Attack on Titan
| Over time through the final arc i pushed it from a 10 to about a 4. And i doubt any extra pages will change that either |
 |
| Witnessing the rumbling arc degrade to what it is today has probably been the saddest shit I've seen in awhile. It's very disappointing to see just how bad Isayama fumbled the bag. This arc could've been an easy 10/10, but with the chapters after 131, I can't rate it higher than a 3/10. The extra pages in 139 haven't changed my rating since they're not that bad, but definitely not good either. |
| i changed my 10 to a 9 cuz the ending was very underwhelming. Btw I feel like changing a score of 10 to like a 3 is straight up over exaggerating |
| Pain |
| Still 10/10 , my brain told me to change the score to 9 but I listened to my heart |
| i keep flicking between a 10, 9, and 8. i’ve settled on a 9 now. it’s my absolute favourite series of all time, and i enjoyed every minute of reading it despite the amount of criticism the final chapters received, but i can’t bring myself to give it a 10 bcos i’m not entirely happy with the way isayama concluded any of the characters. |
| Chapter 123: 10/10 and #1 favorite anime/manga. Hail Eren! Chapter 139: 9.5/10, just has an underwhelming ending. Ereh meh. Chapter 139 (one month later): 9/10, the ending really did hurt it more than I'd like to admit. Leaks: 8.5/10 lowered to 8/10. The final arc & ending did too much damage and since my only experience with the manga was the Rumbling, I'm not impressed. I still love pre-timeskip anime though and it still undoubtedly has some of the most epic moments period. |
 |
| 7/10 139 Ending subplots are too messy and ruin the whole series' buildup. In addition, the 8-page mist ending hard carried and saved many themes of the series but every time I think about the love story of Ymir I just cringe. Eren as an MC is still a joke as both his plan and his ambition are a joke. |
| 9 to a 6. I used to have it at a 7 after the first ending but the 8 page ending just added more fuel on to the fire of why this series just feels like a mess at the end. While it acknowledges the problem of the status of the world in the wake of Eren it adds fuel on to the fire that most of the decision making for the characters in the last two arcs is stupid. I still feel I probably will have nostalgia for the earlier arcs. It was the series that helped get me back into anime/manga after a long hiatus and I still appreciate it for that. That said that last arc was terrible probably like a 2/10 if I was rating it alone. |
BilboBaggins365May 18, 2021 1:33 PM
| My overall score went like this: Ch1-123 10/10 Ch124-139 8/10 Ch139+New pages 7/10 The rumbling arc as a whole is probably a 4/10 at best from me and that feels generous. |
 |
| After the leaks,I gave it a 6/10. It used to be 9. While Paradis getting destroyed by the remaining world makes sense now but it absolutely butchers the characters of Eren & Armin. The fact that Armin was saved by Levi instead of Erwin just became useless. Also, I did not like that Mikasa had to marry someone to move on from Eren but she still keeps visiting Eren's grave. Not to mention the countless sacrifices of Erwin Smith & his comrades, all went in vain. They died for nothing. Then there is that Ymir×Fritz problem which is messed up. The ending is 1/10 for me. Still, the good stuff beforehand makes it to a 6 for me. |
| It's gone from 9 to 6 (now), but I'll probably change it to 5 someday. Ending is very important for any story, and Isayama completely ruined it. |
| For me, it went from a strong 9/10 to like a lower but still 9/10. It's still surprisingly similar. |
 |
| I gave it a 7 because everything prior to this shit show of a last arc was good, but I might lower it to a 6 in the future |
 |
| same except 130/131 is a 10/10 |
 |
| nothing has changes dude. the entire manga has the same quality. |
| Chapter 1-123: 10/10 Chapter 124-138: 6/10 Chapter 139: 2/10 Extra pages: wtf/10 |
 |
| Up to the basement 9/10 Up to the rumbling 8/10 Up to 139 4/10 Final rating after the additional pages 1/10. It was a good story but the author became addicted to plot twists and he decided to twist his series to oblivion. He is young so I bet that he will contemplate and revisit it in the future, with eva style treatment. |
| -1 after chapter 139, because I still wanted to value the "emotional impact" of the finale another -1 after the extra pages I never thought AoT was a masterpiece (something like a 7-8/10 at best) and that's probably why I'm not so butthurt to lower the score to 1/10, but I wouldn't blame anyone who did so |
I wish Connie wouldn't stop him from being eaten by his mom. I kinda liked Armin as a character before time-skip, he seemed like a pretty smart fella, a lil bit naive but okay, but AFTER time-skip he turned into a joke. |
| Before time skip it was a 7, after the time skip it became a 5, and after the ending a 3. |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
| before Rumbling Arc it was 10/10 but the Rumbling Arc is 8/10 overall even with the bonus pages i hate the Pro Genocide message of this manga |
deg said: I don't see how it's pro-genocide when the ultimate takeaway is that Eren's actions begot the wrath of the world many decades (or centuries) later. Nothing was ultimately gained and the actual travesty of it all is the notion that the world is somehow "better" without titans.before Rumbling Arc it was 10/10 but the Rumbling Arc is 8/10 overall even with the bonus pages i hate the Pro Genocide message of this manga |
|
| I decided that I will delete the manga from list and pretend I didn't get scammed |
"no one really laughs on the internet, they just go 'hM' and type '𝕃𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸𝕆𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸'." I'm Level 69 on Mal Badges. View My Badges.  |
__kami said: hayzi said: Witnessing the rumbling arc degrade to what it is today has probably been the saddest shit I've seen in awhile. It's very disappointing to see just how bad Isayama fumbled the bag. This arc could've been an easy 10/10, but with the chapters after 131, I can't rate it higher than a 3/10. The extra pages in 139 haven't changed my rating since they're not that bad, but definitely not good either. i still don’t understand how your rating can drop that low just from one chapter Because the ending is a big thing for AoT. There are too many mysteries that need to be explained. And it ruined what all the other chapters built up, the characters, (the mysteries,) what's supposed to be good like rumbling, and he was able to mess all of it up and let Marley fighters live happily with Paradian characters, who are still yelling tatakai even after the rumbling caused because Eren want no war. |
MilkShakeTMay 18, 2021 7:04 PM
"no one really laughs on the internet, they just go 'hM' and type '𝕃𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸𝕆𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸'." I'm Level 69 on Mal Badges. View My Badges. |
__kami said: MilkShakeT said: Because the ending is a big thing for AoT. There are too many mysteries that need to be explained. And it ruined what all the other chapters built up, the characters, (the mysteries,) what's supposed to be good like rumbling, and he was able to mess all of it up and let Marley fighters live happily with Paradians. most of the characters got a decent to good character conclusion.stop being completely closed to the idea that it doesn’t.erens character conclusion was well done.armins was well done.reiners was well done.levis was well done.mikasa conclusion was well done. Wow... Eren decided that, after s1-3 being friends with mikasa, after s4 hating mikasa, he "want her to only love him" and decides to Levi didn't even move a finger, he barely talked and showed in the story. Mikasa showed no human-like feelings Hange did nothing but saying "we need to kill Eren" Armin was a smart guy in s1-3, but then he started thinking he can solve everything by talking, and earned a Marley greencard I sincerely give credit to sequel effect |
"no one really laughs on the internet, they just go 'hM' and type '𝕃𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸𝕆𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸'." I'm Level 69 on Mal Badges. View My Badges. |
| 1 - 60s - wow, this is cool 10/10 61 - 123 - hm.. it's just another shounen manga after all 8/10 124 - 139 - oh my 6/10 139 plus extra panel - Oh, well. Let's move on guys ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ 5/10 |
 |
Bayek said: deg said: I don't see how it's pro-genocide when the ultimate takeaway is that Eren's actions begot the wrath of the world many decades (or centuries) later. Nothing was ultimately gained and the actual travesty of it all is the notion that the world is somehow "better" without titans.before Rumbling Arc it was 10/10 but the Rumbling Arc is 8/10 overall even with the bonus pages i hate the Pro Genocide message of this manga well i interpret it as though Eren wants to complete The Rumbling even he said it in the face of Armin in the last chapter and he does not know why lol wut, also the extra pages shows the consequence of not completing The Rumbling was the destruction of Paradis centuries later |
deg said: Well that one child (presumably a descendant of Mikasa?) survives and it implies that the cycle repeats. Genocide never actually leads to a permanent victory - it only delays an inevitable pendulum swing.Bayek said: I don't see how it's pro-genocide when the ultimate takeaway is that Eren's actions begot the wrath of the world many decades (or centuries) later. Nothing was ultimately gained and the actual travesty of it all is the notion that the world is somehow "better" without titans. well i interpret it as though Eren wants to complete The Rumbling even he said it in the face of Armin in the last chapter and he does not know why lol wut, also the extra pages shows the consequence of not completing The Rumbling was the destruction of Paradis centuries later |
|
| It was a 10 until 138. 9 after 139. And finally a 8 after the extra pages. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| it was a 7 until chp 123, 4 after chp 127, 3 after chp 138, 2 after the extra pages |
| ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ |
| Ending itself didn't really affect my rating becouse for me this manga got ruined already - with this ridiculous and implausible alliance thing. Really noone will convince me that so many of Eren's friends would betray him and betray their own nation for the sake of people who want to genocide them. It doesn't make sense at all. Those alliance chapters were boring, cringe and felt out of place like some poor fanfiction. Taking into consideration how big steaming pile of garbage was the whole last arc I expected much worse ending so I was pleasantly suprised that the ending wasn't as silly as that scene when Connie says "to save the world." Before the alliance arc I rated manga 9/10. After I rated it 6/10. Additional pages proved Alliance to be wrong so I decided to rise score to 7/10. At least in the end they were punished for their retarded behaviour. |
Andrzej2May 19, 2021 3:57 AM
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 138 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )deg - Mar 5, 2021 |
1128 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 25, 11:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 139 / Ending Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )NextUniverse - Apr 7, 2021 |
1874 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 25, 10:48 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 4 DiscussionMagEarwhig - Sep 11, 2011 |
25 |
by HenryDanger
»»
Apr 24, 6:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 141 Discussionventi_e - Sep 30, 2022 |
32 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 20, 1:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 77 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 7, 2016 |
137 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Mar 31, 12:03 AM |