Favorte genre's(If your gonna recommend me anime, recommend me anime with these genre's/demographics): Seinen, romance, Isekai, Slice of life, apocalyptic(if thats a thing)
Before checking my list. Check how I rate anime right below this sentence. This is so you dont get triggered by my "horrible taste"
I rate based off enjoyment and what I consider good quality. Basically I put in the tags section how much I enjoyed it when I watched it first. Then in the main rating I put the rating I think it should get based off the qualities.
Animes like Neon Genesis Evangelion aren't final ratings. As I didn't understand them at all so I plan to rewatch them soon. My rating may or may not change.
Now, this is how I rate anime for each rating:
10- In order to get this rating I need to: have an enjoyment rating of 10, and a normal rating of 10. This anime has a special place in my heart and I can name a lot of things I like about it.
10 Enjoyment- This anime is perfect for me. I enjoyed it so much I cannot see anything that I would consider bad with it. Not a single thing I would change. Unforgettable.
9- I like the plot, characters, and setting. Either didn't enjoy enough to rate a 10, or just didn't think it was a 10.
9 Enjoyment- Enjoyed enough to binge watch. Loved everything from the characters to the plot, setting and story. Never a moment I felt bored. High chance of post anime depression.
8- Thought the characters and plot were good, but had too many things missing for me to give it a 9.
8 Enjoyment- Also enjoyed enough to binge watch. Might've gotten post anime depression. I can easily find stuff that I didn't like but that didn't affect my enjoyment much, as I can mention more stuff that I did like.
7- Thought it had good aspects, but way too many things wrong with it.
7 Enjoyment- Enjoyed the anime but nothing more. Wont give me post anime depression, and is probably gonna be forgotten.
6- A big gap between the 6 and 7. Any anime I rate a 6 I dont think its mid. But it has a shit ton of flaws that I can easiliy find.
6 enjoyment- Not bland enough to be considered "mid" but not good enough to be considered good. Right inbetween.
5- Has to be boring and I have to be able to find reasons why its boring to get this rating. But also has to have moments that make up for it being boring.
5 enjoyment- Feels like a chore to watch, but some enjoyable moments.
4- Most of the time these are animes that I can do a whole rant on why I think they are shit.
4 enjoyment- I either cringed a lot watching or was pretty bored. But a plot good enough.
3- Has incredible pacing issues, nothing happened, or has a shit plot.
3 enjoyment- Doesn't make sense to me or a anime that loses my attention quickly. Could possible be insanely boring close to unwatchable.
2- The entire anime must be a shitfest, not shitty enough for a 1 but still shit.
2 enjoyment-This is very hard to get from me. But in order to get a 2 from me the anime must be: Insanely boring to the point of almost dropping it. Didn't understand the story at all. Or the characters. Felt the characters were bland or worse than bland, or was cringy.
1- I can find so many things wrong with the anime that Japan themselves with ask for the anime to get banned.
1 enjoyment- To get this rating I have to enjoy talking shit about the anime. The anime has to be so bad I celebrate when finishing it. I cringe every second of the show and hate all the characters.
So thats how I rate anime. Remember all of this is my opinion, so there is no "wrong". If you get offended get your ass out of here.
This list is from top priority to low priority.
Basically the number 1 spot would mean im gonna rewatch that before the number 2 spot.
1. Attack on titan season4(Ep 2-5)
2. Neon genesis Evangelion
1# Attack On Titan
#4 A silent voice
#5 Fate series
#9 Vinland saga
#10 Violet Evergarden
(May replace Violet evergarden with Re:Zero if Re:Zero season 2 part 2 is really good. I wont replace Violet evergarden with Re:Zero if the Violet Evergarden movies are really good.
Keep in mind this list will most likely be updated when I watch more anime. But so far this is it.