| None, It usually comes out bad and I don't think the Anime you mentioned would be any different. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Baccano: It is pretty much a western gangster movie already. Girls Und Panzer: This is just me wanting to see real girls battling in real tanks. Practical effects tank drifting needs to be done. It has been a long time since I watched Attack on Titan, but isn't everyone white with Mikasa being half-asian. It is less, they have more races, but more they have more of the primary one. |
| 1. manga 2. manga 3. anime! 4. light novel 5. visual novel |
| I could totally see a live-action Trigun or Cowboy Bebop. Hell, I'd go into them with moderate expectations just because they could translate to live-action so well. Probably Steins;Gate too. |
 |
| Just don't do SAO, please, I know that's gonna be shit... I'm happy that it has a S1 You do have SAO in there, yet you don't want Harem/Ecchi to have a Live Action... Ohhh... I've heard that, Prison School will have one... I'll search in some porn site later. |
Darek said: _Ako_ said: Just don't do SAO, please, I know that's gonna be shit... I'm happy that it has a S1 am I the only person who actually enjoyed the second season more? especially the second half? I don't know dude... The anime was kinda, in the middle for me. [quote=Darek message=48151427 2D>>>>3D buddy, live action porn is boring anyways[/quote] ALL THE WAY DUDE! ALL THE WAY! |
martiooo said: I think the visual effects would look cheesy af, but something like Gangsta could possibly work though.OtakulSensei said: None, It usually comes out bad and I don't think the Anime you mentioned would be any different. I think Fate and Evangelion are totally feasible. There's just enough western style for a studio to pull it off right. Copy/pasting the anime. The others, would get fucked up, but I'm just looking at it from a merit perspective. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| If you have watch some series or movies from Japan, you would know that they are good at drama and horror genres but suck at CG. I would say Kokoro connect because other shows I can think of will be very weird with real person acts for characters like Hachiman Hikigaya, Taiga Aisaka and Nagisa. |
 |
| Monster or Legend of the Galactic Heroes(would need a Game of Thrones Budget) HBO show would fit well |
| Sup... |
| NO! PLEASE NO! All that is great in anime, will become total trash once they goes live action and I never want that.... And AoT is a already shit anyways so I wouldn't mind that... |
 |
Z-Dante said: You could say the same thing with stuff like Marvel, and look how well they turned out after being executed well...even tough we had to go through years of sufferingNO! PLEASE NO! All that is great in anime, will become total trash once they goes live action and I never want that.... And AoT is a already shit anyways so I wouldn't mind that... |
| Sup... |
martiooo said: Yeah i was referring to the magic it would look really cheesyOtakulSensei said: I think the visual effects would look cheesy af, but something like Gangsta could possibly work though. Possibly. With Fate I think it's just speeding up battle sequences which could turn out really well, or really cheesy. Or did you mean the magic? As far as Eva goes, we've got Transformers looking like real life now, I think we can make an Eva. It'd have to be an extremely high budget studio though(Almost thinking Bay himself, which would make it suck, Disney/Marvel as well, which wouldn't pick it up. The only guy I think could handle it might be Cameron) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Fate is practically impossible in a live action, they might be able to make the special effect with CG but they won't be able to capture the insane superhuman movement of the servant which ufotable succeed perfectly and Deen fail horribly at. If they use a CG for the aervant than they need to pull hundred dollar of budget to make it as believable as Davy Jones CG on POTC. The same case would apply to SAO imo. |
 |
| I have no expections for liveaction versions of anime, they always end bad :3 |
"No matter what painful things happens, even when it looks like you'll lose... when no one else in the world believes in you... when you don't even believe in yourself... I will believe in you!" |
| Ask this instead: BEST anime you wouldn't want to have a live action adaptation. |
 |
| Why the hell do we need live action adaptations for anime??? I would HATE it if they started doing live adaptations of Pixar movies...they're good as they are! We don't need live adaptations of anime. Besides making our perfect 2D waifus into filthy 3D abominations should be a crime. |
SenpaiJay98 said: Legend of the Galactic Heroes would need a bigger budget than that. Much bigger. You can see the budget limitations in Game of Thrones. I also don't want any cheap Battlestar Galactica CG in my space battles. I'm pretty doubtful HBO's writers would do it right. They would probably try to make it more exciting and insert more intrigue and backstabbing.Monster or Legend of the Galactic Heroes(would need a Game of Thrones Budget) HBO show would fit well |
| undoubtedly, Bananya i want to see japanese men in banana pijamas |
 |
martiooo said: It's not just the speed, it's the overall insane superhuman movement and how fluid it is.tr1ckst3r said: Fate is practically impossible in a live action, they might be able to make the special effect with CG but they won't be able to capture the insane superhuman movement of the servant which ufotable succeed perfectly and Deen fail horribly at. If they use a CG for the aervant than they need to pull hundred dollar of budget to make it as believable as Davy Jones CG on POTC. The same case would apply to SAO imo. The speed is simply well placed motion blur and speeding up the frames. Some scenes would be tough though, like Saber vs Lancer, where it's moving fast as light. The issue is getting the right studio to do it. So many get gamey motion. You'd need some dedicated people, maybe even game artists who deal with motion blur all the time, but I think it's feasible. Magic would be damned easy. From Saber and Assasin swordplay, Lancer agility and Archer overall movement. It's on a different level of difficulty compared to Superman light speed flying sequence. How will they capture Saber vs Lancer? Lancer vs Archer both fight? Archer vs Caster? Saber vs Berserker? The only fight they might able to capture properly is Saber vs Assasin, Gilgamesh vs Berserker. |
|
martiooo said: Pure Romance- Western society sucks at romance. Case in point, Twilight, 50 Shades of Grey. Point made. Maybe Japs could pull it off? Doubt it, though. martiooo said: This is why I said Japs were needed. Westerners are only good at effects IMO... I hear you, man. I've never seen a good Western romance, nor indeed is anything Western that isn't just special effects worthwhile. /weeb |
 |
| Monster. If not, maybe Monogatari, as I'd like to see if it continues to use abstract visuals and fanservice, and if it doesn't, how people will feel about that. |
 |
| None. It never works out. Never. And there's no reason it will work out now. |
  ♦ Anime List ♦ Manga List ♦ Friend Request ♦ Message Me ♦ DeviantArt ♦ |
| ImoCho is the only good Live Action. |
 |
| hellsing ultimate,cowboy bebop and akira |
 |
| Michiko & Hatchin directed by Quentin Tarantino would be amazing. |
 |
| Black Lagoon, but then again it was already kind of a hollywood action flick Monster could also work very well |
| "I like young-girl sexual creations, Lolicon is just one hobby of my many hobbies," he says. I ask what his wife, standing nearby, thinks of his "hobby". "She probably thinks no problem," he replies. "Because she loves young boys sexually interacting with each other." |
| Keijo all the way. That movie would be porny quite cool to look at in a different entertainment medium. |
 |
| None. Live Action movies are always a bad idea. |
HikiMaru said: Keijo all the way. That movie would be porny quite cool to look at in a different entertainment medium. The only cinemas that would be willing to show Keijo would be the kind that are poorly lit and have suspiciously sticky floors. The kind of cinema Paul Reubens gets caught in high on coke and jacking off. |
|
| I really want to see Akatsuki no Yona be turned into a K-drama. |
 |
| Nichijou: Yuuko - John Cleese Mai Minakami - Rowan Atkinson Mio Naganohara - Richard Ayoade Genderbending done right. |
 |
| Inferno cop is the perfect anime to adapt in live action. Attack on Titan - already done if I remember correctly. Fate Stay/night - one of the most boring possible adaptations. SenpaiJay98 said: Guglielmo del Toro seems to want to adapt monster but HBO refusedMonster or Legend of the Galactic Heroes(would need a Game of Thrones Budget) HBO show would fit well http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2015/10/16/guillermo-del-toro-offers-update-on-status-of-monster-adaptation |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| 12 Kingdoms if they can find some good pop artists for the monsters and the world. From the New World got a good concept. Dennou Coil if Google or any AR carrier want to promote. A remodeled Roujin Z - a 1991 Sci-fi senior home care, still real nowadays, in fact, too real Patlabor - Robot Cop Capeta - for I don't like the arts in manga/anime Anything can be made, there's no such limitation. Those failed only because they cannot find the right team of persons. |
zal said: I'm still waiting for his "At the mountain of Madness" movieInferno cop is the perfect anime to adapt in live action. Attack on Titan - already done if I remember correctly. Fate Stay/night - one of the most boring possible adaptations. SenpaiJay98 said: Guglielmo del Toro seems to want to adapt monster but HBO refusedMonster or Legend of the Galactic Heroes(would need a Game of Thrones Budget) HBO show would fit well http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2015/10/16/guillermo-del-toro-offers-update-on-status-of-monster-adaptation |
| Sup... |
| For a studio to want to make it good, it would need to have reason to, beyond just every single person doing their job at trying to make it good. You need to have advertising on board with it. Japanese studios won't cut it, because they'll accept that it's niche and therefore the fans will accept some mediocrity to just get live action versions of their favourite anime. It'll also take plenty of money, so the best choices would be ones that could be made in Hollywood. What kind of live action series/film based on anime could make that work? Something that isn't principally Japanese or very typical of an anime. Something that is already popular with western anime fans and that could appeal to people outside of anime fans. The effects also need to be doable to create it, and not just end up with something that looks bad, so something that can be pulled off with minimal CG--or at least no interaction between CG and reality. It's very hard to mix CG and reality together, especially CG that is supposed to look organic. The best qualifiers? Steins;Gate, Psycho-Pass, Death Parade, and Baccano! Cowboy Bebop could've worked, but that's basically Firefly already. Fate/Zero requires more CG than most, but it can be limited to just backgrounds rather than organic stuff, so it could be possible as well. Effects-wise, you can just compare that one to Chronicles of Shannara. Steins;Gate could be made on a relatively low budget. Some of the timeshift effects and building the time machine would take the most out of it. Gel bananas would be practical effects, and the cast is pretty small. Kyouma and Kurisu just need to have real good actors. Psycho-Pass is basically a cop film with a sci-fi twist. It has an intellectual aspect, but can be sold as essentially a cop film, which have often sold well. Death Parade is very stylish, jazzy (which arose in America), an interesting premise, and not incredibly Japanese. It couldn't be as low-budget as a potential Steins;Gate live action series/film, but it could be close if the studio got creative. Baccano! takes place in America with all American characters (or ones that immigrated there, at any rate), so it would work best if made in America. It's also basically "The Godfather with superheroes", so it shouldn't be a hard sell for studios. Only issue might be the somewhat confusing storytelling method, but that can be alleviated. |
 |
| Best live action anime of all time |
 |
Lu-Ru said: Oldboy was a very good movie. It's a manga, but close enough.None. Live Action movies are always a bad idea. |
_Ako_ said: Ohhh... I've heard that, Prison School will have one... I'll search in some porn site later. The live-action Prison School is actually streaming on FUNimation; it isn't half-bad. |
| "No, son, you may not have your body pillow at the dinner table!" |
More topics from this board
» Which, out of all your favorites, would you be least inclined to recommend to others?WatchTillTandava - 8 hours ago |
40 |
by ShatteredSans
»»
23 seconds ago |
|
» Who are your enemies in the anime industry/fanbase?Catalano - Yesterday |
42 |
by Serafos
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Is watching a show for the cute girl weird?fallout45 - Yesterday |
27 |
by Horshu
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Have you ever refused to watch an anime because of its toxic fanbase?Alpha_1_Zero - 7 minutes ago |
2 |
by Horshu
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » do you want more emotional or more intelligent anime?deg - 9 hours ago |
38 |
by MichaelJackson
»»
6 minutes ago |