Let’s be real here: Oono has zero personality aside from being good at games. Yes, it’s occasionally cute when she gets upset over him, but that’s nowhere near as endearing as hidaka supporting him and watching him play, not to mention all her character growth. In comparison Oono does not grow at all, aside from hitting the mc less.
I fucking hate when authors make it so that the less-best, first girl wins in the end, just because she’s some sort of ‘damsel in distress’. If they do get together, Oono loses anything that makes her character interesting (outside of the game), and both characters end up choosing not to grow or change.
Hidaka is the type of character who SHOULD have forced our mc to grow, and look outside of himself/gaming for once. He is never once punished for how inconsiderate he is of others, and never changes in the end. Yes, he puts in more physical effort toward things like school, but emotionally and mentally he is stagnant. And he only does those things for Oono, even though she keeps leaving him and being ambiguous. In real life this behavior from women motivates men to better themselves, and find someone who will return their affection/dedication.
Even in the end, the only change he undergoes mentally is realizing he likes Oono. This is the extent of his growth, outside of gaming tech skill. With very little reason behind his love, aside from “she needs help and is good at video games”. And even though he pretty much admits he likes her to himself the second time she leaves (iirc). He never even considered Hidaka to be an option the entire way through, even when she clearly put herself out there for him, changed for him, and pushed him to reach the only thought conceived in his smooth little pea brain that isn’t about fucking video games. She set him up to be ABLE to say he likes Oono.
Think back to one of their first interactions: the time when he was playing out in the snow in front of her house. Imagine if at any point during this arc, he actually engaged with the girl in front of him. If he spared even a single brain cell on her as well as the video games. She is pulled in by his enthusiasm, and captivated by the games, yet he looks right past her. There is no interaction. He never even sees her as a person. Imagine if he started trying to play with her. Imagine if he asked her to play, and watched her for once (both things he does with Oono immediately after meeting her, and serves as the fucking CRUX OF HIS LOVE FOR HER FOR THE ENTIRE REST IF THE SERIES). Imagine how charming their interactions could have been.
All this to say, the story could have been GREAT. But its not. It’s a fucking dumpster fire, and stories that end up taking this route- where the mc does not spare a single bumass brain cell of his for other people, disgust me. The manga really resonated with me at first, which is why it annoys me that the author chose not to explore something that had so much potential. It spits in the face of good romance writing. I liked this manga, until I realized just how forced his relationship with Oono is. Now that I think about it, even his best friends get hurt by his carelessness more than once, and he gets away scott free.
TL;DR: Hidaka as a character offered quite literally everything Oono did AND MORE, and the mc never even spared a thought on her. Yet he never stops thinking of Oono, just because she’s a “damsel in distress”. This is horrible character writing, and is really unsatisfying. By picking Oono, the mc fails to grow and is never punished for being inconsiderate to literally every other character in the manga. The gaming aspect of the writing ended up in direct conflict with the romance aspect, when there was so much potential for both to work in tandem. 0/10, worst girl wins again, if not for miku in quints I would have stopped reading romance manga altogether. |