscussionHomura24 - Nov 19, 2022 |
45 |
by chinesecartoonz
»»
Jul 16, 1:58 AM |
|
» Why no sequel?chriskris91 - Jun 29 |
5 |
by Broleta
»»
Jul 1, 3:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Berserk: Ougon Jidai-hen - Memorial Edition Episode 10 Discussionvon_Lohengramm - Dec 3, 2022 |
30 |
by SonnaBaka
»»
May 19, 6:48 AM |
|
» Do I need to watch the old berserk to watch this?Pink_Chipmunk - Oct 1, 2022 |
17 |
by iluvanime69
»»
May 6, 9:51 PM |