| Yes. If I really don't like the art or animation then I'm not going to force myself through it. |
black1blade said: Yeah it totally can. Equally for both old and new. It's a visual medium so visuals are very important. I will punch someone in the face if they can call cowboy bebop, end of eva or GITS SAC ugly. So, if I tell you I think Cowboy Bebop is ugly, you'll punch me in the face? Good luck with that. |
 |
Working_Designs said: black1blade said: Yeah it totally can. Equally for both old and new. It's a visual medium so visuals are very important. I will punch someone in the face if they can call cowboy bebop, end of eva or GITS SAC ugly. So, if I tell you I think Cowboy Bebop is ugly, you'll punch me in the face? Good luck with that. Internet punch. You just got healed for negative damage. |
 Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| I die a bit inside when I see bad cgi. |
StevenHu said: black1blade said: Yeah it totally can. Equally for both old and new. It's a visual medium so visuals are very important. I will punch someone in the face if they can call cowboy bebop, end of eva or GITS SAC ugly. You don't care about people complaining about the quality of the first two movies, right? Well GITS sac looks better than a lot of shows coming out now. |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
black1blade said: Working_Designs said: So, if I tell you I think Cowboy Bebop is ugly, you'll punch me in the face? Good luck with that. Internet punch. You just got healed for negative damage. Lol. But seriously, Cowboy Bebop doesn't look appealing to me. I know that almost everyone seems to find it interesting, but there's so many other better looking Anime I would rather watch instead. That being said, Cowboy Bebop doesn't look half as bad as something as downright ugly as Bakemonogatari. |
|
| Not ruin an anime but maybe reduce my enjoyment. It also makes me reluctant to start a show. Good example being what you just mentioned, Higurashi. It'll be hard for me to take a horror seriously with those character designs. |
Working_Designs said: black1blade said: Internet punch. You just got healed for negative damage. Lol. But seriously, Cowboy Bebop doesn't look appealing to me. I know that almost everyone seems to find it interesting, but there's so many other better looking Anime I would rather watch instead. That being said, Cowboy Bebop doesn't look half as bad as something as downright ugly as Bakemonogatari. Bakemonogatari looks really really good especially on blu ray. It's like a feast for the eyes. |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
Working_Designs said: That being said, Cowboy Bebop doesn't look half as bad as something as downright ugly as Bakemonogatari. I'm confused by this statement. |
| I come back to this thread and there's a war going on. /mayukaout |
Agafin said: Not ruin an anime but maybe reduce my enjoyment. It also makes me reluctant to start a show. Good example being what you just mentioned, Higurashi. It'll be hard for me to take a horror seriously with those character designs. Made it even creepier for me. The first arc is just paranoia ++++. The character designs may give me the chance to show friends who like those silly character designs. It will totally fool them as long as I skip the opening. |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
Hulohot said: Working_Designs said: That being said, Cowboy Bebop doesn't look half as bad as something as downright ugly as Bakemonogatari. I'm confused by this statement. Simple. I think Bakemonogatari looks ugly as shit. If you want good newer Anime that also looks good, check out the Precure series. |
|
black1blade said: that's what happened to me ahaha. I skipped the opening first time and the short clip at the beginning of ep 1, and then I was like WTF AM I WATCHING when I saw blood and death everywhere. Agafin said: Not ruin an anime but maybe reduce my enjoyment. It also makes me reluctant to start a show. Good example being what you just mentioned, Higurashi. It'll be hard for me to take a horror seriously with those character designs. Made it even creepier for me. The first arc is just paranoia ++++. The character designs may give me the chance to show friends who like those silly character designs. It will totally fool them as long as I skip the opening. It was a pleasant surprise though, ended up being one of my fav anime. |
 |
orario said: this would be true if art was objective, and if you also factored in animation. But alas, art is purely subjective.AN ANIME WITH BAD ART CAN'T POSSIBLY BE CATEGORIZED AS A GOOD ANIME It doesn't matter how good the storyline might be or how well are the characters made. If you only care about those you'd better read the LN instead of watching the anime since the novel has much more details and it's better structured. What makes me want to watch the anime instead of reading the LN or also watch the anime after reading the novel, is the artwork. An anime can't be good if it doesn't have a good artwork. good plot + good artwork = great anime |
|
Working_Designs said: Hulohot said: I'm confused by this statement. Simple. I think Bakemonogatari looks ugly as shit. If you want good newer Anime that also looks good, check out the Precure series. I think the anime in your profile pic/sig look like shit. Opinions yay. Visual novels are the best combination of visuals and writing imo. |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| Yes and No Ping Pong - Great! Aku no Hana - Rotoscoping at its worse!~ |
 |
Magnolia said: orario said: this would be true if art was objective, and if you also factored in animation. But alas, art is purely subjective.AN ANIME WITH BAD ART CAN'T POSSIBLY BE CATEGORIZED AS A GOOD ANIME It doesn't matter how good the storyline might be or how well are the characters made. If you only care about those you'd better read the LN instead of watching the anime since the novel has much more details and it's better structured. What makes me want to watch the anime instead of reading the LN or also watch the anime after reading the novel, is the artwork. An anime can't be good if it doesn't have a good artwork. good plot + good artwork = great anime this. |
| Shinsekai Yori Ping Pong And some others not coming to my head right now. Nah. |
Working_Designs said: Hulohot said: I'm confused by this statement. Simple. I think Bakemonogatari looks ugly as shit. If you want good newer Anime that also looks good, check out the Precure series. When I see you post something it just makes me think you're not serious at all every time lol. |
black1blade said: Working_Designs said: Simple. I think Bakemonogatari looks ugly as shit. If you want good newer Anime that also looks good, check out the Precure series. I think the anime in your profile pic/sig look like shit. Opinions yay. Visual novels are the best combination of visuals and writing imo. Yeah, I hate the art style of most new Anime. You're obviously not into the old school stuff like I am. |
|
mayukachan said: +1Magnolia said: this would be true if art was objective, and if you also factored in animation. But alas, art is purely subjective. this. |
Bittenfeld said: To tell you my honest feelings, Admiral Müller, as the groom at a wedding ceremony, the Kaiser is simply just a handsome man, I'm afraid to say. But as the supreme fleet admiral who leads entire fleets, he's really a godly person. Don't you think so, too? Müller said: I think he's quite godly as a groom, too. |
Taewan said: No! |
 All credit goes to Sacred. |
| Bad Art isn't just the only factor ruining Baby Steps but yes, it can |
 |
gedata said: MyNameIsTaken said: Higurashi was enjoyable but everyone looks like a moe, it was kinda disturbing since you have Moe characters killing each other that's the point, though the show still looks like shit Same with Kanon. |
Working_Designs said: Hulohot said: I'm confused by this statement. Simple. I think Bakemonogatari looks ugly as shit. If you want good newer Anime that also looks good, check out the Precure series. Art style is subjective as fuck m8. I also rather watch Panty and Stocking than precure. |
| Ruin, no, but it really can make it less enjoyable I would give lamune a 8 if not the absolutely crappy art |
 |
| Lmao people are calling art objective now K |
Hulohot said: Working_Designs said: Simple. I think Bakemonogatari looks ugly as shit. If you want good newer Anime that also looks good, check out the Precure series. Art style is subjective as fuck m8. I also rather watch Panty and Stocking than precure. That's your opinion. I think Panty and Stocking look ugly, and also, it's Seinen, and I'm not into that stuff. There's only a small amount of Seinen Anime I can watch, like Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou. |
|
| Although Tatami Galaxy and Kaiba looks pretty original and inventive for me. |
Eletrophonic said: Although Tatami Galaxy and Kaiba looks pretty original and inventive for me. And I'm not calling it bad art. It's just... uncommon. |
| Kaiba looks gorgeous. |
mayukachan said: Yo there is such thing as computational aesthetics, you can use Machine Learning techniques to infer aesthetic quality of images, granted there has to be some framework of determining quality I'd imagine.Lmao people are calling art objective now K |
| Giving an honest answer i don't really care about art too much, hell i'd watch stick men if the story is good enough. But is really nice to watch an anime that has good plot and a pleasent artstyle. Also i think some things might look "bad" but if the artstyle fits the setting then is all good (for me) i.e. Adventure Time. |
| at the beginning of Bleach the art was shit. but now the newer episoes just look weird. I was also drunk for the first 120ish episodes of bleach so that could also be a contributing factor. |
  |
Lancehot said: I feel like a boring fart because I like new & old artstyles. But then I don't get all pissy at the suggestion that Western animation artstyles looks good either, so maybe I'm just not :weeb: enough :( I do too first point anyway :p |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| bad in a moe or ping pong way yes it can |
הלב שלי כבר מת |
 Yes it can |
 |
Kisuke_ said: Yes it can Assuming Naruto is good. |
| As far as I'm concerned, if it is ruined it can't be good. But bad animation or poor art choices can definitely take away a varying degree of enjoyment depending on the focus of the show. |
Hulohot said: Kisuke_ said: Yes it can Assuming Naruto is good. it is decent, to be fair. |
 |
jal90 said: As far as I'm concerned, if it is ruined it can't be good. But bad animation or poor art choices can definitely take away a varying degree of enjoyment depending on the focus of the show. for example badly animated fight scenes in battle shounen ?? :| |
|
WAD1992 said: jal90 said: As far as I'm concerned, if it is ruined it can't be good. But bad animation or poor art choices can definitely take away a varying degree of enjoyment depending on the focus of the show. for example badly animated fight scenes in battle shounen ?? :| Yep, that would be an accurate example. Funnily enough, in One Piece this tends to bother me more when the characters are walking/running or having conversations than in fights. |
jal90 said: WAD1992 said: for example badly animated fight scenes in battle shounen ?? :| Yep, that would be an accurate example. Funnily enough, in One Piece this tends to bother me more when the characters are walking/running or having conversations than in fights. despite the fact that the art is ... in OP i think it really does fir the overall theme of the show, which is like an adventure tale from a book. On the other hand i found some "arguably" good art , really hard to look at or appreciate , JOJO's for example, its like seriously too sharp!!! also it makes me look out of shape >_> |
|
WAD1992 said: jal90 said: As far as I'm concerned, if it is ruined it can't be good. But bad animation or poor art choices can definitely take away a varying degree of enjoyment depending on the focus of the show. for example badly animated fight scenes in battle shounen ?? :| Really annoying when battle scenes in general look bad. Claymore for example-the fights haven't aged well. |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
black1blade said: WAD1992 said: for example badly animated fight scenes in battle shounen ?? :| Really annoying when battle scenes in general look bad. Claymore for example-the fights haven't aged well. ahh, claymore :( seriously, only THE GOOD battle shounen never get full adaptations !!!! |
|
black1blade said: WAD1992 said: for example badly animated fight scenes in battle shounen ?? :| Really annoying when battle scenes in general look bad. Claymore for example-the fights haven't aged well. It's not that the fight scenes in Claymore are poorly animated, it's just that it devolves into "DBZ with swords" |
 |
More topics from this board
» What Will It Take for You to Quit Anime?Dragevard - 12 hours ago |
47 |
by APolygons2
»»
13 seconds ago |
|
» who was your first/best anime waifu?Coldsp33d - 2 hours ago |
10 |
by isolated-otaku
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» What's your waifu's "sparkle power"?Catalano - 2 hours ago |
7 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» What exactly are the perks of having waifu?SgtBateMan - 3 hours ago |
13 |
by deg
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» How much anime is too muchST63LTH - 50 minutes ago |
10 |
by Zarutaku
»»
12 minutes ago |