| Yes i was hoping for another season of the anime. That's fucking awesome. I already read the manga and it's already one of my favorite mangas. I just hope they don't change the end. |
I despise woke people. |
| Yay! An anime adaptation that may actually end the story like the Manga. That's pretty rare nowadays so great for them! Watch it air in 2018 in the same season that Shingeki no Kyojin S3 airs. SnK and SnK goodness! |
 |
| is this really the final season? i may have to watch it if this anime will have a complete adaptation and i also heard that Blame movie will have a sequel so great news |
j0x said: is this really the final season? i may have to watch it if this anime will have a complete adaptation and i also heard that Blame movie will have a sequel so great news The anime S2 ended at the volume 9 of the manga so there is only 6 more volumes. They most likely can finish the story with just more 13 episodes. |
| I despise woke people. |
Kaetokiha said: j0x said: is this really the final season? i may have to watch it if this anime will have a complete adaptation and i also heard that Blame movie will have a sequel so great news The anime S2 ended at the volume 9 of the manga so there is only 6 more volumes. They most likely can finish the story with just more 13 episodes. thanks for that, i will look for a torrent of this later |
| Why does the anime still pending approval ? if Sidonia3 is got cancelled I'll be sad af |
| YES!!! I just rewatched season 1 & 2. This is more than welcome. |
 |
| Polygon Pictures is actually the best... Damn why did I heard the news about final season just now? This is so amazing, cant wait!! The second season was absolutely insane |
| HELL YEAH, I'm pumped, will definitely have to rewatch the first 2 seasons as it's definitely had an impact on me ! Great music, visuals and story telling =) |
 |
| I was going to start watching this series today, but maybe I will wait for season 3 and start watching then. I read the manga years ago until I caught up to the raws and never got back into it after that. The more I think about the manga the more I remember how awesome it is. |
| Whoops, how did I miss on this one. This world's just a great place, isn't it. |
  |
 Awesome that they are finishing this. |
| Hype it was so bad if they left the story unfinished this makes me happy. |
| I am happy to read this notice!!! |
| Very well. I look forward to it. |
| Please, save us from things like ‘Darling in the FranXX.’ We need you! |
 |
MUSTANG651 said: Scientiiaa said: Please, save us from things like ‘Darling in the FranXX.’ We need you! Darling is very promising so far ;) No news or rumors about SnK 3? Okay, I would agree that it is watchable. But right now it is that ‘nothing but clichés’ type of mecha. Think for a second…, just for one second. There is no Zero Two chick in this anime. Will people watch it? No. She is like the only reason people are still watching it. Do not get me wrong, I am perfectly fine with the fact that some people are enjoying it; they are free to do it. And I too want to enjoy and find something good about this show, but it is too early for that. As far as I know, we do not know the date, but we know that there will be season 3. |
| |
| Didn't anime stray from manga's path, remember(don't) reading and it was quite confusing after watching, thought there were quite heavy changes. Down for another season, but not really feeling rewatch, so don't know how it'll go. |
 |
| I don't know why mal mods approved this entry. There is no confirmation that there will be another season. |
 |
| I absolutely loved season 1 and absolutely despised season 2. They can´t redeem themselves at this point on my opinion. Where was the realist hard sci-fi on S2. Where are the deaths? Where is the plot, nothing is explained about Ochiau or the Inmortal Council, origin of the Gaunas, where did they find those firs Kabis... Instead we get a shitty harem slice of life comedy. And I´m not against this kind of anime, but god the shift was to abrupt from season 1 to season 2. I´m not saying don´t put in romance, most mecha shows have had romance since forever, just do it in a convincing and mature way that harmonizes with the atmosphere that was previously presented. I will still be watching this anyway... |
 |
ConfusionHaze said: I absolutely loved season 1 and absolutely despised season 2. They can´t redeem themselves at this point on my opinion. Where was the realist hard sci-fi on S2. Where are the deaths? Where is the plot, nothing is explained about Ochiau or the Inmortal Council, origin of the Gaunas, where did they find those firs Kabis... Instead we get a shitty harem slice of life comedy. And I´m not against this kind of anime, but god the shift was to abrupt from season 1 to season 2. I´m not saying don´t put in romance, most mecha shows have had romance since forever, just do it in a convincing and mature way that harmonizes with the atmosphere that was previously presented. I will still be watching this anyway... Do you know what hard sci-fi means? Hard sci-fi is all about trying to be as much accurate as possible to real science. Sidonia is not a hard sci-fi anime/manga. The second part is a little slower, yes. Most of what you are asking was explained latter in the manga (past the part where the anime reached), except... Gaunas are a alien race, period. There is nothing else to explain here cause humans doesn't know much about the Gaunas and their origin. I don't even think it's important for them to know where the Gaunas came from cause in the end the only thing they need to do is to destroy the Gaunas in their path and keep going forward as a ship designed to populate other planets. Hans_0819 said: I was hoping for this to never happen, the last arc of the manga and the ending was awful. Why? You just have to not watch it. You don't have to watch it just because they are adapting it. People who dislike the end were basically everyone was shipping Tanikaze with someone else. |
KaeUBWMay 4, 2018 8:07 PM
| I despise woke people. |
| I thoroughly enjoyed the first two seasons. Can't wait! Kaetokiha said: ConfusionHaze said: Where was the realist hard sci-fi on S2. Where are the deaths? Where is the plot, nothing is explained about Ochiau or the Inmortal Council, origin of the Gaunas, where did they find those firs Kabis... Instead we get a shitty harem slice of life comedy. And I´m not against this kind of anime, but god the shift was to abrupt from season 1 to season 2. I´m not saying don´t put in romance, most mecha shows have had romance since forever, just do it in a convincing and mature way that harmonizes with the atmosphere that was previously presented. I will still be watching this anyway... Do you know what hard sci-fi means? Hard sci-fi is all about trying to be as much accurate as possible to real science. Sidonia is not a hard sci-fi anime/manga. As far as "science fiction" goes, I believe that Sidonia leans more towards the "realistic" side of sci-fi than most. There is not FTL travel. Gundams/Mecha with multiple thrusters on their limbs operating under Newtonian physics will [i]always[/b] be more realistic than spacefighters with a single engine at the back flying as if they are in the air. The cloning technology is already plausible, and "laser" weapons can work, albeit if you look into alternatives such as particle weapons and electric cannons. To me, the most "unrealistic" aspect of the series was Sidonia's artificial gravity, (season 2 spoilers) in the second season. I for one enjoyed the SoL. It's rare to find a science fiction anime that takes aside the time to actually explore its speculative setting from the perspective of people's ordinary lives, outside of mecha pilots engaging in philosophy debates over open comms and Skynets trying to take over the world. It also lent tension to the crises that erupted, as we have become intimately familiar with the people and lives that are being threatened, and root for the heroes even more. As for character deaths, I'm of the opinion that the whole "characters must die for there to be stakes" trend that GoT started to be rather silly. Only one major character died in LotR (and did so 30% of the way into the story) and I was still unsure as to whether or not Faramir would overcome his jealously, if Saruman would realize that there still is hope, or if Frodo's soul would survive. In that case, Tolkien got me invested in "whether or not the character will overcome their flaw", not "whether or not they will survive". On that note, I am unable to recall if Nagate was in the midst of a moral or spiritual struggle. If so, that may explain why people are feeling as if there is no "question" outside of the obvious "will they defeat the Gauna? (ofcourse they will!)" It's been a couple year since I last watched Sidonia, so I may be remembering incorrectly. |
Valyrian1124May 4, 2018 10:16 PM
| @MilkmanDan mb, but i remember when continuing reading after season that something was confusing (mb it wasn't that bad), about Izana and Tsumugi. Definitely don't remember what, only the ending and even it here and there. |
|
Kaetokiha said: ConfusionHaze said: I absolutely loved season 1 and absolutely despised season 2. They can´t redeem themselves at this point on my opinion. Where was the realist hard sci-fi on S2. Where are the deaths? Where is the plot, nothing is explained about Ochiau or the Inmortal Council, origin of the Gaunas, where did they find those firs Kabis... Instead we get a shitty harem slice of life comedy. And I´m not against this kind of anime, but god the shift was to abrupt from season 1 to season 2. I´m not saying don´t put in romance, most mecha shows have had romance since forever, just do it in a convincing and mature way that harmonizes with the atmosphere that was previously presented. I will still be watching this anyway... Do you know what hard sci-fi means? Hard sci-fi is all about trying to be as much accurate as possible to real science. Sidonia is not a hard sci-fi anime/manga. The second part is a little slower, yes. Most of what you are asking was explained latter in the manga (past the part where the anime reached), except... Gaunas are a alien race, period. There is nothing else to explain here cause humans doesn't know much about the Gaunas and their origin. I don't even think it's important for them to know where the Gaunas came from cause in the end the only thing they need to do is to destroy the Gaunas in their path and keep going forward as a ship designed to populate other planets. Hans_0819 said: I was hoping for this to never happen, the last arc of the manga and the ending was awful. Why? You just have to not watch it. You don't have to watch it just because they are adapting it. People who dislike the end were basically everyone was shipping Tanikaze with someone else. I didn't hate the manga ending because of ships, but because I probably won't watch this. I loved season 1 and 2, but having read the manga I don't want to have to see the the same godawful ending again. For fans of the anime, I suggest you stay away from the ending (likely being the 11th or 12th episode), as it's VERY disappointing. |
When people tell me to stream anime on CR instead of downloading from fansub sites.  |
| omg no plis no last arc got me traumatized |
| 4th times getting signature banned wtf |
| I cannot find the news confirmed anywhere. Why the mods approve this? |
| "Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov |
teubert2 said: I didn't hate the manga ending because of ships, but because I probably won't watch this. I loved season 1 and 2, but having read the manga I don't want to have to see the the same godawful ending again. For fans of the anime, I suggest you stay away from the ending (likely being the 11th or 12th episode), as it's VERY disappointing. I liked the entire manga (inclusive the end) and i don't have any problems with the plot even though i still have some doubts about a few things. Now about your doubts... My post is already too long so i'm not going to write more, but if you have any other arguments then i would be happy to read them. |
KaeUBWMay 5, 2018 2:28 PM
| I despise woke people. |
Valyrian1124 said: As far as "science fiction" goes, I believe that Sidonia leans more towards the "realistic" side of sci-fi than most. There is not FTL travel. Gundams/Mecha with multiple thrusters on their limbs operating under Newtonian physics will [i]always[/b] be more realistic than spacefighters with a single engine at the back flying as if they are in the air. The cloning technology is already plausible, and "laser" weapons can work, albeit if you look into alternatives such as particle weapons and electric cannons. To me, the most "unrealistic" aspect of the series was Sidonia's artificial gravity, (season 2 spoilers) in the second season. I for one enjoyed the SoL. It's rare to find a science fiction anime that takes aside the time to actually explore its speculative setting from the perspective of people's ordinary lives, outside of mecha pilots engaging in philosophy debates over open comms and Skynets trying to take over the world. It also lent tension to the crises that erupted, as we have become intimately familiar with the people and lives that are being threatened, and root for the heroes even more. As for character deaths, I'm of the opinion that the whole "characters must die for there to be stakes" trend that GoT started to be rather silly. Only one major character died in LotR (and did so 30% of the way into the story) and I was still unsure as to whether or not Faramir would overcome his jealously, if Saruman would realize that there still is hope, or if Frodo's soul would survive. In that case, Tolkien got me invested in "whether or not the character will overcome their flaw", not "whether or not they will survive". On that note, I am unable to recall if Nagate was in the midst of a moral or spiritual struggle. If so, that may explain why people are feeling as if there is no "question" outside of the obvious "will they defeat the Gauna? (ofcourse they will!)" It's been a couple year since I last watched Sidonia, so I may be remembering incorrectly. I understand what you mean when saying Sidonia is more "realistic" than Gundam, but it's still very far from being truly realist so it cannot be called hard sci-fi. I agree with the other things you said. I enjoyed the manga a lot and i liked the sol stuff too. Sidonia was in space for more than 1000 years so i found it enjoyable to see their daily lives instead of just battles. It was one of the things i enjoyed about the manga. Care to elaborate what you considered asspull? |
| I despise woke people. |
Kaetokiha said: teubert2 said: I didn't hate the manga ending because of ships, but because I probably won't watch this. I loved season 1 and 2, but having read the manga I don't want to have to see the the same godawful ending again. For fans of the anime, I suggest you stay away from the ending (likely being the 11th or 12th episode), as it's VERY disappointing. I liked the entire manga (inclusive the end) and i don't have any problems with the plot even though i still have some doubts about a few things. Now about your doubts... My post is already too long so i'm not going to write more, but if you have any other arguments then i would be happy to read them. |
teubert2May 6, 2018 3:41 AM
| When people tell me to stream anime on CR instead of downloading from fansub sites. |
| Nice the final season, really looking forward to it. I remember how I binged through the first season and I have to admit the CGI really fits well with the space setting. |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
Comander-07 said: Nice the final season, really looking forward to it. I remember how I binged through the first season and I have to admit the CGI really fits well with the space setting. Don't get hyped over nothing, this was added by the mistake, there is no confirmed third season anywhere. |
|
bastek66 said: considering what others have said about the manga ending, im not really hyped for it anyway. I just loved the initial episodes, kinda adventure/mystery/sci fi. Season 2 was already just the CGI sci fi.Comander-07 said: Nice the final season, really looking forward to it. I remember how I binged through the first season and I have to admit the CGI really fits well with the space setting. Don't get hyped over nothing, this was added by the mistake, there is no confirmed third season anywhere. |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Sidonia no Kishi: Ai Tsumugu Hoshi Episode 1 Discussionjjrocks24 - Sep 15, 2021 |
27 |
by monster855
»»
Dec 4, 4:08 PM |
|
» Anyone still watching this??GERANSASAKI - Nov 8, 2023 |
2 |
by zckfox
»»
Nov 8, 2023 4:26 AM |
|
» Where can I watch this?Kirukato05 - Dec 25, 2021 |
8 |
by ZGUEGCHOV
»»
May 30, 2022 6:51 AM |
|
Poll: » Do you think the big finale should be changed? (manga spoilers)raull127 - Dec 31, 2020 |
10 |
by nyugvo6
»»
Dec 9, 2021 6:28 AM |
|
» It Lives as a Movie!64BitRatchet - Jul 2, 2020 |
17 |
by Kendoka76
»»
Aug 8, 2021 1:54 PM |