| bakemonogatari - it was fun but i preferred the other seasons a lot more 7/10 naruto shippuden - My first anime, love it with all my heart but the fillers kinda got to me so I prefer the first season where I didn't even know what a filler was and enjoyed them so much 7/10 Monogatari Series: Second Season - Shinobu for best girl 8/10 |
| Baccano - it was enjoyable, but I still think it's overrated (same case with Durarara) - my rating is 7 Gankutsuou - I liked the art and it was indeed a good adaptation, I agree that it's underrated; nevertheless, I wouldn't give it a 10 CG - same rating here. No matter what anyone says, it was one of the first anime I've seen and it blew me away Monster - too long for my tastes, but very good indeed, deserves its praise |
| The only thing you can rely on is that you can't rely on anything. |
| Code Geass and Death note deserve nothing less. I gave them both tens too. The rest I've never watched, but I've heard good things about Monogatari. |
| Code Geass deserve's its praise easily, one of the best anime i've ever watched 10/10 Death Note - I know im being extremely picky with this but i really was annoyed by certain changes from manga to anime. however i did enjoy the hell out of it 8/10 Soul Eater - Possibly my favorite group of characters ever. The story's second half wasn't so good and ofc I'm hoping for a reboot. 10/10 |
| Akira: I enjoyed it, but I wouldn't call it any kind of masterpiece. I gave it a 7. Mononoke Hime: I've been meaning to rewatch this one since it's so highly praised, but I certainly don't remember it being my favourite Ghibli movie. Definitely worth a 7 though. Nausicaa: This however is one of my favourite Ghibli movies. I gave it a 9 then bumped it down for some reason. My only problem was that I didn't feel like it was very polished. FLCL: Not sure why some people consider this some kind of masterpiece. Maybe theirs something that I'm missing but I just found it to be a fun, but rather stupid show. 6/10 Hotaru No Haka: I have problems with this movie, mainly with the actions of the main character and how they ultimately killed his sister. I did however enjoy it as a great portrayal of the struggles of war in a country that's often portrayed as "the enemy" by all the American media that surrounds me. 6/10 Princess Tutu: I certainly never expected to enjoy this one, but it ended up being one of my favourite shows. I only had a problem with the progression of Mytho's character, which to me seemed necessary to the plot, but poorly executed. 9/10 Toki wo Kakeru Shoujo: I really liked this movie, not really much else to say. I don't think it's the best thing I've ever seen but I really liked it. 9/10 Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki: Another amazing one by Hosoda. I thought it was a very good portrayal of the struggles of parenthood (although I'm no expert). I also found the development of the children to be very realistic. 9/10 Doggy Poo: A timeless classic. |
Slyr3do0nMay 4, 2014 10:18 AM
| Cowboy Bebop? Instantly a great list. With the additional Ergo Proxy, that's a nice list. Good tastes. Dat Inferno Cop Hate Death Note lel All in all, I give your 10/10's an 8/10. |
Robin6128May 4, 2014 9:55 AM
| Aria the origination - This must be fricking amazing if you have this so much higher than everything else you watched. Although i heard its comparable to Mushishi, if this is true my rating will probably be 8-10 |
| Hajime no Ippo - Hell fucking yeah Hajime no Ippo: New Challenger - Not as good as first season. (9/10) Hajime no Ippo: Rising - ^ (9/10) Hunter x Hunter (2011) - Best battle shounen. (9/10) Baccano! - Good anime with a great cast. Need to rewatch it. (8/10) Code Geass - Nothing to say about this one, was good. (8/10) Monster - The greatest thriller. (9/10) Gankutsuou - Haven't seen. |
| -Mushishi (both seasons) - It's a pretty enjoyable and quite unique series, it somehow relaxes me and I really love Ginko. I gave the first one an 8, while I still haven't rated the 2nd one, though it's probably going to be the same. -Hajime no Ippo - Deffinitely one of the best sports series around, the matches are always so intense and interesting to watch, there are so many feels here sometimes and this series has a great character development. I also quite enjoy the humor. I gave it a 9, however, but it's not far from 10 at all :D And I haven't seen Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu... |
| Danshi Koukousei no Nichijou - Had so much expectations for it, I was hoping to have a lot of good laughs but it appears to be boring most of the time... 6/10 Death Note - Not much to say, totally agree with you. One of the best show ever 10/10 Durarara!! - it was a really pleasant show to watch with extremely good characters (Izaya and Shizuo <3) Can't wait for 2nd season 9/10 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - I'm still watching it, gave 9/10 to the first show and I'm expecting much of it to eventually give a 10/10 to this one ~ Gintama - same here, still watching the first show but I can already say that this is the best comedy ever, love the characters 9/10 Katekyo Hitman Reborn! - extremely brilliant characters, loving almost all of them, story is awesome, loved both anime and manga and was so upset when anime then manga finished 10/10 Kuroko no Basket - the show who got me interested in sport anime, one of the best characters a show could have, Kurokocchi <3 9/10 Kuroshitsuji - loved the history setting and characters but it could have been certainly much more than that (totally hated 2nd season though...) 8/10 Natsume Yuujinchou - still have to watch the 2 last seasons, but already loving all of it. Natsume and Madara are a really good together, can't wait to see more 9/10 One Piece - can't agree more, awesome characters, amazing story 9/10 (that's just me who don't give 10 until I finish a show but will certainly give that score when the anime ever been finished ~) Shingeki no Kyojin - interesting story and characters overall, I still don't think it's the best show ever like I heard so much but deserve at least 8/10 :) |
| Clannad: After Story - I cried. Just a bit though. 9/10 Death Note - Definitely one of those shows I just can't understand with all the hype backing it. It was difficult to take in, mostly because it felt really half-assed at times. 5/10 Madoka Magica - This I CAN agree with. Brilliant show through and through. 10/10 Psycho-Pass - This one was really good. 9/10 Steins;Gate - Another show I can't understand the hype backing it. But still good. 7/10 Toradora! - I could go back and forth with myself about how I didn't give this show a 10. But it was really good, one of the best rom-coms I've ever seen. 9/10 |
| Just need to find out how to quote this every time so I can dodge the stupid 30-character limit. |
| guys can do 9's on my list as well since I don't have many tens just because the tens are from shows I haven't seen recently. they'd probably be 8 or 9 if I rewatch just cause I enjoy things as a whole slightly less....anyway: gurren lagann is god madoka magica is sraight, but...i'd give it like a 7 or 8. maybe it was the characters probably that didn't do it for me i'll do your 9's too: pscyho pass is god. akane=virgin mary shinsekai yori is pretty dope. just pretty confusing for me though. too deep4me. 8/10 fumoffu is so funny. haven't seen that in a while though. but the second raid is still on point. |
| Eureka Seven: boring anime, tries too hard for romance. 6/10 Hell Girl: I've always wanted to watch it actually. TTGL: You gained my respect.. Baccano: Good, although I prefered DRRR, still a great anime though. |
 |
| TTGL: You have my respect as well. FLCL: Too short and cryptic with not enough time to figure the characters out. The fact that I had to re-watch it puts it at a 9/10 on my list. Still brilliant, though. (If you're feelin' lucky, you can do my 9's.) |
Derp-chan said: Jojo's Bizarre Adventure had me on the brink of an orgasm, then plunged me in to tears within seconds. |
| Detroit Metal City, JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (2012), Gintama, Redline, Stranger: Mukou Hadan / didn't watched so no idea Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, I think KLK was better in term of nonsense, so TTGL isn't top 4me. |
 |
| SSY - Objectively fantastic, but subjectively pretty boring. 8.5/10 S;G - One of the most awesome shows ever, not much to add here that hasn't been said a million times already. 10/10 3rd Madoka movie - For most of it I thought it was good but was hoping for more... and then the last 20 mins of it happened and suddenly everything turned to fucking insanity, absolutely loved the ending, made the entire thing so awesome all of a sudden. 10/10 Umineko - I'm not gonna rate it since I haven't seen the anime, but I've played the full VN series (longest VN ever written) and it's in my top 5 all time in that regard. Despite its length it never stops being captivating, never stops surprising you and had a great ending as well. Furthermore it has by far the best OST I've ever heard. Now as far as the anime goes I've intentionally avoided it because I know just how incredibly little of the story is actually adapted, not to mention they never even finished the story in the anime so I'm still not feeling too hyped about watching it. Just suspect that my view of the series would go down if I did, same as with Total Eclipse among others. Rest haven't seen (yet?) |
HaXXspettenMay 5, 2014 12:42 AM
  |
| Code Geass R1 and R2 - Lelouch's flamboyant pontifications and the overall pretentious vibe I got from the show makes it nowhere close to being a perfect ten for me, despite its entertainment value. But meh, when one is rating based on sheer enjoyment and character drama, a ten is not too off the mark. Death Note - The leaps in logic were sometimes too ridiculous for a show that takes itself so seriously. And the show lost its shine after a certain character death midway. Again, subjectivity comes to play. FMA;Bth - Had every factor that determines the worth of a shounen in perfect proportions. I gave 9, IIRC, but a ten's not implausible either. Steins;Gate - The mad scientist FTW. Totally worthy of ten, if for the sheer entertainment I got out of this. The meticulous use of time travel and butterfly effect further justifies the score. It was nine for me because there were unanswered rudimentary questions that nag me to this day. SAO - Disliked it. Perfect for self insert fantasies and the art was commendable. I can see why one would like it without overlooking the flaws. But tbh, I couldn't enjoy it all due to the shallow characters, underdeveloped plot and Gary Stu mc. I can't say this is not due to prejudice though, as I did read some hate posts about the anime before watching it and I judged it as such due to preconceived notions regarding its quality, so I'm a biased here. Haven't seen/completed the rest of the tens on the list. |
DeigerMay 5, 2014 1:13 AM
| - My creativity is plummeting. - |
| fate/zero 2nd season - many deaths. great enjoyable series with amazing characters. kiritsuguru's backstory <3. kiritsuguru vs kirei <3 - 8/10 mushishi - this is the best fucking show ever. I have no idea how to describe it but i am in love with it. my only problem is that there was, once in a while, an episode that bored me. 9/10 TTGL - overrated as fuck. very fun to watch but i hated most of the characters 7/10 |
| I'm also gonna comment on your 9's. Baccano! - I actually liked this show so much I got a DVD for this. I gave it a 7 but that's because I thought Durarara! was better. Code Geass - Drew me in. Marathoned it. Really good show. 8/10 Code Geass R2 - But the ending made me sad. 9/10 Black Lagoon - This show is badass. There should be a warning that this show will make you want to go out and do stuff like a badass (and probably fail). 8/10 Psycho-Pass - Another one of Gen Urobuchi's great works. Just not nearly as good as Madoka Magica in my opinion. 9/10 Madoka Magica Rebellion - Speaking of which.... 10/10 Steins;Gate - I just need to rewatch this once. I need to find out what was so great about it. 7/10 Durarara! - This show was good. I don't consider 9's on my list unless I feel they can beat Durarara! out. 8/10 |
| Just need to find out how to quote this every time so I can dodge the stupid 30-character limit. |
| @ iSheep Havent seen any of ur 10's. Nichijou; Heard a lot of good things about it, and looking forward to watching it Madoka Magica; Not sure what to expect, but since it's praised for a darker scenic route I tend to watch this one day. |
 |
| I agree with all your 10s with the exception of SAO. |
| Sakura Trick - Now, I'm not a fan of fanservice, nor am I really a fan of yuri. But after watching Yuru Yuri, I did have some expectations for a yuri show to be good. This was, decent. 6/10 Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 - The ending. ;-; 9/10 Steins;Gate - Seriously, either something is wrong with the way I was watching it or maybe I'm just missing something. 7/10 Mirai Nikki - Not as "compelling" as I'd hoped. But it does have a way with being addictive to watch. 7/10 Nichijou - Best [pointless] slice-of-life comedy ever. I got my brother to laugh at it and he doesn't generally watch anime. 10/10 Monogatari Series: Second Season - Gets boring from time-to-time. But still good. 8/10 Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari - Incredible ending to an incredible series. 10/10 |
iSheepMay 5, 2014 1:22 PM
| Just need to find out how to quote this every time so I can dodge the stupid 30-character limit. |
Shiny_Goomy said: I agree with all your 10s with the exception of SAO. Fair enough! :D |
|
| Code Geass, Clannad, Death Note, One Piece, Steins;Gate - can't say more as I totally agree with you, all these shows deserve the 10 (did rate first season of both Clannad and Code Geass with a 9 though) Mirai Nikki - I would not expect a show to be that intense, every episode made me want to watch the next one so much 9/10 AnoHana - really touching story, almost made me cry but haven't so 9/10 :P Kokoro Connect - was expecting more of it but good anime overall 7/10 (I found the 4 last ep of the "Michi random special" better) Bakemonogatari (and other Monogatari) - its uniqueness and awesome characters are the best 9/10 Shingeki no Kyojin - good show overall but I can't rate it more than 8/10 Sword Art Online - that's where I disagree... good premise but spoiled by awful characters and romance (<- worst one I ever seen in a show...) 5/10 |
| Haven't seen any of your 10's, but I really wanna watch Psycho Pass. I don't think it'd be a 10 in my opinion, but rather something around 8. |
Derp-chan said: Jojo's Bizarre Adventure had me on the brink of an orgasm, then plunged me in to tears within seconds. |
| Not bad; I don't give 10's out easily so I don't quite agree but can see how someone else would rate those highly EXCEPT Elfen Lied: 10 Really???? That has to detract from the rest of your lists taste ;_; |
  Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet |
| monster - may favorite anime of all time 10/10 sakura trick - dat yuri the legend of the whatever - need to watch |
| Monster - Well writen, mature show with good characters. But pacing is pretty bad and some side stories are bad compared to main plot of this one. Still have not finished it, but i am pretty sure my rating will be 7 or 8. Geass R1 - Overated, but still good, better than r2 at least. 5/10 Code Geass R2 - Try to look like well writen show with all those strategies and Sun Tzu quetes, but at the end of the day just action with few op mechas. Ending was good. Euphemia arc was brilliant. Everything else pretty boring. 4/10 Baccano! - Fun to watch, amzing characters and ost, not bad story. Overall 8/10 |
GhostOutOfShellMay 6, 2014 3:14 AM
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| Haven't seen Mushishi yet so I don't know what I'd rate it, but it is on my mental ptw list ;) |
| For those who seek perfection, there can be no rest on this side of the grave. Hope is the first step on the road to disappointment. |
| Angel Beats! - too short for my liking, should have made it 2 cour to fully flesh out the characters. 7/10 Aria the Origination - I'm on epi 10 at the moment, 3 more episodes to go. episode 9 was just perfect and beautiful - its for me, the best Aria episode so far. 5 Centimeters per Second - need to rewatch this one. 8/10 |
 |
| Clannad:as - Way better than s1, still i find characters pretty boring, even though story was good. 6/10 Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu - Haven't see tv series so it might be underated by me, anyway this was a good movie. 7/10 Fate/Zero S2 - Good show, Rider was awesome. 8/10 For persone below: If you have not seen mushishi feel free to use my 9s. |
GhostOutOfShellMay 6, 2014 5:28 AM
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| :S Baccano! - Yes it's Baccano and not Durarara 9/10 |
| *insert philosophical quote here* |
| SAO - Besides ost i dislike evrything about it. 2/10 TTGL - Still watching, so far it's awesome. 7/10 Clannad (s1) - Too long for only char development, idk bad imo. 3/10 Clannad:as - Way better than s1, still i find characters pretty boring, even though story was good. 6/10 Toradora - pretty good romance show. 6/10 SnK - Idk why it's so overated, visual was the best part of the show. (Production I.G. knows how to do theyr work.) Overall 4/10 Angel Beats! - Had potential, but should have been 26 ep. 4/10 |
GhostOutOfShellMay 6, 2014 4:05 AM
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| @ Temoze Only Mushishi ... Def worth a 10, also makes sense with ur avatar ^^ I really liked the calm episodic feature of this anime, normally I don't like episodic. |
|
| Mirai Nikki (TV) I think the TV series is not good enough bcos its ending :/ 9/10 SG, AnoHana, SAO, SNK, Clannad - So we're alike eh ^^ |
| *insert philosophical quote here* |
| Baccano! - Fun to watch, amzing characters and ost, not bad story. Overall 8/10 Fate/Zero S2 - Good show, Rider was awesome. 8/10 SY - Intresting and deep show. 7.5/10 If you have not seen mushishi feel free to use 9s. |
GhostOutOfShellMay 6, 2014 5:28 AM
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| Mushishi - 8 |
Landmines said: There is only two 10s and I have not seen it. But it looks cool. |
| *insert philosophical quote here* |
| Angel Beats! - its been a while since i saw this but it was around the time i started to watch anime, i might ve given this a higher score than it deserves considering its rushed pacing but its still a very good anime Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae wo Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai. - i disliked the characters an the over the top melodrama, 6/10 Clannad - typical harem, disliked the buch of moeblobs that it had as characters, 4/10 Clannad: After Story - it had some improvements, eps 15-20 were quite good but the rest were meh an the conclusión is among the worst ive ever seen, 5/10 Durarara!! - it had some cool characters but the story focussed on the wrong ones, the music an animation was good, 7/10 K-On!! - cute girls doing cute things for 20 eps, not something id enjoy Kill la Kill - sometimes entertaining other times boring, the caracteres werent particularly good an the action was average, 6/10 Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica - it had great animation an soundtrack, the characters were forgettable but the action an history were good, 8/10 Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari - it had a boring story an there was some much shit going on in the screen that sometimes looked like i was watching one of those AMVs instead of a movie, the ending was absurd but the production values were great, 6/10 Shingeki no Kyojin - some fantastic action scenes, epic soundtrack an engaging story, the only problema is the characters werent interesting, 9/10 Steins;Gate - 3rd fav anime, not much else to say, 10/10 Sword Art Online - boring story, annoying characters, average action scenes but overall nice production values, the one scene that comes to mind whenever i think of SAO is the butterfly man licking Asuna, thats one of the most hillarous things ive ever seen, 5/10 Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - some impressive action scenes, a few good characters an engaging story, 9/10 |
silversaintMay 6, 2014 8:38 AM
 |
| All the 10's I know are; Dragonball Z Death Note Steins;Gate Ookami Kodomo ... And they are all worth a 10! I absolutely loved all of these anime. |
|
| One Piece-6 Clannad AS-6 Cowboy Bebop-10 DBZ-5 Bakemonogatari-9 Monogatari S2-10 |
 |
| Cowboy Bebop - 9, maybe an 8 Monogatari Series: Second Season - probably a 5 like the first season Ping Pong - it's been a 6 so far Oyasumi Punpun - ∞ To Love-ru Darkness - probably a 3 like the prequel NHK ni Youkoso! - maybe a 9 like the manga |
Fenryr19May 6, 2014 11:29 AM
 |
| GITS SAC 2nd GIG - So far it's my second favorite anime. 9/10 Texhnolyze - 3th favorite. 9/10 SY - Intresting and deep show. 7.5/10 Note for person below: if you have not seen mushishi feel free to use 9s. |
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| mushishi is beautiful 9/10 |
| Monster- Not Urasawa's best work but it had a great supporting cast, Johan was a nice touch aswell. 10/10 Gankutsuou- Bootiful, homosexual tension. 9/10. Hajime no Ippo- It's not Ashita no Joe. 9/10 Baccano- The novel was better 9/10. Hunter x Hunter (new adapt.)- It's alright, above par battle driven shounen, not one of my favorites but a solid 8/10. One Piece- Anime is pretty dull, the Manga is a 9/10 but I'd give the Anime an 7-8/10. Code Geass- Pretty average for a mecha, some of the s2 fights got into "my robot is bigger than yours" territory but the plot held up, sorta. 7/10 |
 |
More topics from this board
» Deny or Comply v.4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 5, 2021 |
7595 |
by zzz
»»
4 seconds ago |
|
» Describe the user above you in one word v.9 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Tensho - Feb 10, 2021 |
4995 |
by MitsukiHimeka
»»
6 seconds ago |
|
» The user above you is falling. Would you catch them? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Mr_Libra - Apr 10 |
999 |
by SongOfCreation
»»
51 seconds ago |
|
» "Marry/Fuck/Kill" the 3 people above you! - V.5 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Nov 19, 2021 |
7875 |
by zzz
»»
53 seconds ago |
|
» Post a comment on the above user's profile v5 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Sep 11, 2021 |
6158 |
by Laniakea-
»»
1 minute ago |