Attack on Titan
Is there a chance of this season ending up with a score near 9?
Yes
72.5%
459
No
27.5%
174
633 votes
| I read it everywhere that this season is going to be insane, that this is the best part of the entire series etc, and I'm really looking forward to it. So it's just simple curiosity: do you think it's going to be good enough to get a score near 9? PS: please spare me from "MAL score means nothing" comments |
 |
lakelurk said: it will get a score of 9 no doubt about it, but will fall down to 8 after the Hype settles down Considering MAL, we don't even need to wait for the hype to die down before the downvoting squad comes in lmao. |
| this has some really good shit in it, the big reveals are gonna be here which will make anime only watchers finally understand what the plot is actually about there is good action and the ending will be super exciting hyping people up for season 4 also people who don't like shingeki no kyojin will be more likely to have dropped it by now EasyGo-er said: lakelurk said: it will get a score of 9 no doubt about it, but will fall down to 8 after the Hype settles down Considering MAL, we don't even need to wait for the hype to die down before the downvoting squad comes in lmao. if it doesnt reach 9 this is why |
| The moment it reaches 9, watch as the % of score "1" increases dramatically. |
| I don't care whether it reaches a score of 9 or not. It's a 10 for me at least. |
 |
| Definitely not. I'm a big fan of the series but action alone doesn't carry a series on its own. This season does have the best moments of the story thus far in the anime but the basement itself is going to be divisive af. I expect some 1, 2 or 3/10 just because of the basement. |
| Maybe at we the first two episodes, but when it ends I do not think so, because the first season is al worth score near to 9 :( but nevertheless I expect to end the rating between 8.65 and 8.8 :) |
 |
| -Aincrad- said: So it's just simple curiosity: do you think it's going to be good enough to get a score near 9? PS: please spare me from "MAL score means nothing" comments You want to be spared the truth? Garbage like Dororo is more highly rated than every season of AoT despite AoT being vastly superior in every aspect. Story wise, music, animation, voice acting, dialogue, etc. Make sense of that. Anyway the answer is no. There's a trend. None of the previous seasons have reached 8.5 so how sensible is it to assume it will score "near 9" |
tzarye14 said: Definitely not. I'm a big fan of the series but action alone doesn't carry a series on its own. This season does have the best moments of the story thus far in the anime but the basement itself is going to be divisive af. I expect some 1, 2 or 3/10 just because of the basement. What's wrong with the basement story? It reveals a lot and it's not boring (At least not as boring as uprising was.) If anything, the worst-received point will be the first episode which will be a bunch of guys lining up on a wall as the episode ends with the stare down. |
| im just so hyped i cant take it anymore.. this needs a 9+ or ill grind my eyes out |
nanidatosama97 said: SamHandwich said: What's wrong with the basement story? It reveals a lot and it's not boring (At least not as boring as uprising was.) If anything, the worst-received point will be the first episode which will be a bunch of guys lining up on a wall as the episode ends with the stare down. A few people quit just because the story changed and they didnt like how it went, although, the basement reveal IS a obvious story changer and they shoulda been prepared for that Hopefully it will grind out the rest from watching the series so when season 4 hits, most of them will be gone and only the folks that understand and appreciate where the story is going will watch it. But we all know snk has a dedicated hate base that will downvote it without even watching the remaining seasons. Skana said: I mean, is it really important for a show to have a high score? It is just in human nature, anything you like you will like to see it do well. |
| the first part of season 3 has been absolutely amazing. It reminded me why I fell in love with the series in the first place and expanded on it. Its like "remember watching that cool action anime? Now whitness how there is actually a grand plot as well" So I do hope the rest of season 3 lives up to it. |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
nanidatosama97 said: SamHandwich said: What's wrong with the basement story? It reveals a lot and it's not boring (At least not as boring as uprising was.) If anything, the worst-received point will be the first episode which will be a bunch of guys lining up on a wall as the episode ends with the stare down. A few people quit just because the story changed and they didnt like how it went, although, the basement reveal IS a obvious story changer and they shoulda been prepared for that I'd like to add that sometimes people just like to use the term "asspull" when something , for them unexpected, is happening. Even if it's totally on spot with the story being told. And some dumb people might just actually think about asspulls after the basement revelation. |
I don't think so. This spot is reserved only for masterpieces like Code Geass Season 2, not even NGE and Monster come close. MAL rating at its finest. |
| I will say it's hard, because people on MAL love to bitch about SNK and praise some overated stuff, but if those people stop being retarded, then yeah, it will 100% |
 |
| @nanidatosama97 Sorry for the late answer. As I'm not really sure anymore what you're talking about, I've just looked up the panel in volume 16. Truth be told, I still don't know what what you're on about since all I see in Rod's case is the syringe and a bottle.^^ Care to enlighten me? |
nanidatosama97 said: ArrRti said: @nanidatosama97 Sorry for the late answer. As I'm not really sure anymore what you're talking about, I've just looked up the panel in volume 16. Truth be told, I still don't know what what you're on about since all I see in Rod's case is the syringe and a bottle.^^ Care to enlighten me? The bottle then HAS to be the armor stuff, hes probably sucking that into the serum to allow hardening from historia Edit: Yeah, its the same bottle, just more detailed in the close up shot at the end of volume 16 Hm, so according to the SnK wiki, Rod has several serums with him, one of them being the "hardening serum" which is why Eren got hardening powers just like several other titan's we saw up to that point. Kinda like how people call eren getting hardening powers an asspull when the armor stuff was in the case with the serum Rod had? In that case I answer your question with a "yes" @Changelog Code Geass is my favourite anime so it's only natural I would want it to stay on top of others. even if it means another show has to suffer. Stuff like Kimi no Nawa and One Punch Man seriously do not deserve to be up there. Total cringe right here. |
| If mob didnt make it, neither will AoT |
 |
nanidatosama97 said: you do realise some abitrary scoring on MAL doesnt make any anime suffer? You seem to be pretty new here so I will just be very clear.changelog said: Code Geass is my favourite anime so it's only natural I would want it to stay on top of others. even if it means another show has to suffer. Stuff like Kimi no Nawa and One Punch Man seriously do not deserve to be up there. Thats the worst type of fanboy you can be, I get wanting it to do well, but I never want an anime to suffer just so my favorite can be on top, its fine its your favorite, but wishing for the failure of the other anime in the industry is basically asking for the animators to fail at their job, I HOPE you realize that assholish way of thinking. Nobody gives a shit about MAL scores. First and foremost anime is made for the japanese target group. Any international success beyond that point barely influences the "success" of an anime project, as income gets "lost" along the way and neither the author, nor the studio, nor the production commitee get anything from it in the end. If anything, popularity is far more important. And that doesnt has anything to do with the quality. So, no, AoT Season 3 Part 2 will not "suffer" if its score ends up below that of Code Geass. |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
nanidatosama97 said: I genuinely did not want to look like a smartass, but I do tend to become somewhat edgy around this time of day.@Comander-07 Thats something I already know, but I still dont agree with logs way of thinking, so I merely stated my thoughts. At first, you sounded like a smart-ass but I reread your post and realized that prolly wasnt your intention. The way he worded it he sounded like he wanted the other animes to fail in japan as well. Though I have to say, you certainly did not "merely state your thoughts". You insulted him as "the worst kind of fanboy you can be" and devalued his entire being by calling his "way of thinking assholish". |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
| The score will drop just like it did for the previous seasons, and the degenerates with multiple accounts are at fault. Nothing that can be done about that, just enjoy the series like usual. You will definitely enjoy this until they reach the basement. From there on, it's just about each and everyone's perspective. But imo, it only gets better afterwards, you'll see what i mean if you'll start reading the manga when this season is over or if you're patient enough to wait for the next season, which will most likely be the last one. Probably split in 2 parts as well, but who cares, as long as they do it by the book i'm down for waiting.. |
| tbh most likely not we do have a lot of people who dont like this series so |
| I think maybe 8.5 to 8.8 |
 |
| I’d like to say ‘yes’ but realistically speaking, it’ll probably just linger around the 8.60 mark and maybe 8.70 if Wit Studio manages to blow this outta the park, like with Season 1’s start for instance. For better or for worse, this franchise is super popular! As such, there’s a lot of haters or downvoters too. Besides, I’ve a feeling the revelations, after the fighting, will not really sit right with plenty of people so a 9.00 is very unlikely imo. I’d be happy and satisfied to see this in the 8.70-8.85 or so but probably even that is being too optimistic. Whatever the case, I’ll binge it after the 10 episodes will be out nevertheless even if the score somehow manages to hit the 9 from the get-go and that’s what’s important for me personally. |
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni  |
DupeusT31 said: Not even close. After the reveals by the end of the season the hate bandwagon will come crashing down with their genius argumentation like never before, saying nonsense like AoT is or that the reveal was an asspull. It's sad but I don't see this season scoring at the 8.60's after it's finished airing, even though it more than deserves it. how can someone even claim "asspull" especially with grishas backstory and all the references/foreshadowing AoT has throughout Season 1-3 o_O its beyond me xD |
poemofdevil said: -Aincrad- said: So it's just simple curiosity: do you think it's going to be good enough to get a score near 9? PS: please spare me from "MAL score means nothing" comments You want to be spared the truth? Garbage like Dororo is more highly rated than every season of AoT despite AoT being vastly superior in every aspect. Story wise, music, animation, voice acting, dialogue, etc. Make sense of that. Anyway the answer is no. There's a trend. None of the previous seasons have reached 8.5 so how sensible is it to assume it will score "near 9" Part 1 of season 3 was actually above an 8.5 for a good while after it had finished airing. |
 |
| It definitely has the potential based on the arc it's going to adapt and Wit studios amazing animation but there's definitely gonna be a bunch of salty idiots who downvote it. Oh well I don't care, it's one of the most popular anime and manga so it's guaranteed to get a complete adaptation. changelog said: nanidatosama97 said: Oof fanboy alert? Code geass having a good score should be enough for you you shouldnt hope for other animes to suffer just so your favorite can stay ontop Code Geass is my favourite anime so it's only natural I would want it to stay on top of others. even if it means another show has to suffer. Stuff like Kimi no Nawa and One Punch Man seriously do not deserve to be up there. You're judging the new season before it has even aired. You shouldn't get overly attached to one show that you hope no anime surpasses it. If anything, we as anime fans should hope that one day some anime comes that blows our expectations out of the water and becomes our new favorite anime. I agree on One Punch Man, I just don't see the appeal that made it so popular and highly rated. I liked Your Name, the animation was beautiful and the story was entertaining enough. It's not even in my top 10 but I do see how it can appeal to the masses. |
<Something> |
-InfiniteLoop- said: If anything, we as anime fans should hope that one day some anime comes that blows our expectations out of the water and becomes our new favorite anime. brilliantly said, this was yakusoku no neverland for me this year, havent heard of it before and after ep 1 aired, i got so engrossed with it that i read the entire thing within a day and it became one of my all time favourites |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 2, 2019 |
813 |
by Mluc
»»
Oct 11, 1:52 PM |
|
Poll: » What is your LEAST favorite episode?Enri_eu - Sep 25 |
6 |
by Rishabh_452
»»
Oct 7, 8:06 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 23, 2019 |
411 |
by graciana
»»
Oct 4, 6:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 9, 2019 |
417 |
by mateben
»»
Oct 4, 7:47 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Thorf - May 26, 2019 |
746 |
by Goxist
»»
Sep 21, 4:35 AM |