Horror fan here.
Inexplicable said:Out of all the "horror" anime I've watched (71 titles according to anime.plus), Shiki is the closest to an actual horror and none of the others even come close
Agree with this wholeheartedly.
Shiki is the best example of a "pure" horror anime series I've seen to date where the core central genre is indisputably horror; almost exclusively so (you could credibly argue it's also part thriller and part drama, but that's a natural consequence and outgrowth of the story and situation itself common to many non-anime horror titles). It definitely has as well the characteristic atmospheric tension of an isolated setting, wandering dark deserted streets at night while a menace is on the prowl unbeknownst to the PoV character at the time, a feeling of hopeless and despair at being surrounded and outnumbered, threatened to be consumed, by a seemingly unstoppable force that is perverting nature/the natural order, giving in/submission to the terror and circumstances as there's no likelihood of being saved, small world around you collapsing in on itself leading people to break with the pretenses of their previous roles and personas under normal circumstances, questioning the meaning of life & death/basic precepts of morality, dread, existential depression, etc.
Now, whether one finds it scary is another thing. That's always so completely individual. Personally, I find there are a number of tense moments where you're waiting for the hammer to drop similar to in a thriller, and some gruesome and evocative imagery, similar to in most at-least-decent horror. But 99.9% of either anime or non-anime horror alike in the whole breadth of media doesn't genuinely scare me in a deep and lasting manner in the sense of where I actually feel physiologically stimulated to feel physically uncomfortable and on edge at the time of viewing and/or thinking about it long afterward in the hours, days, even weeks or more ahead and coloring my perception of the world at all when, say, in the house alone at night.
I'm very desensitized to horror media in general having watched obscene and obsessive level amounts of it from a very young age and it long being one of my favorite genres, and that extends to anime titles too. I can count on less than two hands all the non-anime horror films and series which actually scare me in that real visceral way at any point in their runtime, and for anime, I think I can confidently say only parts of Higurashi season one did so.
It isn't the reason I watch horror anyway though, truth be told. I watch (hopefully, usually reasonably above average quality) horror for the same reason I watch and seek out good thrillers, drama, Sci-Fi, or fantasy - to see what kind of world and story they construct and, complementary to that, how they use it to explore the human condition and the mysteries of life/the universe. Unexplored or, typically rather, underexplored, thoughts and feelings with the who/what/when/where/why/how of the plot, setting, characters, etc. merely serving as its structural basis and a conduit. Shiki delivers that in spades, making it an excellent example of horror fiction, regardless of how subjectively frightening or not one individually finds it.
|