| I feel like there are some seriously underrated show this season and some overrated ones. Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru is definitely underrated. Can't think of any overrated ones that aren't blatantly obvious. Thoughts? |
[center] [/center] |
| Garo deserves alot more viewers than it has, though it does require a bit of patience as the plot is only just picking up, but its been great. |
Immahnoob said: Jizzy, I know you have no idea how to argue for shit, tokiyashiro said: Jizzy as you would call yourself because youre a dick The most butthurt award goes to you And clearly you havent watched that many shows thats why you cant determine if a show is unique or not Or maybe you're just a child who likes common stuffs where hero saves the day and guys gets all the girls. Sad taste you have there kid you came up to me in the first place making you look more like a kid who got slapped without me even knowing it and start crying about it to me |
| Garo is the most underrated thing by far. It handles it's themes so well and it has some pretty solid action. I have no idea why people aren't watching or why those that are aren't liking it. As for overrated, I'd go for Fate (by the general community) and Shirobako (by the elitist community). I'm enjoying both of them to an extent, but they're both no where near as great as people make them out to be, at least for me anyway. |
| Thread close in 3,2,1... |
  |
| Underrated: Twintails. This show is just perfection. |
| We have an all-purpose OR/UR thread. But... Underrated: Donten ni Warau, Akatsuki no Yona, Shingeki no Bahamut (by a little..), Ookami Shoujo (should be on Maid-sama's level) Overrated: Amagi Brilliant Park, Inou Battle, Gundam Build Fighters Try, FATE/STAY NIGHT Miraclezify said: As for overrated, I'd go for Fate (by the general community) and Shirobako (by the elitist community). I'm enjoying both of them to an extent, but they're both no where near as great as people make them out to be, at least for me anyway. +1 Yeah Shirobako's nice but I still don't feel much about it. Too many things are going on. I'd rather it follow a linear structure like Bakuman. |
| Ah yes, I forgot Trinity Seven in my OR list. Every week's been "oh man Arata stripped another girl!!" and the comments on the threads are like "Arata's such a badass" and "My waifu is so cute when she's naked!" |
| Underrated : Amagi Brilliant Park. It's a pretty fun show with a unique premise. Overrated: Fate Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks 2014. The main characters are kind of annoying with the exceptions of Archer and Saber. The plot is also moving too slowly. |
 |
| Only watching 5 shows atm, but i can defo say that Selector Spread WIXOSS is underrated. |
| Overrated: Fate/Stay Night UBW It's good, but some of the Fate/Stay Night fanboys and fangirls on here hype the hell out of the show |
mayukachan said: Ah yes, I forgot Trinity Seven in my OR list. Every week's been "oh man Arata stripped another girl!!" and the comments on the threads are like "Arata's such a badass" and "My waifu is so cute when she's naked!" > girl watching harem and complain ... >girl watching low budget harem and complain ... do u watch this just to find some gore ? LOL |
| Here we go again! |
moonnya said: mayukachan said: Ah yes, I forgot Trinity Seven in my OR list. Every week's been "oh man Arata stripped another girl!!" and the comments on the threads are like "Arata's such a badass" and "My waifu is so cute when she's naked!" > girl watching harem and complain ... >girl watching low budget harem and complain ... do u watch this just to find some gore ? LOL I thought there might be an interesting story because the manga's rated highly on MAL :| It looks like a cool Harry Potter-esque magic fantasy anime from just the cover. Hell, I was more satisfied with Mahouka and SAO rather than this. |
| Underrated: Wixoss, Bahamut Overrated: can't think of any, maybe the sequel of Psycho Pass. |
 |
| cross ange is underrated there i said it |
| Bahamut is overrated if anything, doesn't do anything to really break the mold. The art and animation are good but the plot is very uninspired. |
| Underrated: Donten ni Warau, beautiful show and Amagi Brilliant Park which is pretty fun. Overrated: Shit like Trinity Seven and Grisaia no Kajitsu. I love and enjoy harem in general, but this two are just under my expectatives. |
 |
Okashi_sama said: That sarcasmUnderrated: Twintails. This show is just perfection. |
| Underrated: Fate/Stay Night UBW, the score is not high enough. Overrated: Everything else, because it doesn't have Rin. |
BahamutPriest said: Underrated: Fate/Stay Night UBW, the score is not high enough. You're funny. |
gissellebatista said: Grisaia is copping mad flack for being a god awful adaptation, not overrated at allOverrated: Shit like Trinity Seven and Grisaia no Kajitsu. I love and enjoy harem in general, but this two are just under my expectatives. |
 |
| underrated: wixoss (it's average) overrated: kiseijuu (it's average) |
| Underrated: Twintails, 7 Deadly Sins (Nanatsu no Taizai) Overrated: Gundam |
| Personally I think Amagi Brillant Park is underrated, along with Ookami Shouo. |
Eearu said: I'd be really happy if Kiseijuu was average, the medium would be awesome then.overrated: kiseijuu (it's average) |
Feaor said: Bahamut is overrated if anything, doesn't do anything to really break the mold. The art and animation are good but the plot is very uninspired. I don't see how this is a problem if the execution is nigh perfect. mayukachan said: BahamutPriest said: Underrated: Fate/Stay Night UBW, the score is not high enough. You're funny. Aren't they all? |
Flume said: gissellebatista said: Grisaia is copping mad flack for being a god awful adaptation, not overrated at allOverrated: Shit like Trinity Seven and Grisaia no Kajitsu. I love and enjoy harem in general, but this two are just under my expectatives. Well, every day I see a ridiculous amount of people in threads who would rate it 10/10 and gets wet for Grisaia and its disgusting characters. |
|
| Overrated: Amagi Brilliant Park Underrated: Cross Ange (you're missing out on a sad and edgy series if you dropped it because of fanservice) |
 |
| I feel that Sanzoku no Musume Ronja is underrated. Though it deals with simple theme and requires a little patience, it did prove to be enjoyable which was especially true with the most recent episode. |
 |
| Tribe Cool Crew is underrated, no way it deserves to be under 6, a score of 7-7.5 would be more accurate. It's a fun show for what it is. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| Overrated : Fate/stay night (it's kinda shit, it may live up to the hype once one of the two good characters actually gets introduced...oh and once we get more of the other good charater > Kirei) I feel like this show has the worst characters this fall (Rin/Archer are average, the rest are shit). |
 |
| Overrated : Fate/stay night ive seen the original but still dont like shiro. And the other servant and masters are crap in comparison to Fate/zero P.S people die when they are killed |
Feaor said: Yeah it's just a decent monster of the week show. The characters are kinda fun but not much else.Bahamut is overrated if anything, doesn't do anything to really break the mold. The art and animation are good but the plot is very uninspired. |
 |
| Wait, Garo looked really stupid based on the screenshots I've seen. Is it really that good?? Also, to answer OP's question, the most overrated anime of the season is probably Parasyte anlong with Fate/Stay Night Underrated would be Amagi Brilliant Park and Donten ni Warau Although, I must add I haven't seen any of these. Just judging based on synopsis, reviews, popularity, and overall what I've heard about them |
| the fact that it's still possible for me to post in this thread indicates that something needs to be fixed |
 |
GhostMaster1 said: Wait, Garo looked really stupid based on the screenshots I've seen. Is it really that good?? Well, it's not really stupid, so you might like it? |
GhostMaster1 said: Wait, Garo looked really stupid based on the screenshots I've seen. Is it really that good?? Also, to answer OP's question, the most overrated anime of the season is probably Parasyte anlong with Fate/Stay Night Underrated would be Amagi Brilliant Park and Donten ni Warau Although, I must add I haven't seen any of these. Just judging based on synopsis, reviews, popularity, and overall what I've heard about them You could at least try to make sense |
 |
ReaperCreeper said: Feaor said: Yeah it's just a decent monster of the week show. The characters are kinda fun but not much else.Bahamut is overrated if anything, doesn't do anything to really break the mold. The art and animation are good but the plot is very uninspired. yeah I have the same feeling too, I hoped that it would be good when I watched the first eps. Its sale will be fucking high, about 15k first vol, but mostly thanks to the free cards. I dont know that without the free cards, how much the following vol will sell. May be 5k, fuck this game has so many players GhostMaster1 said: ... > having avi of ugly rl girl in MAL > reported |
| I gotta agree, why comment on a thread if you literally have no personal experience of what the question is asking about? It'd be like me trying to answer a question about Gundam Recog. |
| Underrated: ookami shoujo, gugure kokori san Overrated: Fate stay night unlimited whatever whatever |
Hand_of_the_King said: GhostMaster1 said: Wait, Garo looked really stupid based on the screenshots I've seen. Is it really that good?? Also, to answer OP's question, the most overrated anime of the season is probably Parasyte anlong with Fate/Stay Night Underrated would be Amagi Brilliant Park and Donten ni Warau Although, I must add I haven't seen any of these. Just judging based on synopsis, reviews, popularity, and overall what I've heard about them You could at least try to make sense Perfect example of hipster trash. |
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
| Thread Locked Please use this club: http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=64093 Over/Under threads aren't allowed on the forums anymore. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Will we ever get a anime cross over as big as the MCU?Old_School_Akira - 26 minutes ago |
4 |
by Theo1899
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Opposite sex AND same sex characters you most relate toIpreferEcchi - 2 hours ago |
3 |
by Zarutaku
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Good characters trapped in bad series.Anjuro - 40 minutes ago |
2 |
by SleepySteamBun
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Secondary charactersJoeChip - 3 hours ago |
15 |
by JTRAnimeNewb
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» What filters do you use while browsing MAL?Dije - 49 minutes ago |
4 |
by 23feanor
»»
30 minutes ago |