Let me start by saying I have been using desktop version way more than the mobile app. I have always loved using the seasonal section and I actually spend a lot of my time on MAL on it, not only for the current season but for previous seasons, too. I've been a fan of almost every change introduced in the last 5 years and could never say anything but praise for all your hard work so far. But honestly, this one is a huge, disastrous downgrade in my opinion. I feel that is has been made with the presumption that people mostly look only at the current season and not previous seasons which has led to some horrible decisions which made the seasonal page way worse. The things that I've found worse so far are:
1) Studio name shoved below description. Studio name is probably one of the most important things about an anime because, well... it tells us who created it. Few things could be more vital than this and now they are in an ugly and hardly noticeable spot.
2) Average duration of episodes moved way above. Okay, seriously? We are talking about seasonal anime. In 99% of the cases, it's something between 22 and 24 minutes. Who would want to know if an anime is 1 minute longer or shorter?! What information does that bring us? Absolutely nothing. Awful move, to say the least.
3) Air date moved way above without mentioning the hour. Another hideous change. Ok, I might have not detested this change if it was at least serving its purpose of giving me an information when will an anime I anticipate start. But it's not even doing that - because of timezones, Jan 10 might be Jan 10 or Jan 9 for me. So not only did you completely ignore all people who look at previous seasons and don't care which date exactly did an anime start airing in Summer 1992, you demolished the chance to give the full information and gave only the sole date, which on its own does more to mislead people than give them to correct time when they'd expect the anime to air. So, to summarize it - you introduce a change which could have been useful only for one page out of the entirety of above 400 anime seasons in history (and number would only rise), only for around of 4 months (at the very end and beginning of each quarter), but actually would might often prove to be misleading.
4) Number of members rounded in a weird way. Ye, it might be not that significant whether the members of an anime are 867K or 868K, for example. But for the rounding of millions, this change is makes us lose visibility of tens of thousands. 1.7M might be 1,650,000 but it might also be 1,749,999. Furthermore, it looks simply weird and way worse than it used be. And you had enough to space for those few more digits so you don't actually win anything with it. If you want to give us information - give us the full one.
5) "Add" button uses almost the same color as "completed". This one is a very niche change for people like me who want to be able to recognize in just a glance the status of their seasonal anime for the given season, without reading its name. Before these changes, it was easily visible - grey for not added and blue for completed. Ye, well, not anymore. Now "Completed" and "Add to List" are colored almost the same and I have to stop for a split-second and take a look to see whether I completed the anime. Which completely destroys the idea of being able to tell which anime I have or haven't watched without reading the names cause I take the time to look at the status, I'd rather just read the name.
6) Promotional video button made larger and more visible. This also might be something that affects only me and a small portion of people - but there are some who don't really care about promotional videos. Great, you've added the option for enthusiasts to do so - why make it larger now? Furthermore, the blue color adds up to the blue of "Completed"/"Add to List" buttons and becomes too dominating and tough on the eyes.
Of course, it hasn't been all bad. To end with something positive, I'd say that I really dig the way you added our rating next to the status of the anime. Now that's a great change. But for all the rest, they really hinder the way I use the site and I'd definitely start using it way less if at least some of them aren't resolved in the near future. It just kills my fun when looking at seasonal anime's page. |