ElChOrC said: Hah, well thanks. If I aim to be one thing it's consistent even if my point of view may be controversial at times. Sure, I might be proven wrong and apologize, but I won't backpedal. That's not how the world works, you can't pretend you never said something or that you ment something else to make you look better.I know this will sound weird, but thank you for being a human being! I'm sick of idiots lying, contradicting themselves, changing their entire arguments in one message, and denying the previous ones existed, denying reality, etc, etc, etc, so reading you is a really pleasant breeze of fresh air. Please, don't ever stop being a human being, you are too few to risk the chance of losing one xD And yeah, probably not a human being, in my case, but that's how I rank myself +/-. The most important things I consider, I guess, are how much I want to see the next episode, and how much I'm invested in the story. And I say consider, not because I objectively start trying to decide where to put it, but I believe that they haev a lot of weight on the internal equation (or there's no reason for me to give a 10/10 to One Piece). And every once in a while, when I feel to, a little fine-tuning, comparing a series to those that landed next to it, and playing with the scores. Basically, as I said a few days ago, its MY anime list for a reason Mmhm, that is how to properly use the site. Every person has their own opinion on shows. There will also always be people who stan a show to downvote anything threatening their "rightful spot" so this system also will never reflect the truth. I still go back to my previous comment: "Give MAL a critic score" while leaving the audience score alone. In anime there is an Interspecies reviewer, why not an Ecchi reviewer, comedy reviewer, ect. Just choose people who like a chosen genre and have them review what's there. In that case you will have a general idea of what fans and just a random person who likes the genre of the anime thinks of it. Even this system won't promise people agree on it, but heck, if they wanna be the rotten tomatoes of anime, be the rotten tomatoes of anime, go all out. |
| How would they verify actual critics though. Should it be like Users with written reviews that some people find helpful. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
GoodZoom said: How would they verify actual critics though. Should it be like Users with written reviews that some people find helpful. Paid reviewers please, I'll volunteer to be the first one lol |
CondemneDio said: GoodZoom said: How would they verify actual critics though. Should it be like Users with written reviews that some people find helpful. Paid reviewers please, I'll volunteer to be the first one lol What kind of reviewer would you be? |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
Didn't think that far to be honest. I'm a cynical pessimist, so my reviews would be super negative most of the time probably. |
unamerican said: ElChOrC said: Don't look that, it's full of misinformation! The whole tone of the video is meant to add weight in the one side of the scales. A few examples * Fake references to sex intended to make people feel a little sorry about the company, sprinkled here and there. (even claiming there's sexual content (sic) in One Piece) * Hiding the fact that they are not just FUNimation, but Sony, with everything that entails, so that the viewer doesn't thing of it as the faceless conglomerate it is. (AnimeLab is owned by FUNimation, FUNi and PS are owned by Sony) * Suggesting that Sony could lose 50+% of its market due to this series, with Google, Microsoft, and even Sony itself dropping their app, comparing Sony, a giant, to a regular app developer. As if Google or Microsoft (or Sony itself, according to the video) would ever get at odds with Sony over one anime... Worst case scenario, they would meet and talk it over until reaching a common ground, yet the only possibility presented by the video is "Poor FUNi, they are gonna get their app dropped" which is just a lie. * Hiding the fact that hey have not actually dropped the series, just limited to a portion of the world through a subsidiary. They didn't say "Hey, no, we're done with this, here's your license, is too lewd for us" but kept it, just refusing to release it in a determined part of the world. As I said, AnimeLab IS FUnimation, acquired through Sony Music's Aniplex a year ago. * And finally presenting as ridiculous the comparison with 4Kids, when it's actually pretty accurate The whole video hides facts, presents a few lies, and it's tendentious. An entire piece of misinforming crap. Oh, you're one of those people who seems to think Funi and Sony are out to get you. Okay buddy old buddy old pal I'll leave you there in your conspiracy corner. Other anime have sexual content, they just don't happen to be genitalia flashing porn. Including other ecchi. Coming from someone who absolutely loathese ecchi I can still say, with all the trash I've dropped, that most ecchi does not push the envelope as far as this one did. Because most ecchi shys away from actual sexuality or showing the act and shoves tits in your face and demands you either laugh at them or fap to them. I'd argue it's not much better to shove outright sex in your face either, because it's something you can easily find in porn. The problem is that if there's literally a point where ecchi becomes porn, then what's to stop that oversexualized content from leaking out into other anime? I don't think anime about sex should be as fetishized as this one is, which unfortunately is the case for most anime that either have ecchi content that doesn't even show sex, it's crass and stupid and lowbrow, and this is no different, it just involves actual penetration for the audiences extra fapping pleasure. If there were an anime produced that were actually about sex and sexuality that handled the act maturely then perhaps just perhaaaaaps I would start to take the industry seriously, but this is not what I would call a mature series, pornographic doesn't equal mature, and people trying to use it's not porn it's art as an excuse when people have more often first found this show on pornhub? Sure Jan. Also of course you're not mentioning that Japanese network Tokyo MX dropped it from airing because that would defeat your purpose of portraying the western side as the epitome of prudish censorship when even the Japanese centralized it to their pay per view channel ATX only after seeing how adult the show got. Of course they didn't want to broadcast a show they'd have to so heavily censor on their fucking mainstream channel, even if late at night. The amount of time taken to have to censor the scenes with genitalia and sex to make them broadcast friendly isn't worth it. Frankly I'm not so fond of hentai levels of sexuality being paraded around out in the open. Or at least it always seems to pander to men and to an uncomfortable degree it always feels impersonal and never romanticized. Do I want it venturing into my mainstream anime? Of course not. Could this pave the way for worse degeneracy down the line? Yes. Because if this becomes the standard for ecchi, shitty as a genre as it is and as many women hate it, it could trickle down the line. It's honestly a bad show conceptually to introduce because it's so inherently pornographic and yeah, call me a prude, but at least most ecchi, as tasteless as they are, never have the audacity to show pussy penetration and sex toys on screen. If it makes me a prude to feel like sexuality in anime is often geared only towards one demographic and portrayed in a way that brings about the phenomenon called cumbrain where people start to associate everything with sex when it's been too sexualized, then yeah, I'll be a prude. Lots of things in anime are sexualized but there's a difference between subtle sexualization and outright pornography. And some things… I don't know… ya jus don't show on your networks sweetie. Can't blame anyone for dropping it. And frankly most of the blame lies on the studio (Passione I think) for adding extraneous sex scenes for nothing. They were the ones who distributed this to the networks and licensors with likely no forewarning of what the episodes were going to entail before they aired and subbed them. It was really starting to push the envelope early on but obviously if there's a fuckin' scene with a dildo and actual penetration… well… they say this isn't a hentai, but it fucking sounds like one. I'll let you all know when I get to produce my own gross anime relating to my private fetishes to their fullest and most explicit extent, then show you an advanced screening. In this case the first episodes going to be the one that likely would get the penetration out of the way. The MC would also be someone you couldn't project upon and there would be actual romanticism or acts that would make people uncomfortable. But wait, I would never do such a thing because I have the restraint. If the hormones of the dudes in the anime are really so out of control that ecchis crosses the threshold into outright porn then I seriously do not want to see what's next. If there's not some kind of distinguishing factor between public and private sexuality then that's how cumbrain comes about, and that's often something that brings about other social behavior. Basically if you can't stop sexualizing something because you're constantly exposed to sexualization in the form of something that's pornographic that's claiming not to be, then you can find a way to claim that it's totally fine for you to parade more extreme fetishes out in the open to the point where it's considered antisocial behavior. It's not good for society. Like oh god I sound like a conservitard but I was never a huge fan of people parading around their fetishes and god they should keep it behind closed doors and not intersect it with media to the point where it's not even artful porn with a "story", it's fetishized porn with no plot. You clearly haven't seen it, and are going off second hand information. I get it, you hate ecchi, to each their own, why don't you go your way and people who enjoy Ishuzoku for more then just the ecchi, which apparently it "has none of", will go our own way. (Oh, and given this is the Ishuzoku forum, I will likely be sticking around) |
GoodZoom said: How would they verify actual critics though. Should it be like Users with written reviews that some people find helpful. There is two routes you could gather anime critics: I am 100% sure there are people that could be hired for the job. Alternatively they can go the route they do with their mods: Find volunteers that would be willing to take their time to review anime of their chosen genre. Part of their selection process could be a questioner pretty much asking their taste in anime and their preferred genre/ what they like in it. Hah, I am with you. It would be cool to be a paid reviewer. Even if not it would be kinda fun to be one reviewing without payment. As for what I would enjoy reviewing most, I don't know. I've liked stuff in action/ adventure/ horror/ comedy/ romance/ ecchi/ ect. Overall, my reviews would focus on emotion, fun, and investment, as I usually review anime, but if I was a critic I'd type up a response as to why I put the score I did as well instead of it being a number that does not mean much without context. |
ChaoticHaruFeb 17, 2020 8:15 AM
RebuffedFatkid said: I think MAL has shown their true colors. This kind of thing happens all the time to shows that are not controversial and they don’t get slapped down. Now the rules will be different and honest people will probably have to jump through hoops to leave an honest opinion. The system wasn’t broke and it didn’t need to be fixed (in my opinion). No this kind of thing doesn't happen all the time. This is the first time a YouTuber has commanded his followers to rate an anime on a specific website 10/10 for "flex" |
DomineLkira said: You are right but only to an extent.RebuffedFatkid said: I think MAL has shown their true colors. This kind of thing happens all the time to shows that are not controversial and they don’t get slapped down. Now the rules will be different and honest people will probably have to jump through hoops to leave an honest opinion. The system wasn’t broke and it didn’t need to be fixed (in my opinion). No this kind of thing doesn't happen all the time. This is the first time a YouTuber has commanded his followers to rate an anime on a specific website 10/10 for "flex" A youtuber has not lead a vote brigade before Interspecies (to my knowledge.) However, real viewers intentionally manipulate scores all the time. Think about times such as when Attack on Titan passed FMA for a bit and the FMA fans downvoted it to keep FMA in it's spot. MyAnimeList should know this has always been an issue. |
ElChOrC said: unamerican said: Hei is a grifting crackpot who's harassed, targeted, and stalked various VA's on Twitter. He doesn't have an ounce of credibility and he does whatever will garner him the most views. I don't think most anitubers have integrity but he is among the worst to be talking about this. If I had to pick the one video about the situation I thought was the least annoying, it'd have to be this one. Don't look that, it's full of misinformation! The whole tone of the video is meant to add weight in the one side of the scales. A few examples * Fake references to sex intended to make people feel a little sorry about the company, sprinkled here and there. (even claiming there's sexual content (sic) in One Piece) * Hiding the fact that they are not just FUNimation, but Sony, with everything that entails, so that the viewer doesn't thing of it as the faceless conglomerate it is. (AnimeLab is owned by FUNimation, FUNi and PS are owned by Sony) * Suggesting that Sony could lose 50+% of its market due to this series, with Google, Microsoft, and even Sony itself dropping their app, comparing Sony, a giant, to a regular app developer. As if Google or Microsoft (or Sony itself, according to the video) would ever get at odds with Sony over one anime... Worst case scenario, they would meet and talk it over until reaching a common ground, yet the only possibility presented by the video is "Poor FUNi, they are gonna get their app dropped" which is just a lie. * Hiding the fact that hey have not actually dropped the series, just limited to a portion of the world through a subsidiary. They didn't say "Hey, no, we're done with this, here's your license, is too lewd for us" but kept it, just refusing to release it in a determined part of the world. As I said, AnimeLab IS FUnimation, acquired through Sony Music's Aniplex a year ago. * And finally presenting as ridiculous the comparison with 4Kids, when it's actually pretty accurate The whole video hides facts, presents a few lies, and it's tendentious. An entire piece of misinforming crap. Sony's been getting a steady stream of hate from Japanese developers and others for forcing them to censor their projects. It's one of their polices now, due to american societal developments. AKA the #metoo movement. |
ChaoticHaru said: DomineLkira said: You are right but only to an extent.No this kind of thing doesn't happen all the time. This is the first time a YouTuber has commanded his followers to rate an anime on a specific website 10/10 for "flex" A youtuber has not lead a vote brigade before Interspecies (to my knowledge.) However, real viewers intentionally manipulate scores all the time. Think about times such as when Attack on Titan passed FMA for a bit and the FMA fans downvoted it to keep FMA in it's spot. MyAnimeList should know this has always been an issue. Yeah , I know that and I bet the mods also know that (the extent of that issue was the reason the thread regarding the illegitimate account was closed inthe first place) Just wanted to point out that this EXACT situation has never happened with MAL. |
unamerican said: JunkYardHiro said: Sony's been getting a steady stream of hate from Japanese developers and others for forcing them to censor their projects. It's one of their polices now, due to american societal developments. AKA the #metoo movement. Twitter hashtags about sexual assault within the media industry are completely unrelated to some video game or media company doing something you don't like. Tick tock false equivalency it's not a conspiracy. Not according to Sony themselves and the Wall Street Journal. https://www.businessinsider.com/sony-metoo-censorship-playstation-games-2019-4 And here's a response from a Japanese developer in regards to the new polices. https://nichegamer.com/2018/10/27/new-sony-censorship-policy-is-forcing-even-japanese-developers-to-censor-themselves-in-japan/ |
unamerican said: JunkYardHiro said: Not according to Sony themselves and the Wall Street Journal. https://www.businessinsider.com/sony-metoo-censorship-playstation-games-2019-4 And here's a response from a Japanese developer in regards to the new polices. https://nichegamer.com/2018/10/27/new-sony-censorship-policy-is-forcing-even-japanese-developers-to-censor-themselves-in-japan/ Funimation and Sony gaming are, as aforementioned, still not the same division despite being under the same parent company, not even close. They do not have an influence on another's decisions. There is no trickle down of leadership from Sony Gaming to Funi. There's no hierarchy when Sony, which is a vast conglomerate of all of Sony's parent and child companies, consists of so many divisions that it's very doubtful that anime and video games are going hand in hand especially when funimation, before the Sony acquisition, had its own staff. Likewise AnimeLab, owned by both funimation and Sony, did not cancel the broadcast of IR. Tokyo MX did not its broadcast in Japan because of Americans. They cancelled on their own merit. it's ridiculous to assume that each of these are somehow involved in a mass conspiracy to take away anime lewdness from you. When they are under different leadership. If you understood anything about media it's that money drives it. If they look to lose more than they'll gain, shit gets dropped. It happens with films, television shows, and so on all the time. Some things get cancelled mid season, mid airing. It only happens to be when it's an anime where someone showed a pussy that someone bats an eyelash. If it were a mundane anime that didn't draw that kind of controversy there wouldn't be backlash. Point is if it's too porny people aren't going to want to license it and I'm surprised the AUS service kept saying they were going to air it. If y'all hate the anime industry so much then just pirate and watch illegally instead of pouring copious amounts of money into licensors pockets. I never did it so how can I feel either happy or guilty? If you don't "support" them yourself or never did then where's your right to complain either? I ain't complaining, I'm just laughing at the fact that people are so offended by a perfectly sensible decision that happens in normie television and film all the time. Things get cancelled. Big whoop. If they're still airing elsewhere then just find ways to pirate. Stop trying to say it's an Evil Liberal Conspiracy's fault when such a thing doesn't exiiiiist You're under the wrong assumption that I was speaking out against censorship or supporting it. I was just summarizing what I've read, which is provided in the links mentioned. |
Probably not. But you can be sure that if you vote FMAB 10/10, it will count 👍 |
| bruh |
unamerican said: JunkYardHiro said: Not according to Sony themselves and the Wall Street Journal. https://www.businessinsider.com/sony-metoo-censorship-playstation-games-2019-4 And here's a response from a Japanese developer in regards to the new polices. https://nichegamer.com/2018/10/27/new-sony-censorship-policy-is-forcing-even-japanese-developers-to-censor-themselves-in-japan/ Funimation and Sony gaming are, as aforementioned, still not the same division despite being under the same parent company, not even close. They do not have an influence on another's decisions. There is no trickle down of leadership from Sony Gaming to Funi. There's no hierarchy when Sony, which is a vast conglomerate of all of Sony's parent and child companies, consists of so many divisions that it's very doubtful that anime and video games are going hand in hand especially when funimation, before the Sony acquisition, had its own staff. Likewise AnimeLab, owned by both funimation and Sony, did not cancel the broadcast of IR. Tokyo MX did not its broadcast in Japan because of Americans. They cancelled on their own merit. it's ridiculous to assume that each of these are somehow involved in a mass conspiracy to take away anime lewdness from you. When they are under different leadership. If you understood anything about media it's that money drives it. If they look to lose more than they'll gain, shit gets dropped. It happens with films, television shows, and so on all the time. Some things get cancelled mid season, mid airing. It only happens to be when it's an anime where someone showed a pussy that someone bats an eyelash. If it were a mundane anime that didn't draw that kind of controversy there wouldn't be backlash. Point is if it's too porny people aren't going to want to license it and I'm surprised the AUS service kept saying they were going to air it. If y'all hate the anime industry so much then just pirate and watch illegally instead of pouring copious amounts of money into licensors pockets. I never did it so how can I feel either happy or guilty? If you don't "support" them yourself or never did then where's your right to complain either? I ain't complaining, I'm just laughing at the fact that people are so offended by a perfectly sensible decision that happens in normie television and film all the time. Things get cancelled. Big whoop. If they're still airing elsewhere then just find ways to pirate. Stop trying to say it's an Evil Liberal Conspiracy's fault when such a thing doesn't exiiiiist Thank you for saying this. I am real tired of the evil corporate and anti-sjw approach. I tried clicking on the articles source and got a paywall the title of the article didn't have any Me Too mentions on it. It's important to check your source's sources and Writer for credibility, folks. Two companies owned by Sony to Sony Entertainment and Sony interactive and further down. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
unamerican said: Oh, you're one of those people who seems to think Funi and Sony are out to get you. Okay buddy old buddy old pal I'll leave you there in your conspiracy corner. Other anime have sexual content, they just don't happen to be genitalia flashing porn. Including other ecchi. Coming from someone who absolutely loathese ecchi I can still say, with all the trash I've dropped, that most ecchi does not push the envelope as far as this one did. Because most ecchi shys away from actual sexuality or showing the act and shoves tits in your face and demands you either laugh at them or fap to them. I'd argue it's not much better to shove outright sex in your face either, because it's something you can easily find in porn. The problem is that if there's literally a point where ecchi becomes porn, then what's to stop that oversexualized content from leaking out into other anime? I don't think anime about sex should be as fetishized as this one is, which unfortunately is the case for most anime that either have ecchi content that doesn't even show sex, it's crass and stupid and lowbrow, and this is no different, it just involves actual penetration for the audiences extra fapping pleasure. If there were an anime produced that were actually about sex and sexuality that handled the act maturely then perhaps just perhaaaaaps I would start to take the industry seriously, but this is not what I would call a mature series, pornographic doesn't equal mature, and people trying to use it's not porn it's art as an excuse when people have more often first found this show on pornhub? Sure Jan. Also of course you're not mentioning that Japanese network Tokyo MX dropped it from airing because that would defeat your purpose of portraying the western side as the epitome of prudish censorship when even the Japanese centralized it to their pay per view channel ATX only after seeing how adult the show got. Of course they didn't want to broadcast a show they'd have to so heavily censor on their fucking mainstream channel, even if late at night. The amount of time taken to have to censor the scenes with genitalia and sex to make them broadcast friendly isn't worth it. Frankly I'm not so fond of hentai levels of sexuality being paraded around out in the open. Or at least it always seems to pander to men and to an uncomfortable degree it always feels impersonal and never romanticized. Do I want it venturing into my mainstream anime? Of course not. Could this pave the way for worse degeneracy down the line? Yes. Because if this becomes the standard for ecchi, shitty as a genre as it is and as many women hate it, it could trickle down the line. It's honestly a bad show conceptually to introduce because it's so inherently pornographic and yeah, call me a prude, but at least most ecchi, as tasteless as they are, never have the audacity to show pussy penetration and sex toys on screen. If it makes me a prude to feel like sexuality in anime is often geared only towards one demographic and portrayed in a way that brings about the phenomenon called cumbrain where people start to associate everything with sex when it's been too sexualized, then yeah, I'll be a prude. Lots of things in anime are sexualized but there's a difference between subtle sexualization and outright pornography. And some things… I don't know… ya jus don't show on your networks sweetie. Can't blame anyone for dropping it. And frankly most of the blame lies on the studio (Passione I think) for adding extraneous sex scenes for nothing. They were the ones who distributed this to the networks and licensors with likely no forewarning of what the episodes were going to entail before they aired and subbed them. It was really starting to push the envelope early on but obviously if there's a fuckin' scene with a dildo and actual penetration… well… they say this isn't a hentai, but it fucking sounds like one. I'll let you all know when I get to produce my own gross anime relating to my private fetishes to their fullest and most explicit extent, then show you an advanced screening. In this case the first episodes going to be the one that likely would get the penetration out of the way. The MC would also be someone you couldn't project upon and there would be actual romanticism or acts that would make people uncomfortable. But wait, I would never do such a thing because I have the restraint. If the hormones of the dudes in the anime are really so out of control that ecchis crosses the threshold into outright porn then I seriously do not want to see what's next. If there's not some kind of distinguishing factor between public and private sexuality then that's how cumbrain comes about, and that's often something that brings about other social behavior. Basically if you can't stop sexualizing something because you're constantly exposed to sexualization in the form of something that's pornographic that's claiming not to be, then you can find a way to claim that it's totally fine for you to parade more extreme fetishes out in the open to the point where it's considered antisocial behavior. It's not good for society. Like oh god I sound like a conservitard but I was never a huge fan of people parading around their fetishes and god they should keep it behind closed doors and not intersect it with media to the point where it's not even artful porn with a "story", it's fetishized porn with no plot. This is such a bizarre tirade towards ecchi in a thread that isn't really even about discussing the merits of ecchi that I feel that this may be the only post in this entire 89 page thread that is worthy of the coveted response of "Ok, boomer" |
| People who put MAL stats in their sigs are losers lol |
| @Atomizer74 Take a look at her list, it's clear she hates anything ecchi and is just here to annoy ecchi fans and is clearly seeking attention. |
| "Well, she's flatter than a pancake" -Mimi Alpacas "Woof" -Tobiichi Origami "Are you trying to turn the dormitory into a strip club!?! -Atena Saotome |
Tropisch said: @Atomizer74 Take a look at her list, it's clear she hates anything ecchi and is just here to annoy ecchi fans and is clearly seeking attention. To be fair their mean score is like 5.4 in total. which means passable according to MAL anything below that is bad. So it seems the majority of what they watches they considers bad. And eh they just don't like ecchi shows and has a reason for it. Not hurting anybody. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
GoodZoom said: Tropisch said: @Atomizer74 Take a look at her list, it's clear she hates anything ecchi and is just here to annoy ecchi fans and is clearly seeking attention. To be fair their mean score is like 5.4 in total. which means passable according to MAL anything below that is bad. So it seems the majority of what they watches they considers bad. And eh they just don't like ecchi shows and has a reason for it. Not hurting anybody. Except her post condemns anyone who likes and even basically called those who like it degenerate. |
| "Well, she's flatter than a pancake" -Mimi Alpacas "Woof" -Tobiichi Origami "Are you trying to turn the dormitory into a strip club!?! -Atena Saotome |
Tropisch said: GoodZoom said: To be fair their mean score is like 5.4 in total. which means passable according to MAL anything below that is bad. So it seems the majority of what they watches they considers bad. And eh they just don't like ecchi shows and has a reason for it. Not hurting anybody. Except her post condemns anyone who likes and even basically called those who like it degenerate. Semantics. She calls herself a prude to what's the point in weighing her opinion on stuff you don't agree with. Everyone has things they disagree with within a certain argument ,but not that argument in a whole. Just Ok boomer her lol. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
DragonGamerZ said: Now I WANT something to top FMA:B just to see how MAL will react, because it's been made clear that they WANT to keep it at the top Attack on titan will do that alright. |
| One piece: Kai imagine how much filler content could be cut. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
| I'm not sure if anyone pointed this out but the stats page still remain intact. Currently the scores are... 10- 62208 9- 4035 8- 4494 7- 3961 6- 1781 5- 899 4- 536 3- 338 2- 360 1- 4521 Which leaves with an average of 8.96. Which means that Izzoku reviewers would be at the 15º place if the mods didn't intervene. The dream is dead.  |
Strife425Feb 17, 2020 9:57 PM
| If you're this obsessed with getting an anime at the top of an anime site, your priorities need to be straightened out. lol |
 |
Gonzo-lewd said: If you're this obsessed with getting an anime at the top of an anime site, your priorities need to be straightened out. lol While it was a funny meme to see Interspecies skyrocket to the top, and to laugh at the insanity from various sides that took place, the score does not matter. If you try to go by Nux's own words he already said: He feels like he already won. He met his goal. So, if Nux himself already is satisfied why should his fans continue to worry about making Interspecies number one? I do agree that Interspecies is better than many anime in the top 100 list, I won't fuss if it stays low. That said, it's been going up in rank because the show is good even with brigade/ bot accounts not counted. PS. Gonzo, I know the ....anime... your display is from. Fairly good taste. I admit it is hard to find a decent show of that type at least in the sites I've looked. Well, there was one featuring a ghost I suppose but... I won't go into details because the shows involved are off topic of this thread. |
Tropisch said: GoodZoom said: To be fair their mean score is like 5.4 in total. which means passable according to MAL anything below that is bad. So it seems the majority of what they watches they considers bad. And eh they just don't like ecchi shows and has a reason for it. Not hurting anybody. Except her post condemns anyone who likes and even basically called those who like it degenerate. All you gotta do is look carefully at the signature image, "together we can stopp ecchi fans". |
| https://www.oneangrygamer.net/2020/02/myanimelist-bans-users-for-condemning-censorship-of-interspecies-reviewers-votes/102946/ Another biased article. So many half truths and some lies like "If you check the Top Anime list as of February 12th, 2020, Interspecies Reviewers has been moved out of the top 50 anime list." They use the term "moved", when the truth is every anime had or will have its score recalculated. |
Fortune favours the bold!  |
DeathTheKid4 said: https://www.oneangrygamer.net/2020/02/myanimelist-bans-users-for-condemning-censorship-of-interspecies-reviewers-votes/102946/ Another biased article. So many half truths and some lies like "If you check the Top Anime list as of February 12th, 2020, Interspecies Reviewers has been moved out of the top 50 anime list." They use the term "moved", when the truth is every anime had or will have its score recalculated. " MAL Bans Users" Seriously all these media houses are so full of shit nowadays that this article doesn't even come off as a surprise. |
DomineLkira said: Inferno792 said: The 10/10 votes still haven't stopped. Neither have the favorites. :( Hello Mr"Almost same profile picture", nice to meet you. And the 10's and favourites are not a problem. They were a problem when they were on the orders of a guy. Most of those 15k favorites are on the orders of that guy though, which is a problem. Not a big one considering it's not really that big a number in comparison to the top favorited anime, but a problem nonetheless. |
ChaoticHaru said: If you try to go by Nux's own words he already said: He feels like he already won. He met his goal. So, if Nux himself already is satisfied why should his fans continue to worry about making Interspecies number one? I don't even know who this Nux guy is because I avoid anime YouTubers like the plague because they're all garbage and this whole meme proves that. sllypper said: Why are you so obsessed? Straighten your priorities, will ya? Look yourself in the mirror. In my opinion this is a revolutionary show, one like no other. It deserves my top rating. This is literally the first time I ever talked about it. Lol |
|
| Does anyone care about character favorite numbers. Checked the website and the amount of times i saw the word SJW, from that author is fucking hilarious. I juts am mentally fatigued from the mental gymnastics some people really do just to publish an article. I am tired of the same hack journalism style of screenshot (not sourced) and videos being embedded into the article. Shit they advertised a Neir Titmouse pad, that's really classy to have next to your articles, Yoko Taro would probably like them though. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
Gonzo-lewd said: ChaoticHaru said: If you try to go by Nux's own words he already said: He feels like he already won. He met his goal. So, if Nux himself already is satisfied why should his fans continue to worry about making Interspecies number one? I don't even know who this Nux guy is because I avoid anime YouTubers like the plague because they're all garbage and this whole meme proves that. sllypper said: Why are you so obsessed? Straighten your priorities, will ya? Look yourself in the mirror. In my opinion this is a revolutionary show, one like no other. It deserves my top rating. This is literally the first time I ever talked about it. Lol Nah Code Geass is revolutionary. I see no Japanese teens rebelling. |
| The Pickled Cactus Himself. |
Strife425 said: I'm not sure if anyone pointed this out but the stats page still remain intact. Currently the scores are... 10- 62208 9- 4035 8- 4494 7- 3961 6- 1781 5- 899 4- 536 3- 338 2- 360 1- 4521 Which leaves with an average of 8.96. Which means that Izzoku reviewers would be at the 15º place if the mods didn't intervene. The dream is dead. What you choose to calculate? |
| From what i read somewhere, another TV company stopped Ishuzoku Reviewers ? Until it's not AT-X ... |
 |
penrhos said: Looks like Ep.6 broke another TV station... Kobe's Sun TV - Cancels IR - Fortunately its still on AT-X. If they keep this up we'll have to wait for the BD release to finish the series and the rating will become a mute-point. It already was a moot point. Problem is, the blurays are not going to sell well: Amazon.jp listing Priced at ¥15,780 Which according to google is about $144 USD And this is for PART 1 of a 3 part bluray release, which means episodes 1-4. For all 3 it is ￥47,130, which is $430 USD, for a 12 episode anime series. As much as I love the series, I cannot justify $430 USD for 12 episodes.(For me, being in Australia, it is actually over $600 AUD) If this is just for the launch period, and quickly drops in price to something more reasonable, then I will pick it up, but it won't sell very well at those prices. |
penrhos said: Atomizer74 said: It already was a moot point. Problem is, the blurays are not going to sell well: Amazon.jp listing Priced at ¥15,780 Which according to google is about $144 USD And this is for PART 1 of a 3 part bluray release, which means episodes 1-4. For all 3 it is ￥47,130, which is $430 USD, for a 12 episode anime series. As much as I love the series, I cannot justify $430 USD for 12 episodes.(For me, being in Australia, it is actually over $600 AUD) If this is just for the launch period, and quickly drops in price to something more reasonable, then I will pick it up, but it won't sell very well at those prices. Part one is supposed to come with a model of the fairy brothel madam if my google-translate fu is strong. There is 2 versions if you go to the official website: https://isyuzoku.com/products/ If you scroll down you will see a picture of the figure, and below you will see: 【Blu-ray】 品番：ZMXZ-13861 税抜価格：20,000円／税込価格：22,000円 Basically 2 prices, one says(according to my translation), before tax, the other is after tax. This is for the figurine version 22,000 yen(after tax), and there is a few other goodies you can see listed: "Aloe" original figure Digipack drawn by character design Makoto Uno Special BOX Original / Amahara / Drawing / masha comics Original soundtrack CD1 Special booklet Non-credit OP / ED WEB notice But if you go down you will see the regular versions listed at 14,300 yen for the bluray. However, I just noticed, there is a "First production bonus": Digipack drawn by character design Makoto Uno Special BOX Original / Amahara / Drawing / masha comics Original soundtrack CD1 Special booklet Which I assume is a pre-order bonus, maybe that is why it costs so much to pre-order? If so, I have hopes that when they come out in May, we will see the price drop, though usually the pre-order price is the same, even with extra bonuses, maybe it is different for anime, I don't know, I haven't ever preordered anime goods. Edit: Going over the list more closely, seems your standard fair pre-order bonuses, so I don't think the price will drop after pre-orders, either way, it still stands that, at those prices, it won't sell well. |
Atomizer74 said: penrhos said: Part one is supposed to come with a model of the fairy brothel madam if my google-translate fu is strong. There is 2 versions if you go to the official website: https://isyuzoku.com/products/ If you scroll down you will see a picture of the figure, and below you will see: 【Blu-ray】 品番：ZMXZ-13861 税抜価格：20,000円／税込価格：22,000円 Basically 2 prices, one says(according to my translation), before tax, the other is after tax. This is for the figurine version 22,000 yen(after tax), and there is a few other goodies you can see listed: "Aloe" original figure Digipack drawn by character design Makoto Uno Special BOX Original / Amahara / Drawing / masha comics Original soundtrack CD1 Special booklet Non-credit OP / ED WEB notice But if you go down you will see the regular versions listed at 14,300 yen for the bluray. However, I just noticed, there is a "First production bonus": Digipack drawn by character design Makoto Uno Special BOX Original / Amahara / Drawing / masha comics Original soundtrack CD1 Special booklet Which I assume is a pre-order bonus, maybe that is why it costs so much to pre-order? If so, I have hopes that when they come out in May, we will see the price drop, though usually the pre-order price is the same, even with extra bonuses, maybe it is different for anime, I don't know, I haven't ever preordered anime goods. Edit: Going over the list more closely, seems your standard fair pre-order bonuses, so I don't think the price will drop after pre-orders, either way, it still stands that, at those prices, it won't sell well. These are just normal Japanese Bluray prices. This is why I think a lot of people were so bummed when Funimation completely dropped the show. They would have kept the entire show at around $60. |
Atomizer74 said: either way, it still stands that, at those prices, it won't sell well. A few 100 bucks for a one cour anime series is pretty much standard in japan. Also it seems like Ishuzoku Reviewers is among the top selling series this season. But even if we disregard all that, BD sales haven't really been that important in recent years anyway. Overseas success (licensing fees) and streaming success have become very important after all. |
| The votes here, positive and negative, are not worth much as of late anyway - anime went mainstream, and this site too, and so unlike before when you usually had people with at least a few shows under their belts voting based on their how they liked the anime from the base of comparison to others, you now have people who just see a major title or two and rush here to vote 10/10 "best EVA". For example take my hero academia, 7.2-7.8 on "anikore" (Japanese equivalent of MAL), awhile here it has 8.3-8.5, that's over one point of difference just from all the 10/10 flooding from the new mainstream watchers. Here's some more - "Your name" 8.4 vs 9.1 here, "mob psycho100 2" 7.8 vs 8.9 here, "Kimetsu no Yaiba" 8 vs 8.9, "The promised neverland" 7.8 vs 8.7, "Dr. stone" 7.6 vs 8.5... So yeah, if you want a more honest score that's NOT inflated by the influx of newbies, nor the west's politically correct kerfuffles, check there. As for this show, its not good, its not bad. I don't care much for most of the lewd stuff in here, the drawing's kinda meh anyway, so its around 7/10 for me, just for the comedy. |
Zsayel said: These are just normal Japanese Bluray prices. This is why I think a lot of people were so bummed when Funimation completely dropped the show. They would have kept the entire show at around $60. DarkDooM2 said: A few 100 bucks for a one cour anime series is pretty much standard in japan. Also it seems like Ishuzoku Reviewers is among the top selling series this season. But even if we disregard all that, BD sales haven't really been that important in recent years anyway. Overseas success (licensing fees) and streaming success have become very important after all. Ah, fair enough then, I have only ever bought localized BDs/DVDs, so this is the first time I have been looking at BDs/DVDs from japan(for the obvious reason, that I don't speak japanese). I wonder if there is going to be an english BD release, I mean, AnimeLab is still streaming it, surely there is some company willing to release a BD.(Or maybe because the dub was dropped, it won't ever get one) |
mkzxwing said: The votes here, positive and negative, are not worth much as of late anyway - anime went mainstream, and this site too, and so unlike before when you usually had people with at least a few shows under their belts voting based on their how they liked the anime from the base of comparison to others, you now have people who just see a major title or two and rush here to vote 10/10 "best EVA". For example take my hero academia, 7.2-7.8 on "anikore" (Japanese equivalent of MAL), awhile here it has 8.3-8.5, that's over one point of difference just from all the 10/10 flooding from the new mainstream watchers. Here's some more - "Your name" 8.4 vs 9.1 here, "mob psycho100 2" 7.8 vs 8.9 here, "Kimetsu no Yaiba" 8 vs 8.9, "The promised neverland" 7.8 vs 8.7, "Dr. stone" 7.6 vs 8.5... So yeah, if you want a more honest score that's NOT inflated by the influx of newbies, nor the west's politically correct kerfuffles, check there. As for this show, its not good, its not bad. I don't care much for most of the lewd stuff in here, the drawing's kinda meh anyway, so its around 7/10 for me, just for the comedy. Kimetsu =8 Mob = 7.8 No thanks , MAL is better. Edit : Most of them DO make sense tho. Like Dr Stone. Come on people , it ain't 8.5 |
DomineLkiraFeb 18, 2020 6:01 AM
More topics from this board
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Ashhk - Mar 28, 2020 |
190 |
by JeanFranciss
»»
Mar 24, 10:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Feb 8, 2020 |
134 |
by JeanFranciss
»»
Mar 10, 10:38 AM |
|
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 18, 2020 |
138 |
by JeanFranciss
»»
Mar 3, 9:19 AM |
|
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 4, 2020 |
279 |
by JefersonLima00
»»
Feb 25, 2:19 AM |
|
» Season 2 petitionThegordon - Jan 1 |
1 |
by deg
»»
Jan 1, 10:08 PM |