mouadessaddiki said: pff, screw that taste of them, if they cant stand fanservice, they should be gay. I have been struggling with sexuality my whole life, uncertain what I should identify myself as, since I was always unable to appreciate sexual fanservice. I thought something was wrong with me, but this post has changed my life. I have decided. I am gay and since y-you are t-the one who made me realize it  |
 |
| ^2 dark & 3d9y 4 m3 |
 |
mouadessaddiki said: umm, since u didnt touch the source material Oh heavens no! Are you telling me someone is basing an opinion from the synopsis of an upcoming title that can stand alone without prior knowledge of the source material? That's unheard of. We all know only fans of the source material can make valid opinions regarding the adaptation of the material. What they're doing is completely insane! |
Ducat_RevelAug 13, 2015 8:25 AM
lordzeru said: I'm agreeing to that it being what you considered as harem is not relevant...Is Ore Monogatari a harem?There are more than 2 girls having feelings for MC...If Ore Monogatari is considered as harem by your definiton then yes,Rakudai is a harem...And i'm perfectly fine with it...Oh, so you're agreeing it's a harem? Well good. Then we have no issue! MAL just needs to fix it's tagging. |
 |
Grey-Zone said: ^2 dark & 3d9y 4 m3 *sniff* F-fine, I d-didn't like you anyway, b-baka. I'll drawn my sorrow in Hachiman. He never judges me for being edgy. |
|
Ducat_Revel said: mouadessaddiki said: umm, since u didnt touch the source material Oh heavens no! Are you telling me someone is basing an opinion from the synopsis of an upcoming title that can stand alone without prior knowledge of the source material? That's unheard off. We all know only fans of the source material can make valid opinions regarding the adaptation of the material. What they're doing is completely insane! Truly a bunch of uncultivated brutes. No fine gentleman would ever sink quite that low. |
 |
| As of today, the word "harem" joined the "glorious group of buzzwords" in MAL. |
|
| Yea, even if 3 girls has a 1-sided crush it would be considered a "harem" here, right? So by the definition here, if 2 pedophile rapists had "interest" in a little girl, she would have a "reverse harem", wow, MAL, good job! You guys are setting examples! Really the high ground of morality here! Who needs something like "consent" anyway? As long as 3 gazes of the same gender come across someone of the opposite gender it's automatically a "(reverse) harem"! |
|
Grey-Zone said: So by the definition here, if 2 pedophile rapists had "interest" in a little girl, she would have a "reverse harem", wow, MAL, good job! Throw yourself into the mix as well and you will be correct! Glad you have learned something today. |
|
lordzeru said: Grey-Zone said: So by the definition here, if 2 pedophile rapists had "interest" in a little girl, she would have a "reverse harem", wow, MAL, good job! Throw yourself into the mix as well and you will be correct! Glad you have learned something today. Stay away from my husbando. |
|
Grey-Zone said: lol'd(btw not 2 rapists,make it 3 rapists and we have a legit reverse-harem '_')So by the definition here, if 2 pedophile rapists had "interest" in a little girl, she would have a "reverse harem", wow, MAL, good job! Ducat_Revel said: Yes,only fans of original material can make valid opinions until they actually watch the anime...Until then you can only make baseless assumptions and prejudgements based on your previous experiences which has nothing to do with current title which doesnt give you right to evaluate the anime...We all know only fans of the source material can make valid opinions regarding the adaptation of the material. What they're doing is completely insane! |
| |
lordzeru said: Grey-Zone said: So by the definition here, if 2 pedophile rapists had "interest" in a little girl, she would have a "reverse harem", wow, MAL, good job! Throw yourself into the mix as well and you will be correct! Glad you have learned something today. whoops, I made a typo and accidently defined a love triangle by your standards instead, so sorry! |
|
LoneWizard said: Yes,only fans of original material can make valid opinions until they actually watch the anime...Until then you can only make baseless assumptions and prejudgements based on your previous experiences which has nothing to do with current title which doesnt give you right to evaluate the anime... Yeah. I can't look at the trailer of an Adam Sandler movie and dismiss it. Sure. Thanks for the heads up. I'm sure the people who disregarded Pixels were proven wrong. |
Grey-Zone said: lordzeru said: Throw yourself into the mix as well and you will be correct! Glad you have learned something today. whoops, I made a typo and accidently defined a love triangle by your standards instead, so sorry! Well a love triangle is a different ordeal. We'll have to save that for another day, another thread. |
|
Grey-Zone said: Of the 3 only 1 has romantic interest in the MC. If you actually paid, you know, attention to the series, then you would see that it's like that. In one of the pages you posted, right next to it one of the girls clearly says that she has NO INTEREST in the MC (and doing so in a calm, sincern manner, i.e. no "tsundere saying the opposite" BS). But I don't blame you, taking things out of context to appear "superior" and "be right in the internet" is a common occurance. Nowadays no one cares about facts anyway, right? Instead everyone makes sure the facts fit their own opinions instead. It may be because of my filthy secondary eyes, but those pictures seem to allude to romantic interests of all three. Perhaps "So before the day is over, I'll confe--" may be misleading. Confe-- could be the start of multiple words and I can see how statistically confess may be low compared to the numerous possibilities. Albeit the page after seems to infer that she actually did mean confess, which is usually effectuated from romantic feelings for a person. Perhaps it was the author's ingenuity showing through and the generic well formulated main girl was misunderstanding and it is merely the illusion of romantic interests-- perhaps used as a plot point for a grander scheme of things. Also the other girl clearly kissed him, which again used to infer some sort of romantic or sexual feelings. But, she may be foreign and it might be her way of saying hello and she meant absolutely nothing of it. She did call him Onii-sama, clearly no self respecting female would want to date their own brother. No one has possibly shown that before-- it's obviously a platonic love. It's like how in Mahouka Miyuki's feeling for Tatsuya are perfectly normal and healthy. I have a little sister, she never gave kissed me so passionately as shown in the panel, she clearly doesn't love me (platonically). Hey, we're just dumb, ignorant secondaries. Lordzeru is clearly making some egregious claims, the pictures absolutely do not infer anything because obviously we aren't looking at it through a correct perspective. There is no way those panels infer any romantic tension at all. Pay no heed to the obviously incorrect deductive work of inferior people. |
 |
Ducat_Revel said: LoneWizard said: Yes,only fans of original material can make valid opinions until they actually watch the anime...Until then you can only make baseless assumptions and prejudgements based on your previous experiences which has nothing to do with current title which doesnt give you right to evaluate the anime... Yeah. I can't look at the trailer of an Adam Sandler movie and dismiss it. Sure. Thanks for the heads up. I'm sure the people who disregarded Pixels were proven wrong. Pixels received a lower score than Birdemic, only reserved for the best of masterpieces. Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? 100% |
|
Ventris said: sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? 100% What if it becomes one of our favorite bad anime? We could possibly be making the Davids watch this one day down the road. |
|
| It's a shame this isn't done by Diomedia, though. Their seasonal iteration chain of the exactly same LN show seems to be broken now unless something happens. Ventris said: sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? 100% It might be so bad that it is remembered as another Absolute Duo! |
| Steel Ball Run anime when? |
Ventris said: I'm in...Lets bet on something that can never be proven and completely subjective...sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? 100% |
| |
sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? Sir, please. I respectfully disagree with your, frankly baseless, assumption. You clearly have not read the source material. I cannot demand of you to read the LN, but I urge you to at least acquaint yourself with a panel or two from the manga which, I am sure, will be enough to convince you such level of writing prowess will not be forgotten by true connoisseurs. |
metamorphiusAug 13, 2015 8:42 AM
|
 /thread I'm out |
LoneWizzyAug 13, 2015 9:14 AM
| |
| Seeya |
|
Nidhoeggr said: It might be so bad that it is remembered as another Absolute Duo! Wasn't that the show where the dude with the lame, special ability is rooming with that foreign princess in a magical school for people fighting with magical weapons powered by their soul? Now that is obviously something entirely different from the masterpiece we're talking about here! |
|
metamorphius said: sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? Sir, please. I respectfully disagree with your, frankly baseless, assumption. You clearly have not read the source material. I cannot demand of you to read the LN, but I urge you to at least acquaint yourself with a panel or two from the manga which, I am sure will be enough to convince you such level of writing prowess will not be forgotten by true connoisseurs. What are you saying? This series is Not DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE enough! We need cool smoking old men at night saying cool "philosphical" lines instead! How can you watch this "generic harem stuff" instead? You, sir, are going the wrong path! You must follow the DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE path instead! Episodic throw-away stories from cowboy beepop for example! That is MATURITY! MATURITYYYYY! |
|
metamorphius said: sushiisawesome said: Speaking of which, any bets that this will be forgotten a month after it's done? Sir, please. I respectfully disagree with your, frankly baseless, assumption. You clearly have not read the source material. I cannot demand of you to read the LN, but I urge you to at least acquaint yourself with a panel or two from the manga which, I am sure, will be enough to convince you such level of writing prowess will not be forgotten by true connoisseurs. I stand corrected, sir. This is truly a masterpiece that would put the likes of Stephen King and Tolkien to shame. The intricate writing, complex characters and intelligent dialogue are certainly convincing me that this is a new Lord of the Rings, 1984 or Crime and Punishment. I urge everyone in this thread to read this divine, godly masterpiece. |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
mouadessaddiki said: TheNaturalPerm said: Ppl who read the LN or the manga know how this show is different from other lousy LNs that got adapted lately like Absolute Duo aka Absolute shit and Kuusen madoshit but these ones are harem, and Rakudai isnt imoB-but how? It's the usual copy paste magical highschool anime. There is nothing original about this. This screams generic. You can watch this show at least twice a season. they all says that when a LN is adapted. |
 |
Grey-Zone said: What are you saying? This series is Not DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE enough! We need cool smoking old men at night saying cool "philosphical" lines instead! How can you watch this "generic harem stuff" instead? You, sir, are going the wrong path! You must follow the DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE path instead! Episodic throw-away stories from cowboy beepop for example! That is MATURITY! MATURITYYYYY! Listen. Metamorphius, being the mature gentlemen he is, is only allowed to watch Mature anime for Mature people like him. Having just come to terms with his latent and hidden sexuality, you should perhaps give him a chance to come to the LN side. |
lordzeruAug 13, 2015 8:51 AM
|
Ventris said: Nidhoeggr said: It might be so bad that it is remembered as another Absolute Duo! Wasn't that the show where the dude with the lame, special ability is rooming with that foreign princess in a magical school for people fighting with magical weapons powered by their soul? Now that is obviously something entirely different from the masterpiece we're talking about here! You are right, forgive my ignorance. Do you think there will be a fighting festival of sorts? |
| Steel Ball Run anime when? |
Grey-Zone said: metamorphius said: Sir, please. I respectfully disagree with your, frankly baseless, assumption. You clearly have not read the source material. I cannot demand of you to read the LN, but I urge you to at least acquaint yourself with a panel or two from the manga which, I am sure will be enough to convince you such level of writing prowess will not be forgotten by true connoisseurs. What are you saying? This series is Not DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE enough! We need cool smoking old men at night saying cool "philosphical" lines instead! How can you watch this "generic harem stuff" instead? You, sir, are going the wrong path! You must follow the DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE path instead! Episodic throw-away stories from cowboy beepop for example! That is MATURITY! MATURITYYYYY! Ya sure you're not describing Akame Ga Kill, Elfen Lied or Mirai Nikki? |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
sushiisawesome said: Grey-Zone said: What are you saying? This series is Not DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE enough! We need cool smoking old men at night saying cool "philosphical" lines instead! How can you watch this "generic harem stuff" instead? You, sir, are going the wrong path! You must follow the DARK, EDGY AND MATUUURE path instead! Episodic throw-away stories from cowboy beepop for example! That is MATURITY! MATURITYYYYY! Ya sure you're not describing Akame Ga Kill, Elfen Lied or Mirai Nikki? Those aren't episodic though. But I really wish I we would get OVAs/a manga gaiden about Yukiteru in the first timeline, because that one seemed to have been able to take care of himself, compared to the one from the second timeline with the yandere watching his every step, in the end letting her do too much of the dirty work and not getting the growth he needs. The first timeline would definitly be a lot more interesting that what we saw in the series of the second timeline itself... |
|
ggYeti said: sushiisawesome said: Nop that shit was so boring and cliche I almost felt asleep. Trigun definitely felt better.Ya sure you're not describing Akame Ga Kill, Elfen Lied or Mirai Nikki? You haven't seen any of them... |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
Grey-Zone said: sushiisawesome said: Ya sure you're not describing Akame Ga Kill, Elfen Lied or Mirai Nikki? Those aren't episodic though. But I really wish I we would get OVAs/a manga gaiden about Yukiteru in the first timeline, because that one seemed to have been able to take care of himself, compared to the one from the second timeline with the yandere watching his every step, in the end letting her do too much of the dirty work and not getting the growth he needs. The first timeline would definitly be a lot more interesting that what we saw in the series of the second timeline itself... Well, assuming the writer can improve their writing, why not. |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
Dragon_Slayer_X said: Yes, but in most cases they were actual (fake*) harems. Usually the only buzzword in that case was "cliché", though I can't deny that in quite a few cases the word "cliché" was actually accurate. A case like now where the word in question is th word "harem" itself is rather rare.Oh boy the thread has gone out of control and the edgy troll lord and his disciples are in here too. RIP thread............ Grey-Zone said: As of today, the word "harem" joined the "glorious group of buzzwords" in MAL. You sure it wasn't in there before............because you know they usually start the comments with "This generic harem shit.........." or something along the lines. *NOTE: not to be confused with "true harems" where the MC actually has sex with 3 or more wives, for example in the Mushoku Tensei Novel. |
Grey-ZoneAug 13, 2015 9:07 AM
|
Dragon_Slayer_X said: Oh boy the thread has gone out of control and the edgy troll lord and his disciples are in here too. RIP thread............ Please, refer to him by his real name. Edgelord. And he is my disciple, unless you were already referring to myself. If so, carry on. |
|
lordzeru said: Dragon_Slayer_X said: Oh boy the thread has gone out of control and the edgy troll lord and his disciples are in here too. RIP thread............ Please, refer to him by his real name. Edgelord. And he is my disciple, unless you were already referring to myself. If so, carry on. I'm Nid and zeru's disciple. I shall fight you in their name. |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
| I came here to only check out the new cast (and I did)…… I was a bit surprise that there were 2 pages (almost 3 now) of comments already though (I mean this is just news about additional cast announcement), then realized than most of them are not about the cast, but lots of arguing and hate comments about trivial and off-topic things,…… and then I remembered! This is MAL. Cast announcement for LN = usually lots of bashing and derailing. At this point you would think people that do no care about these specific LN types of series (for personal reasons, which I fine with) would not bother to comment on them anymore. Why waste your time doing so really? P.S. Cast looks solid. PV was alright. I wasn’t fan of the song played during the PV whatsoever (is that going to be the OP?). I’ve mixed feeling regarding Ali Project doing the ED. I either really like her songs or dislike them (it’s always 50/50 change for me). |
 We ultimately fear what spawns from within us ~Shinsekai yori Music is freedom. ~Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso |
zero-r said: At this point you would think people that do no care about these specific LN types of series (for personal reasons, which I fine with) would not bother to comment on them anymore. Why waste your time doing so really? Because it's uninspired and instantly forgotten the moment it's done, yet we always see people defend them and say "the LNs are better". Some of the people in this thread are the very same ones who defended the SAO and Mahouka LNs, and vanished once they realized that people are not falling for it. This is another such case. |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
| Just usual user here. I'm just gonna leave my fav illustration here. |
 Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| can't wait ^^ finally a magic-highschool animu that isn't a harem |
| A show doesn't need to be a harem to be shitty. Just being a Light Novel is usually enough. #Mahouka |
 |
sushiisawesome said: zero-r said: At this point you would think people that do no care about these specific LN types of series (for personal reasons, which I fine with) would not bother to comment on them anymore. Why waste your time doing so really? Because it's uninspired and instantly forgotten the moment it's done, yet we always see people defend them and say "the LNs are better". Some of the people in this thread are the very same ones who defended the SAO and Mahouka LNs, and vanished once they realized that people are not falling for it. This is another such case. Actually SAO was very well received, at least until the first half of the first season ended, from there on it went downhill. But if anything a lot of the hate for SAO was evidently by people disliking its popularity, i.e. the "hate" was more targeted at the SAO fans than the series itself, after all most arguments were along the lines of "why are so many people liking this bad show?", without giving any real reasons why it was "bad". Though to be honest I am quite indifferent about it myself, seeing SAO as "above average", but not lower. Not sure about the second season as I have yet to catch up with it. Mahouka, while I never read the LN, I can see it had the problem of having a lot of lore (yea I am talking about 5 minutes of exposition per episode about the mechanics of magic, this DOES work in LNs, but NOT in Anime). It really suffered from that I must say, but just from that I can be sure that the anime is absolutely not enough to evaluate the LN. |
|
| I've been reading it's manga and as far as the PV goes, everything seems to be great. For those whov'e never read it, this isn't a Harem and despite it's story being so common, this show is pretty fun to watch and has a bit of different feel than other you know stories. Really looking forward to it. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Dragon_Slayer_X said: TheNaturalPerm said: A show doesn't need to be a harem to be shitty. Just being a Light Novel is usually enough. #Mahouka Yes yes "anything i don't like is shit" comments which are actually the ones full of shit. It isn't obviously shitposting neither is your taste. Oh wait........ *sigh* where did I say that? Nice ad hominem though; great response. Seriously there is not one well written magical highschool anime out there and nearly all of them are based on light novels. What is that if not a pitch-black flag. Always strange to see people defend these copy paste shows. |
|
| the character design looks generic as hell not expecting much from this show |
TheNaturalPerm said: With that kind of generalisation you can also mistake Kara No Kyoukai(Which is another LN adaptation) as a magical Highschool Anime ...Which wouldnt be a good thing to do...Dragon_Slayer_X said: Yes yes "anything i don't like is shit" comments which are actually the ones full of shit. It isn't obviously shitposting neither is your taste. Oh wait........ *sigh* where did I say that? Nice ad hominem though; great response. Seriously there is not one well written magical highschool anime out there and nearly all of them are based on light novels. What is that if not a pitch-black flag. Always strange to see people defend these copy paste shows. Also you said that when you declared LN=Shit |
| |
More topics from this board
» 'Bleach: Sennen Kessen-hen' Fourth Part Announced as Final SeasonVindstot - Yesterday |
8 |
by branko7171
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» New 'Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha' TV Anime in ProductionVindstot - Yesterday |
15 |
by ItsXolo
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» Mamoru Hosoda's New Movie 'Hateshinaki Scarlet' Set for Winter 2025 ReleaseVindstot - Dec 23 |
17 |
by malvarez1
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» 'New Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt' Reveals Cast Members, Additional Staff, Teaser Promo for 2025Nioxys - Dec 24 |
14 |
by Playcool
»»
Yesterday, 2:25 PM |
|
» Original TV Anime 'Maebashi Witches' Announced for Spring 2025Nioxys - Sep 5 |
24 |
by AmanoDaichi
»»
Yesterday, 12:28 PM |