DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Looks great! I hope that anime gets a long life (meaning: that we get a lot of seasons). |
 |
kimmiechan said: Arcanus said: wakka9ca said: People think the focus is on the twins and find them annoying. The short haired twin (didn't memorize her name yet) sure is annoying though! xD That's the annoying part. The short haired one is a boy...... >_> He's a useless little manling. Is there still a chance that the black knights might get 'im? Pray that it happens. If only to have Guin beat the crap out of his would-be captors. Personally, I'd love to see Guin pull a Whirlwind Throw on one of these guys. |
 |
Roronoa_Zoro said: I really hope there will be more then 26 episodes ^^ I guess that is one of the advantages to this series, there certainly is no shortage of subject material. I agree that I found the Mistwalker sub frustrating having read some things about the series prior to watching the episode. The music was great and the EP sounds epic. The action, while physically ridiculous (anything strong enough to pound a man into the ground like that would likely just turn him into a pulp!), is actually very fun in a Herculean kind of way. When Guin first started pounding on the horsemen I started to thing cheesy WWF action and was waiting for a pile-driver or something. However, seeing the character handle a blade and the intelligence he demonstrates in the ghoul scene made me think more of the Elric of Melniboné and the Eternal Champion series by Michael Moorcock than stereotypical barbarian. If I have any complaints with the episode itself, it's that if feels rushed to me. I have no problem jumping headfirst into the story, but it felt as if they were trying to cram the whole first volume into one episode. I'm not sure what gave me this feeling, most likely the dialogue. Definitely going to keep watching! |
| The beginning was a bit rushed, and I found strange the total absence of Palos soldiers ins the palace. Also they fallowed the books to closely, usually it's not a bad thing but some scenes seemed taken straight from the book which didn't fit well. But it was a pretty epic anime. Note to self: Never mess up with Guin |
 |
| Animation, background art and especially music (by the God of video games' music Nobuo Uematsu) were on top for this episode. On the other hand, I don't like the chara-design so much and the story felt classic but has a lot of room for improvement, and Guin Saga isn't considered one of the masterpieces of heroic-fantasy for nothing, I'm pretty sure it will get much more ambitious and better. Good cliffhanger also at the end of the episode. Still, what really stroke me in this first episode was the FANTASTIC fight scene at the middle betwen Guin and the savages. I'm truly amazed by this part, even now, the direction was so well-executed and the animation so great... Ah and second thing: the ED is by far the best ED of the season, it's absolutely out of this world. I have quite mixed feelings about this anime for now, I believe that the original story is a masterpiece from what I heard, but will the anime become the next LOGH or just a simple Tytania, or even worse? I don't know, but this first episode was quite promising and one of the best I've seen this season (behind Higashi no Eden, K-ON and FMA 2 for now). |
 In every age, in every place, the deeds of men remain the same. |
| Looks like AniYoshi has taken up Guin Saga too. Hopefully they'll have a better translation. |
DeadBonesBrookApr 10, 2009 8:35 PM
| |
SLiK said: Looks like AniYoshi has taken up Guin Saga too. Hopefully they'll have a better translation. Hai! Confirmed: http://www.animeyoshi.net/ Good that serious subs picked up. This one is good. |
| everything happened so fast....wow. pretty good. lots of hooks. so far it seems this will be an interesting story. |
| Good start. From a technical standpoint, it was solid. Totally loved the fight scene. And yes, useless brother is useless. I understand that he will develop, but considering the amount of material this will cover, I may have a hard time trying not to bang my head on the wall because of hit. But anyways, I've been craving a traditional fantasy for awhile now, so hopefully it meets my expectations. |
 |
Faust721 said: Good start. From a technical standpoint, it was solid. Totally loved the fight scene. And yes, useless brother is useless. I understand that he will develop, but considering the amount of material this will cover, I may have a hard time trying not to bang my head on the wall because of hit. But anyways, I've been craving a traditional fantasy for awhile now, so hopefully it meets my expectations. Can this series have 3 seasons? |
japanme32 said: Faust721 said: Good start. From a technical standpoint, it was solid. Totally loved the fight scene. And yes, useless brother is useless. I understand that he will develop, but considering the amount of material this will cover, I may have a hard time trying not to bang my head on the wall because of hit. But anyways, I've been craving a traditional fantasy for awhile now, so hopefully it meets my expectations. Can this series have 3 seasons? cant say how many there will be, but its almost certain they will make another season if you look at the length of the series - 124 volumes i thought this was a pretty good start though the thing that might ruin it for me later on is the dumbass brother, you could tell he was going to be useless practically right off when he was shown |
 |
mrSmiles said: japanme32 said: Faust721 said: Good start. From a technical standpoint, it was solid. Totally loved the fight scene. And yes, useless brother is useless. I understand that he will develop, but considering the amount of material this will cover, I may have a hard time trying not to bang my head on the wall because of hit. But anyways, I've been craving a traditional fantasy for awhile now, so hopefully it meets my expectations. Can this series have 3 seasons? cant say how many there will be, but its almost certain they will make another season if you look at the length of the series - 124 volumes i thought this was a pretty good start though the thing that might ruin it for me later on is the dumbass brother, you could tell he was going to be useless practically right off when he was shown Oh good was hoping to have this be long. |
| I heard a lot of good things about the novel. However, it looks like this is going to be a very long series. I sure hope that this show will drive my interest up. So far, the first episode wasn't so bad at all. The fighting scenes are nicely animated. |
     |
| If they actually intend on animating as much of the novels through several seasons, that would be epic. |
 |
| I found out after subs that ED has Latin/English/Japanese. |
| That was alright. Not too bed, plenty of room for improvement too. The ED is really nice. Latin, English, Japanese. I like it. |
 staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| I loved how fast paced it was, it covered so much in a single episode and i enjoyed every minute of it. The animation is great and oh man i loved the ED. Such a pretty song ;_; |
| Guin is freaking awesome. Looking forward to more of this. Remus annoys me a bit tho... >_< |
"Thousands have lived without love, not one without water." -Wystan Hugh |
| During show I had this strange feeling that some dialogues and scenes doesn't fit one after another - like some important stuff wasn't told. |
| What an interesting start, looking forward to the next episode. Really enjoyed the ending song, too. ♥ And, I really couldn't help but think of King when I saw Guin.. :x But that just makes him even more awesome. |
 |
| I was fairly disappointed in the first episode. I never got the feeling that this is or would become an "epic" story as it seems most people did and it felt extremely rushed. Another two episodes is probably all I can give this to pick a direction before I drop. |
 |
| Weird first episode. I still find Guin laughable because he reminds me of King, but he seems compelling enough. I'm hating Remus severely though, so his whining is really going to play a part in how enjoyable I find this show. |
| Hmm. High quality animation, and lots of potential (especially with Rinda, who seems to have it together), but like others, I found Remus really whiny (lol boy skirt) and the episode as a whole felt very rushed. Also, Guin's huge muscles were a little bit too much for me o.o; I hope he puts on some clothes soon ... It hasn't reeled me in yet, but I'll watch a few more episodes, I think. |
 [avatar from Tales of the Abyss] |
noteDhero said: Weird first episode. I still find Guin laughable because he reminds me of King, but he seems compelling enough. I'm hating Remus severely though, so his whining is really going to play a part in how enjoyable I find this show. Me too Guin made me think of King a lot. |
japanme32 said: noteDhero said: Weird first episode. I still find Guin laughable because he reminds me of King, but he seems compelling enough. I'm hating Remus severely though, so his whining is really going to play a part in how enjoyable I find this show. Me too Guin made me think of King a lot. Out of curiosity, who is this King that everyone keeps referring to? I don't think I'm familiar with him. |
King is a playable fighter from the long running Tekken series for Playstation (and since Microsoft likes to pay people off, now XBox 360) |
| Aha! Well now I see why people are comparing the two. xD They really are similar in appearance. o.o |
noteDhero said: Weird first episode. I still find Guin laughable because he reminds me of King, but he seems compelling enough. I'm hating Remus severely though, so his whining is really going to play a part in how enjoyable I find this show. This is like the 5th time I repeat: King is a Guin rip-off no matter how you look at it. Judging the popularity of Guin Saga, King's design was clearly inspired by Guin Saga and Tiger Mask. People saying this series lack originality should reconsider the definition of originality. The pure age of this series (30 years anniversary) put it at an advantageous start/position (i.e. you can't say this is rip-off since Tekken didn't exist 30 years ago) |
wakka9caApr 11, 2009 7:56 PM
bla bla bla The endless debate between fans and haters. At one point, after spending a lot of time on MAL, you just realize it's totally pointless.Niko-kun said: On MAL, everyone who has used the lame rating system becomes a critic and an intellectual by default, haven't you heard? |
wakka9ca said: noteDhero said: Weird first episode. I still find Guin laughable because he reminds me of King, but he seems compelling enough. I'm hating Remus severely though, so his whining is really going to play a part in how enjoyable I find this show. This is like the 5th I repeat: King is a Guin rip-off no matter how you look at it. Judging the popularity of Guin Saga, King's design was clearly inspired by Guin Saga and Tiger Mask. People saying this series lack originality should reconsider the definition of originality. The pure age of this series (30 years anniversary) put it at an advantageous start (i.e. you can't say this is rip-off since Tekken didn't exist 30 years ago) I agreed Tekken ripped off Guin. Story was before even Tekken came out. |
| I didn't say anything about ripoffs or originality. If the first encounter I had of a large man wearing a leopard mask and little else was in a videogame where said character was one I loathed because of his chain moves that could render you dead once you get caught, it's understandable how if I see the inspiration of the character more than a decade later escorting the wonder twins around in a fantastical setting with slight allusions to a mash of mythologies amusing and a little trippy. |
| I won't make any refernces to Tekken because I know at least three people have already made them or at least thought of them. All I'll say is that it was an interesting first episode. |
 |
meonlyme775 said: Well, as ridiculous and generic all the premises and events that happened were, there is something incredibly entertaining about watching a man with a leopard face beating the shit out of people and burying them alive (dead?). I can't believe that tree burned up. Damn, lol. On another note, the music is epic as expected from the person who did FF7 Advent Children and the scenery is quite good as well. The only thing lacking is nongeneric characters and an actually believable fantasy story. All the troops are too "uber" and everything that happens is blown way out of what could even be considered reality. ie: "Oh! The coordinates just happened to get messed up. Oh well, nothing we can do." Lmao at the part where their brother (?) dies in the beginning. "I will get my revenge" *hit by projectiles and falls.* Overall 5/10 +1 for leopard man kicking ass +1 for music = 7/10 You said everything I was thinking. Except that the boy was really freaking annoying. |
 Felli disapproves of this thread. |
| this is a pretty interesting story line, reminds me of Utawarerumono, the whole guy waking up with a mask and kicking ass with a pair of siblings kind of thing. |
the only way to stop a gamer from playing is either: beat them, or wait until they get bored (though 2% percent suffer seizures  |
| The animation was gorgeous, and the action scenes are good. The brother is useless after I noticed that he is scared quickly and never aware around the surrounding in the woods, but I am pretty sure that he will grown up into a mature person someday. Overall, I really enjoyed it so far, and I will continue watching Guin Saga. |
| this series seems like it's going to be very promising, very good first episode. Great animation, interesting story, Guin is freakin badass and though Remus is an annoying twat Rinda seems like a pretty cool character. I will definately be watching this. |
| The soundtrack brings back lots of memories. So far one of the best I've seen for this season if not the best. I can't wait to see how the story goes. |
| Looks like it has a lot of potential. Good first episode, too. |
Confucius say man who stand on toilet is high on pot. |
| Well, animation is fluid with gorgeous art. But first episode was kinda decent. |
| Seeing the name Remus(one of the brothers that founded Rome) was the thing that made me want to watch the anime. Knowing nothing about the series except that one of the mains wheres a leopard mask.. I was realy disapointed with Remus being sutch a pussy... The on the good side. This is like the first series where trained soldiers a actualy do something so that was good. I liked the fighting but the rest was kinda boring and the story didn't get me interrested but I hope that will change. |
| "Never imagine yourself not to be otherwise than what it might appear to others that what you were or might have been was not otherwise than what you had been would have appeared to them to be otherwise" |
Remus_Lupa said: Seeing the name Remus(one of the brothers that founded Rome) was the thing that made me want to watch the anime. Knowing nothing about the series except that one of the mains wheres a leopard mask.. I was realy disapointed with Remus being sutch a pussy... The on the good side. This is like the first series where trained soldiers a actualy do something so that was good. I liked the fighting but the rest was kinda boring and the story didn't get me interrested but I hope that will change. One thing that I like about Remus being whiny is that no one is born as a hero... That is much more realistic than all-heroic cast.... It provides variety to the series. One of the main focus of the series is on how Remus always is dependent on his sister Linda and never think on his own. He has this inferiority complex problem though that makes him disliked.... This inferiority complex will prove be a serious flaw in him...Yes, he will play more the role of the "evil" twin in the future, but that's another story....Let's say that he is sorta like a very weak minded version of Anakin Skywalker in Guin Saga.... |
bla bla bla The endless debate between fans and haters. At one point, after spending a lot of time on MAL, you just realize it's totally pointless.Niko-kun said: On MAL, everyone who has used the lame rating system becomes a critic and an intellectual by default, haven't you heard? |
| Evil twin?..... thanks.... for the heads up........ |
| |
| Guin did remind me of King. LOL wakka9ca said: Remus_Lupa said: Seeing the name Remus(one of the brothers that founded Rome) was the thing that made me want to watch the anime. Knowing nothing about the series except that one of the mains wheres a leopard mask.. I was realy disapointed with Remus being sutch a pussy... The on the good side. This is like the first series where trained soldiers a actualy do something so that was good. I liked the fighting but the rest was kinda boring and the story didn't get me interrested but I hope that will change. One thing that I like about Remus being whiny is that no one is born as a hero... That is much more realistic than all-heroic cast.... It provides variety to the series. One of the main focus of the series is on how Remus always is dependent on his sister Linda and never think on his own. He has this inferiority complex problem though that makes him disliked.... This inferiority complex will prove be a serious flaw in him...Yes, he will play more the role of the "evil" twin in the future, but that's another story....Let's say that he is sorta like a very weak minded version of Anakin Skywalker in Guin Saga.... Very well said. |
| Ill be keeping an eye on this series, i liked the story. The dialogue was pretty weak though >_< |
 |
Remus_Lupa said: The on the good side. This is like the first series where trained soldiers a actualy do something so that was good. I liked the fighting but the rest was kinda boring and the story didn't get me interrested but I hope that will change. Same goes for me... If the next episode is better I'll be watching the show |
| We're all insane |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Guin Saga Episode 15 DiscussionShanaFlame - Jul 12, 2009 |
27 |
by abystoma2
»»
Mar 13, 5:13 AM |
|
Poll: » Guin Saga Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )wakka9ca - Apr 12, 2009 |
70 |
by MeanEYE
»»
Jan 30, 7:24 PM |
|
Poll: » Guin Saga Episode 11 DiscussionShanaFlame - Jun 14, 2009 |
17 |
by Adam_R
»»
Sep 25, 2023 9:08 PM |
|
Poll: » Guin Saga Episode 16 DiscussionShanaFlame - Jul 20, 2009 |
32 |
by nhkam
»»
Sep 17, 2023 8:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Guin Saga Episode 9 DiscussionShanaFlame - Jun 1, 2009 |
24 |
by BaronLukis
»»
Aug 20, 2023 4:05 AM |