papachulu said: Well, that says a lot about today's generation, same with gamers. Fancy graphics/directing and suddenly it's the best ever!! best of the year etc, even if a story is average. Don't be salty your favorite Japanese cartoon isn't given the same attention luv. You sound like a boomer. |
 |
| More than 750 votes is too high of a cutoff. Think of it this way, most KnY episodes don't even meet have more than 500 votes. 750+ votes would only include the most newer popular anime or episodes that have garnered an immense amount of viewers. Even a popular series like Death Note only has like 2 episodes that meet the requirement. Cutoff should be more like 100-150 to add the niche, but well-deserving titles in the list. |
 |
Tohsaka_Rukia said: The episode also impact the general score for KnY. I remember just a few days ago it was 8.56 and now it has gone up to 8.61. I just noticed it has a higher score than Vinland Saga and the controversial Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation (can we take minute to appreciate this title, by the way?) but is still at 2nd spot in the Top Airing anime. Is this a bug or has it just not updated yet? GoldenDevilGamer said: That'd make it too easy to abuse IMO. Haven't you seen the latest FMA vs SnK dick measuring contest? It wouldn't take much for a small fanbase to create those fake accounts and take the entire list for themselves.Cutoff should be more like 100-150 to add the niche, but well-deserving titles in the list. |
AnotherGuyAug 12, 2019 10:23 AM
Tohsaka_Rukia said: The episode also impact the general score for KnY. I remember just a few days ago it was 8.56 and now it has gone up to 8.61. Actually, before this episode, the score was 8.51 Since then, it has already went up to 8.61 The same thing's happening that did to SnK when episode 5 had aired Its score was like 9.04 IIRC, and after episode 5,it went up to 9.19 in a few days, and it blew up the internet, everyone was talking about that episode And that's what's happening to KnY now too The whole anime community is talking about it, people can't stop praising the anime and the studio I think KnY's score won't stop until 8.7, thanks to this episode That's how much such a godlike episode can influence the overall opinion of the show of people I'm not different either, it was a 9/10 for me until episode 19, after that I'd immediately changed it to 10/10, because I'd realized this is a real masterpiece |
-Aincrad-Aug 12, 2019 10:49 AM
 |
AnotherGuy said: Tohsaka_Rukia said: The episode also impact the general score for KnY. I remember just a few days ago it was 8.56 and now it has gone up to 8.61. I just noticed it has a higher score than Vinland Saga and the controversial Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation (can we take minute to appreciate this title, by the way?) but is still at 2nd spot in the Top Airing anime. Is this a bug or has it just not updated yet? Lol no kidding it's my first time knowing the English translation since I mostly refer to it as that Chinese anime. I've been planning on watching it for some time now. I think it just hasn't been updated yet. -Aincrad- said: Tohsaka_Rukia said: The episode also impact the general score for KnY. I remember just a few days ago it was 8.56 and now it has gone up to 8.61. Actually, before this episode, the score was 8.51 Since then, it has already went up to 8.61 The same thing's happening that did to SnK when episode 5 had aired Its score was like 9.04 IIRC, and after episode 5,it went up to 9.19 in a few days, and it blew up the internet, everyone was talking about that episode And that's what's happening to KnY now too The whole anime community is talking about it, people can't stop praising the anime and the studio I think KnY's score won't stop until 8.7, thanks to this episode That's how much such a godlike episode can influence the overall opinion of the show of people I'm not different either, it was a 9/10 for me until episode 19, after that I'd immediately changed it to 10/10, because I'd realized this is a real masterpiece Even better then since it's a bigger jump. Oh definitely. I've been browsing Twitter and Facebook and everyone's sharing a clip of that fight scene. Sasuga ufotable. I think the studio was overwhelmed of all the positive reactions since they took the time to thank everyone for the support. It has always been a 10/10 for me. I tried reading the manga because of the anime and I can definitely say this is one of those anime that transcends its source material. That alone is a big plus for me. I hope they can keep this quality for the rest of the season and of course the inevitable 2nd season. |
|
AnotherGuy said: Even if the cutoff was higher, the upvoting/downvoting would be the same. Lowering the cutoff would simply allow for more niche titles like 3-gatsu, Gintama or LOTGH to make it into the list. One could argue that since these series have a low vote count, they could easily get upvoted faster. But even if the cutoff was 750 instead of 150, no one's stopping these people just making alt account to make up 750+ votes. In short, lowering the cutoff won't affect the upvoting/downvoting. Instead, increasing the cutoff could cause more alt accounts to be make to made to pass the cutoff.Tohsaka_Rukia said: The episode also impact the general score for KnY. I remember just a few days ago it was 8.56 and now it has gone up to 8.61. I just noticed it has a higher score than Vinland Saga and the controversial Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation (can we take minute to appreciate this title, by the way?) but is still at 2nd spot in the Top Airing anime. Is this a bug or has it just not updated yet? GoldenDevilGamer said: That'd make it too easy to abuse IMO. Haven't you seen the latest FMA vs SnK dick measuring contest? It wouldn't take much for a small fanbase to create those fake accounts and take the entire list for themselves.Cutoff should be more like 100-150 to add the niche, but well-deserving titles in the list. |
|
-Aincrad- said: Err no, that was by the end of it. If you want the full progression then it's:Tohsaka_Rukia said: The episode also impact the general score for KnY. I remember just a few days ago it was 8.56 and now it has gone up to 8.61. Actually, before this episode, the score was 8.51 Since then, it has already went up to 8.61 The same thing's happening that did to SnK when episode 5 had aired Its score was like 9.04 IIRC, and after episode 5,it went up to 9.19 in a few days, and it blew up the internet, everyone was talking about that episode Week 01 - 9.12 Week 02 - 9.06 (-0.06) Week 03 - 9.04 (-0.02) Week 04 - 9.05 (+0.01) Week 05 - 9.10 (+0.05) Week 06 - 9.15 (+0.05) Week 07 - 9.16 (+0.01) Week 08 - 9.17 (+0.01) Week 09 - 9.19 (+0.02) Week 10 - 9.16 (-0.03) then the FMA:B bug happened shortly thereafter mind you but that's a different story |
  |
HaXXspetten said: It's somewhat wrong I think(not completely though) as I remember episode 5 took the ratings to 9.11 not 9.10 whereas there are other things too which aren't completely right.-Aincrad- said: Err no, that was by the end of it. If you want the full progression then it's:Actually, before this episode, the score was 8.51 Since then, it has already went up to 8.61 The same thing's happening that did to SnK when episode 5 had aired Its score was like 9.04 IIRC, and after episode 5,it went up to 9.19 in a few days, and it blew up the internet, everyone was talking about that episode Week 01 - 9.12 Week 02 - 9.06 (-0.06) Week 03 - 9.04 (-0.02) Week 04 - 9.05 (+0.01) Week 05 - 9.10 (+0.05) Week 06 - 9.15 (+0.05) Week 07 - 9.16 (+0.01) Week 08 - 9.17 (+0.01) Week 09 - 9.19 (+0.02) Week 10 - 9.16 (-0.03) then the FMA:B bug happened shortly thereafter mind you but that's a different story |
| Should I troll in the troll bait threads? It is kinda idiotic to be logical in the troll bait threads. Well, it will depend on my mood. |
puneetsingh said: This is all recorded about 48 hours after each episode aired. This is what MSP does for a living so I’m pretty sure it’s correct. Just that sometimes it’ll spill over to the next episode update if further score changes comes later during the weekHaXXspetten said: It's somewhat wrong I think(not completely though) as I remember episode 5 took the ratings to 9.11 not 9.10 whereas there are other things too which aren't completely right.Err no, that was by the end of it. If you want the full progression then it's: Week 01 - 9.12 Week 02 - 9.06 (-0.06) Week 03 - 9.04 (-0.02) Week 04 - 9.05 (+0.01) Week 05 - 9.10 (+0.05) Week 06 - 9.15 (+0.05) Week 07 - 9.16 (+0.01) Week 08 - 9.17 (+0.01) Week 09 - 9.19 (+0.02) Week 10 - 9.16 (-0.03) then the FMA:B bug happened shortly thereafter mind you but that's a different story Only exception is the last episode which was updated a few weeks after the anime ended in order to give people more time to catch up to the show. Though it was still before the downvote race started |
| |
HaXXspetten said: After ep. 10 score was stable and according to 1/5 rule Aot score went to 9.23 and then came back to 9.16 as you said after few weeks time. The list is true to a certain point but somewhat untrue also.puneetsingh said: This is all recorded about 48 hours after each episode aired. This is what MSP does for a living so I’m pretty sure it’s correct. Just that sometimes it’ll spill over to the next episode update if further score changes comes later during the weekIt's somewhat wrong I think(not completely though) as I remember episode 5 took the ratings to 9.11 not 9.10 whereas there are other things too which aren't completely right. Only exception is the last episode which was updated a few weeks after the anime ended in order to give people more time to catch up to the show. Though it was still before the downvote race started |
| Should I troll in the troll bait threads? It is kinda idiotic to be logical in the troll bait threads. Well, it will depend on my mood. |
| https://mobile.twitter.com/ufotable/status/1161145710995099648 So beautiful to see such things! Ufotable really appreciates the outpouring of positive comments, keep it up guys and thank you from my side too! |
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni  |
| This episode was really well put together, anyone who can't acknowledge that fact and insist calling it derogatory names are complete attention seeking trolls or just plain haters with nothing better to do. You'll see some of them try to eloquently rationalize their hollier than thou contrarian choice. |
| "Manga readers are annoying, all they do is complain or spoil the anime we discuss in an anime forum. They should really do their whining at manga forums. USERS ON MY IGNORED LIST: RayReynolds - SSL443 - Dr4kon - Nerdanimefan1992 - ToTheMountains - Fiveskies To add users to the Ignore list: (1) Go to Account settings (2) Click Forum tab and toggle down (3) Type or paste user name on entry box (4) Click Add and you're done. Problem solved, you'll never have to see someone trolling ever again because their post will be closed/collapsed. |
Janethan23 said: I think it's more that some people are more easily won over by good animation whereas others would like something more... substantial I guess? Not that I've seen Yaiba but I've experienced similar responses with other anime like Mob Psycho II a few months back in somewhat similar scenariosThis episode was really well put together, anyone who can't acknowledge that fact and insist calling it derogatory names are complete attention seeking trolls or just plain haters with nothing better to do. You'll see some of them try to eloquently rationalize their hollier than thou contrarian choice. |
| |
Tohsaka_Rukia said: papachulu said: Well, that says a lot about today's generation, same with gamers. Fancy graphics/directing and suddenly it's the best ever!! best of the year etc, even if a story is average. Don't be salty your favorite Japanese cartoon isn't given the same attention luv. You sound like a boomer. Where in that comment did you get the impression they was salty? They was pointing out something they noticed in general. |
on 
kowaidesune said: My question is, can ufotable even afford to make another season of this XD. This quality comes with a price. Ufotable don't release 20 anime per year *coughjcstaffcough* so they can probably afford it |
| @mafd12 How the balls does FranXX have- ...never mind, thanks anyway lol |
| |
mafd12 said: I mean considering how much of a shitstorm FranXX caused within the anime community in general and how polarising it was, I'm just surprised any episode of it could reach that level of universal approvalMaybe an aftermath of those weeks when MAL wasn't active xD, I don't know really. Being fair, that was a good episode, one of the few from FranXX. |
| |
| I do think it's probably more fair to have a cutoff point at something like 750 votes instead of 1000 though. Obviously you can't go too low but I swear it's almost impossible finding any anime that qualifies if it aired in 2010 or earlier otherwise Although I guess if I did that then the amount of entries on the list would probably multiply tenfold so that seems like a lot of work :c |
| |
| the score is too high for the first season,next season will be 2 full points better,almost everything on mal is 2 points above or even more the score it deserves,for now this season is a 6.5 imo,this episode was really good. |
Only_Brad said: yeah but it's not really a power up,he didn't become stronger or faster he just used a new breath technique and caught rui by surprise and won only because nezuko blood fire,it's not that now he can use this new technique everytime,his body and breath aren't trained enough and honestly i've never seen a "power up" done better than this,this episode is a good 7/10.There's nothing special about this episode. Near death situation => flashback => power up It's literally Shounen 101. It just came with good animation, that's it. |
nanashi796Aug 14, 2019 2:34 AM
Samoan said: Yeah i agree with you! I hope they will anounce about the next season right after the first one finished xDkowaidesune said: i think yes since they dont adapte a lot of anime look at fate serie they make a lot of season with qualityMy question is, can ufotable even afford to make another season of this XD. This quality comes with a price. |
| People are still saying "it's just good graphics?" SMH, seriously the soundtrack, the pacing, the voice acting, all of these things that come together to make an amazing emotional experience are non-factors? I think it's not a matter of everyone else jumping on the bandwagon for "just graphics", but rather Edge Lords tossing their edgy comments just because the plot is generic shounen. What's wrong with a generic shounen when it is executed to this level of perfection? People need to stop being edgy for edge's sake. |
Lel0uchZer0 said: Gorochu said: It seems like as of today, Kimetsu no Yaiba has the highest percentage of 5/5 voted by fans with 97.7%. Congratulation. The other closest episode is Clannad After Story episode 18. However, Kimetsu no Yaiba has higher voting samples, over 3k as of today. Here are the rest of the best single episode rated which I found thanks to this thread which I linked below. Episode 19 stand above the rest. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1629889 Not anymore haha. Clannad took over Anyway the top is bs No way it was anywhere nesr episodes like Code geass R2 ep 25 Steins gate ep 23 Attack on titan s3p2 ep 5 and 6 You know, if you didn't add that "haha", I would just think "oh fine, this guy just posted a fact, that it's not the highest rated anymore, and mentioned some others he liked much better, fine, nothing wrong with that." But with that, I can't stop thinking that you're either a stupid brat, or a hater, or both I'm not saying you are, but you really left an impression like that on me |
|
| I dont know how but i am impressed, do people only look at one scene when with good animation when rating a episode? Its just...the typical Shounen thingy well directed. fight....nearly loosing.....some neat flashbacks.....deus ex machina powerup/new ability....oMg wE wOn Get the amount of votes down to a 100 or something, otherwise its just a fucking "What battle-Shounen fuckery episode is the best"....with some others mixed in to spice it all up. |
-Mullerio-Sep 19, 2019 1:07 PM
 |
Lel0uchZer0 said: Gorochu said: It seems like as of today, Kimetsu no Yaiba has the highest percentage of 5/5 voted by fans with 97.7%. Congratulation. The other closest episode is Clannad After Story episode 18. However, Kimetsu no Yaiba has higher voting samples, over 3k as of today. Here are the rest of the best single episode rated which I found thanks to this thread which I linked below. Episode 19 stand above the rest. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1629889 Not anymore haha. Clannad took over Anyway the top is bs No way it was anywhere nesr episodes like Code geass R2 ep 25 Steins gate ep 23 Attack on titan s3p2 ep 5 and 6 You look like you were waiting all day for the scores to update. Someone's getting a bit desperate here considering that the last post is a month ago lmao. |
|
Lel0uchZer0 said: -Aincrad- said: You know, if you didn't add that "haha", I would just think "oh fine, this guy just posted a fact, that it's not the highest rated anymore, and mentioned some others he liked much better, fine, nothing wrong with that." But with that, I can't stop thinking that you're either a stupid brat, or a hater, or both I'm not saying you are, but you really left an impression like that on me It was not meant to be offensive at all towards the series tho You are way to easy to fuck around with Maybe But tbh it doesn't matter if it's the highest rated one or not Even if the rating went down to 90%(obviously impossible), it wouldn't change the fact that it was trending world wide, which I believe rarely ever happens to any anime, and was a huge success Just some rating on an anime site doesn't mean anything There are multiple anime that have no high rating here, but are really popular and well known in Japan, and that's all that matter to anime studios Or if it matters to someone, then it's still one of the highest rated ones, probably in top 5, and has the most 5/5 votes on MAL Previously Re:Zero had the most |
-Aincrad-Sep 19, 2019 2:02 PM
|
| I don't bother giving EACH episode a score, it seems like an obsession or nitpicking and a waste of time to me. episode 19 was so hyped, i actually expected something mind-blowing to happen, but it turned out just some ordinary "MC unlocks new power"x2 with Nezuko doing magic - all of which was simply very well animated. In other words, I'd hardly call this particular episode - the best single episode in anime history lol. Nor would i call this anime a masterpiece or an anime of the year, even though it's certainly not bad, nor average. It's just good...in my opinion of course... BTW, the score for the ep. is already below 97% so maybe putting this episode on a pedestal wasn't that great of an idea... |
AzorAhai said: I don't bother giving EACH episode a score, it seems like an obsession or nitpicking and a waste of time to me. episode 19 was so hyped, i actually expected something mind-blowing to happen, but it turned out just some ordinary "MC unlocks new power"x2 with Nezuko doing magic - all of which was simply very well animated. In other words, I'd hardly call this particular episode - the best single episode in anime history lol. Nor would i call this anime a masterpiece or an anime of the year, even though it's certainly not bad, nor average. It's just good...in my opinion of course... BTW, the score for the ep. is already below 97% so maybe putting this episode on a pedestal wasn't that great of an idea... I mean, it’s 0.31% below 97% now. That still makes it one of if not the single highest rated episode on MAL, so nothing’s changed really. You are entitled to your opinion, of course, but if you really think this was just a decent episode with good animation then I’m afraid the episode’s magic was just lost on you. The episode was a perfect harmony of emotional buildup, stunning animation, phenomenal direction, and a beautiful soundtrack that actually made me tear up a little when I watched it. Many others felt the same way, and that’s why it’s so highly rated. |
| the fact that trash like bnha is in the top10 shows how little this means |
| There's nothing special about this episode. Near death situation => flashback => power up It's literally Shounen 101. It just came with good animation, that's it. How is it that good? > Pretty coloros xD |
 |
AlphaOmegaKnight said: There's nothing special about this episode. Near death situation => flashback => power up It's literally Shounen 101. It just came with good animation, that's it. How is it that good? > Pretty coloros xD Yes I agree. To be honest I didn't even care about the animation. I don't really like CGI. I just found the music awesome. |
Hrybami said: But others do care about animation + other things.AlphaOmegaKnight said: There's nothing special about this episode. Near death situation => flashback => power up It's literally Shounen 101. It just came with good animation, that's it. How is it that good? > Pretty coloros xD Yes I agree. To be honest I didn't even care about the animation. I don't really like CGI. I just found the music awesome. Isn't CGI a big future though? |
| Should I troll in the troll bait threads? It is kinda idiotic to be logical in the troll bait threads. Well, it will depend on my mood. |
AlphaOmegaKnight said: It is shounen because it is shounen. You want seinen a shounen? The difference is that it represented it's shounen elements well enough to get an eye from the fans.There's nothing special about this episode. Near death situation => flashback => power up It's literally Shounen 101. It just came with good animation, that's it. How is it that good? > Pretty coloros xD |
| Should I troll in the troll bait threads? It is kinda idiotic to be logical in the troll bait threads. Well, it will depend on my mood. |
puneetsingh said: Hrybami said: But others do care about animation + other things.Yes I agree. To be honest I didn't even care about the animation. I don't really like CGI. I just found the music awesome. Isn't CGI a big future though? Yes people may like it if they want. I'm personally not a fan of anything CGI, demon slayer included. 3D is in a good way to improve and has a lot of potential. It is relatively new compared to standard 2D animation which is already 100 years old. 2D drawings is a lot more effective to me compared to CGI no matter how shiny it could get. And I'm convinced the future of anime would never become 100% CGI. |
Hrybami said: Sure it will not become 100% and I didn't said that either but it will be more common.Yes people may like it if they want. I'm personally not a fan of anything CGI, demon slayer included. 3D is in a good way to improve and has a lot of potential. It is relatively new compared to standard 2D animation which is already 100 years old. 2D drawings is a lot more effective to me compared to CGI no matter how shiny it could get. And I'm convinced the future of anime would never become 100% CGI. |
| Should I troll in the troll bait threads? It is kinda idiotic to be logical in the troll bait threads. Well, it will depend on my mood. |
| It's gotten to 95%, and Clannad after story ep 18 has 96%. So.....not so fast. |
| Rem is best girl |
Shizokami said: It's gotten to 95%, and Clannad after story ep 18 has 96%. So.....not so fast. Well, it was 97%+ for weeks IIRC, which was by far the highest rated episode. But of course, since so many (thousands of people) have rated it already, it's expected to go down by time, since more people who didn't think it's a 5/5 rate it as well. |
|
| Snk s3p2 ep 5 hero has 95.84% loved it with a staggering 3750 5's. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » what makes zenitsu hated? ( 1 2 )deg - Aug 7 |
81 |
by Viritveus
»»
Sep 4, 6:45 PM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 29, 2019 |
283 |
by GT1Studios
»»
Sep 1, 9:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - May 4, 2019 |
246 |
by IHJ_Martinez
»»
Aug 31, 8:28 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 26 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )-Stray - Sep 28, 2019 |
599 |
by Ishaan_S
»»
Aug 30, 11:20 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 19 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Aug 10, 2019 |
1114 |
by lalindu
»»
Aug 29, 3:44 AM |