??
Yes it is
47.7%
948
Nope
52.3%
1,041
1,989 votes
| Yes but the same can be said about the majority of shows on MAL so it doesn't mean much. Nevertheless it's still the best non-sequel show this year. |
 |
| OP, that is for you to discuss. Not for us to decide. |
| Too soon to tell |
My Queens  |
| OPM manga is not overrated (the art is god tier). Anime? Probably. |
| Not even the best non-sequel show this season, it does get better but not for much (I read the manga), people are just surprised by the animation. I mean, I like it but it is not thaaaaat good. Overrated as fuck |
| idk barely 3 eps in, but considering it's only 12 eps it should start getting better soon. If you don't like the comedy than you're pretty much screwed, cause the action sequences we've seen so far are limited to the villian beating up on weaker people until saitama comes in, but atleast they're really well done. Genos is kind of cool though. It'd help if people stopped viewing it as a shonen-like series. |
 Oh maybe, maybe it's the clothes we wear The tasteless bracelets and the dye in our hair Or maybe, maybe it's our nowhere towns or our nothing places But we're trash, you and me We're the litter on the breeze We're the lovers on the streets Just trash, me and you It's in everything we do It's in everything we do |
| Oh and I forgot, License-less Rider alone will carry the show hard. |
| It's good, but nit that hype good. |
 |
| i personally hold much disdain for madhouse and its cult following but one punch man is definitely fantastic so far i wouldnt say its overrated/is undeserving of its score because well i like it and plenty of others do too. animation wise its great and the comedy is too. so stop being a pussy? |
| it's not a bad show, but yeah it's overrated. |
 |
ios said: its doing a great job especially on the animation side for a suppose to be action series with comedy in it if you do not like action anime then you will hate One Punch Man but if you like seeing eye candy action then you will love One Punch Man so to me it deserves it praise from all the action fans how about your OP do you think its overrated? I disagree with this, the way you look at it was pretty one dimmensional. You're basically saying if one likes action anime then they will like this. Not true. I and I've seen many as well in the one punch man anime discussion forum. Admit that the action scenes and ost is good. But the series overall lack substance, and that kills the entertainment factor, even if the action scenes and ost looks great. The story isn't interesting an the comedy is stale. What left is the action. The series story is nothing special, the comedy sucks. What that left us with is basically only the action and ost. Its like taking away the meat from the chicken leg, and leaving us with only the bone to chew on. That's one punch man for me. So yes, its highly overrated for me, but not a bad show. |
| One Punch Man is good and enjoyable, but not worth the hype |
 (っ◔◡◔)っ 𝓘 𝔀𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓸𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓯𝓾𝓵 𝓭𝓪𝔂 ♥ |
keragamming said: I disagree with this, the way you look at it was pretty one dimmensional. You're basically saying if one likes action anime then they will like this. Not true. I and I've seen many as well in the one punch man anime discussion forum. Admit that the action scenes and ost is good. But the series overall lack substance, and that kills the entertainment factor, even if the action scenes and ost looks great. The story isn't interesting an the comedy is stale. What left is the action. The series story is nothing special, the comedy sucks. What that left us with is basically only the action and ost. Its like taking away the meat from the chicken leg, and leaving us with only the bone to chew on. That's one punch man for me. So yes, its highly overrated for me, but not a bad show. And what type of "substance" are you expecting from a parody anime? The story also hasn't even started yet. These 3 past episodes were only an introduction for the characters and the type of world that Saitama lives in. The 4th episode will adapt the Paradise Group chapters and introduce the second to last important character for this anime. It's after this that it'll get more serious with the Heroes Association arc and even then it doesn't even compare to the currently ongoing arc in the manga. OPM, unlike most shows this season, is actually spending some time to properly introduce through showing what they're like instead of spending 5 minutes at the beginning of the first episode to infodump on who the characters are before sending them straight into the story. After all this show lives or dies depending on how much you like the characters. As for the comedy, I can't even see how it could be considered stale since it's not repetitive at all. Heck the idea of the show is pretty original, coupled with the at times random and unforeseeable comedy scenes makes it anything but stale. Like people said, it's way too soon to say anything about the show since the best parts have yet to come. |
|
| It's the best one of this fall, so I'd say no. |
| Yeah its score is inflated by its massive fan base at the moment. Nearly an 8.70 with only 3 episodes in, lol. Its been quite good so far but that is a tad over rated. If it continues like this there will probably be back lash like there was for AoT and NGNL. |
I think both of you are right, it's too soon. The only thing I know is the "weight "of its richness is originated by secondary characters. The MC is pretty inactive...he is driven by the plot. I hope it change in a near future. |
DuskSunDawnOct 21, 2015 12:02 AM
 |
| @"Kruzy and ios" The main thing about OPM its the comedy and I'm so far not enjoying it, there's some parts here and there that made me chuckled a bit, but overall I found it to be stale. The latest episode was also the worst episode so far for this series. I'm not looking for some great story or anything. But at least give me something, since the comedy part isn't doing it for me. But since Kruzy said the story hasn't even started yet, and will supposedly get "better" then some hope is still left for this series. You both said it will get more interesting in later episode, so I'll sit back and see what happens. Who knows, I'll maybe even become a big fan of the series when the series ends. But for now, with these 3 episodes currently release. Hell no. I don't think anything is wrong in speaking out on what I think of the series so far, just like how a lot of people are praising the first 3 episodes so far. |
| It's currently overrated for a very simple reason. There is no valid reason to rank # 44 an anime when only 25% of it has been aired. After 3 episodes, that's just plain ridiculous. it may deserve or not this place after being finished airing, but currently, it doesn't. |
 |
Zefyris said: It's currently overrated for a very simple reason. There is no valid reason to rank # 44 an anime when only 25% of it has been aired. After 3 episodes, that's just plain ridiculous. it may deserve or not this place after being finished airing, but currently, it doesn't. It had about an hour of airtime, which isn't exactly nothing and more importantly so far it's been very formulaic, almost following a monster of the week approach. If it's possible to rate shorts which last less, I'd say it's fair to rate OPM as well. |
| 5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
Zefyris said: It's currently overrated for a very simple reason. There is no valid reason to rank # 44 an anime when only 25% of it has been aired. After 3 episodes, that's just plain ridiculous. it may deserve or not this place after being finished airing, but currently, it doesn't. We don't rank the whole anime, MAl ask how many episode we have seen and the rank for them. |
Zefyris said: It's currently overrated for a very simple reason. There is no valid reason to rank # 44 an anime when only 25% of it has been aired. After 3 episodes, that's just plain ridiculous. it may deserve or not this place after being finished airing, but currently, it doesn't. Meanwhile the currently airing Gintama is on rank 4 and Haikyuu!! S2 is on rank 15. It's a flaw with MAL's system and not just OPM. |
|
| I haven't seen anything in these 3 episode that would make me believe it should even be near the top 100 so yes it is for now. |
Kruzy said: Zefyris said: It's currently overrated for a very simple reason. There is no valid reason to rank # 44 an anime when only 25% of it has been aired. After 3 episodes, that's just plain ridiculous. it may deserve or not this place after being finished airing, but currently, it doesn't. Meanwhile the currently airing Gintama is on rank 4 and Haikyuu!! S2 is on rank 15. It's a flaw with MAL's system and not just OPM. It's just eveybody don't have the same taste as you. |
Guilek said: It's just eveybody don't have the same taste as you. It's not about taste. OPM is one of my favorite manga and I consider it to be the best non-sequel anime this year but airing anime shouldn't be in the top anime list unless they're long running shows. |
|
| rating can change a lot since only 3 episodes aired so far.. its early to say overrated or not |
| As long as it's Madhouse pure madhouse and VAP no it's not. |
 CLICK ME! |
Kruzy said: Guilek said: It's just eveybody don't have the same taste as you. It's not about taste. OPM is one of my favorite manga and I consider it to be the best non-sequel anime this year but airing anime shouldn't be in the top anime list unless they're long running shows. That's your opinions and others think the same. Me I think it deserved it and others think the same, it's why it have a good ranking. MAL ask how many episode, we have seen, and we rank the episode we have seen. And ranking don't matters a lot anyways. |
Guilek said: That's your opinions and others think the same. Me I think it deserved it and others think the same, it's why it have a good ranking. MAL ask how many episode, we have seen, and we rank the episode we have seen. And ranking don't matters a lot anyways. It's not about whether it deserves the score or not. It's that airing anime shouldn't be allowed in the "Top Anime" list. I also think that OPM deserves the rating far more than most series in the top 100 but that is irrelevant. It's fine to rate anime that is still ongoing, I do it myself but they should only be listed in the "Top Airing" category. |
|
| No,but the manga is even better. |
| Well I like it so who cares |
 |
| Since OPM is considered "popular" and people who think it is overrated generally dislike it, while people who do not think it is overrated generally like it, this thread is really nothing more than asking "are you (the vocal people) liking it or not?" What a pointless thread. |
 |
| This thread is overrated Kruzy said: Well as long as you're actually aware of the fact that it's still airing you can just take the numbers with a grain of salt since it's only temporary anywayGuilek said: That's your opinions and others think the same. Me I think it deserved it and others think the same, it's why it have a good ranking. MAL ask how many episode, we have seen, and we rank the episode we have seen. And ranking don't matters a lot anyways. It's not about whether it deserves the score or not. It's that airing anime shouldn't be allowed in the "Top Anime" list. I also think that OPM deserves the rating far more than most series in the top 100 but that is irrelevant. It's fine to rate anime that is still ongoing, I do it myself but they should only be listed in the "Top Airing" category. |
  |
| Nah, not in my opinion...and boy do i hate the word 'overrated'...people start arguing over what is and isn't when there's no right or wrong, it's all a matter of opinion |
MichaelMyers100Oct 21, 2015 9:31 PM
| Why every hyped anime is considered overrated?, only 3 episodes are aired and people are already losing the head for it. |
 |
HaXXspetten said: Well as long as you're actually aware of the fact that it's still airing you can just take the numbers with a grain of salt since it's only temporary anyway True that but way too many people get bothered by them and there's really no need for airing anime with only a couple episodes to be in the top list. Pretty similar to the shit that happened when MAL allowed anime that didn't air yet on the top list. |
|
| Ah, the good ol "overrated" thread. Created, removed and here it is again People who love it will say yes, people who don't like it very much will say no and I will say, who the fuck cares. Let's just go to the point. Nothing is overrated! If a show have an mean score, being high or low, it means the big majority of people love it or hate it respectively, so, no matter your opinion as an individual, a show is never underrated or overrated. It's all the majority opinions There are shows I simply don't like on the top anime list on mal, however I never even once called any of them overrated. It's just not of my liking Let me just enjoy the show, goddamit xD |
Veldin461Oct 21, 2015 11:34 AM
Imaishi said: mayukachan said: What is then? Gundam: Iron Blooded Orphans I agree given what's aired so far. It could go either way though. OT: OPM has been pretty good so far, but it does feel overhyped. |
| NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO noooooooooo nope..... This definitely naive answer but at least thats what I thought (〜￣△￣)〜 |
 |
Kruzy said: Yes but the same can be said about the majority of shows on MAL so it doesn't mean much. Nevertheless it's still the best non-sequel show this year. it won't get a sequel?! |
| what i dont understand is ppl recently have used the argument that overpowered MCs are boring, bad, not well written. examples are in mahouka threads. more specifically its a criticism used in harem battle type anime with overpowered mcs. but when u have something like opm it gets praised as something spectacular. all im saying is ppl are praising this anime for a number of reasons that makes them hate other anime. |
| It been called numerous times that all hype comes from the manga readers. Second season of Haikyuu is on the 15 place. You can now say - It is a second season, so it is understandable. And OPM is on top 50. And this called high for a new series. And why is such popularity? Like i mentioned before - all hype comes from the manga readers (especially, Murata's version). If you read his version - it is a anime in the manga form. Because of that, anime is close to a second season form. Some new moments is a nice fanservice, but, basically manga is just like a full script for a anime. |
 |
moodie said: what i dont understand is ppl recently have used the argument that overpowered MCs are boring, bad, not well written. examples are in mahouka threads. more specifically its a criticism used in harem battle type anime with overpowered mcs. but when u have something like opm it gets praised as something spectacular. all im saying is ppl are praising this anime for a number of reasons that makes them hate other anime. Hypocrisy is madhouse fanboys trademark |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Dec 6, 2015 |
455 |
by mabuchi10
»»
Oct 12, 6:37 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 25, 2015 |
345 |
by SHS13
»»
Oct 8, 1:03 AM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Mills - Oct 17, 2015 |
441 |
by SHS13
»»
Oct 7, 4:08 AM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Nov 1, 2015 |
456 |
by kerimdeve54
»»
Sep 12, 12:40 PM |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Dec 20, 2015 |
1009 |
by Jinx_Araragi
»»
Sep 3, 10:30 PM |