| Evangelion. First I read the manga and maybe I watch the anime with very high expectations because I really love the manga, but I dislike the animation (too old, too ugly) and the story (that is different from the manga in many aspects) and the anime can´t show the characters thinkings what turn in a big difficult to understand their personalities. I can´t deal with the characters theirselves (very different from the manga) with annoying and plain personalities (wtf with that asshole shinji?) |
     |
| Naruto, One Piece, Bleach, Negima, Love Hina, Ichigo 100%, D.N.Angel, Tsubasa Chronicles, D-Gray Man, Tokyo Babylon and R.G Veda should all stay manga. These mangas are not too good for an anime adaption. And the second and third ones...... It just doesn't interest me. |
MomoHime125Dec 19, 2007 12:12 PM
 Current Avatar: Sawako from Kimi ni Todoke |
accela said: Tsubasa Chronicles Dear lord. hounddog said: DEATH NOTE. Skarith said: Love hina, and I haven't even read the manga.. x_x Angel Sanctuary wasn't very good either :/ But the Love Hina manga was sooooo much better than the anime in so many different ways. Over half of the story was lost and overall comedy mood just didn't exist in the anime. It was painful. |
 |
Baman said: Claymore. The anime was great at the start, when it followed the manga. When it went all it's own way however, it turned bad. Quite bad. Agreed. Even I could tell that it was ....bad after a certain point.. Not that I know what the rest of the manga is like (since I'm just starting it), but give me a couple of days to get up there and I'll know. |
 Felli disapproves of this thread. |
| Violinist of Hamelin. My god did it have some of the worst animation I'd ever set eyes upon. They completely changed the back stories of the two main characters for no good reason and changed their personalities. The humor from the manga was done away with making the anime one of the bleakest, depressing plots in the world. Story elements were chopped up and distributed willy nilly. Scenes that happened near the beginning of the manga some how got moved to the end of anime. It should've at least been a 52 episode series, possibly longer. The anime only covers the first arc and the beginning of the second yet the pacing was so god awful. They got to the second arc mid-way through the anime and then decided to drag out the events the second arc as long as they possibly could to the point I wished they'd just ended th series at the end of the first arc. At least that way it would've had a slightly more satisfying resolution and the possibility of a second season which the ending they did choose killed any chance of. |
 |
| ^ ouch. i had no idea that the anime and manga were so different. ive been meaning to watch the anime for a few years now but the animation keeps throwing me off. i guess itd just be better if i read the manga haha |
| Ichigo 100% |
 |
tungwene said: Violinist of Hamelin. My god did it have some of the worst animation I'd ever set eyes upon. Hahah, saying that this show was 'animated' is being too generous :) It's really just a radio drama set to still frames with the occasional bit of animation during key moments ^_^ ;; that is what happens when you have no budget whatsoever ;_; I still liked the Hamelin anime, but it really is totally different than the manga, and the manga is much more fun. But the anime does have amazing music. The Hamelin movie matches the comedic tone of the manga much better. |
| Like Shoujo? Visit: Emily's Random Shoujo Manga Page |
isaubella said: The anime was an original. The manga for it was released as a promotion for the anime - the anime is not actually based off of it ^^Evangelion. Of course, TRC takes the cake. I couldn't watch more than 3 episodes. And, as much as I love Revelations for sticking to the manga plot, it's animation isn't much better. You can totally tell which scenes Beetrain did for it. But, it just feels great because it's better than what we've been given before... |
| Love hina. My first manga. I hate the anime so very much. Not just the anime but the dubs and musicals made me hate it even more. |
 |
| in my opinion Aishiteruze Baby should had stayed in Manga form, cause i loved the manga but when i watched the anime it was a really dissappointing! |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| one piece Yakitate!! Japan (love the manga eventhough I did not watch the anime yet) bleach mayb more... |
 |
| Saiyuki, if only because the anime's really, really ugly. Which is saying a lot considering that I don't like the manga's art very much either. |
| SHAMAN KING the anime makes me emo x 50 |
| Only anime I could think of that I thought should never have come out was Ichigo 100%. It went far passed the level of altering the manga, and the OVAs afterward, although they were truer to the manga, pretty much messed the series up further. There are others that kind of piss me off because they always cut short from the manga like Kenshin, Berserk, Gantz, Air Gear, etc etc... but they didn't make me feel as if they messed up the manga version as bad as the Ichigo 100% anime did. |
 |
| Angel Sanctuary. WTF with the boring OAV? |
 |
accela said: Tsubasa Chronicles Dear lord. Ditto. D: |
 |
| TSUBASA TSUBASA TSUBASA TSUBASA!!!! AHHH! So much. Bee Train just... ruined every part of it. I'm so glad that Production I.G took over and made the OVA for it. The OVA is just 1000 times better than that horrible fillery anime. Also, Fruits Basket. If they didn't intend to continue it they shouldn't have started. Plus the secret about Akito, ppft. |
     |
Splitter said: Negima Three attempts already, and they STILL haven't gotten it right >< |
Karura said: Splitter said: Negima Three attempts already, and they STILL haven't gotten it right >< Negima!? isn't so bad =X But the manga pwns all the anime adaptations hard. |
| i thought the anime adaptations were messed up as well. the first attempt failed at design and completely destroyed the story with the demon thing, but captured the general ideal pretty well. The second attempt completely destroyed the story plot, but its design looked amazing. they should really tidy it up and try to make another attempt and animate the school festival arc, since i really want to see that animated. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
hounddog said: DEATH NOTE. And from the little i've read of Chobits. COMPLETELY DIFFERENT! |
   |
danobou said: The Fullmetal Alchemist anime wasn't really entertaining as the manga. Neon Genisis Evangelion- Some things are better left UN-TOUCHED!!! First: Whole-hearted agreement! Second: the anime was first, and far better. |
How is the world ruled and how do wars start? Diplomats tell lies to journalists and then believe what they read. | Report rules abuse | Your Panel | Clubs | Messages | Forum | Recent <img src="http://img593.imageshack.us/img593/4672/stuhlbarg.png" /> |
| Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne.. The manga is actually pretty good (if you like the genre) with nice style and all, and the anime has horrible big eyes and pointy faced charas... Not to mention the one monster /week format which goes through until the last episodes.. with a horrible ending that so differs from the manga... If the people that made it didn't plan on making it good, it never hould have been made...Geez.. |
 |
| for me: love hina, negima (only watched the first episode. it was just terrible), kenshin (the first part was very good; the second part, where they abandoned the original story, was terrible) p.s. don't forget to join the "The manga is always better" club ^.^ |
| URGH, Gravitation! That was the WORST adaptation I've seen in all my days. So many awful changes and missing characters! Second, Strawberry Panic. The manga is so much lighter, and more fun. Where as the anime is so ANGSTY. Aoi never passes out in front of Etoile, which REALLY annoyed me, the way she was portrayed made her seem weak and easily manipulated, the relationships are presented ALL WRONG. The characters are pretty much reversed on themselves... Sorry ^///^ I guess this adaptation really got on my nerves xD |
| Rosario + Vampire. Seariously...the Anime sucks hard. Fanservice is all you get from the this adaption.. |
     |
| Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne...Pita Ten...oh and Tsubasa Chronicles o_O |
hounddog said: DEATH NOTE. Skarith said: Love hina, and I haven't even read the manga.. x_x CriMsoNGenoCidE said: D.Gray-man; dear lord where did the plot go...? yuuko said: Tsubasa Chronicles, definetely. My favourite manga became a terrible, terrible, terrible anime. Let's hope Tokyo Revelations is good.... Most of CLAMP's greatest mangas have terrible anime adaptations. So I'll add RG Veda, Tokyo Babylon, xxxholic and X to that. Baman said: Claymore. The anime was great at the start, when it followed the manga. When it went all it's own way however, it turned bad. Quite bad. to sumarize: Love Hina, Claymore. That and, Hellsing (tough the OVA makes up for it), Zombie Loan (only because production errors caused it to be shorter). Have not even completed the anime and I still agree: Death Note, D. Gray-man, Tsubasa Chronicles, RG Veda, Tokyo Babylon, xxxholic and X . |
| I'd have to agree with a lot of the posts already but D. Gray-man and Naruto are my two biggest pet peeves. The mangas are generally good, but I can't stand either of the animes. |
     |
what_ever said: Rosario + Vampire. Fanservice is all you get from the this adaption.. I heard the manga was nothing like the anime adap. Meaning, not half as many panty shots or exploding clothing. Sounds like Ikkitousen, but that was just awful all round. |
| Claymore Hellsing Naruto Bleach (although I am not opossed to OVA's of these) |
 |
| I thought that Tenjo Tenge should have stayed an anime. TRC as well. |
Kyocool said: Hellsing Hellsing was disappointing, but I think it was due to the fact that it remains unfinished. Although there is a new series titled, Hellsing Ultimate. It's a re-telling. Four OVA episodes I believe, the fourth not out yet. I have seen the first three. Hmmm, better but not fulfilling, in my opinion. |
     |
| Well, I think Death Note was made into a really amazing anime, but they ruined the second Arc very badly ._." The OVAs of Angel Sanctary disappointed me too. No question, the manga is far better! |
  |
| Fruits basket! |
muffin-chan said: Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne...Pita Ten...oh and Tsubasa Chronicles o_O Agree with you about Tsubasa. Also Fruits Basket and Claymore. -__-' |
 |
muffin-chan said: Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne...Pita Ten..oh and Tsubasa Chronicles o_O I agree with you on kamikaze kaitou Jeanne. The anime is so horrible. As for Tsubasa.. i don't know.. I liked the anime. |
| |
yuuko said: xxxholic I thought they did a pretty good job adapting that. yuuko said: And Naruto is a good manga to read but it's a torture to watch the anime. so..sloooowwwww.... Agreed >.< I'll also add Fushigi Yugi, Ceres (anything by Yuu Watase tbh) and of course TSUBASA CHRONICLES. Apart from the recent OVAs. |
 |
| Negima, also Rosario + Vampire |
    |
| Definitely Gantz... The anime story is (as most anime) for 999/1000 the same in 23/24 episodes, and in the 24th they cut it off with some dumbass ending... |
| Definitely Negima =_="" |
| Black Cat Fullmetal Alchemist Tenjou Tenge Claymore Gantz History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi Not because any of these were horrible or even bad. I just hate it when they make the anime shorter then the manga. It's always seemed retarded to me. I can understand it if it were cancelled like Kenshin or Inuyasha(even though that ending sucked), but can't stand it when they end it before the manga is done.<_< I love manga and all, but I will always prefer anime over it. |
 |
| Tsubasa Chronicles, D. N. Angel, Tokyo Babylon, Naruto (Shippuuden) and everything after episode 135 of Naruto, haha, the original Hellsing (Hellsing Ultimate is doing pretty good), Tenjo Tenge, xxxHolic, Gantz, Loveless (while it was pretty, it was just NO.), Hunter x Hunter... and a LOT more o.0 come to think of it. |
| Naruto. Seriously, the way the did the anime in with all the filler and crappy pacing and QUALITY >_> |
     |
More topics from this board
» What older manga do you wish would get an anime adaptation? (Or an anime remake?) Why?Rheanne_Harkness - Mar 6 |
23 |
by deg
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Recently Bought Manga, Mahnwa, Manhua, or Light Novels. ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Maora - Oct 24, 2008 |
5999 |
by Midna
»»
5 hours ago |
|
» Where can I find the people screeching "manga's better"?Tenderizer79 - Aug 24 |
3 |
by raviwe
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» Do you collect physical copies of manga?DesuMaiden - Sep 6 |
43 |
by SkullKn1ght
»»
Yesterday, 8:03 PM |
|
Sticky: » 2024 Manga Reading Challenge - Sign Up ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MRC_mod - Jan 18 |
450 |
by NUGAzz
»»
Sep 18, 4:05 PM |