Scum's Wish
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- The story comes to the end, @Encipher you guessed it. Akane was cute at the wedding, so was short-haired Sanae. As for Hanabi & Mugi, just go on for your genuine. Maybe there is an answer blowing in the wind, maybe not. And that will be that, right? Six years have gone, finally I am aware of the emotions in that letter now. Thank you, Yokoyari Sensei. You've told a significant story. 100/10. |
2thurielMar 25, 2017 9:31 PM
 |
| And so we're left wondering... I guess an abstract ending is only suiting for this story. I liked it. Everyone's gonna have his different thoughts about the future. |
Almost wished I didn't! Felt there wasn't full "closure". But seeing how this manga has been all this while, I guess I was expecting too much. Oh well, not too bad of an end anyway. This was one of the most mature manga about relationships I've read and thoroughly enjoyed the ride! |
 |
| I went in here expecting to be greeted with pure shit writing albeit atleast being able to come away with some sort of satisfaction for being able to have completed another story from the day it went up, chapter 1, to the day it reached its conclusion, the end. Went in with the lowest of low expectations, and was still utterly disappointed in powers of 100. My heart literally sank in the early hours of this morning while I was reading what I couldn't believe was the finale of this story. The score of 1/10 was cemented volumes ago, and it seems, that I have yet again come across another title where I wished -ve values were an available option. Yokoyari, I love your art, you have so much god given talent for creating beautiful characters. In my book, you rival and rank among the greatest that I have seen. That much, can NEVER be taken from you. As a storyteller however, you fail hard, really hard. Forced bittersweet stories are not for me. GG. |
  |
2thuriel said: how come it says it's going to have 53 chapters? Is it some kind of mistake?THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- The story comes to the end, @Encipher you guessed it. Akane was cute at the wedding, so was short-haired Sanae. As for Hanabi & Mugi, just go on for mamono. Maybe there is an answer blowing in the wind, maybe not. And that will be that, right? Thank you, Yokoyari Sensei. You've told a significant story. |
EGOIST said: how come it says it's going to have 53 chapters? Is it some kind of mistake? Everything after Chapter 47 pertains to the "Nyan Nyan One Shots", which for the most part, were really good. |
NaxrrhidMar 24, 2017 5:34 PM
|
Naxrrhid said: I see, thanks! :)EGOIST said: how come it says it's going to have 53 chapters? Is it some kind of mistake? Everything after Chapter 47 pertains to the the "Nyan Nyan One Shots", which for the most part, were really good. zz |
| They all moved on. Can't wait until the translation to read exactly what was said. |
  |
| I knew hoping for an ending that's an actual ending was too much. At the very least, they've all moved on from each other so it wasn't all bad. |
 |
| So I guess Mugi/Hanabi shippers are salty that the manga ended this way? I think it's the most suitable ending for such a series. I don't think Mugi going back to Hanabi after his relationship with Akane ended is the answer. I'm sure anyone in Hanabi's shoes wouldn't want to be a replacement for someone else. I, for one, would not be happy to be with a man who stood me up because he was busy having sex with another woman and what's more, a man who did not contact me since then. Yes, Mugi did send a text to Hanabi the next morning but saying sorry with a text shows that he didn't really care to talk to her. Mugi was in love with Akane and so Hanabi wasn't in his mind. She was just someone he was fooling around with as a replacement for the one he loves. I'm not saying he was bad but he wasn't in love with Hanabi. It's as simple as that. He and Akane not working out doesn't mean that he should go back to Hanabi. I'm not saying that he didn't care for her. He did and he felt guilty for leaving her alone but his desire and love for Akane was much stronger. If Akane rejected him that night, maybe things would have been different between him and Hanabi but I guess it shows that it wasn't meant to be. Hanabi was ready to start a new chapter in her life with Mugi but things didn't go the way she expected. Well, the whole thing was a mess, so I wouldn't wish for Mugi and Hanabi to be together and have a happy ending. The best thing is that they both moved on with their lives. |
| How are there so many people hating on this series yet read it all the way to chapter 47? Jeez. Couldn't have stopped reading it after chapter 10 if it was such an eyesore? Deep down, they all enjoyed it I bet. |
|
Encipher said: How are there so many people hating on this series yet read it all the way to chapter 47? Jeez. Couldn't have stopped reading it after chapter 10 if it was such an eyesore? Deep down, they all enjoyed it I bet. I guess they didn't really like it, but still had an interest in it? From what I've heard, this manga (and anime) is one of those series where you either love or or hate it. Though, I'm totally with you that it's kinda stupid that people read the whole thing just to bash about it. |
| Holy shit, I love how the manga ends, there's going to be a lot of salty tears from both anime watchrs and manga readers. |
Encipher said: How are there so many people hating on this series yet read it all the way to chapter 47? Jeez. Couldn't have stopped reading it after chapter 10 if it was such an eyesore? Deep down, they all enjoyed it I bet. cant agree more, that's why I dropped Fuuka anime after ep.10 lol |
|
2thuriel said: Encipher said: How are there so many people hating on this series yet read it all the way to chapter 47? Jeez. Couldn't have stopped reading it after chapter 10 if it was such an eyesore? Deep down, they all enjoyed it I bet. cant agree more, that's why I dropped Fuuka anime after ep.10 lol I envy you. I couldn't do it. |
| Well that was a shitty end to a beautiful yet amazing story, bitter sweet ends are not for me either. 5/10. |
  |
| Sayonara Hanabi-chan... Sayonara Mugi... That's right, their lives crossed, but they were never meant to unite, after all, their lines were sweetly parallel, so is... Heikousen.  After all this is not a story of love and sweet romance, this is the story of a wish...  This is an wish... an Scum's Wish. |
Lolikon_ExtremJan 18, 2019 12:11 AM
| I like this ending, Mugi and Hanabi are simply not meant for each other. Mugi had the opportunity to make something out of it but he picked Akane. Hanabi would be dumb to return to him. Well Love that Ecchan finally stand by Hanabi side. |
Encipher said: probably because of the amazing art, not to mention some people release their lust by reading these type of things :pHow are there so many people hating on this series yet read it all the way to chapter 47? Jeez. Couldn't have stopped reading it after chapter 10 if it was such an eyesore? Deep down, they all enjoyed it I bet. |
| I have a question though, Why does mal set this up to 53 chapters if it ended on 47? Will still continue? |
WaffleMint said: I have a question though, Why does mal set this up to 53 chapters if it ended on 47? Will still continue? It counts extra chapters |
WaffleMint said: Everything after Chapter 47 pertains to the the "Nyan Nyan One Shots" someone already replied to that question :)I have a question though, Why does mal set this up to 53 chapters if it ended on 47? Will still continue? |
EGOIST said: Encipher said: probably because of the amazing art, not to mention some people release their lust by reading these type of things :pHow are there so many people hating on this series yet read it all the way to chapter 47? Jeez. Couldn't have stopped reading it after chapter 10 if it was such an eyesore? Deep down, they all enjoyed it I bet. Hahaha "release lust"? Surely they've heard of something called :p Or are these people just like angry fapping. "I HATE THIS SERIES! BUT..." *fap fap fap* XD |
|
Encipher said: yeah since this is much tamer than hentai lolEGOIST said: probably because of the amazing art, not to mention some people release their lust by reading these type of things :p Hahaha "release lust"? Surely they've heard of something called :p Or are these people just like angry fapping. "I HATE THIS SERIES! BUT..." *fap fap fap* XD |
Ironwarrer said: Sayonara Hanabi-chan... Sayonara Mugi... That's right, their lives crossed, but they were never meant to unite, after all, their lines were sweetly parallel, so is... Heikousen. After all this is not a story of love and sweet romance, this is the story of a wish... This is an wish... an Scum's Wish. Nice! It ended just like the title. Man I love. It's sad how people can't appreciate well-written stuff like this. |
 |
TragicRomance said: Ironwarrer said: Sayonara Hanabi-chan... Sayonara Mugi... That's right, their lives crossed, but they were never meant to unite, after all, their lines were sweetly parallel, so is... Heikousen. After all this is not a story of love and sweet romance, this is the story of a wish... This is an wish... an Scum's Wish. Nice! It ended just like the title. Man I love. It's sad how people can't appreciate well-written stuff like this. Hehehe is true, anime was spectacular, a different animation with manga cuts, and the music very beautiful! Without forgetting that Hanabi was Best Waifu in this Winter Season 2017! đź’śđź’śđź’ś |
I read through it and enjoyed it but it wasn't particularly well written, it felt like a soap opera through the entirety of the manga |
drunkmuggle said: I read through it and enjoyed it but it wasn't particularly well written, it felt like a soap opera through the entirety of the manga Still better than most other high school love romance, don't you think? It's original, too. |
| |
TragicRomance said: drunkmuggle said: I read through it and enjoyed it but it wasn't particularly well written, it felt like a soap opera through the entirety of the manga Still better than most other high school love romance, don't you think? It's original, too. I can't deny that. it definitely is unique and I think that's what made me enjoy it as much as I did. but I can't condone some of the thoughts and actions from some of the characters, it was a little wacky at times, and I know what it is like to make silly decisions as a result of being in love but I still think this is overblown |
PapaShango said: What happens in chapter 47?Spoil me. The same thing as the last episode of the anime. Hanabi and Mugi decide that they can't be together because their relationship wouldn't be built off true love and decide to go their own ways in search of it. |
| “Humankind cannot gain anything without first giving something in return. To obtain, something of equal value must be lost. That is alchemy's first law of Equivalent Exchange. In those days, we really believed that to be the world's one, and only, truth. But the world isn't perfect, and the law is incomplete..." -Alphonse Elric "Then and now, what I protect has never changed!" -Sakata Gintoki I'll take anything like The Pet Girl of Sakurasou. Anything as good as that. |
More topics from this board
» About the adaptation…TEMPEST_1 - Mar 23 |
1 |
by LiamTheLaz
»»
Mar 23, 7:20 PM |
|
Poll: » Kuzu no Honkai DĂ©cor Chapter 2 DiscussionEGOIST - Jan 31, 2018 |
5 |
by Quiddity131
»»
Feb 5, 9:31 AM |
|
Poll: » Kuzu no Honkai DĂ©cor Chapter 6 Discussion64BitRatchet - Aug 17, 2018 |
17 |
by Quiddity131
»»
Feb 5, 9:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Kuzu no Honkai Chapter 7 DiscussionStark700 - Dec 27, 2013 |
3 |
by marquinti2
»»
Jul 20, 2023 11:10 PM |
|
Poll: » Kuzu no Honkai Chapter 5 DiscussionStark700 - Aug 24, 2013 |
9 |
by marquinti2
»»
Jul 20, 2023 10:42 PM |