| Recently, I changed my grading scale of anime, and I found myself filled with some 1s... I rate an anime 1 to those which I find myself preaching to others about how bad the it was... (they are often popular ones which didn't meet the hype). What about you? (Or am I really a critic? I give some of my favorite series 7/10 to differentiate between my favorites>) |
| My ratings are pretty much based on gut feelings instead of being a critic. So if I feel like something is beyond shit, then it gets a 1. And vice versa for 10s/9s and etc. |
 |
| I don't I have rated one that low (yet), but I tend to avoid anime I know I'm not going to like instantly. It's kinda setting yourself up to fail if you know prior that's going to be garbage. I mean, try new things, but not to that extent if the series is going to be bad. |
 "Achieve not with the squad, but by yourself." - Urie  |
| I wont give anything a 1. Not a single anime deserves it since a little effort was put into it, so the lowest ill do is 2. |
| I don't think I really will ever rate one ever a 1 mostly since I check out an anime before determining if I should buy it on DVD or not (which I do for every series I have on my MAL) but if theirs ever a time that would happen it would have to be really bad (imo) The lowest scores I have are 6/10's (atm anyways) |
  All the Anime's on my list are all one's I own Personal physical copies of, or have seen in theaters that I plan on buying, series that I've watched on FUNimation or HIDIVE will not be on here unless/until I have already bought it. |
| My ratings are entirely based on my overall experience watching the show, because to me enjoyment and "critical" value are the exact same thing. Higher/lower a show is scored on my MAL, the better/worse I think it is. So anything that is a 1 is something that is so unbelievably bad that it manages to impact me as a person due to how bad it was, to the point where I will think about the show often, "man, that show was fucking awfuler then what could be considered awful." |
| every single one of my forum posts is dumb and invalid except for 1, I don't claim them it was a different person it was all fake |
| I just give an 1 rating to unwatchable crap like Pupa, Mars of Destruction, etc. I also call that rating the "Insult to animation" section. The only good part about those anime is the "so bad, it's funny" moments they have sometimes. |
Futari wa Milky Holmes was a mistake Yoshii did nothing wrong |
ShadowCode said: I wont give anything a 1. Not a single anime deserves it since a little effort was put into it, so the lowest ill do is 2. I can agree with that (sorry for this part I needed an extra 13 characters you can ignore this part) |
All the Anime's on my list are all one's I own Personal physical copies of, or have seen in theaters that I plan on buying, series that I've watched on FUNimation or HIDIVE will not be on here unless/until I have already bought it. |
| I give 1's to any popular anime that I don't consider to be "good" because I want attention. |
| I give 1s to anime that I thought were just unbearable to watch. |
| :) |
Fang said: I give 1's to any popular anime that I don't consider to be "good" because I want attention. I gotta agree with you in some parts here. |
| When there's nothing redeemable to be found. It isn't even funny bad, otherwise it would get at least a 2. |
| 1/10: anyone who has basic logic or a shade of taste know this is shit. this thing is an insult to intelligence. not positives whatsoever. anyone who think this is good, is truly an idiot. i didnt like the premise not most thing that happen in this show. anything i dont like i drop. so i dont really have rated a show with 1/10. mars of destruction however is 1/10. |
| i am shitposter. dont take me seriously. |
| when it's Guilty Crown, That show was SHHIITTT |
| When the anime is so abominally bad that I shouldn't have even picked it up out of morbid curiosity. For contrast, I'd give a 3 to "normal" terrible anime. |
| Usually things that are either painful to watch, barely anime, or otherwise absolute trash. I don't group things like SAO and Glasslip in with the stuff that truly deserves to be marked as waste products that never should have existed. Papillon Rose is the longest anime I've ever given a 1 to. It was 150 minutes of anime torture. |
  |
Fang said: I give 1's to any popular anime that I don't consider to be "good" because I want attention. The Jim Sterling of the anime world lol. I have given 1's to things that I really hated. Finished them because I thought they might get better but where a complete waste of time and effort IMO of course. If it fails at everything it does in everyway. I agree sometimes it's so bad it's good and that doesn't deserve a 1. |
| Giving a 1 is an honor. 2-3 is bad in a boring way. 1 is bad in a "you have to see it" way. Aside from the third Berserk movie. That just triggered me. |
| I rate a 1 if either I can't find enough or any positives about the show, or I despise it on a personal level. All of the shows I've given a 1 to except Gakuen Handsome follow this rule. |
     |
| Haven't rated an anime that low yet, probably because I immediately drop anime that I know will disappoint me and bore me out of my mind. |
Fang said: I give 1's to any popular anime that I don't consider to be "good" because I want attention. Proper answer: I don't give 1's out at all really. 10's/Masterpieces are something that I intentionally look for and stumble across once in a while after searching through a ton of highly scored anime. Just like that, I believe 1's are the same. They are the worst of the worst. I think that if you rate properly and you've truly given an anime a 1, you've looked for it, just like you look for masterpieces. |
| I give a 1 rating if I can't think of a single thing I like about the show. |
| Garbage-Tier Shows, Cause It's suprisingly Horrendous to continue the whole thing for now |
 "Think about that glowing dust That destroys the night sky's dream of Just being nothing"--  -- |
| When an anime fails in every aspect, from plot, pacing, character to animation/presentation and sound. It doesn't necessarily piss me off to "earn" a 1, in some case like Hatsune no Mars, it simply forced me to do it without even hesitation lol, and i didn't feel irritated when watching it. |
| Simple. If it is as bad as Mirai Nikki, I rate 1. |
| I have not yet given an anime a 1. Then again, I've only completed around 30 anime. However, I have never given an anime a 10 either, I'm like you in trying to keep an average around 10. Even anime that are rated 6 are considered good in my book. But anyway, since I rate it on 5 points objectively and 5 points subjectively, the anime has to be appalling in both aspects. It has to be missing all aspects that any good anime have. It has to be a struggle just advancing from one episode to the next. Shallow character development (or unlikeable characters), lack of entertainment, lack of plot, too much resemblance to other anime, bad voice acting or illustrations, lack of creativity... Rudan said: Simple. If it is as bad as Mirai Nikki, I rate 1. The fact that Mirai Nikki got a 1 in your book and One Punch Man got a 9 is wholly embarrassing. This is when you have to take a step back and realize that you are not judging by any means of objectivity. I don't usually judge people based on their anime ratings, but this is just.... sad. Then again, your mean rating is 7.7 despite that, so I didn't really expect fairly weighted ratings. |
 |
primaltare said: I have not yet given an anime a 1. Then again, I've only completed around 30 anime. However, I have never given an anime a 10 either, I'm like you in trying to keep an average around 10. Even anime that are rated 6 are considered good in my book. But anyway, since I rate it on 5 points objectively and 5 points subjectively, the anime has to be appalling in both aspects. It has to be missing all aspects that any good anime have. It has to be a struggle just advancing from one episode to the next. Shallow character development (or unlikeable characters), lack of entertainment, lack of plot, too much resemblance to other anime, bad voice acting or illustrations, lack of creativity... Rudan said: Simple. If it is as bad as Mirai Nikki, I rate 1. The fact that Mirai Nikki got a 1 in your book and One Punch Man got a 9 is wholly embarrassing. This is when you have to take a step back and realize that you are not judging by any means of objectivity. I don't usually judge people based on their anime ratings, but this is just.... sad. Then again, your mean rating is 7.7 despite that, so I didn't really expect fairly weighted ratings. dude those are my ratings, go live ur life lul leave me alone ffs its my opnion mirai nikki is shit. if u think its good then good for u i dont even care edit: oh lol i see u have yuno and mirai nikki in ur favs nevermind then, i wont complain anymore |
WorthinessMay 16, 2017 8:25 PM
| An anime deserves a 1/10 when it's so incomprehensibly bad that my entire day is ruined by my having been reminded of its existence--an anime that is almost entirely bereft of any positive qualities whatsoever. 1/10 indicates BOTH the absence of Good and the overabundance of Terrible. |
 This glorious signature image was created by @Mayumi! I am the Arbiter of Absolute Truth, and here is my wisdom: "Anime was always influenced by the West. This is not news. Shoujo is the superior genre primarily aimed at young people. Harem/isekai are lazy genres that refuse any meaningful innovation. There is no 'Golden Age.' There will always be top-shelf anime. You should be watching Carole & Tuesday." |
| My scores are pretty much based on my personal enjoyment. Heck i scored Danmachi 1 :D |
on 
| Bad anime, bad. Don't do that, you get the squirt bottle. |
 |
| I've never given a 1 to any show because if I see it's bad right from the start I'll drop it without even rating (e.g. Seitokai Yakuindomo). You know, things could get better later on, but I won't waste my time waiting for it. The lowest scores on my list (3s and 4s) are either one episode OVAs or shows that started good and went downhill afterwards. I would totally give a 1 to one of these if it was too boring, too full of flaws, if it ruined a good franchise or otherwise had no redeeming qualities to it. EDIT: Also, an anime making light of a serious issue or using one just for shock value is the quickest way to make me drop a show. Watamote and Kaichou wa Maid Sama both fall under that category. |
AnotherGuyMay 16, 2017 8:34 PM
AnotherGuy said: if I see it's bad right from the start I'll drop it without even rating ([...]Watamote) JNFJNWDWDIOQSNIOSQOMWDOMKWQIPSJKQWJK I WILL FIGHT YOU IN THE STREETS. |
This glorious signature image was created by @Mayumi! I am the Arbiter of Absolute Truth, and here is my wisdom: "Anime was always influenced by the West. This is not news. Shoujo is the superior genre primarily aimed at young people. Harem/isekai are lazy genres that refuse any meaningful innovation. There is no 'Golden Age.' There will always be top-shelf anime. You should be watching Carole & Tuesday." |
| When someone rate something 1/10, that's the time they rate it 1/10. |
| When my penis isn't rock hard. ///// |
| When I'm sure enough that my impression about the anime won't change... usually I tend to think from all perspectives... animation,story, music etc. before I give it a rating. However,for long animes there is an exception...they earn their rating before they are finished...every long anime consists of one or more moments which gives a feeling," Oh! I bet it deserves this rating !"...and that's that...I give them the rating... usually my judgement doesn't change. |
 |
| _Ako_ said: When someone rate something 1/10, that's the time they rate it 1/10. Good point here! I like your thinking. :D It means that anime is simply awful and with some extremely poor quality. |
thatPinkSpiderMay 16, 2017 10:06 PM
 "Please stop talking about math when I'm eating." |
| I haven't rated an anime with 1 yet as like others I am also avoiding anime that I am quite sure that I will not like or enjoy. Though I rate an anime not exclusively to enjoyment (but also other aspects that make an anime), the scores I give on each criteria are still base on my own judgment/opinion. So even if I really hate the anime but the art style and sounds are good to my eyes and ears, then it will end up with a score greater than 1 for me (even though my enjoyment to that anime is absolutely a 1/10 LOL). |
 |
| I rate an anime a 1 if the anime pisses me off and I have barely any enjoyment from it (and the enjoyment isn't enough to overcome the negatives) |
MechKingKillbotMay 17, 2017 9:22 AM
 |
| never rated a 1 before. lowest was a 4, borderline 3. i usually don't pick stuff i don't think i'll enjoy |
 |
| I only really rate an anime that low as a kek, very rarely do I find a series horrid enough to actually deserve a 1 rating. |
╮ (. ❛ ᴗ ❛.) ╭ |
| never ...I usually drop anime but don't mention it in the dropped list |
 |
More topics from this board
» Is there hope for classic super robots?Timeline_man - Yesterday |
7 |
by IKKIsama
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Misandry ( 1 2 3 )ColourWheel - Apr 21 |
137 |
by KittenCuddler
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Is anime just more honest about it's intent than western media?Spunkert - 2 hours ago |
3 |
by FanofAction
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
» Is there an anime character who looks like you in real life?Alpha_1_Zero - 1 hour ago |
4 |
by Rinrinka
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Is it weird to be attracted to anime characters under the age of 18?bluefin2004 - Yesterday |
47 |
by LostSpectre
»»
26 minutes ago |