| agree people are hating on it for no good reason. we've only seen 2 episodes so far, obviously unfair to judge it as a whole. i have no issue with the story or animation yet. i dont mind the cgi. plus ive seen worse anime with better scores, so. honestly itll jump back up to 7 in a few weeks https://myanimelist.net/anime/39063/Fairy_Gone/stats?m=all&show=75 plus the majority are voting either 6 7 or 8 so |
fairyApr 14, 2019 3:27 PM
| Why do you even take MAL average scores serioulsy at this point? |
| Who are you and why do you show your hostility towards a complete stranger whom you've not once spoken with before. Are you seriously asking to get blocked? Well, if that's what your intent is; to tempt me into throwing hands with someone as lowly and insignificant as you, then i may grant your wish provided you articulate yourself a bit better when trying to spite a person of my wavelength. |
| MAL reviews are memes, MAL scores are memes, MAL is a meme |
 |
| But it's still better than Tate no Yuusha |
  |
Rorek said: But it's still better than Tate no Yuusha It's not really difficult |
Fayteco said: The score should be even lower lul lul but it will get lower my boi. Worry not. You can be reassured. The wannabe critics will justify rating this show 1-4. |
Cheeza said: Yes,I agree. This is becoming so ridiculous at this point but like you said there is nothing much that can be done apart from not allowing any rating below 3 and above 9. At this point if people are looking for reliable ratings they need to look for other sites. Any suggestions? I find places like IMDB suck for anime and Reddit isn’t much better |
"Whether doing good or evil, I will be the boss." |
| It doesn't matter how other people here rate a series because I personally think that in the end MAL rating is somewhat accurate. 6~6.99 is under category of "fine" which is not "bad (4)". I don't go into detail cuz I'm poor at explaining thing but I personally think the series is totally "fine", it's not good because there's bad part, it's not average because there's some quality in it. I always give a chance to series (finished) that's rated above 5.5 but skip anything below that. |
| . |
| The argument has merit, however suggesting the admins disable 1/10 and 10/10 ratings as any sort of solution or hope of positive or ideal outcomes is the idea of a fucking idiot that will solve literally nothing. Suggesting admins disable scores such as 3< or >9 is equally stupid, you'll just get an artificially maintained score, which you can trust even less than the current system. The users of this fucking site seem unable to math or read the ratings associated with each score number. 5/10 is average, this manga is average at best. While the extreme ratings of this anime and most anime are usually undeserved, the average score, at least in the case, is well more than deserved. I understand what the mean scores and average scores of MAL are, but mathematically and by the site's own guidelines, they're inflated. Ratings on this site have always been a joke, and taking the joke seriously and suggesting the stupid solutions such as disabling certain scores or to higher professional reviewers is incredibly fucking stupid. Learn to use your brain and judge anime on your own instead of taking the opinions and often arbitrary ratings of other degenerates on the internet so seriously and personally. There are literally no websites with consistent or logical ratings, anime or not. |
 |
| i've always thought it was weird we could rate a show before it ended. reviews are okay, if tagged as preliminary, but rating it??? it would be much better if we could only rate completed shows. |
  |
fukumenkei said: i've always thought it was weird we could rate a show before it ended. reviews are okay, if tagged as preliminary, but rating it??? it would be much better if we could only rate completed shows. this was suggested a lot actually, heck some even suggest users can still rate ongoing shows but those ongoing shows will not count on the top rankings its a good idea both ways but make an exception on those long running anime though |
deg said: fukumenkei said: i've always thought it was weird we could rate a show before it ended. reviews are okay, if tagged as preliminary, but rating it??? it would be much better if we could only rate completed shows. this was suggested a lot actually, heck some even suggest users can still rate ongoing shows but those ongoing shows will not count on the top rankings its a good idea both ways but make an exception on those long running anime though they could have two rankings too, one for ongoing and another for completed series. something like they have for series/movies/OVA's. |
|
fukumenkei said: deg said: this was suggested a lot actually, heck some even suggest users can still rate ongoing shows but those ongoing shows will not count on the top rankings its a good idea both ways but make an exception on those long running anime though they could have two rankings too, one for ongoing and another for completed series. something like they have for series/movies/OVA's. ye that too, just remove All Anime or Top Anime ranking and just add Top Completed Anime there since there is already Top Airing for ongoing shows anyway, i might suggest that now if i do not find a similar thread about it on the suggestions forum |
deg said: fukumenkei said: they could have two rankings too, one for ongoing and another for completed series. something like they have for series/movies/OVA's. ye that too, just remove All Anime or Top Anime ranking and just add Top Completed Anime there since there is already Top Airing for ongoing shows anyway, i might suggest that now if i do not find a similar thread about it on the suggestions forum the ratings never bothered me much because i've always thought they were extremely unreliable because of this. i usually look for the number of drop-outs and compare to the people who completed it first. but that is a pretty good idea. the only thing that have to keep in mind is that aftee an anime is finished, only people with them on their finished lists would count on ratings. |
|
Hrybami said: Fayteco said: The score should be even lower lul lul but it will get lower my boi. Worry not. You can be reassured. The wannabe critics will justify rating this show 1-4. Not a critic but this anime is pretty shit, so... you know. |
| This will become one of those "underrated gems", I've seen a lot (literally) series which been doing much worse than this, yet their scores are better. In the end you are the one who will watch anime, and when it's finished airing, you will know by then how did you enjoy or hated it (if not dropped earlier), don't give scores what rest give for it (if there are people like that...), choose by yourself! |
GaichiMay 5, 2019 4:30 AM
"A half moon, it has a dark half and a bright half, just like me…", Yuno Gasai |
Escaethorne said: I don't understand why people care so much about scores to begin with. Does Code Geass R2 deserve an 8.94? Fuck no. In the case of Fairy Gone, I feel the current score of 6.27 is fair, since it's only a little above average if I'm to be generous. GarLogan78 said: Putting this anime aside, I have taken a few years off of anime. I really think when I left the mean score for anime was often 7.4 or so. Now every season TONS of shows are below 7s, and even in the 5 range. I feel like the whole system is skewing lower over time. Isn't that a good thing though? 5 is supposed to be "average", so the average show should indeed be a 5. 5 is theorically average. Actually, the mean rating for the shows on MAL is 6.88 https://graph.anime.plus/s/globals If the mean rating on MAL would be 5.00, then yes I'd say that 6.27 is a good score. However it's not the case and it would never reach 5.00 because people just naturally prefer to watch things they enjoy. So the final result has to be above average. What you want is probably a equal proportion of the shows ranged of 0% to 100%. Which mean that 50% (5.00) would be the set bar for the a theorically "average" show. The lowest rated show on MAL is 1.90 from Skelter Heaven and it is ranked at 10744. This ranking would be the set bar for the 0% (0.00). The set bar for the 50% (5.00) would be the anime ranked at 5372 which is https://myanimelist.net/anime/3436/Meme_Iroiro_Yume_no_Tabi . A show with a score of 6.63. So with that. a quick math could tell me that Fairy Gone which is ranked at 7009 is 34% (3.48). I did the same math for TV anime exclusively: 3661 is the lowest ranked TV anime. https://myanimelist.net/anime/34223/Forest_Fairy_Five while Fairy gone is at 3070. In the end, for TV anime series alone, Fairy Gone would have a score of 16% (1.61) which is extremely low and far from the observed average. So if the average score on MAL would indeed be 5.00, then I'd say that yes 6.27 is not a bad score, but currently the data tells that Fairy Gone is ranked amongst the lowest anime they can reach. This means that Fairy Gone stands on about the same level of those unwatchable shorts and experimental anime that have almost no redeeming feature. Well, scores changes anyway, so in the end, when the show will be done airing, I'll expect its score to turn around a 7.00 (6.8 to 7.2) |
KryzakamiHrybamiMay 6, 2019 6:44 AM
| Its pretty boring for me and with a stupid MC like the girl, a 6-7 is the best it can get. I think the rating's fine, its mediocrity at its finest as of now. So far its a 5 for me(would've been a sure 7 if that Maria girl didn't exist), will definitely give it a higher rating if it manages to entertain me more by the end. EDIT : it seems like most people agree that the current rating is fine lmfao git gud OP. |
NothinComplexPlsMay 6, 2019 7:32 AM
Eiruki17 said: Who the fuck decides what to watch based on score anyway? One of my favourite anime this season is scored 5.84. Do you see me complaining and calling for 'unbiased reviewers'? No, because it doesn't fucking matter what score MAL gives an anime. If you enjoy it, who gives a fuck. Seriously grow the fuck up man, this is pathetic. Pretty much this. This entire thread is based on the laughable conclusion that ratings matter and are being weaponized by evil people and MAL needs to step in to stop it. It's absurd.  |
Hrybami said: Escaethorne said: I don't understand why people care so much about scores to begin with. Does Code Geass R2 deserve an 8.94? Fuck no. In the case of Fairy Gone, I feel the current score of 6.27 is fair, since it's only a little above average if I'm to be generous. Isn't that a good thing though? 5 is supposed to be "average", so the average show should indeed be a 5. If the mean rating on MAL would be 5.00, then yes I'd say that 6.27 is a good score. However it's not the case and it would never reach 5.00 because people just naturally prefer to watch things they enjoy. So the final result has to be above average. Personally I feel my own scores are skewed higher by all the shows I drop early and dont rate. You've also got to remember a lot of people hand out 9s and 10s as if they don't know any other score. I certainly used to do that, only reserving 1s for shit I really hated. DiscoMilf said: Eiruki17 said: Who the fuck decides what to watch based on score anyway? One of my favourite anime this season is scored 5.84. Do you see me complaining and calling for 'unbiased reviewers'? No, because it doesn't fucking matter what score MAL gives an anime. If you enjoy it, who gives a fuck. Seriously grow the fuck up man, this is pathetic. Pretty much this. This entire thread is based on the laughable conclusion that ratings matter and are being weaponized by evil people and MAL needs to step in to stop it. It's absurd.  |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fairy Gone Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 5, 2019 |
51 |
by Thewatcher_22
»»
Feb 18, 2022 9:11 AM |
|
Poll: » Fairy Gone Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 23, 2019 |
72 |
by JaniSIr
»»
Jan 23, 2022 7:58 AM |
|
Poll: » Fairy Gone Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 16, 2019 |
65 |
by JaniSIr
»»
Jan 23, 2022 7:18 AM |
|
» Is this worth watching?removed-user - Oct 7, 2021 |
6 |
by Pangolin44
»»
Nov 3, 2021 8:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Fairy Gone Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 9, 2019 |
51 |
by Kap92
»»
Aug 15, 2021 5:20 AM |