Your Lie in April
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
-Skyleo- said: I really hope I'm wrong though, I would love to see in Kousei's style a combination of his "accurate" style with a bit of deep sensibility. A style without too much mannerism. After all, it was one of the qualities of Rubinstein, because even if Chopin was a romantic, I think he was still "manly" in his own way. I think that your wish is very likely to happen, even for the piece in question. I don't know if it was the mangaka's choice or the studio, but Etude no. 5 doesn't fit what I said about playing lively with keeping with the accurate rhythm, it should be replaced with another Etude. Not that it matter though, we still gotta see what happens. Are you, by any chance, refering to Artur Rubinstein or Anton? The way you write, it feels like you fucking listened to Anton playing it. Chopin was known for never performing the same thing in the same way twice, thats quite manly, I think. He didn't managed to be an eclectic composer, but his pieces are quite interesting and genuine enough to be recognized by anyone that knows a minimum of him. |
| I get the intention behind it to an extent, but Kaori's overblown personality is getting very old. I really couldn't buy her owning what she did to Kousei either, it just came too late for me to see as genuine. She knew she opened up old scars by forcing him into the accompaniment, and then tried to push him further without really addressing those scars. I like her character more for owning that, but there's a disconnect from what it should have been and what it really felt like. Had she apologized properly like this the next time she saw him(outside of the hospital at least) it would have come across more sincere and the drama would have been more genuine. It's like her apology was put off to this point so that when it happened Kousei would actually be at a point where he could give such a bright, confident answer so we wouldn't have to deal with too heavy an atmosphere without being immediately 'healed'. I didn't completely dislike the scene though and I did like how Kousei said that it was painful, but I just feel a lot of sketchiness in the delivery of the show sometimes(slapstick bits aside) |
 |
| damn the feels episode had me good. don't worry tsubaki I've got your back. childhood friends don't get the justice they deserve. the ost for this show will sell like hot cakes. |
 <--- Who Your Waifus Look Up To --->  |
| Wow Saori Hayami AND Yuki Kaji for the new rivals? Interesting. They're not my favourite seiyuu but I'm interested to hear how they'll voice these characters. On that note...Diamond no Ace anyone? Haruichi, Eijun, AND Mei xD So, this is probably the second or third best episode out of the six (number one goes to episode four obviously). I liked these four scenes: - Kaori and Kousei in the music room at night (I'm so glad the show didn't insert cheesy slapstick there!!) - Tsubaki's almost home run - Kousei and Tsubaki piggy back ride near the end ("I wish time would stop") - Tsubaki passing by the railroad thingy after asking senpai out And most of all, I'm loving the parallels used. The show emphasizes how much Kaori is playing in Kousei's life, in a positive, colourful way while it also emphasizes how Kousei is Tsubaki's colour and light. Also, as usual...Great OST. I liked that piano track near the end. I relate to Tsubaki btw. I've been in the position of someone who sees someone else as their light and grew to be attached to him while he was separating further. Anyway, really looking forward to the piano competition!!! YAAAS CHOPIN MUSIC :D edit - Took some time to skim through the comments in this thread... No, it's still a shounen but can appeal to girls/women because of the romance and the way it's presented. Jonesy974 said: Most annoying episode opening of the season goes to You don't have to listen to it, you know... |
MayukaNov 13, 2014 9:50 PM
| Another great episode. Kousei hard a work preparing for the competition. A lot of focus on Tsubaki this episode. To bad they lost the game. Kousei carrying her on his back at the end was sweet. Some new competitors. This will be interesting. |
"I’ve set myself to become the King of the Pirates…and if I die trying…then at least I tried!" Monkey D. Luffy (One Piece) |
Balakirev said: Oh, but no.5 is perfect. You have the "wrong notes" in section A, with its strict rhythm, and then as kousei gets more into the music, with flashbacks of his childhood then times with kaori, and then his style suddenly changes in the section B, playing with intense emotion and rubato, surprising all the judges and his 2 rivals. Section A1, will probably be skipped. The scene will show the surprised judges and rivals smirking, tsubaki and the soccer guy enchanted, and kaori smiling, then the music smoothly transitions to the trill at the end. Honestly I hope the girl playing winter wind wins... :D Ye you convinced me this will totally work out. Still, I wish there was no flashback, but a raw scene of him performing and yeah, we don't need to see all those insuferable generic gestures, along pedestrians yelling "yeah!" during the performance, or meaningless "muh feels" moments, we already know its irrelevant and helps with nothing but brainless children posting "epic!!!! aoty!!!!". Uh oh, maybe thats what A-1 is looking for |
| Dang girl. I feel you so much Tsubaki :'( Kaori must make something really huge now, so that I start shipping her with Kousei... |
 |
| Finally they spice thing up with those two rival. Will be interesting to see how Kousei handle them. Cannot wait for next episode. |
 |
| I mainly checked out this anime because I heard that it had a good soundtrack but I have to say that I am actually really enjoying it. It might not be my favorite this season but it is pretty high up on the list. |
 |
-Skyleo- said: Lol, nope ! xD I'm refering to Arthur Rubinstein of course, I don't even know Anton Rubinstein as a performer, just as a composer (I listened to a few of his symphonic stuff as well as some of his operas). I thought you could be mentioning Anton Rubinstein on a historical perspective (because he was somewhat close to Chopin at some point of his life, as well regarded as a good performer of Chopin's works) -Skyleo- said: Yeah, you nailed it. This is why I think Rubinstein (Arthur) is a great interpreter of Chopin. His sound is always bright and accurate, he always avoid to fall into the trap of the "honeyed" Chopin. Particularly I don't like Rubinstein (Artur) that much, at least not for the nocturnes and mazurkas. What do you think of Evgeni Koroliov? I really like how he play Chopin's Mazurkas, whenever I hear another performance I can't help but compare to how different it is from Koroliov. He also have a fantastic recording of the Art of Fugue (JS Bach). |
| So many funny, enjoyable scenes in this episode. The scene of Kaori opening the window to see Tsubaki was hilarious. I like the part when Kaori went back to school for Kousei inspite walking home with Tsubaki. Too early to decide who to ship, but so far, both girls are great... Kaori may be tipping the scale a bit more than Tsubaki because of her personality and her inclination of bringing the best in Kousei, but we'll still see. |
You can just be yourself. Do things your own way, one step at a time. You'll get there. Just be yourself, you'll be fine." ~Fruit Basket |
| Kousei rivals. Notice how one of them is a chick. inb4 this develops into lowkey harem |
 ☩ Discord: the.path.to.pathos ☩ RateYourMusic ☩ last.fm |
| Nice episode on Tsubaki's side. Liked the way they showed her feelings over Kousei and Kaori's relationship, very bittersweet. |
 |
TragicRomance said: Nice episode on Tsubaki's side. Liked the way they showed her feelings over Kousei and Kaori's relationship, very bittersweet. Yeah, that's exactly how I felt too. Though her jealousy thing is a little ridiculous. If she's never made her feelings known she's got no reason to be jealous. |
| Kaori is a wonderful character, but I do like Tsubaki as well. She's so.. real. lol. The rivals seem very serious about their work. I wonder how things will turn out. |
 check out my twitch: https://twitch.tv/slowy |
| Finally Arima's rivals make an appearance. Though the episode didn't really have much to do with music, was still quite enjoyable. Also, Tsubaki-chan. <3 |
 |
| 4/5 if they could get rid of the awful mix of slapstick and drama i'd be happy, reminds me of akame ga kill |
 |
| I badly want Kaori x Kousei, but I don't want Tsubaki to get hurt either. And I don't want anyone gone. (I'm scared to read the manga). If only Ryouta fixes is playboy act, then he'd be perfect pair for Tsubaki. |
| Dramatic episode again, Damn you Kousei, don't make Tsubaki cry like that again, I know that feeling. But they spent more time together than Kaori. I really hope Kousei and Tsubaki end up together. It seems like Kousei's opponents is getting hype. I'm excited for Kousei's performance. |
| Uh oh, looks like Tsubaki is getting jealous...........of Kaori. |
| Great episode as usual. I wonder what Kaori's feelings are? Finally Kousei's rivals appear. Next episode should be fantastic. But is feels like everything goes so fast... how will they keep this up to 22 episodes? |
 |
| The thing that really impressed me about this part of the story is that the author is not afraid to make his characters lives miserable on so many levels. Life sucks for just about everybody in the long run. (I haven't read far enough in the manga to know if it starts not sucking for anyone any time soon...) In most shounen stories like this, I would expect Tsubaki to win her game and other things like that. In this series, it takes the hopeful and dashes that hope against the rocks. |
Now blogging at TheZenOf Mysterious Girlfriend X Anime Fan Club - It's about more than drool! Tari Tari Fan Club - Hyouka Fan Club - Chitanda Eru Fans Club~ |
| For me Tsubaki is a little bit annoying... I hope this show won't be predictible as it appears to me rn. |
Hibiki07 said: Great episode as usual. I wonder what Kaori's feelings are? Finally Kousei's rivals appear. Next episode should be fantastic. But is feels like everything goes so fast... how will they keep this up to 22 episodes? I think they're going slow, actually. 6 episodes gone and its only in manga chapter 10. Manga should end with... 48~ chapters and they aren't going to be enough if they keep this pace, lol |
y123y said: mayukachan said: edit - Took some time to skim through the comments in this thread... No, it's still a shounen but can appeal to girls/women because of the romance and the way it's presented. ...To whom might you be referring to Mayuka? im referring to the conversation you started about this being a josei in disguise haha and by females i mean myself and the other females who enjoy this show |
| lol i was saying that its still shounen (as in guys can like this and the maturity level is for teenagers as well as how the romance is written) but can appeal to females. it might be too feminine for you but other guys like this. i finished dfrag out of the two. you can talk about it with me through profile comments lol |
| One thing that breaks the suspension-of-disbilief for me is how some anime make kids think and act like adults. Namely in that scene at night with Arima carrying Tsubaki, he was much more eloquent, wise and perceptive than any 14-year old should have the right to be. He's supposed to be a TEEN. And you tell me a 14-year old girl would start reflecting on the philosophy of music after seeing her love rival, while batting in a national competition? Give me a break. The excessive ambition of the script writers botched up this episode for me. |
Kelvets said: One thing that breaks the suspension-of-disbilief for me is how some anime make kids think and act like adults. Namely in that scene at night with Arima carrying Tsubaki, he was much more eloquent, wise and perceptive than any 14-year old should have the right to be. He's supposed to be a TEEN. Human being isn't a singular entity. Anyone can be eloquent and perceptive at any time in their lives. This isn't reserved for adults. |
| This was my favorite moment of this episode,it partially describes this show so far for me: Just think of it as if Kousei was talking about the anime as a whole instead of Kaori back there. |
| Kosei doesn't only have friend, it look like he have is load of rivals as well. Well, it was an episode centered around jealousy and the fear of being abandonned. I was abandonned once by a close friend, so I kinda see her fear, even if she don't see how much Kosei care for her. That last scene was really sad somehow, because you just know that it's a one-sided love, and she knows it too. She can just watch that destined couple, that also seem to have a lot of fated problems. Just go with your sympatic senpai then! Ahhh, sorry, that would break the square love triangle. I bursted out laughing when Tsubaki said ''I can see that he's suffering''. HE'S SUFFERING SINCE THE BEGINNING DAMNIT. DIDN'T YOU SAW WHEN HE GOT A BALL IN THE FACE, GOT BEATEN BY A GIRL HE BARELY MET, GOT THROWN OFF A BICYCLE TO FACEPLANT ON THE HARD GROUND? It was just sooo ironic. Kosei, you sure are a misleading guy, presenting a girl that got out of the shower in your shirt :P Awwwn, he didn't got laid... Story of my life. Edit : MgMaster said: This was my favorite moment of this episode,it partially describes this show so far for me: Just think of it as if Kousei was talking about the anime as a whole instead of Kaori back there. That was hilarious, exactly what I thought at that moment xD Kaori is adorable in her own ways, but damn, is she crazy and manipulative, always crying and making Kosei feel guilty :P |
minouneetzoeNov 14, 2014 6:11 PM
| «Time is passing so quickly. Right now, I feel like complaining to Einstein. Whether time is slow or fast depends on perception. Relativity theory is so romantic. And so sad.» - Kurisu Makise a.k.a. The Zombie |
| AWHH TSUBKAI <33 Fuck I thought I could get through this series without completely siding with one heroine but dammit i have such a sweet spot for the childhood friend. I hope they don't dive into her anymore or else I'll be committed to team Tsubaki completely and her odds of being the winning heroine are slim. :( |
The best anime is the Road to El Dorado |
Kelvets said: One thing that breaks the suspension-of-disbilief for me is how some anime make kids think and act like adults. Namely in that scene at night with Arima carrying Tsubaki, he was much more eloquent, wise and perceptive than any 14-year old should have the right to be. He's supposed to be a TEEN. And you tell me a 14-year old girl would start reflecting on the philosophy of music after seeing her love rival, while batting in a national competition? Give me a break. I can't believe people are complaining that the kids don't act immature enough LOOL |
| ^ are you disagreeing with me because I wasn't siding with anyone |
y123y said: mayukachan said: ^ are you disagreeing with me because I wasn't siding with anyone Sorry, just having a bad day. nevermind me. lol it's fine. I was originally just quoting Kelvets because I thought it was funny how that could be something to criticize this show for, when it has other flaws that are easier to point out. |
Hulmy-chan said: You saw the moment she hurt her leg when she was playing baseball right?Watch anime more carefully before criticizing it without thinking please...>very lightly kicks her shin >somehow causes her extreme pain and a sore foot Not gonna explain how that happened there, anime? No? Okay then... |
 |
| Romance anime wouldn't be complete without the jealousy part. It's nice to see Kousei returning the favor to Tsubaki by giving her a piggyback. Small, but precious memories. At the end, rivals appear. Kousei should be prepared for the challenges. |
Hulmy-chan said: >very lightly kicks her shin >somehow causes her extreme pain and a sore foot Not gonna explain how that happened there, anime? No? Okay then... Confirmed for never experiencing something similar. Her problem started during the match. Later when Kousei softly kicked her foot, she could have realized the pain on her foot (yeah, sometimes you can only notice that something hurts after paying attention to it) or it might have caused a bad reaction like worsening the situation. Hulmy-chan said: So that explains why the ice was on her foot, right? Read posts on MAL more carefully before replying please... So you cannot forgive this thing but relevate those gore slapstick scenes? The anime itself contain exagerated parts (being the slapsticks one of the examples). Maybe she didn't even needed that ice, but just an illustration to make us think she had a serious problem right there and couldn't walk, all to reemulate that piggyback scene they had long ago. |
| Ugh, the monologues are drowning out good moments again. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso Episode 22 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 19, 2015 |
1185 |
by owisty
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Your Lie in April is 10yrs Old Today 🥳Cestlavie_ - Oct 9 |
48 |
by RobertBobert
»»
Today, 2:39 AM |
|
Poll: » Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Nov 27, 2014 |
241 |
by Ambrous
»»
Nov 5, 6:56 AM |
|
Poll: » Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Dec 11, 2014 |
337 |
by Gansas
»»
Oct 17, 9:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 23, 2014 |
288 |
by chris1763
»»
Sep 28, 10:05 AM |