Kaiba is in my top ten, fixed at number seven for now.
I'm not familiar with the history of all the different shows he's been involved in, but I did add Ping Pong to my To-Watch list a short while ago and it seems promising and unique for an anime with sports as one of the main genres.
How I feel about Kaiba is as follows: Sometimes you see an anime with a very distinct look and feel that isn't as comparable to others. It's a very singular experience (that doesn't make it high quality or necessarily even good though). Kaiba is one of such anime, which I think would be acknowledged even by those who dislike it.
Many people are repelled by Kaiba at first glance because they don't think they can get properly drawn into a story where the visuals are so alien looking, cartoonish or stylized as opposed to more based in realism. I love the artwork, how he modeled it clearly on Osamu Tezuka's Astro Boy of the 1950s and the early quaint, now thought of as kind of juvenile or embryonic stage of anime to tell a story set in the distant future where the planets, history, daily lives, common morals and values and laws are so removed from our own in the present. He tells a story set in one possible future (usually called dystopian, though I don't necessarily see it that way) that explores the boundaries of human existence - body swapping, memory erasing, interplanetary travel, physically entering the minds of others, etc. with a traditional aesthetic from our recent past.
I was so-so on the art style before jumping in too, but it's one of those series you really have to watch in full before you can appreciate what it is trying to say and do, and that very much extends to the animation. Also considering that it's not based on a manga but is instead an original work for television, it was incredibly ambitious. It's a little bit inaccessible because of the nature of the story, the way the story is told, and the art, but that's even more ballsy to do something that you know from the outset is going to be divisive and not necessarily for everyone by its very nature.
Even still, it's not flawless by any means and I have a number of problems with it. A lot of reviewers say they like the first half which focuses on more episodic one-off tales on different planets more than the second half which gets to the main story of the show. I don't think it's one or the other. I like both, but they weren't connected in a way that was always coherent to understand or always made for enjoyable viewing. The main story is the heart of the show so I don't agree with reviewers who said it should have remained more episodic throughout, but the second half is too rushed and muddled. To have both the episodic episodes and the central conflict told well, the series needed to be longer - at least 20 episodes instead of 12.
I also don't think all the characters received proper amount of introduction and so you were left apathetic or puzzled at times when the narrative switched from focus on one storyline and roughly transitioned to another.
Yet still - the possibility of human immortality through mind preservation and limits of the human body, human colonization of other planets in the galaxy and limits of the Earth - these are some of the most important subjects in existence if you really think about it, and when that combines with the art and music of the series, it's a special world. Reminds me of the highly specific worlds created in Yoshitobe ABe's work. They really aren't replicated in any other series and you just have to watch it, because there's nothing else quite like it.
So I'd like to see more anime in the spirit of Kaiba. They don't have to be sci-fi epics that span star systems. They could be about hermit crabs nesting or a blacksmith guild. I just want to see that type of commitment to world-building and fleshing out details, vision, and enthusiasm used to create so many different show-universes.
|