| "Special score" lmfao. It doesn't matter. |
| Frankly speaking, I don't like a list with tons of 10 because it would mean that u enjoy every third anime but it's MYANIMELIST for a reason so it doesn't matter much. |
  |
| What's wrong with it? Unless you are in a position where people actually look up to your opinions nobody will really care nor be bothered to look at your scorings |
| i do agree that 10/10s are special and should be reserved for those special animes that really mean something to you but it doesn't have to be an "objective masterpiece" (if one even exists lmfao). if you think it deserves it then go ahead. if you also rate every anime a 10/10 then i dont really care either. I'm not gonna force you into rating an anime lmao. |
 |
| I think it’s very fair because enjoyment should be the main criteria for rating a anime although I would not give something a 10/10 even if it was the most enjoyable show I ever watched if it it doesn’t impact me in anyway. Grand blue manga is a 11/10 in terms of enjoyment for me and I find Yokohama kaideshi kikkou flawless in every way but I would still give both a 9.5 because it didn’t have a major emotional or thought provoking impact on me. On the other hand even with its many flaws,I would give a silent voice a perfect 10 for me because of the influence it had on me and how it changed my life. |
| All my ratings are based in enjoyment. If I rate something a 10 then I just really like it, nothing more nothing less. |
 |
| nothinhg wrong with it. it s honestly pretty common. each one of us has their own way of understanding things so yea it's should be ifne to give animes a 10 when u think it deserves it |
 |
| There's nothing wrong with it. This is MyAnimeList after all. |
 |
| Scores are always subjective as i have no justification for why i gave TTGL 10 i just enjoyed it too damn much. |
| 2025 might be the year where I will be happy. This year is not happy year. |
| The word "masterpiece" is a subjective one anyway, so if you liked the anime a lot then it actually could be a masterpiece, at least to you, and it's your list so that's all that matters. For me giving an anime a 10/10 means that not only did I enjoy it a lot when I watched it, but I continue to think about it a lot and I felt a deep connection to it. They are all anime I really enjoyed, but there's extra requirements for them to be a 10. You don't have to do it this way, though. As long as everyone looking at your list knows what it means for you to give an anime a 10 then it's all good. |
  |
| And those people who say it are retards. What is a "true 10/10"? Its a proven fact not everyone(Yes, not even people who believe they are "objectively rating")rates the same animes a 10/10. We have people who consider Eva to be a "objective masterpiece". Same with Attack on titan, Steins;gate, and literally every anime you can find that has atleast a 7+ score you will find atleast 1 person who thinks its an "objective masterpiece". And to say "what I think is completely correct" even though others also think the same yet disagree, is pretty pretentious. So to answer your question OP. There is nothing wrong with rating an anime you enjoy a 10/10. Why? Because first off, every anime technically has a "flaw" according to what the majority considers a "flaw". People will tend to find more "flaws" in an anime they don't enjoy over an anime they do enjoy, which doesn't mean that the anime they enjoy is "objectively better". Since anyone with a working brain knows enjoyment is subjective. People are able to find more problems with an anime they dislike because they have more problems with it than someone who actually enjoys it. I kinda find it funny how people also try to say "You can enjoy something but that doesn't make it good!!!" The point im trying to get across is that just because you like something and think liking it is the "correct opinion" doesn't mean someone else will see that same anime, dislike, and explain their problems with it that they have simply because they didn't enjoy it. No ones opinion is more "factual" than any others. So most of the time, people are rating on enjoyment in the first place. |
| I gave up on character of the week since it takes too much thinking. I'll just change my forum pfp to whoever I want every week lol. |
| i don't care lol but sometimes i snicker when i see people who rate recent trashy harem anime with 10/10 |
 |
| WELL! that's how I base my ratings of the show. Unless you want to be very critical, I think it's completely fine. |
| This is exactly what I do, and some randos from Twitter will not make me stop |
| "If the cuckoo doesn't sing, I guess I'm fine with that." - Natsuki Andou, Kitaku-bu Katsudou Kiroku |
| I thought score system is for this??? If I should give scores about realisation, no feelings then for sure I shouldn't even give 10 Shelter, Petshop of Horrors or Dogs: Bullets & Carnage yet I don't reget this decision, FOR ME they're worth it. |
| I wouldn't do that but other people are free to if they like. besides, even though I don't rate solely based off of enjoyment, it is without a doubt a factor in mine and everyone else's ratings. I mean, like all entertainment media, anime exists to be enjoyed. |
 |
| I think you can kind of get away with giving everything you enjoyed 10/10 if you only watched a few anime. With more titles, you'll come across a lot of enjoyable shows and to give all of them 10s would just make the rating lose value |
 |
| By giving a 10/10 that means the anime either was meaningful to me in a personal way or that I've enjoyed it to my heart's content. Even in my favorite anime, I acknowledge its imperfections and the gaps it might have, but the pros outweigh the cons. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
| Easy and simple answer 10/10 : amazing anime and perfect adaptation 1/10 : worst and overrated anime and also poor adaptation |
| You can if you want, who is stopping you. People and have differing opinions and it's ok. |
   Has a 8.60 mean score Akasaka > Other Mangakas  |
| Taking advice from twitter is like asking the toilet's opinion before taking a shit. Fuck twitter. Rate anime how you like. In my eyes the basis for all rating is dependent on your level of enjoyment. There is no such thing as objective rating. People are idiots. Fly free and rate how you like. |
-Ecliptix-Aug 9, 2021 3:06 PM
| People can do whatever they want, sure, but that doesn't change the fact that the way they score are incorrect. And honestly, the community only loses by doing that imo. |
 |
| If ya can't give your favorite anime a 10 then what's the point of scoring anime at all. |
| Enjoyment over all Although I DO think are some things that are objectively good or bad in a Show. |
 |
| Your rating system is just that - yours! It's meant to be personal, it's meant to be subjective. Personally, I rarely give out 10/10. In my opinion, giving every show that I simply enjoy a top score, isn't really a great way to judge a show. I have varying levels of enjoyment based of things like story, plot, writing, art style, music and emotion. There are some shows that I really enjoyed, but only give them a 7/10 because they're not hitting the marks the same way a 10/10 show would. But again, this is just the way I like to rate shows. |
 |
| I don't see what's wrong with that. A lot of shows I score 10/10 are shows I really enjoy watching; regardless of the story. |
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
| I honestly don’t see a problem with it. People should be allowed to rate it however they want. |
| people rate anime the way they want to. there's no general way to rate anime. |
  โโโโโโโ  โโโโโโโ |
| Just rate how you want and be honest with yourself when rating |
| as much as i love twitter, anitwitter is just full of accounts that repost tweets about mainstream anime. you shouldn't let a random person dictate how you rate scores. Some of my favorite anime are given a 10 because i enjoyed it on top of it being good (quality standards). That's how I rate sometimes and it has helped me reflect on how I rate other anime |
  ๐ถ๐๐๐๐๐๐, ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ ๐๐  » [๐ถ๐๐ ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ ๐๐๐๐] « ๐ถ:๐ถ๐ถ ใโโโโโโ ๐พ:๐ท๐ฟ โบ |โ II โท| โก |
| I give 10s to animes that are in my favorites and ones I incredibly enjoyed a lot, even if I can't say their a favorite of mine. Honestly its your rating system and your preference, don't let others tell you how to rate your animes. Everyone should be able to give a rating of their own Anitwitter is just a plague that you should be avoiding. Watch them milk the next big mainstream shounen anime (2019 KnY, 2020 JJK, 2021 Tokyo Revengers) their opinions shouldn't even affect you. |
 |
| That's an entirely subjective matter. I personally do not give 2 seperate fucks about objectivity and will not rate based on it. If it feels like a 10, it feels like a 10. |
  tysm iva-๐ข๐ |
| There is no objective measure on which to rate and score art. Almost nothing is objective. You can say cowboy bebop was created by so and so and first aired on x date, those are objective facts. However it is not “objectively” good, nothing is. Art you like varies from person to person and highly depends on a wide array of different factors. Therefore, judging based on enjoyment is really the only way to score anything. |
Just the sort of brainless sentimentality I'd expect from you. |
| People can rate their anime list however they want it doesn't affect me and why should I tell someone else how to rate their anime. Also yeah enjoyment plays a major in what score you give anything that's the point. I would rather someone give everything high scores than someone who just shits on everything. Also I hate Twitter. |
| Subjectively correct. Anyone who disagrees blatantly is not aware of the term opinion ;P |
| I mean when you're scoring an anime, you have to base it off your enjoyment? How else would you? |
| My opinion is that I will continue to give 10/10s if I want to when I want to. What are they going to do about it? |
 Life is a despicable endurance race |
| if someone wants to rate anime solely on enjoyment, who am i to judge? it's not the way i do it, but it's perfectly valid. it's your ranking system, do as you like. |
 blockberry creative will pay for its crimes |
More topics from this board
» Waifu War V5 (Anniversary-Edition!) (Round 1) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )TheMinkalex - Sep 28 |
296 |
by Sensual_Yuri_69
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» "We have (this series) at home" anime. (Cheaper, budget versions of other more popular anime)TheBlockernator - Aug 1 |
47 |
by Ihatefatbitches
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Fate series anime ruined Kotomine Kirei's characterswirlydragon - Yesterday |
12 |
by Ihatefatbitches
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Do you have any "Near Favorites"? (Anime that almost made your favorites but just miss out)TheBlockernator - 6 hours ago |
8 |
by WaterMage
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» ๐ Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 )nirererin - Oct 9 |
114 |
by WaterMage
»»
11 minutes ago |