CrimsonLight said: I don't buy this happily ever after ending.
There's no way this could end happily... Her just reverting back to her old self.
I sort of agree. It seemed not only rushed but unrealistic. Although I'm sure that's KyoAni's fault. It's probably well explained in the novel. I'll address Rikka reverting to her old self at the end of this post, but first, I will discuss what really bothered me about this episode that sort of a killed a series that was on a roll.
First off, some inconsistencies. the whole think with Kumin pretending to be the wicked eye is never truly explained. I suppose Rikka out of frustration called her and poured her heart out to Kumin, leading her to do what she did and say what she did to Yuuta. (Although I don't understand how the hell she got to the middle of the highway where yuuta was on a bike on, wouldn't a phone call from Kumin to Yuuta have worked better?)
Second, Rikka's grandfather and his reaction to what was going on. any idiot can tell a boy on the roof next to a girls room at night telling her to come with him means a romance meetup. I don't buy the whole "grandfather thought he was a burglar" BS, unless he's just stupid. The policeman popping out of nowhere was sort of weird as well, as was the three friends also showing up randomly. This is starting to seem more like a weird dream than a believable episode. OK, moving on.
Third, the Ethereal horizon. I think it was amazingly cute and romantic what Yuuta did when Rikka and him got to the beach. Although, I wonder if what was animated is truly what the author had in mind. The way I see it, Yuuta told Rikka that was the ethereal horizon, and that she should tell it the feelings she's holding back. In other words, he's telling her to let go of her past by saying goodbye to her father. I believe that moment was completely obliterated though by the fact that yuuta turned into a nuclear reactor and blew the fuck up, followed up by a scene out of something like 2001: A Space Oddysey. There was no need at all for the explosions and all that BS. In fact, I am almost sure the author meant for that scene to be pictured only as a girl and her lover on a "beach" looking at the lights; with Yuuta comforting her to accept her feelings and her "fantasies" as natural. Not as some time travel scene.
Fourth, the end of the end (or lack of proper resolution). This is sort of stupid, but can you blame me for being a bit peeved about the fact a damn cop car wasn't able to catch a guy on a bike? If anything, either the author (if this is how he wrote the story), or KyoAni should have taken the time to make ONE more freaking episode to explain how the conflict was resolved. This is where I address what CrimsonLight referred to.
The main conflict of this story was that Rikka's "Chuunibyou" was causing her big problems with her family. It was getting her sister and grandfather pissed and causing her mother and grandmother grief. That conflict was pacified when Yuuta convinced Rikka to stop the "act". As Rikka said, her family was now relieved and happy. But then another conflict came about:
Rikka herself was unhappy. I don't believe it was because she was no longer pretending ot have the wicked eye, but because she was away from her friends, and, especially, Yuuta. The part where she's holding the thingamajig to water the plants and begins to cry shows us she misses the time she spent with Yuuta. Of course we then see Yuuta come to the rescue after riding on a bike, blah blah blah, Yuuta gets her to come to terms with her father death, etc. And then, simply, "The end".
What?
No, it's not the end, how cna you end a story without explaining how the conflict was resolved? As explained above, Rikka's Chuunibyou was causing big family problems. They do not realize the Chuunibyou is what she uses (or used) to deal with her father's death. in the end, it is implied Rikka went back to her older self, wearing the patch again, etc, etc. Back to square 1. Do you truly believe her grandfather and sister are just going to take that? If anything, I am sure they would be pissed at the fact she is back to her old self. This is where Chuunibyou lacks in what ToraDora! had: a confrontation with the conflict. The (in my opinion) logical thing to do would have been that Rikka confront her family about her feelings, and how she was treated by them, how they ignored her personality and her feelings, how they are making her miserable by telling her to move to gramp's place when she has set roots in Yuuta's town, has friends there, and has the boy she is in love with there. The logical thing would have been that Rikka do what almost any other human would do and set her foot down once she realizes what she wants.
Why the hell would they have moved back to Yuuta's town after all of this? (implied when she goes to Yuuta's balcony), unless she were to explain that she needed to be there instead of at gramps' place? It makes no sense. That's the problem with this episode, and this "ending". It makes no realistic sense. I don't expect anime ot be devoid of fiction, of course not, but they really killed this ending by making it seem more like a dream than something that really happened.
Not to mention what others have said. No kiss? Not even an "I love you?" or a "Thank you Yuuta"?, or anything that confirmed what everyone watched romance in general for: whether or not they ended up as a couple? What I got out of this ending is Yuuta being like a best friend more than a lover. I'm sure it's intended Yuuta and Rikka became lovers, but what was the problem with taking 2 or 3 seconds out of the episode to animate a kiss? (Maybe after the beach thing; I can just picture Rikka telling Yuuta to close his eyes and pop!)
I truly believed this was going to end with Rikka (and Dekomori) accepting their fantasies weren't real, but that they weren't anything to be ashamed of, that they were natural, and, if anything, allowed them to do what kids should do: have fun. But that is was time to move on, and to grow up a little bit. I really loved the mssage the narrator said at the end. I agree with it completely, but why not show this with Rikka doing what I said above instead of simply narrating it? In the end, Rikka going back to the pretend games would only cause problems, if not for her family to forbidding her to see Yuuta when they realize it was him that convinced her to be true to herself.
Chuunibyou will get either an 8 or 9 out of 10 from me, I'm sad ot say, it had the potential to, but didn't, surpass ToraDora! |