Sabishisugite Lesbian Fuuzoku ni Ikimashita Report
My Lesbian Experience with Loneliness

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

This is a very personal story, evident from the title itself, but the author really invites the reader to delve deep into her mind as we read. Most of the people who will come across this manga will be familiar with at least some of the feelings and experiences described here, be it the loneliness or the shame, but in a way it's good to know others feel this way, too. The manga really does ground us in a way few other works I've read manage to do, being filled with the very essence of the author's life in such a practical way.

The art ... style is good — the simplicity makes it so the intent between each panel is very clear, and the pink reminiscent of a "classic girl's color", or even the lesbian flag, does it's work to make what's really important pop out to the reader immediately, as good composition ought to do, and it's not overwhelming in any of the chapters. It's not a classic manga in the way that we expect dialogue + a few thought boxes here and there, and coming in hoping for such will disappoint you immediately. It's a memoir, despite it's medium, so it ought to be treated as such.

Of course, in being a memoir, it's not as comedic or dynamic, and (I do suspect it is a translation issue more than anything) there are some stiff moments in the writing, but it doesn't impede the ability of the author to describe deeply cuttng experiences in such a way that leaves us baffled until the next time she does it again. The final chapter, especifically, feels like a gut punch after the other.

I'd recommend this to anyone feeling stuck in one place, or anyone who doesn't see a future ahead, because even if it doesn't manage to pull us out, it's good to know these experiences aren't exclusive. Unique, sure, but just a part of being human.

My Lesbian Experience with Loneliness – Spoiler Free – Mixed Feelings

TLDR
Story – 6,5/10 – 6,5 x 0.275 = 1,7875
Art – 6,5/10 – 6,5 x 0.2 = 1,3
Characters – 7,5/10 – 7,5 x 0.225 = 1,575
Enjoyment – 6/10 – 6 x 0.3 = 1,8
Total: 6,4625 -> 6

Story – 6.5/10
The story's premise is fairly basic – Kabi Nagata is reaching the end of her 20s and is still a virgin; her, a lesbian, decides to contact an escort agency to lose her virginity with another woman. It is a very personal and autobiographical story, and rightfully so. The manga deals with the anxieties of such an ... adventure. The premise, however, is also its conclusion: it offers nothing more than this. There is a build-up until the culminating point and an overview of an after; all very simple.
There is a strong emphasis on depicting mental illnesses—mostly depression—and their symptoms, such as isolation or self-harm. The manga does a fairly good job of explaining these internal psychological mechanisms in a friendly, intuitive, and truthful fashion. This is the story’s greatest victory and the reason it gains a few points in the story’s rating.

Art – 6,5/10
The art style in “My Lesbian Experience with Loneliness” is anything but ugly, although sui generis. It is flashy (in the good sense of the word) because it uses more than the black-and-white scheme with great success (it has pink in almost all pages); it is fairly minimalistic and does not have much detail at all, since its focus is obviously the main character’s story. The character design, however, is well-done. The scenarios are also minimalistic, to say the least.

Characters – 7,5/10
The characters, in a typical short story, are hardly well developed (or at least the chances of being so are fewer), but since this is an autobiographical manga, characters do provide a sound basis of believability and empathy; although only the main character receives a proper development. This is a short one-shot and, thus, there would arguably any space whatsoever to include a second character. This only focuses, then, on Kabi Nagata. And, on this matter, she depicted herself in a human, warm, and entertaining fashion.

Enjoyment – 6/10
Personally, the enjoyment in this manga isn’t very high, but it all depends on what you are searching for: if you want a truthful depiction of self-harm and depression, as well as living with self-harm scars, Kabi Nagata provides an engaging work of art, if you want a fully fleshed story, you won’t find it here. This manga, however, is one-of-kind: and, in all fairness, it sticks with you, which I believe means a lot in such a short story. Its depiction of depression is one of the best I’ve seen in manga, and for that I believe it deserves a recommendation. However, the story simply doesn't allow for a plain recommendation, and thus a mixed feelings stamp.

I saw this at first from anime man. Then I kept hearing about this manga until i decided to just buy it and give it a go... Gay social commentary Its a trend right now. So I go in expecting a cry-fest, i loved the pitch, i dig the concept i'm all in!!!

So I start reading it and in the first scene this 28-year old woman is in bed with a female escort, then it pauses and starts from her high school life...Why would you spoil the lesbian scene? I didn't like that.

So the book goes on, my biggest problem is that It's more of ... a picture book than a comic book.The entire book is narrated and the pictures show an exaggerating depiction of the narration. It reminded me of cartoon story-time youtubers and I couldn't get past that, I would have prefered if this was a podcast or a stand up show, I don't get why was this in a comic book form, it clearly looks like a true story so why didn't she perform this story instead ?
Also a huge knit peak for me is when i read comics-mangas I like when the story comes from the characters, this entire book is narrated.

Last thing is that I felt the narrator was kinda preachy especially in the work force related subjects. I felt this book was more about being indie than homosexual, hahaha the book wasn't gay enough hahaha.

The art is amatuerish and it is pink colored which i hugely dislike these days when some manga will choose a color and everything that would be pink is colored pink...It throws me off, just be black and white, why color it if you are going to have only a single color?

The main character i explained earlier why i disliked her, and then the lesbian payoff finally happens and is meh, for me it upgraded it from a 2 to a 3.

Its ok if we disagree, have a nice day.