Forum Settings
Forums

When did the term “Japanimation” started to become “anime” and what was the cause of that?

New
May 23, 4:36 AM
#1
Offline
Apr 2022
400
Back in the early 80s to early 90s, anime wasn’t even called “anime”, it was called “Japanimation”. Japanimation is an amalgamation of the words "Japan" and "animation" used to refer to Japanese Animation. But by sometime, that word quickly faded from the mainstream and become “anime” soon after. I want to find out when “Japanimation” started to be called “anime” and what led to it being called by the latter term?
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
May 23, 4:40 AM
#2

Offline
Sep 2016
4497
Don't know when but almost sure it's because Anime is a shorter term and rolls off the tongue more easily.
This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.
May 23, 4:49 AM
#3

Offline
May 2019
6703
around the late 90's to early 2000's.
May 23, 4:54 AM
#4

Offline
Mar 2023
2021
Anime just sounds more catchier than “Japanimation”.
May 23, 6:53 AM
#5

Offline
Jan 2009
93679
no idea animax already calls them anime by 1998
May 23, 6:53 AM
#6
Offline
Jul 2018
564487
I kinda miss calling it Japanimation. Saying that now feels like someone would call you racist for it...
May 23, 7:04 AM
#7

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to removed-user
I kinda miss calling it Japanimation. Saying that now feels like someone would call you racist for it...
@Lhundrup Actually I would point out that you are being racist. You see, anime is not just exclusive to Japan anymore. It is a global phenomenon with creators and fans all over the world. Using Japanimation could be seen as limiting or even be negative of the contributions from other countries. China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works. South Korea has emerged as a key player in the animation industry, with studios like Studio Mir and Madhouse Korea producing top notch anime series and films. Using terms like "Japanimation" may unintentionally diminish the rich diversity of animated content produced worldwide.
Gashadokur0May 23, 8:51 AM
May 23, 7:58 AM
#8

Offline
Jan 2022
679
Reply to Gashadokur0
@Lhundrup Actually I would point out that you are being racist. You see, anime is not just exclusive to Japan anymore. It is a global phenomenon with creators and fans all over the world. Using Japanimation could be seen as limiting or even be negative of the contributions from other countries. China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works. South Korea has emerged as a key player in the animation industry, with studios like Studio Mir and Madhouse Korea producing top notch anime series and films. Using terms like "Japanimation" may unintentionally diminish the rich diversity of animated content produced worldwide.
@Gashadokur0 Is this bait? Please tell me this is bait.
May 23, 8:00 AM
#9
Offline
Apr 2014
238
Reply to LenRea
@Gashadokur0 Is this bait? Please tell me this is bait.
@LenRea of course it is, you can even see it is clearly written by AI.
May 23, 8:02 AM

Offline
Jan 2022
679
Reply to velvetnyan
@LenRea of course it is, you can even see it is clearly written by AI.
@velvetnyan yeah. dumb question i guess, sorry.
May 23, 8:14 AM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to LenRea
@velvetnyan yeah. dumb question i guess, sorry.
@LenRea Lol the only part that was meant to bait was when I said 'you are racist.' Everything else I mentioned is based on facts. You can look it up on Wiki.
May 23, 11:20 AM

Offline
Jan 2022
679
Reply to Gashadokur0
@LenRea Lol the only part that was meant to bait was when I said 'you are racist.' Everything else I mentioned is based on facts. You can look it up on Wiki.
@Gashadokur0 anime is not korean or chinese animation...
yes there's tons of neighboring countries to japan involved in it's anime industries, there's japanese animation adaptations of manhwa and such, but no, Chinese/South Korean/North Korean/Netflix independent animation is not anime... i refuse to believe otherwise, i guess it's a matter of preference what anime means to anyone. Japan itself officially considers all animation from everywhere "anime', it doesn't matter what japanese anime fans or non-japanese anime fans think.
I'll just add whatever cartoon i watch to my list on this website if it has an entry here, i guess.
May 23, 12:11 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
3467
Does it honestly matter? It is just anime, bro...
May 23, 12:19 PM

Offline
Mar 2008
47612
It wasn't originally called anime in Japan. It went by terebi manga (TV manga). The term anime ironically came from the West calling it Japanese animation so Ive heard. So the word "animation" was ported to Japanese as "anime" for short. This eventually made it's way back full circle.
May 23, 2:24 PM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
funtime43_tr said:
When did the term “Japanimation” started to become “anime” and what was the cause of that?


This might be helpful for those who might be unclear. This is simply just from my own perspective growing up in both the West and Asia.

It was originally a Western marketing ploy in the late 80s to start acclimating Japanese Animation to Western Audiences as it's own unique medium where before they started doing this Japanese animation was simply just a genre in the west. It actually all started around the time when "Akira" was 1st produced (it was the 1st Anime to actually be marketed in theaters in the west as Japanimation). But as someone who actually frequently visited and even for a short time lived in Japan in the late 70s to mid 80s, Japanese animation has always been called Anime in Japan dating back to when I was still a very young child (my father use to record Lupin the 3rd and other Anime titles on VHS tapes to take back with him to South Korea to watch later, I still own some of those old VHS tapes my father ended up giving me sometime in the 90s once he started going blind when we all officially finally became American citizens). I even remember my father who use to watch Anime called it Anime in the late 70s because it was simply just a shorter term for Animation.

Anime stopped being called Japanimation in the west sometime between the mid to late 90s when Japanese Animation finally became officially recognized as it's own unique medium. It's a shorter term and easier to market too.
ColourWheelMay 23, 11:23 PM
May 23, 2:59 PM

Offline
Feb 2023
318
Reply to traed
It wasn't originally called anime in Japan. It went by terebi manga (TV manga). The term anime ironically came from the West calling it Japanese animation so Ive heard. So the word "animation" was ported to Japanese as "anime" for short. This eventually made it's way back full circle.
@traed I've heard that the word "anime" was a loanword from French.
May 23, 3:41 PM

Offline
Mar 2008
47612
Reply to ForgotEyeWasHere
@traed I've heard that the word "anime" was a loanword from French.
@ForgotEyeWasHere
That was what I originally heard years back but apparently it isnt the case. It just is the English and French words both have Latin origin. Though it might have gone both maybe. I had came across a video on the topic from a smaller anituber. I left out a lot of steps though when summarizing. The term is thought to came from this magazine's name.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animage



His French "dessin animé" literally meaning design cartoon comment he later corrected as a mistake.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QB-DE7Xlrvc
May 23, 5:31 PM

Offline
Jul 2016
1335
Around 80s/90s sounds about right to me.
May 23, 7:01 PM

Offline
Feb 2021
4129
Not sure but Japanimation is too mouthful to say so anime works better.

Though, Japanese people refer to anime as "Nihon no anime" or "Japanese animation".
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio-

May 23, 7:05 PM
Offline
Aug 2018
17353
I don't know the details, but it's probably catchier and easier to call it anime rather than Japanimation or Japanese cartoons.

May 23, 10:13 PM

Offline
Oct 2013
7810
Dunno, in my place we never used such term as "Japanimation", though truth to be told, English is not the first language here, lol. Anyway, in my place people back in the day referred to Japanese animation mostly by calling it either "Japanese cartoons" or name it by using a good old French word "animé".
May 23, 11:05 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
5356
Reply to Gashadokur0
@Lhundrup Actually I would point out that you are being racist. You see, anime is not just exclusive to Japan anymore. It is a global phenomenon with creators and fans all over the world. Using Japanimation could be seen as limiting or even be negative of the contributions from other countries. China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works. South Korea has emerged as a key player in the animation industry, with studios like Studio Mir and Madhouse Korea producing top notch anime series and films. Using terms like "Japanimation" may unintentionally diminish the rich diversity of animated content produced worldwide.
@Gashadokur0 lmao. No. Anime means Japanese and only Japanese animation in the west. It was always like this. Stop forcing your nonsense.
Dub = fake crap. Always.
May 23, 11:31 PM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to rsc-pl
@Gashadokur0 lmao. No. Anime means Japanese and only Japanese animation in the west. It was always like this. Stop forcing your nonsense.
@rsc-pl True, but have you ever wonder about how most people don't live in the West? In lots of places, anime is a more inclusive term used for all kinds of animation, not just Japanese.
May 23, 11:46 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
564487
I think it was at the stat of the 00s and the reason was because it sounded racist or something like that.

Where I am from anime used to be called manga, yeah.
May 24, 12:37 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
Reply to Gashadokur0
@rsc-pl True, but have you ever wonder about how most people don't live in the West? In lots of places, anime is a more inclusive term used for all kinds of animation, not just Japanese.
Gashadokur0 said:
@rsc-pl True, but have you ever wonder about how most people don't live in the West? In lots of places, anime is a more inclusive term used for all kinds of animation, not just Japanese.


The only place I know like this is Japan, where they call "Bug Bunny" Anime simply because anything animated to the Japanese is Anime regardless if it's domestic or not (the use of the word has two meanings where one is just to describe any animation while the other is a specific name for their own Domestic Medium). To the Japanese, Anime as a word is a Homonym. It's the equivalent in the English language of the use of words such as Bark, Right, Bat, Novel, and even the word Medium, etc... You go to South Korea, they don't call their domestic animation Anime, they call it Aeni. In China they call their own domestic animation Donghua.

Anime is part of Japan's culture regardless if it's a global phenomena and it belongs to no one else. Reminds me back in the 70s and 80s when Ninjas started becoming hip in the West for the 1st time, where you started to see movies being made like "American Ninja". When basically all a ninja really was in Japan was a 12th century assassin. Even Ninja wasn't really what they truly were called to begin with, they were known as shinobi. The word ninja actually came from just one of many feudal Japanese societies, so it was more of an identifying name for just a particular group of mercenary assassins during this time period. Just the name Ninja was easier for westerners to grasp even though there were technically many kinds of shinobi. So it's weird how the word Ninja got so over used when it basically just amounts to just a name referring to two clans (Iga and Koga). Even the word Ninja isn't even Japanese by origin, it's actually Chinese.
ColourWheelMay 24, 4:16 AM
May 24, 12:44 AM

Offline
Feb 2024
233
Japanimation contains seven syllables. Americans didn't commonly use the word, and it was too long for Japanese speakers.

There is an article that a man looked up about Japanimation.
https://note-com.translate.goog/sudotadashi/n/ne5b7c88873b7?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=ja&_x_tr_pto=wapp&_x_tr_hist=true
May 24, 1:07 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
2035
Reply to Gashadokur0
@Lhundrup Actually I would point out that you are being racist. You see, anime is not just exclusive to Japan anymore. It is a global phenomenon with creators and fans all over the world. Using Japanimation could be seen as limiting or even be negative of the contributions from other countries. China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works. South Korea has emerged as a key player in the animation industry, with studios like Studio Mir and Madhouse Korea producing top notch anime series and films. Using terms like "Japanimation" may unintentionally diminish the rich diversity of animated content produced worldwide.
@Gashadokur0 Terrible bait, try harder next time. South Korean and Chinese animation already have their own domestic names, aeni and donghua respectively, thus they're not anime.
Hot Blood saves lives.
May 24, 1:23 AM

Offline
Mar 2008
47612
Reply to GinIonSui
Japanimation contains seven syllables. Americans didn't commonly use the word, and it was too long for Japanese speakers.

There is an article that a man looked up about Japanimation.
https://note-com.translate.goog/sudotadashi/n/ne5b7c88873b7?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=ja&_x_tr_pto=wapp&_x_tr_hist=true
@GinIonSui
How are you getting 7? It is closer to four syllables in American English and more like five if enunciated more like British English.
May 24, 2:12 AM

Offline
Feb 2024
233
Reply to traed
@GinIonSui
How are you getting 7? It is closer to four syllables in American English and more like five if enunciated more like British English.
@traed It seems to be called a "mora". Japanimation is written in katakana as "ジャパニメーション", and it contains seven morae: "ジャ", "パ", "ニ", "メ", "ー", "ショ", and "ン".
May 24, 2:16 AM

Offline
Mar 2008
47612
Reply to GinIonSui
@traed It seems to be called a "mora". Japanimation is written in katakana as "ジャパニメーション", and it contains seven morae: "ジャ", "パ", "ニ", "メ", "ー", "ショ", and "ン".
@GinIonSui
Mora is a little different from syllables and not used in English. Also Japanimation was not a Japanese originating term. For one thing they call their country Nippon or Nihon way more often than Japan.
May 24, 4:18 AM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
Gashadokur0 said:
@rsc-pl True, but have you ever wonder about how most people don't live in the West? In lots of places, anime is a more inclusive term used for all kinds of animation, not just Japanese.


The only place I know like this is Japan, where they call "Bug Bunny" Anime simply because anything animated to the Japanese is Anime regardless if it's domestic or not (the use of the word has two meanings where one is just to describe any animation while the other is a specific name for their own Domestic Medium). To the Japanese, Anime as a word is a Homonym. It's the equivalent in the English language of the use of words such as Bark, Right, Bat, Novel, and even the word Medium, etc... You go to South Korea, they don't call their domestic animation Anime, they call it Aeni. In China they call their own domestic animation Donghua.

Anime is part of Japan's culture regardless if it's a global phenomena and it belongs to no one else. Reminds me back in the 70s and 80s when Ninjas started becoming hip in the West for the 1st time, where you started to see movies being made like "American Ninja". When basically all a ninja really was in Japan was a 12th century assassin. Even Ninja wasn't really what they truly were called to begin with, they were known as shinobi. The word ninja actually came from just one of many feudal Japanese societies, so it was more of an identifying name for just a particular group of mercenary assassins during this time period. Just the name Ninja was easier for westerners to grasp even though there were technically many kinds of shinobi. So it's weird how the word Ninja got so over used when it basically just amounts to just a name referring to two clans (Iga and Koga). Even the word Ninja isn't even Japanese by origin, it's actually Chinese.
@ColourWheel I Know that In South Korea, they don't refer to their domestic animation as anime, instead, it's known as Aeni. Likewise, in China, their own domestic animation is called Donghua. However, in many countries, including where I'm from, there isn't such a clear distinction, and we simply use the term "anime" regardless of its origin. While "anime" strictly refers to Japanese animation, some people may employ it more broadly to encompass animated works from other countries, including China or South Korea. It's a matter of cultural specificity and interpretation, with "anime" holding a specific connotation for Japanese animation but occasionally extending to include animation from other regions as well. You know, it is fascinating how language evolves and changes based on cultural context.

In Japan, anime is a broad term that encompasses all forms of animation, both domestic and foreign. It's like how we might use the word cartoon in English. But outside of Japan, anime has become synonymous with a specific style of animation characterized by colorful artwork, fantastical themes, and vibrant characters.
May 24, 6:33 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
Reply to Gashadokur0
@ColourWheel I Know that In South Korea, they don't refer to their domestic animation as anime, instead, it's known as Aeni. Likewise, in China, their own domestic animation is called Donghua. However, in many countries, including where I'm from, there isn't such a clear distinction, and we simply use the term "anime" regardless of its origin. While "anime" strictly refers to Japanese animation, some people may employ it more broadly to encompass animated works from other countries, including China or South Korea. It's a matter of cultural specificity and interpretation, with "anime" holding a specific connotation for Japanese animation but occasionally extending to include animation from other regions as well. You know, it is fascinating how language evolves and changes based on cultural context.

In Japan, anime is a broad term that encompasses all forms of animation, both domestic and foreign. It's like how we might use the word cartoon in English. But outside of Japan, anime has become synonymous with a specific style of animation characterized by colorful artwork, fantastical themes, and vibrant characters.
@Gashadokur0

So just because some random unnamed nations around the globe call anything that look like Japanese Animation "Anime" that it should no longer culturally belong strictly to Japan? This is just my opinion, but this country where you are are from probably couldn't tell the difference between K-pop and J-pop. Why should the entire world look to where you are from as some authority of what Anime is or not?

Anime being a global phenomenon is irrelevant. Not just anyone can simply create animation and simply pass it off as Anime no matter how much it might look like something Japan would create. Culturally, Anime belongs to Japan and no other country. Anything else that look like Japanese Anime is simply just animation that is inspired by Japanese Anime and nothing more.
ColourWheelMay 24, 6:38 AM
May 24, 7:19 AM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
@Gashadokur0

So just because some random unnamed nations around the globe call anything that look like Japanese Animation "Anime" that it should no longer culturally belong strictly to Japan? This is just my opinion, but this country where you are are from probably couldn't tell the difference between K-pop and J-pop. Why should the entire world look to where you are from as some authority of what Anime is or not?

Anime being a global phenomenon is irrelevant. Not just anyone can simply create animation and simply pass it off as Anime no matter how much it might look like something Japan would create. Culturally, Anime belongs to Japan and no other country. Anything else that look like Japanese Anime is simply just animation that is inspired by Japanese Anime and nothing more.
@ColourWheel Sure, anime started in Japan and it’s a massive part of Japanese culture. Firstly, it is important to recognize that language and definitions evolve over time and across cultures. While anime traditionally refers to Japanese animation, the term has broadened in many places to include various styles of animation that resemble the Japanese style. This doesn't necessarily strip it of its cultural origins, rather, it shows how influential and beloved Japanese animation has become globally. Who gets to be the gatekeeper of what anime is? Culture is shared and appropriated, and it’s a compliment that anime’s influence is so huge. I bet even in your country, people who casually watch anime are calling Chinese and South Korean animations "anime." Why? Because they look pretty similar in art style and vibe, and not everyone is a hardcore fan who knows all the technicalities. Now, saying that anything outside of Japan is just "animation inspired by Japanese anime" is a bit of a stretch. Secondly, defining anime strictly based on its cultural origins can be limiting and exclusionary. The lines between different animation styles have become increasingly blurred in the age of globalization. Chinese and South Korean animation studios have produced works that closely resemble Japanese anime in terms of art style, themes, and storytelling techniques. These similarities make it understandable for people from diverse regions to use the term "anime" to describe such animations, as they share many common characteristics with Japanese anime. Also cut the crap and stop assuming you know what others are aware of.
May 24, 7:32 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
Reply to Gashadokur0
@ColourWheel Sure, anime started in Japan and it’s a massive part of Japanese culture. Firstly, it is important to recognize that language and definitions evolve over time and across cultures. While anime traditionally refers to Japanese animation, the term has broadened in many places to include various styles of animation that resemble the Japanese style. This doesn't necessarily strip it of its cultural origins, rather, it shows how influential and beloved Japanese animation has become globally. Who gets to be the gatekeeper of what anime is? Culture is shared and appropriated, and it’s a compliment that anime’s influence is so huge. I bet even in your country, people who casually watch anime are calling Chinese and South Korean animations "anime." Why? Because they look pretty similar in art style and vibe, and not everyone is a hardcore fan who knows all the technicalities. Now, saying that anything outside of Japan is just "animation inspired by Japanese anime" is a bit of a stretch. Secondly, defining anime strictly based on its cultural origins can be limiting and exclusionary. The lines between different animation styles have become increasingly blurred in the age of globalization. Chinese and South Korean animation studios have produced works that closely resemble Japanese anime in terms of art style, themes, and storytelling techniques. These similarities make it understandable for people from diverse regions to use the term "anime" to describe such animations, as they share many common characteristics with Japanese anime. Also cut the crap and stop assuming you know what others are aware of.
@Gashadokur0

I have lived in South Korea, Japan, and North America. In South Korea I have never heard anyone refer to animation broadly as Anime unless it was actually Japanese Animation. In a place like North America people mistaken anyone who is Asian as Chinese, so I wouldn't put it past them to simply call anything Anime as long as it look like Anime just like they call anyone Chinese as long as they look Chinese (I have been called Chinese so many times in my life living in North America and I am not Chinese). The actual gate keepers should be Japan. If they don't recognize animation as part of their own culture, people shouldn't culturally mix animation produced by some random country as Anime simply because it might look like it. The Tokyo Anime awards even has their own international category for foreign animation and never in history have they ever recognized anything as Anime simply because it just look like Anime.

Culture can be shared but not broadly appropriated, No more than any foreign country trying to appropriate something culturally important to your own country no matter how global it might have spread. So you should cut the crap too.
ColourWheelMay 24, 7:39 AM
May 24, 7:46 AM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
@Gashadokur0

I have lived in South Korea, Japan, and North America. In South Korea I have never heard anyone refer to animation broadly as Anime unless it was actually Japanese Animation. In a place like North America people mistaken anyone who is Asian as Chinese, so I wouldn't put it past them to simply call anything Anime as long as it look like Anime just like they call anyone Chinese as long as they look Chinese (I have been called Chinese so many times in my life living in North America and I am not Chinese). The actual gate keepers should be Japan. If they don't recognize animation as part of their own culture, people shouldn't culturally mix animation produced by some random country as Anime simply because it might look like it. The Tokyo Anime awards even has their own international category for foreign animation and never in history have they ever recognized anything as Anime simply because it just look like Anime.

Culture can be shared but not broadly appropriated, No more than any foreign country trying to appropriate something culturally important to your own country no matter how global it might have spread. So you should cut the crap too.
@ColourWheel LOL, you basically handed me the answer on a silver platter.

ColourWheel said:
In a place like North America people mistaken anyone who is Asian as Chinese, so I wouldn't put it past them to simply call anything Anime as long as it look like Anime


Have you ever thought that this generalization might extend to other regions as well. That's what I've been trying to explain to you. Thank you genius.
May 24, 7:58 AM

Offline
Jul 2022
540
It's called "simplification" my dude

May 24, 8:04 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
Reply to Gashadokur0
@ColourWheel LOL, you basically handed me the answer on a silver platter.

ColourWheel said:
In a place like North America people mistaken anyone who is Asian as Chinese, so I wouldn't put it past them to simply call anything Anime as long as it look like Anime


Have you ever thought that this generalization might extend to other regions as well. That's what I've been trying to explain to you. Thank you genius.
@Gashadokur0

You have completely missed my point by quoting me out of context. Calling any animation as Anime as long as it looks like Anime is basically like calling someone Chinese simply because they look Chinese. It either went over your head or you simply just ignored it. Either way if the Japanese people don't recognize animation as part of their culture it's technically not Japanese Anime. Simply producing Animation in some random country that look like Japanese Anime is just as fake as buying a Japanese katana produced in Mexico.
ColourWheelMay 24, 10:12 AM
May 24, 8:23 AM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
@Gashadokur0

You have completely missed my point by quoting me out of context. Calling any animation as Anime as long as it looks like Anime is basically like calling someone Chinese simply because they look Chinese. It either went over your head or you simply just ignored it. Either way if the Japanese people don't recognize animation as part of their culture it's technically not Japanese Anime. Simply producing Animation in some random country that look like Japanese Anime is just as fake as buying a Japanese katana produced in Mexico.
@ColourWheel ok I will give you some time to reread what you wrote and find what wrong. Take 10 to 20 minutes to understand what you've written. If you understand, don't quote me again. However, if you still don't understand, quote me, and I'll explain what's wrong
May 24, 10:31 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
@Gashadokur0

Not playing some stupid game where you're trying to direct some narrative. If you want to point something out just come out and say it.

I will simply go back to your original statement here...

Gashadokur0 said:
However, in many countries, including where I'm from, there isn't such a clear distinction, and we simply use the term "anime" regardless of its origin.


Even if there are people who can't tell the clear distinction between animation produced in one country over another just makes people in that country just as dumb as people who live in North America who can't tell the difference between someone who is Korean over someone who is Chinese. Even if people in your country are simply just using a broad brush over anything that looks like Japanese animation as Anime that doesn't mean they are right about it. It just means those people have no clue what they are actually watching to begin with. It's like someone going into a restaurant and ordering the Atlantic Cod but since the customers can't tell the difference in fish the restaurant prepares them cheaply caught Groupers. Either way your not making any type of compelling argument to me.

Gashadokur0 said:
In Japan, anime is a broad term that encompasses all forms of animation, both domestic and foreign.


I will say this again. The only reason why anime is a broad term in Japan is because they use anime as a short term for animation but it is also the name for their own domestic animation. Anime is a Homonym, much like the word "Medium" in the English language means several things too.
ColourWheelMay 24, 10:44 AM
May 24, 11:17 AM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
@Gashadokur0

Not playing some stupid game where you're trying to direct some narrative. If you want to point something out just come out and say it.

I will simply go back to your original statement here...

Gashadokur0 said:
However, in many countries, including where I'm from, there isn't such a clear distinction, and we simply use the term "anime" regardless of its origin.


Even if there are people who can't tell the clear distinction between animation produced in one country over another just makes people in that country just as dumb as people who live in North America who can't tell the difference between someone who is Korean over someone who is Chinese. Even if people in your country are simply just using a broad brush over anything that looks like Japanese animation as Anime that doesn't mean they are right about it. It just means those people have no clue what they are actually watching to begin with. It's like someone going into a restaurant and ordering the Atlantic Cod but since the customers can't tell the difference in fish the restaurant prepares them cheaply caught Groupers. Either way your not making any type of compelling argument to me.

Gashadokur0 said:
In Japan, anime is a broad term that encompasses all forms of animation, both domestic and foreign.


I will say this again. The only reason why anime is a broad term in Japan is because they use anime as a short term for animation but it is also the name for their own domestic animation. Anime is a Homonym, much like the word "Medium" in the English language means several things too.
You agreed with me in your previous posts. Our debate was settled a long time ago. It's okay that you lost the debate, but at least you made an effort.

ColourWheel said:
Even if there are people who can't tell the clear distinction between animation produced in one country over another just makes people in that country just as dumb as people who live in North America who can't tell the difference between someone who is Korean over someone who is Chinese. Even if people in your country are simply just using a broad brush over anything that looks like Japanese animation as Anime that doesn't mean they are right about it. It just means those people have no clue what they are actually watching to begin with. It's like someone going into a restaurant and ordering the Atlantic Cod but since the customers can't tell the difference in fish the restaurant prepares them cheaply caught Groupers. Either way your not making any type of compelling argument to me.


Now about this, I have no idea what you talking about. This is another debate about whether it's appropriate to call animation styles from other countries "anime," or if that term should be reserved for Japanese animation only. At no point in my post did I say it was okay to call Chinese or Korean animation "anime." I just said that many people worldwide called Chinese and South Korean Animation 'anime'.

I think you mess everything together.
May 24, 11:46 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
@Gashadokur0

At this point you are just obviously trolling or you are just extremely absent minded.

Gashadokur0 said:
At no point in my post did I say it was okay to call Chinese or Korean animation "anime." I just said that many people worldwide called Chinese and South Korean Animation 'anime'.


really?

Gashadokur0 said:
China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works.


China's domestic animation is called Donghua. China has never produced Japanese Anime and even if one might think their animation rivals animation produced in Japan that doesn't automatically make it Japanese Anime simply because one might think it's better.
May 24, 12:03 PM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
@Gashadokur0

At this point you are just obviously trolling or you are just extremely absent minded.

Gashadokur0 said:
At no point in my post did I say it was okay to call Chinese or Korean animation "anime." I just said that many people worldwide called Chinese and South Korean Animation 'anime'.


really?

Gashadokur0 said:
China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works.


China's domestic animation is called Donghua. China has never produced Japanese Anime and even if one might think their animation rivals animation produced in Japan that doesn't automatically make it Japanese Anime simply because one might think it's better.
@ColourWheel And where in your example did I say it was okay to call Chinese animation "anime"? I know it's called Donghua, but I still call it anime (we just had this debate). I never said that the correct way to refer to Chinese animation was anime.






Gashadokur0May 24, 12:06 PM
May 24, 12:15 PM

Offline
Mar 2021
2547
Reply to Gashadokur0
@ColourWheel And where in your example did I say it was okay to call Chinese animation "anime"? I know it's called Donghua, but I still call it anime (we just had this debate). I never said that the correct way to refer to Chinese animation was anime.






@Gashadokur0

Right here in this quote you out right claim China is producing "Anime". Simply using the term so casually says all one needs to know.

Gashadokur0 said:
China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works.
May 24, 12:23 PM

Offline
May 2024
145
Reply to ColourWheel
@Gashadokur0

Right here in this quote you out right claim China is producing "Anime". Simply using the term so casually says all one needs to know.

Gashadokur0 said:
China for instance, has its own animation industry, producing a wide range of anime content that rivals even some of Japan most renowned works.
@ColourWheel You are just trolling, YES I CALLED IT ANIME. But where did I say it was right to call it anime? The correct term is Donghua. Just show me the proof. Are you genuinely not understanding, or are you just trolling? I hope you're just trolling.
May 24, 1:22 PM

Offline
Feb 2024
54
Reply to Gashadokur0
@ColourWheel You are just trolling, YES I CALLED IT ANIME. But where did I say it was right to call it anime? The correct term is Donghua. Just show me the proof. Are you genuinely not understanding, or are you just trolling? I hope you're just trolling.
@Gashadokur0 Lol I took some of my time and read your debates. It seems to me that you are talking about the same thing, you just did not understand each other. But the advantage is clearly more in your favor, at least because you speak more clearly about your point of view, although English is not my native language, I’m from Russia :)
May 24, 2:10 PM

Offline
Mar 2008
47612
Gashadokur0 said:
Sure, anime started in Japan and it’s a massive part of Japanese culture.

Early stuff from Japan was heavily influenced by Western animation.
May 24, 3:45 PM

Offline
Feb 2024
233
Reply to traed
@GinIonSui
Mora is a little different from syllables and not used in English. Also Japanimation was not a Japanese originating term. For one thing they call their country Nippon or Nihon way more often than Japan.
@traed Thank you for sharing the important information. I've decided to call Nihon "Nihon".
May 24, 4:03 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
3467
I don't care what it is called. I enjoy anime very much...
May 24, 4:34 PM

Offline
Feb 2022
19927
who knows, who cares

anime sounds better maybe thats why
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

» Do you have animes you've rated 5 and under on your completed list, why? ( 1 2 )

melodyily - Jun 15

95 by KeepCalmAndMal »»
5 minutes ago

» Create Your Perfect Staff: ( 1 2 )

APolygons2 - Yesterday

55 by ryzxgum »»
9 minutes ago

» Summer 2024 Season

OldLoser - Jun 18

34 by KeepCalmAndMal »»
14 minutes ago

» Is it just me or is the Shoujo anime category pathetically small?

AngelicSuccubus - Yesterday

35 by RobertBobert »»
21 minutes ago

» Would you watch gender swapped Mushoku Tensei? ( 1 2 )

rohan121 - Jun 17

61 by RobertBobert »»
24 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login